HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Ajedi32

13,439 karma · joined January 5, 2015

submissionscomments
Ajedi32··on As AI eats the web, the internet’s collective memory is disappearing
Yes, there's certainly less of a monoculture now that people have greater choice in what media they consume. Personally I have trouble seeing that as a bad thing. Greater diversity of taste, culture, and opinion makes for a richer, more interesting society in my opinion. Though I recognize it does have downsides.

I wonder if there's a way to keep the positive effects of such diversity but mitigate the drawbacks. Certainly echo chambers are undesirable.

Ajedi32··on Mark Zuckerberg attacks 'closed' AI rivals as Meta returns to open models
I think there's a point of diminishing returns here. A more competent lawyer can only do so much if you're wrong on the merits, assuming your opponent also has a decently competent lawyer.
Ajedi32··on 'Pervert glasses': Backlash against Meta's smart glasses grows
If you want to secretly record someone in public, aren't there already plenty of much subtler ways? Pinhole camera in your shirt pocket, normal glasses with a hidden camera, camera integrated into a hat, etc? "Disable the recording light in your smart glasses" would just be one more entry in that list.
Ajedi32··on Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery
I don't see anything here to suggest that they don't care. Is the fact that 9.2/100,000 full time workers keep getting killed every year in the construction industry proof those companies don't care that they're getting their workers killed? Or is it just that at scale, bad things inevitably happen whether you care or not?

Maybe it's true Facebook doesn't care about this and if so that would be a problem, but I also think HN has an anti-FANG bias that causes people to give far too much weight to every negative news story that comes out about these companies.

The only real issue with FAANG IMO is just the way software copyright and network effects grant them local monopolies in certain spaces. Overall I don't think they're as a whole any better or worse than any other company, large or small.

Ajedi32··on Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery
Yes sorry, man-workyears not man-hours.

> "Our automated review found nothing wrong with [this ad that implies a young child performing sexual activities]"

That's also a screw-up, and they should be fined accordingly, proportional to the amount of harm this screw up is causing to society. If there are any practical steps they can take to fix the problem, that should incentivize them to do so.

But if for whatever reason it turns out the only possible way to fix such screw-ups is for them to hire 100,000 employees to manually review every single ad, and the cost of that both exceeds the cost of paying the fines and the opportunity cost of turning off this feature completely, so they choose not to do that, is that a problem?

It's like if you tried to insist construction companies evacuate all workers from the construction site before operating any heavy machinery. Maybe that would save some lives, but it would also be completely impractical.

Ajedi32··on Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery
Perhaps, but when you're operating at any significant scale accidents become a statistical certainty. 0 screw ups, ever is not a realistically achievable goal. And if some limited number of screw ups is allowable, that necessarily becomes an insurable cost that amounts to "just the cost of doing business", so I don't really see the complaint.

Concrete example: If you run a construction business, even if you take all the required precautions, statistically you're going to get 9.2 of your employees killed for every 100,000 man-hours they work.[1] Is that proof all construction companies are evil, and we should shut them down for murdering their employees? Is it a problem that having to buy life insurance is "just a cost of doing business" for these companies?

[1]: https://www.bls.gov/charts/census-of-fatal-occupational-inju...

Ajedi32··on Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery
Yes it's meaningful, and the fine amount should reflect that. But hypothetically, if it's (just throwing a random number out there) 1 image in 50 billion, and Facebook gets more benefit from the 50 billion good images than society loses from the 1 bad one, and society recovers its loss from Facebook via a fine, but the fine isn't big enough to make them change their behavior, how exactly is that a problem?
Ajedi32··on Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery
As it should be. If the cost of fixing the problem is greater than the amount of harm the problem is actually causing to society, then it shouldn't be fixed. Set fine amounts accordingly. (Whether we actually do set fines this way is, of course, questionable. And probably this particular problem would get fixed even if there were no fine merely because of the reputational damage it's causing, but I'm speaking in generalities here.)
Ajedi32··on Why Book Corners won't sync contributions back to OpenStreetMap
> there are many streams that no one ever canoes down, because it would be an enormous pain. There isn’t a way to represent this is OSM today

Had you considered `canoe=discouraged`?

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:canoe#Access_values

> paddling is technically allowed but may often be unsafe or impractical (e.g. open water or shallow creeks)

Ajedi32··on Why Book Corners won't sync contributions back to OpenStreetMap
You could store the ID in a tag. They already do this for e.g. wikidata[1] and gnis[2].

Though I kinda doubt they want to support maintaining these for every single project that wants one.

[1]: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:wikidata

[2]: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:gnis:feature_id

Ajedi32··on Xbox goes down. You can't play games you own on disc
I agree with you in principle, but from a practical perspective if you make piracy that trivial you'll get a lot more pirates, maybe even accidental pirates.

I think as a compromise I'd be okay with some kind of license database (maybe blockchain-based, maybe not) that keeps track of who owns a legal copy of what. People reselling digital copies of copyrighted material would have to transfer ownership of that license to prove they're conducting legit business and not just minting new copies out of thin air.

Ajedi32··on Google will expand age checks on Android worldwide till the end of the year
Yes, and as I said that's a problem with the laws, which "put the onus on Google to verify the user's age".

If it were legal for the device itself to somehow determine the user's age without involving Google at all, I agree that would be a much better design.

Ajedi32··on Google will expand age checks on Android worldwide till the end of the year
You're seriously proposing letting governments decide which of their citizens are allowed unrestricted access to the internet?

Of all the 3rd parties who could be responsible for this, I trust the government the least.

But really the best solution here is no third party. The device owner (e.g. parents) should be responsible for setting the user's age when setting up the device. Anything that tries to take that responsibility away from parents and give it to a third party is necessarily going to be highly authoritarian; putting that third party in the role of parent for everyone, adults included.

Ajedi32··on Google will expand age checks on Android worldwide till the end of the year
Well, the API itself seems fairly well designed from a privacy perspective. It only shares age ranges, not specific ages, and only if you allow it. The data is also fuzzed to prevent an app from determining your exact birth date, and it's all tied in to the parental control system.[1]

The problem remains though that, since the laws this feature was created to comply with put the onus on Google to verify the user's age and not on the device owner (e.g. the parents), the method they use to determine the user's age to feed into this API is terrible from both a privacy and freedom perspective: they force you to send them a copy of your government ID, and delete your account if you don't comply.[3]

[1]: https://support.google.com/googleplay/answer/17232873

[2]: https://developer.android.com/google/play/age-signals/unders...

[3]: https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/1333913

Ajedi32··on Our position on open-weights models
This is the same mentality that drives companies to sue cybersecurity researchers for exposing vulnerabilities in their software instead of fixing the software, or to insist on keeping software closed source for "security reasons".

If AI makes finding software vulnerabilities easier, then we should deploy it widely to find as many vulnerabilities as possible and fix them, not bury our heads in the sand and pretend the vulnerabilities don't exist as long as nobody knows about them. That's just the same "security by obscurity" strategy that has been tried and failed time and time again.

Ajedi32··on US citizen charged after GrapheneOS phone wipes during airport search
If you can convince a jury with that story then it might work. Personally I wouldn't buy it. Would you?
Ajedi32··on US citizen charged after GrapheneOS phone wipes during airport search
The government can throw people in jail too but if you kidnap someone and lock them in your basement that's a crime. This is no different.
Ajedi32··on Private healthcare makes industries less innovative. It's time for change
Yeah and to be more precise the problem isn't really that individuals don't get tax incentives for buying their own plan, it's that employers don't get tax incentives for giving individuals money to buy their own plans, only for buying a plan for them.

So even if you could get a tax break for buying your own health insurance, you'd still have to give up a bunch of free money from your employer in order to take advantage of that, which isn't realistic.

Ajedi32··on Private healthcare makes industries less innovative. It's time for change
Yes. Employers get huge tax incentives for providing insurance, while individuals don't. This ensures that the only economical way to buy health insurance is through an employer, which means you are not free to change plans without changing employers (or change employers without changing plans).
Ajedi32··on Private healthcare makes industries less innovative. It's time for change
Yes, the title gave me whiplash because I went in expecting an argument for socialized healthcare, then read a couple paragraphs and realized the article was actually presenting an argument against government meddling in the healthcare industry, then read further and realized it was actually using the problems created by government meddling in the healthcare industry to argue for more government meddling.
Ajedi32··on Passkeys were invented by engineers with zero understanding of consumer brain
The passkey design does take this into account, it's only the implementations that don't.
Ajedi32··on Passkeys were invented by engineers with zero understanding of consumer brain
Because as I just outlined, passwords, even when stored in a password manager, can be misused. (Phished, set to something weak/guessable, reused on multiple sites, leaked in a database breach, etc.)

Password managers make it easier to avoid those pitfalls, but passkeys make it nearly impossible to fall into them.

Ajedi32··on Passkeys were invented by engineers with zero understanding of consumer brain
"A better version of password syncing" is exactly what Passkeys are and ought to be. Just like passwords, but unphishable, unguessable, not reusable across sites, not vulnerable to data breaches, and with better UX.

Stranding private keys in clone resistant secure enclaves has unacceptably bad UX for the average user, which is why very few implementations try to do that.

Ajedi32··on Passkeys were invented by engineers with zero understanding of consumer brain
> That's just wrong. I use android, my partner uses ios. If he creates the passkey in safari, it's not going to get synced over to my phone

It would, if the people implementing it weren't all so obsessed with pushing their own platform-specific solutions over enabling open standards. LastPass works fine on Android, iOS, Mac, and Windows, but each one of those platforms defaults to saving passkeys in their own platform-specific store unless you jump through hoops to specifically save them somewhere else.

Ajedi32··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
Compared to multiple competing privately run systems, which you can opt out of even if you're in the minority? Yes.
Ajedi32··on When can a power company take your land for data center infrastructure?
Yeah this is basically my take as well.

The problem with not having eminent domain is that without it, for any project of sufficient size you'll end up with ~100+ land owners who each individually have veto power over the entire project. If 99 of them freely agree to sell, but 1 is really stubborn and refuses to sell at any price, the project is dead.

There's also a prisoner's dilemma problem. Maybe it's not a big deal paying one stubborn guy 100x fair market value for his property to allow the project to continue. But if enough people think they can get 100x what their property is worth if they just hold out a bit longer, that also kills the project.

Eminent domain solves all this by making it so the project only has to to clear a few bars the government has set for it, rather than the many bars ~100 individual landowners set for it. But in the process it also erodes property rights and kills the built-in protections the free market has to ensure such transactions are fair.

A 1.5x or 2x multiplier on the fair market value would help with that a lot and help ensure eminent domain is only used in cases where it's strictly needed.

Or alternately, I sort of like the idea of letting the landowners elect someone to represent them in negotiations with the project developer, and then having a chance to vote yes/no on the final cash offer. Then the final price would still be set by a market of sorts, but there'd be no prisoner's dilemma or individual spoilers. Not 100% sure if that would work better or not though; it is a bit more complicated and there are still some issues with it.

Ajedi32··on Your 'app' could have been a webpage (so I fixed it for you)
Devs can pretty easily implement this on their site using the BeforeInstallPromptEvent.prompt method.

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Progressive_web...

Though of course...

> This is not supported on iOS.

Ajedi32··on Your 'app' could have been a webpage (so I fixed it for you)
It's not that hard to install. The website can just have a button you click to trigger an install prompt: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Progressive_web...

But of course...

> This is not supported on iOS.

Ajedi32··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
> Rights are not inherent properties of facts, they're concessions between people.

We're getting pretty deep into philosophical territory now, but I disagree. Human rights, to the extent they exist at all, are necessarily inherent properties of individuals.

E.g. If the majority decides people with dark skin are subhuman and therefore have no rights, the majority is most certainly not correct about that, because rights are not defined by the majority opinion. They are inherent.

The U.S. Declaration of Independence put it like this:

> We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed

I concur with this perspective; rights are inherent and inalienable, and the purpose of democratic government is to secure those rights (which already exist), not to create them.

Ajedi32··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
Unrestrained democracy, yes. Tyranny.

People need to understand that having a majority opinion does not inherently give you the right to impose that opinion on everyone else. Such impositions must be done with extreme hesitancy and restraint.

That's why many democratic countries have a constitution which prevents the government from restricting certain individual rights even in the face of popular opinion. But ultimately, the constitution is just a piece of paper. If people are determined to impose their will on others, it can only do so much.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →