HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CPlatypus

392 karma · joined February 13, 2010

submissionscomments
CPlatypus··on Why 37signals Doesn't Hire Programmers Based on Brainteasers
Don't worry, the "github or git out" attitude is only common among people you wouldn't want to work with anyway. They're the ones who will change languages or frameworks according to what's fashionable, rat-hole the team on fun but irrelevant projects, and not talk to you unless you dress like a hobo and swear like a sailor. They're over-represented here on HN, but real engineers know that most good code isn't on github and never will be.
CPlatypus··on RedHat to add at least 1000 jobs in 2012, CEO says
First, I disagree with the characterization of Red Hat as somehow being a lower tier than Oracle, IBM, or VMware. During my mostly startup-oriented career I've worked with hundreds of people who later went to those three companies, and in not one of those cases has anyone described an interview process any more rigorous than Red Hat's (with which I'm familiar from both sides). That's not to say that Red Hat's process is particularly rigorous, but characterizing it as "hire whoever they can afford" is simply a lie. Considering that you just registered a day ago and have only commented on this one thread so far, I can't help wonder if the bit about "inadequate pay/benefits/conditions and very rarely sponsor H1B" is a bit of sour grapes.

In any case, even the standard you're trying to apply is ridiculous. People at Google or Facebook might believe that their puzzle-solving interview process ensures that they get only the best employees (how ego-gratifying such a belief must be) but I also know dozens of people who've gone to Google so I know better. On average those people are pretty good, probably even a little better than the Red Hat average, but only a little. By the standard of actual talent that's acquired, Red Hat does just fine. It's simply not true that "nearly all" of the talent goes to any three or four companies, no matter how big or prestigious. The Red Hat contribution to the Linux kernel alone shows that they can match or exceed anyone when it comes to talent in some areas.

In fairness, I should point out that it's not all daisies and starlight at Red Hat either. It's a billion-dollar global company. Yes, they (we) hire quite a few people in other parts of the world, because - believe it or not - engineering talent is not an exclusively US trait. Like any company we try to get the best bang for the buck, and sometimes that means hiring elsewhere. It's not Red Hat's fault that wage scales in the US are unrealistically high. When you have the ability to coordinate teams in many locations, and talent is available in many locations, you take advantage of it. This can be difficult to deal with as an employee, as can the fact that the average level of social ability at Red Hat seems a bit lower than average, but it's not an issue of low technical ability as you portray it.

CPlatypus··on What Americans Keep Ignoring About Finland's School Success
"How can one possibly know this, even in principle?"

Are you seriously suggesting that standardized tests are the only way to measure school or student performance? What about non-standardized tests showing improvement within the same region or district? What about measuring achievement differences after leaving school? There are plenty of other options besides standardized tests.

In addition to cherry-picking and strawman, you've just added the the excluded middle to your list of fallacies. There are more than two options here, not just standardized tests or mere guesswork. Just because something can't be measured by one yardstick, even if it's the most accurate one (which itself is debatable in this case), doesn't mean other yardsticks won't suffice. Do you really want to turn this into a discussion about intellectual honesty? I'd relish the opportunity to cast your disreputable claims and tactics even further into oblivion.

CPlatypus··on RedHat to add at least 1000 jobs in 2012, CEO says
Please don't feed the troll. ;)
CPlatypus··on RedHat to add at least 1000 jobs in 2012, CEO says
I work at Red Hat. Most of my group is scattered all over the world. AFAIK we have multiples in our Massachusetts, Minnesota, Czech Republic, and China offices. The rest are scattered from the UK to Australia, with quite possibly more working from home than in an actual office. I think many other groups are the same way so yeah, I think working remotely is very much an option.
CPlatypus··on What Americans Keep Ignoring About Finland's School Success
"I'll control for the factors I have data on"

Of course you will, even though - or perhaps because - the intermediate result is far more inflammatory than informative.

"Because the Finns don't do standardized tests"

The fact that they don't do standardized tests doesn't mean it's impossible to know whether they're doing better. They embarked on these reforms because of a perceived problem, and seem quite satisfied with the results. If educators and researchers believe there has been improvement, based on other evidence, then I'm disinclined to second-guess them based on one semi-informed and heavily biased blogger's commentary.

CPlatypus··on What Americans Keep Ignoring About Finland's School Success
But student body is not held constant, not even ethnically. Even within the "white European" demographic bucket there's huge variation among ethnic groups - most relevantly regarding attitudes toward education itself, teachers, and relative levels of funding or social priority given to either. Treating US whites the same as European whites is wrong on a whole bunch of levels. For one thing, we're not all white. For another, the American population is drawn from specific subsets of the European population, and has experienced different patterns of population change since then (particularly evident wrt Jews with their known unique educational profile). Lastly there's the fact that even if non-whites aren't included in the sample their effects are still felt because many white students still share schools with non-whites, and not a few of those "white" students in fact have mixed heritage.

Of course, treating ethnicity - and particularly just white vs. non-white - as the only variable other than the educational system itself is itself offensive. One might also consider the effects that 300+ years of distinctly US culture and history have had on attitudes toward education, teachers, or the relative social/economic priority accorded to either. Or the effects that wealth distribution within the US or wealth differences between the US and other nations might have. The US student body is simply not the same as the Finnish one, so if Sanandaji really wanted to isolate the effect of the educational system then he'd have to adjust for more than one other variable.

Alternatively, he or you might take note of the fact that the current Finnish results are the result of change to the system while holding demographics relatively constant. What works in Finland might not work in the US for all sorts of reasons, but claiming that it won't work specifically because of ethnic makeup is both intellectually and morally dubious.

CPlatypus··on What Americans Keep Ignoring About Finland's School Success
Your "authority" is crap. The original article explicitly compared Finland not only with Norway but with individual US states that had similar population and percentage of immigrants. That's about as apples to apples as you can get, considering that US schools are primarily subject to state rather than federal guidelines, and Finland still came out ahead.

By way of supposed refutation, you present a source that is full of strong claims substantiated by little more than the most blatant cherry-picking. The author's "correcting for demography" is no more than throwing out the data he doesn't like. Ignoring the fact that the immigrant factor has already been examined, he pulls tricks like comparing second- and third-generation immigrants in Finland to native Swedes. Notice how the obvious comparison between native Finns and native Swedes isn't made, because it wouldn't support his conclusions. Then he goes on to say "In the case of America, 99% of the population originates from other countries" and suggests that we compare such loosely-defined American immigrants to people in their home countries - without regard for such things as economic differences between the countries. After arbitrarily excluding Asians because they pull the results up, Hispanics because they pull the results down, and undeclareds for no methodologically sound (or even fully explained) reason, he comes up with a highly suspect graph purportedly showing how the US "beats" most of Europe.

Here's the kicker: even after cooking the data that much, Finland still comes out well ahead of the US. No matter how hard he tries, he still can't manage to reverse the original conclusion. In the end, citing that does more to discredit your position than to support it.

CPlatypus··on Richard Stallman Was Right All Along
"The Obama administration requested the indefinite detention provisions."

[citation needed]

CPlatypus··on Good news: Mozilla fixed their damn browser
Yes, the RHEL5 kernel is obsolete in that it lacks the barrier support necessary to implement proper behavior with decent performance. The fact that obsolete ext3 runs better on also-obsolete 2.6.18 kernels doesn't really tell us much except that sometimes two pieces of software evolve together, and sometimes versions that were developed together work better than versions that were not.
CPlatypus··on Good news: Mozilla fixed their damn browser
The problem with data=ordered is that it imposes a global order, allowing one I/O stream to stall others. Imagine if waiting for data to be acknowleged on one TCP socket meant waiting for all data sent earlier on all sockets - even those to slower peers - to be acknowledged as well. That's completely FUBAR, but it's basically what fsync with data=ordered does to an entire filesystem. There are hundreds of performance reports showing this effect, and nobody cares if one user's I/O patterns are too lame for them to have noticed.

The problem is that, in ext3, not using data=ordered is also problematic - this time in terms of potential corruption and security issues. That's why even the people who brought you ext3 abandoned it years ago in favor of making ext4 do these things the right way. If you want reasonable fsync behavior, plus niceties like block-size awareness and trim/discard support, you need to use a modern filesystem.

A piece of software that embodies a broken approach to a solved problem is by definition obsolete, and that includes ext3. Please don't make claims about what's obsolete when you don't even understand the issues that would make it so.

CPlatypus··on Unfortunate Python
I agree with most of these, but a couple seem pretty specific to the use of Python as a language for serious, complex, fully packaged applications. Sorry, but Python has another use as well - to create quick utility scripts in a better language than bash or perl. For example...

* When discussing "__name__ == '__main__' he complains about 13 non-alphanumeric characters, and then proposes a setuptools-based alternative that's 12 extra lines.

* He disses asyncore/asynchat, and then proposes the much more complex Twisted instead.

If your project is already big enough to have multiple files, already complex enough to require Twisted-level functionality (though even then Twisted sucks compared to Tornado or just about anything else), if it's already being packaged for general use via setuptools, then following these suggestions is almost free. OTOH, they're way overkill for other situations. About three years ago some colleagues and I wrote an asynchat-based server to coordinate certain administrative actions on a 1000-node system. It was stable, it performed as well as it needed to, and - even after working around some "infelicities" in asynchat - it was still only half as much code as would have been necessary in Perverted.

I don't think I'll be signing up for any idioms or coding standards that are based on an assumption of using Python as a direct replacement for Java. Neither should anyone else.

CPlatypus··on Sleep Deficit: The Performance Killer
I wish I could upvote that at least twice - once for the game-theory bit, and once for the tracking-effort bit. Those are both excellent insights.
CPlatypus··on Why big companies fail to keep talent
Most of the reasons are good, but how can anyone keep a straight face while they present changing strategic priorities as a big-company problem? Don't startups do 90-degree "pivots" of the entire darn company just as often? The ten startups I've been in all got jerked around far more than the two big companies, and I get the impression this is even more true in today's startup culture.
CPlatypus··on Stop Telling Women To Do Startups
I love the assumption that the men currently in startups have female partners who would want to reverse roles. Most have female partners who would prefer to stay home or work for an established company, so the actual effect of those men staying home would be a smaller talent pool. That is, unless she's trying to tell men who they should marry as well as how they should run their careers. Nothing she suggests would actually lead to the change she supposedly wants. The best way to get more women in startups is to let them see supportive role models . . . most often, their fathers.
CPlatypus··on Parents of overweight children don't know their children are overweight
I wonder how much of this effect is just due to the fact that admitting the child is overweight would be tantamount to admitting that they themselves are overweight. Without making any moral statement whatsoever, that's simply hard for people to do.
CPlatypus··on NYC Man Earns $55,000 A Year Peddling Candy On Subway
The world would also be a better place without a lot of social-media crap startups with "sell more ads" business models using other people's money to bid up the price of talent and office space. Nonetheless, the people starting those companies are entrepreneurs and so is this guy. That's a lean startup, right there. ;)
CPlatypus··on If Everyone Else is Such an Idiot, How Come You're Not Rich?
This same principle often applies to reading others' code. It's common to look at it, see something inscrutable, and decide that the author was an idiot. Then you try to rewrite it, trip over all the same bugs that the author had learned to avoid, and maybe - if you're smart and honest with yourself - accept that you had unfairly maligned your colleague. I've written about this before, as have many others including Joel Spolsky. My favorite is this:

http://notinventedhe.re/on/2010-4-22

If you re-read the article with an eye toward how it describes the behavior of programmers even more than it describes that of business people, it becomes much more valuable.

CPlatypus··on Scala At Yammer (Official position on Scala)
As you yourself said, it ain't gonna happen anyway. Therefore, this thread isn't "spoiling" anything that would have happened otherwise. At least try to be consistent, instead of trying to silence everyone who doesn't share your opinion of an author you obviously idolize.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1998819 http://news.ycombinator.org/item?id=2083997 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2688984 (includes bonus downvote threat against any who disagree)

CPlatypus··on Scala At Yammer (Official position on Scala)
I understand and agree with everything you said. Coda has every right to be angry with Stephen. He might even have the right to sue Stephen. Nonetheless, swearing in public like that was simply not the way to deal with the situation. Think about it in purely strategic terms. What outcome might Coda or Yammer want from this? Perhaps for it to fade away, perhaps for Stephen to apologize, perhaps something else. Does snarling at Stephen bring any of those outcomes closer? Did the swipe at HN? If Stephen or anybody else - I suppose some might think that includes me - harbored any ill will, wouldn't this just give them even more opportunity to do some damage?

Sometimes the right thing to do when you're wronged is to let it pass, no matter how much it sticks in your craw, for strategic reasons. Sometimes giving in to that moral-outrage addiction simply does more harm than good, no matter how justified the outrage might be. And yes, I've very much been in that position myself. It sucks, but I've learned that it sucks even more to have a self-inflicted wound on top of the one I got from someone else.

CPlatypus··on Scala At Yammer (Official position on Scala)
"You can't correct Coda. He doesn't care."

I know that. What I might be able to do, though, is explain why his example might be a bad one to follow. Or maybe it's a good one, for those of the "no publicity is bad publicity" mindset. In any case, I think it's worth it to express my view. These things do affect businesses and livelihoods. Maybe it's too "meta" for some people, but - unlike some - I won't tell people who disagree that they should remain silent.

"I think this is a bad direction for our threads to go"

It's not only a bad direction for "our" threads to go; it's a bad direction for the broader discussion - across here, Twitter, various blogs, etc. - to go. That's my point. HN isn't an island. I've seen quite a few people who disable comments on their blog posts and explicitly direct readers to the corresponding post here for discussion. The real damage to real reputations is being done elsewhere, and condemning those who point it out here seems counterproductive.

"I don't think you can talk about "de-escalation""

Ad hominem, pure and simple. I'm not one of the principals here. I have nothing to do with the companies or communities involved. As a mere commentator, nothing I say affects those relationships one way or another, so de/escalation is an inoperative concept. If you want to disagree with me fine, but please stop finding new ways to tell me I shouldn't even have an opinion.

CPlatypus··on Scala At Yammer (Official position on Scala)
I'm not trying to put anyone in their place. In a way, that kind of dominance-hierarchy BS is exactly what I'm objecting to. The point here is that this new response from Coda doesn't even address the technical debate. It doesn't make one new point in that area. It's entirely about smoothing ruffled feathers, so responses about the ruffling and smoothing of feathers are completely fair game.

Furthermore, this kind of "reputation management" (or whatever you want to call it) really does matter, and I think there are important lessons the HN audience can take away from it. Being conciliatory toward one person or group just isn't very convincing if you're almost simultaneously trying just as hard as ever to alienate others. The mixed messages, even though they're supposedly addressed to different people, make even the conciliatory part seem insincere. If I were in Donald's or Martin's position, I'd be wondering how long the constructive tone - and the original letter was very constructive - will last before the inevitable reversion to form. The lesson is that if you want to claim the moral high ground you have to stand on it for a while. Stephen was wrong to publish what should have remained private correspondence, but calling him out like that only ensures that the controversy will continue. The urge to bare teeth and show dominance overwhelmed the rational choice to let this whole thing fade into a natural and well deserved obscurity.

What was called for was de-escalation, and anybody else who finds themselves in a similar situation (many of us have or will BTW) would do well to watch how this one plays out.

CPlatypus··on Scala At Yammer (Official position on Scala)
...and of course, the professional tone of the blog entry is ruined by the thoroughly unprofessional tone of the accompanying tweet:

"That, @jodastephen, is a fucking announcement by Yammer about Scala." http://twitter.com/coda/status/142047850426146816

Ah, so much better than those "slapfights" we have here at HN, isn't it? Protip: backpedaling and fence-mending don't work if you go right back to the kind of public behavior that got you in trouble in the first place.

CPlatypus··on The Rest of the Story (Yammer & Scala)
He's not wrong, but at the same time I don't think anybody who so enjoys pissing contests on Twitter can afford to be too condescending about slapfights on HN. The last thing either place needs is more hipper-than-thou posturing.
CPlatypus··on X86's Days as a Consumer Microarchitecture are Numbered
Are there many data centers using IB? Yes. SMP was common in HPC before it came down-market, likewise NUMA. Commodity processors have many features - vector instructions, specilative execution, SMT - first found in HPC. Power and cooling design at places liks Google and Facebook is heavily HPC-influenced as well. Certainly some things go the other way - e.g. Linux - but usually today's server design looks like last year's HPC design.

I'm not quite sure it's valid to write off SPARC as an architectural dead end when the current fastest computer in the world uses it, and the next crop of US competitors for that crown are all based on the Cell/BlueGene lineage. GPUs are also more broadly applicable than you might think. Besides video and audio processing, they can be used for many crypto-related tasks (witness their popularity for Bitcoin mining), various kinds of math relevant to data storage (e.g erasure codes or hashes for dedup), and so on. Many of their architectural features are also being copied by more general-purpose processors as core counts increase, as well.

Yes, high-end HPC is too obsessed with LINPACK. Nonetheless, it remains a good place to look when trying to predict the future of commodity servers. Even if ARM does displace x86 instead, many features besides the ISA are likely to come from HPC. Perhaps more relevantly, either outcome is still very bad for Intel.

CPlatypus··on X86's Days as a Consumer Microarchitecture are Numbered
Does it still have plenty of battery life when you're doing something besides commenting on Hacker News? Perhaps more importantly, how fast do you need a single instruction stream to be? I'm writing this on my own three-year-old MacBook Pro, but I know that its battery life is mostly contingent on the CPU remaining idle 99% of the time. For any multi-tasking workload, or even for single-task workloads if the software is written correctly, a more efficient CPU architecture with many smaller cores would offer both greater responsiveness and longer battery life even during my most computationally intensive moments. Maybe you're one of the 1% who really need higher single-thread performance, and not just because of crappy multi-core-naive software, but the market is driven by the other 99%.
CPlatypus··on X86's Days as a Consumer Microarchitecture are Numbered
X86 is not going away, I agree, but Intel can hardly exercise the kind of dominance they've enjoyed for the last several years when they're facing serious threats at both the low and high end. At the low end, ARM simply beats x86 for anything with a battery. Intel has already lost the phone and tablet markets, and laptops are highly likely to follow.

At the high end, look at the http://top500.org/. #1 is based on SPARC VIIIfx. #10 is based on the PowerXCell 8i. #2 and #4 both derive much of their power from GPUs. Even that understates the situation, because many of the most powerful computers next year - Blue Waters, Mira, Sequoia - will also be based on non-x86 architectures. Then look at what Tilera or Adapteva are doing with many-core, what Convey is doing with FPGAs, what everyone is doing with GPUs. Intel is going to be a minority in the top ten soon, and what happens in HPC tends to filter down to servers.

So Intel has already lost mobile and HPC. Even if Intel keeps all of the desktop market, what percentage of the laptop and server markets could they afford to lose before they follow AMD? Maybe it will happen, maybe it won't, but anybody who can see beyond the "Windows and its imitators" segment of the market would recognize that as a realistic possibility.

CPlatypus··on X86's Days as a Consumer Microarchitecture are Numbered
6x the performance . . . for 8.5x the TDP. It's pretty easy to see why ARM designs are already preferable for almost anything that has a battery, and laptops are outselling desktops already. Sure, there will always be applications where single-thread performance will matter more than total performance or performance per watt for many cores - believe me, we learned that lesson at SiCortex - but those applications are not enough to sustain Intel as we know it. There's a reason they're developing MIC; without it they'd be squeezed between ARM clients and servers with 20+ ARM/MIPS/POWER/SPARC cores per chip (not even counting GPU/FPGA server plays). They need their own many-core product to compete.
CPlatypus··on Canonical drops CouchDB because they were unable to make it scale up
I get the impression that the problem was less about scaling within one database than about scaling across many; Lenton practically says as much about a half dozen messages down-thread. Deploying literally millions of separate databases would be a total nightmare of resource contention, version skew, and general administrative burden. U1 was probably looking for ways to use some sort of multi-tenancy to serve the same number of users with fewer CouchDB instances, and that's the kind of scalability they apparently found lacking. Your point about scale vs. federation, while perhaps accurate and valuable, doesn't seem to address the actual reason for this change.
CPlatypus··on What If Facebook's IPO Dreams Are Built On As Much Hype As Groupon's?
Two differences between Facebook and Groupon immediately occur to me. First, despite everything else that's wrong with it, Facebook's business model does not depend on persuading small businesses to sell goods and services at less than their cost. Second, Facebook has generated significant value in the form of non-replicable technology, infrastructure, and connectedness to just about everything else on the net. None of this is true of Groupon. There is nothing hard to copy about Groupon, and "find more suckers" pretty much sums up their business model. These are the differences between a company with staying power and a company without it, so only a fool would expect similar IPO outcomes.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →