HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CapricornNoble

1,420 karma · joined May 28, 2018

Defense industry consultant.

Information management, knowledge management, C4ISR systems, electronic attack, command & control, operations research, modeling & simulation, amphibious warfare, joint operations.

submissionscomments
CapricornNoble··on US Ends Support For Ukrainian F-16s
> This means that no country will want to buy F16s.

This is just HNers being late to the party.

Back in the 1990s, the US blocked sale of F-16s to Indonesia due to human rights concerns (eventually worked out).[0] Thailand has F-16s but more recently switched procurement to Swedish Gripens, partly to avoid reliance on a single combat aircraft supplier. Thailand also does bilateral training with PLAAF (Chinese Air Force), and their F-16s are apparently barred from participating. [1] There are rumors Egypt is switching from F-16s to Chinese J-10s, largely because the US refuses to sell Egypt modernizations and air-to-air missiles that would make them competitive against the Israeli Air Force.[2] The move away from the US as a combat aircraft supplier has been building steam for decades now. In the past there simply weren't many options competitive with the F-16 (both affordable and capable), but that's not the case in 2025.

> This is going to have a massive effect on the US economy, internal consumption will not save it.

I guess this really is the question: what is the expected overall quality of life for the average American when our continent-sized economy is largely functioning under conditions of autarky? The US's imports and exports are lower in 2023 than they were in 1913. Even in 1913 the US had the world's largest GDP (but not GDP/capita, was still much lower than the UK's at the time).

[0] https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA441694.pdf

[1] https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/opinion/article/3279377/why-t...

[2] https://fmso.tradoc.army.mil/2024/egypt-is-rumored-to-have-s...

CapricornNoble··on The 90s Gamer Experience: Handwritten Notes and Maps
I kept the starmap from the Sega Genesis version of Starflight on my wall for decades. I had hand-drawn the wormholes I had discovered on it. Not being able to reveal perfect playthrough strategies and information with just a web search definitely made gaming a different experience.
CapricornNoble··on Asus Eee PC
I think mine had the CMOS battery fail and I never got around to replacing it. Just pulled it out of a Rubbermaid container last week and thought "man I should get this up and running again, what a fun little cyberdeck it was."

This machine was key to helping me learn Backtrack Linux (Kali's predecessor) and introduced me to Fluxbox.

CapricornNoble··on U.S. pauses all military aid to Ukraine
>You have no idea what you are talking about and are clearly trying to spin a narrative out of nowhere.

I have no regional experience with the tiny backwater corner of the world known as "the Baltics"....but I absolutely understand how my country exerts influence in numerous larger, more important places, with even more significant risks.....and it's by heavily using the tools that I mentioned. I'm not willing to give our government the benefit of the doubt, given our extensive list of malevolent priors. If you are saying there was overwhelming domestic support for NATO, okay, but I'd consider that an exception, not a norm.

>I don't need an American NGO to convince me that simply hoping we're not the next item on the menu is not a sound national security policy.

Every nation that isn't at least a major regional power (Turkey as an example) is on somebody's menu. Maybe you guys have been punched in the face so many times by your local Great Powers that reaching for anyone else, even from across the ocean, seemed sound....but as we are witnessing now in real-time, you are also finding out that America's benevolence is neither infinite nor eternal.

Re: 1991 South Ossetia War. Why is it ok for the Georgians to secede from the Soviet Union but not ok for the South Ossetians to secede from Georgia? Why is it morally good for the US to arm the Ukrainians, who feel aggrieved, but not moral for Russia to arm the South Ossetians, who feel aggrieved?

CapricornNoble··on U.S. pauses all military aid to Ukraine
>Yes the above all shows that America thought it was in its strategic interest, that Clinton supported it. That does not eliminate the fact that much of Eastern Europe wanted to join for exactly the reasons I mentioned. And nobody made them do it.

To prove that we'd probably need a FOIA request or a large CIA/USAID/NED document leak. Saying "nobody forced them" while the US operated probably the most effective coercive soft power institutions the world has ever seen, by subsidizing NGOs and "pro-democracy movements", strikes me as incredibly naive. I recommend reading some articles at the New Eastern Outlook by Brian Berletic (or watching his YT channel "The New Atlas"), he has some well-sourced deep dives on US soft power.

> By the point when Georgia engaged with Russia in 2008, Russia had already stirred up separatist groups, armed them, supported their violent takeover, and sent Russian advisors to support them in occupying Georgian territory. You can’t start at the middle.

1. The Reuters article reads" Saakashvili had said Georgia was responding to an invasion by Russian forces when it attacked breakaway South Ossetia, but the report found no evidence of this. It said Russia's counter-strike was initially legal.."

This sounds contrary to your point that Russia stirring up separatists to occupy Georgian territory was considered an acceptable casus belli.

2. Do you have references for WHEN the Russians initiated support for anti-Georgian separatism? If it was after the major NATO expansions of 1999 and 2004 it's kinda a moot point. I focused on the information around the timeframe of the 2008 invasion specifically because it was what you directly called out in your post. Re-reading it, I suppose you were thinking of all Russian grey-zone warfare in Eastern Europe but that context isn't clear.

3. Is your position that subsidizing armed rebel factions is not moral / not justified? Is it wrong for the US to support the MEK organization which actively works towards violent overthrow in Iran? At one point the Pentagon and CIA were funding two different separatist groups in Syria that were also fighting each other. This is what is missed by my most Americans and Europeans: to the rest of the world, complaining about Russia looks like blatant hypocrisy when the US has spent the post-Cold War period doing the exact same shit. Which would be fine, realpolitik and all that....if we didn't constantly posture as if we hold the moral high ground.

CapricornNoble··on U.S. pauses all military aid to Ukraine
> As for German car manufacturers...I already drive a German EV (made in Germany as well) so I'm not sure what the big deal is about.

Sean Foo has numerous videos discussing the German economy and Chinese EVs. Here's one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jFsR-gm8nk

CapricornNoble··on U.S. pauses all military aid to Ukraine
>No. Countries with their own free choice asked to be part of NATO. The US did not push this on them.

I've seen this stated frequently on HN. Here's a quote from President Clinton in February 1999[1]:That is why I have pushed hard for NATO's enlargement and why we must keep NATO's doors open to new democratic members...

NATO would add 12 nations in the decade after those remarks, with the first 3 formally joining 2 weeks later.

Also look at Clinton's remarks from October 1999[2]:NATO must also take in new members, including those from among its former adversaries. It must reach out to all the new democracies in Central Europe, the Baltics and the New Independent States of the former Soviet Union. At the first NATO summit I attended in January of 1994, I proposed that NATO should enlarge steadily, deliberately, openly.

>Russia is both to blame for the expansion of NATO and Russia's subsequent invasions of Georgia and Ukraine.

I used to have a link to a really good interview with a former US ambassador or special advisor to Sakashvilli. In it, he basically says that Sakashvilli is a risk-taker and gambler much like Putin, and in 2008 he gambled and lost. He basically laid the blame for what happened at the Georgian President's feet. Which is also the conclusion of the EU-backed investigation.[3]

[1] https://clintonwhitehouse5.archives.gov/WH/EOP/NSC/html/nsc-...

[2] https://www.nato.int/docu/speech/1996/s961022a.htm

[3] https://www.reuters.com/article/world/georgia-started-war-wi...

CapricornNoble··on Federal workers ordered to return to offices without desks, Wi-Fi and lights
>I feel like your question is trying to excuse reckless disregard (at best) as mere incompetence.

Ehh, sometimes I'm really not sure how many of the sloppy decisions that are made are malicious, and how many are incompetent.

>Like unless it's more than 1% of the national budget (i.e. > 67 billion a year) then it isn't worth the chaos.

For people like Musk, chaos is a feature not a bug. Shaking a lot of low-value-add employees and processes out of their comfort zones is the point.

>And a competent administration that wanted to end leases really shouldn't have started RTO

I think the Scheme of Maneuver is:

Phase 1: Bring everyone into the otherwise-nearly-empty offices.

Phase 2: Figure out who is dead weight. Fire them.

Phase 3: Figure out what max occupancy should be after the fat has been cut from the workforce, and cut all unneeded office space.

Phase 4: Maybe allow some limited WFH (I'm not holding my breath on this one).

CapricornNoble··on U.S. pauses all military aid to Ukraine
>while the EU & the rest of the true free world should focus our efforts on getting nukes, investing in military and intelligence, and leveraging new drone & radar technologies.

You do realize all of that requires massive investment? Where is the EU going to get that money? Raise taxes on a population that is already struggling in a stagnant economy? An economy that is stagnant partly due to the loss of the dirt-cheap energy that European heavy industry was importing from Russia.

As an American (and not one of European decent, so I don't hold the romantic attachment to Europe that many have), I'm perfectly happy with the salty, delusional Europeans agreeing with severing trans-Atlantic relations. Europe has spawned two World Wars and seems intent on flirting with a third. The sooner we disconnect from you guys, and pivot back to a mix of the Pacific Rim + the Americas, the better.

Now if only we could disband AIPAC...

CapricornNoble··on U.S. pauses all military aid to Ukraine
I recommend reading some of the diplomatic cables on Wikileaks https://wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/08MOSCOW3127_a.html <--this one from 2008 has Russian diplomats warning about NATO expansion and Ukraine

https://wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/08KYIV1144_a.html <-- this one is about Ukrainian spending on a pro-NATO information campaign

The Ukrainian president who was anti-NATO is the one that the Euromaidan deposed. https://www.dw.com/en/ukraine-scraps-nato-accession-plans/a-...

Here's France24's take in 2014 when Ukraine voted to abandon "non-aligned" status: https://www.france24.com/en/20141223-ukraine-parliament-vote... Russia’s annexation of the Crimean Peninsula and its support for the separatist insurgency appear partly rooted in fears that the Western military alliance could expand its presence on the Russian border.

Then in 2019 we have this: Ukraine President Signs Constitutional Amendment On NATO, EU Membership (Radio Free Europe, 2019) https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-president-signs-constitution...

Followed up by Zelensky doubling down on NATO later that same year: https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-president-promises-nato-refe...

And then Trump sending additional lethal aid to Ukraine at the end of the year: https://www.defensenews.com/congress/2019/12/04/trump-to-see...

My personal opinion is that these events in 2019 were the last straw for Putin. He probably made the decision to invade early in 2020....but had to pause those plans while the whole world grappled with COVID. It then took them into mid-2021 to get the ball rolling on staging their forces for invasion, and then they were delayed again due to Xi Jinping telling Putin to not fuck up his Beijing Olympics or he wouldn't get tacit support from the PRC. All of which meant that the early-2022 invasion was likely caused by NATO-related issues that were looking increasingly concerning 3 years earlier.

CapricornNoble··on U.S. pauses all military aid to Ukraine
Look at your situation from a different perspective: the Baltics have ~3 times the population of Gaza, and at the very least something resembling air defenses. Gaza was bombed into rubble but the governing body still exists. Or you have roughly the same population as Lebanon, where Hezbollah completely stymied the IDF ground offensive (they wanted to force Hezbollah north of the Litani) even after paralyzing Hezbollah C2 with the pager attack.

Why are the Baltics not fortified as well as Gaza? Why haven't you spent the past 3 years mining the ever-living fuck out of your border with Russia? Why can't 7 million Baltic citizens hold your territory for 72 hours, when 7 million Lebanese are able to bog down the heavily-mechanized IDF for weeks? Now I will admit that terrain is a HUGE factor, but the seeming total unpreparedness of Europeans to invest in the defense of their own homeland communicates a ton to me....none of it positive.

CapricornNoble··on Federal workers ordered to return to offices without desks, Wi-Fi and lights
Interesting that the CNN article makes no mention of how badly under-utilized government office spaces are.

https://wolfstreet.com/2025/01/25/doge-seeks-to-shed-vast-am... “A recent report from Sen. Joni Ernst, a Republican from Iowa who chairs the Senate DOGE caucus, found that not one of the headquarters for any major agency or department in Washington is more than half full. GSA-owned buildings in Washington, D.C., average about a 12% occupancy rate. The government owns more than 7,500 vacant buildings across the country, and more than 2,200 that are partially empty.”

DOGE is hamfisted in its execution but why are we spending massive amounts of money for office buildings while people work from home? I'm a fan of remote work and would prefer that we crash the Commercial Real Estate market by canceling leases rather that stuffing people back into cubicle farms, but I think the context of trying to kill two birds with one stone (improve building utilization and also identify who is actually doing work and not just fucking off) makes some sense.

CapricornNoble··on Passing the Buck: The story of the 2022 Wings Over Dallas air show collision
Yeah unscripted low-altitude aviation control is something a JTAC would do in combat. This is such a high-risk way to manage aircraft over a crowd of civilians, it's shocking to hear this is normalized.
CapricornNoble··on Wealthy Americans fuel half of U.S. economy consumer spending
I think it depends on how you describe "wealthy". The life of someone who makes $200k a year isn't hugely different from someone who makes $50k. You still have to drive yourself to work and sit in rush hour traffic with every other peasant, for example.

When I think about wealth and quality of life, I'm usually trying to eliminate the mundane in my personal life without even thinking of the "cost". I can afford healthcare, and car maintenance.....but I'm not at a level where I can keep a personal assistant on-call 24/7 to sort through my mail and then go buy groceries even if I want them at 2am or something. It's interesting you mentioned spending a "huge sum" on organic groceries....I think I eat decently well but I live in Japan where adequate-quality food in adequate portions doesn't bust your wallet, especially if you have a USD income.

Until I can just tell someone "I have identified a problem. Make it go away, these are your restraints and constraints in finding a solution." I will still consider myself a peasant, no matter how much grass-fed beef or how many Swiss watches (just bought my first... a used limited-edition Edox) I can afford.

CapricornNoble··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
>which implies the US had no need to produce them because they were superseded in US’ arsenal.

No, it does not imply that they were superseded. It means that the stockpile of weapons and spare parts was considered large enough to support the US's expected burn rate of material. Supplying Ukraine in a peer conflict changed that calculus, requiring new production to keep parts supplies above a certain desired threshold. The M777 is proving to be....not that reliable in the harsh conditions of the Eastern Front.[1][2]

>Furthermore, just because Ukraine received X weapon, doesn’t mean they received the latest and greatest variant that’s in use — they might have very well received a previous generation of said weapon.

This is supposition on your part....and it's WRONG. That's my point. You're simply stating things that are factually incorrect. Ukraine received M777A2s[3], the most modern variant of the M777 in service with US forces.[4]

>Asking which weapon or system replaced them as is in service does not look like discussing in good faith simply because the systems might change or newer variants may be used.

>Do better.

It's not a question of "variants", it's not a question of whether systems "might change", and it's not an issue of grammar errors. You made a false statement, perhaps unknowingly. I asked you to clarify with specifics, perhaps you know some weapon system I'm not aware of (despite having a rough idea of the IOC fielding plan for Marine fires assets in my AO over the next several years), and you've now made 2 posts bereft of details or references to obfuscate the fact that your original post was completely wrong and baseless. All this does is lower HN's already-low signal-to-noise ratio on military subjects.

US Army and USMC towed Field Artillery batteries are equipped with M777A2, the same weapons platform and variant we sent to Ukraine. We are not "a generation ahead" of the equipment sent to Ukraine. Period.

[1] https://www.twz.com/land/ukraine-is-burning-through-155mm-m7...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/25/us/ukraine-artillery-brea...

[3] https://newsukraine.rbc.ua/news/m777a2-howitzer-proves-to-be...

[4] https://www.army-technology.com/projects/ufh/

CapricornNoble··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
>I am willing to bet that military spending will keep ballooning now that the broligarchs are in power and fighting to redirect public spending to their pockets.

Why would you think that military spending would go up, given the tasks the executive has currently issued, and diplomatic direction indicated vis-a-vis other world military powers:

https://apnews.com/article/trump-pentagon-cuts-8-troops-budg...

https://www.axios.com/2025/02/13/trump-china-russia-military...

CapricornNoble··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
>What is true dishonour if not to betray a friend in need?

Great Powers don't have friends. Nor do they have enemies. They only have eternal Interests. (paraphrasing a quote often attributed to Henry Kissinger)

As I was looking for a more exact source for this quote, I stumbled upon this interesting piece in Time Magazine....from 1955:

https://time.com/archive/6798908/no-friends-no-enemies-just-... IT is high time the United States quit throwing money and materials around the world like a drunken sailor and settled on a foreign policy clearly consonant with our national interests first and foremost. We pile deficit on deficit until we threaten ourselves with bankruptcy.

CapricornNoble··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
>the us is at least a generation ahead of that equipment.

Can you list the in service equipment that is a generation ahead of M777 and ATACMs? I sure wish we could get some of these wiz-bang fires assets out here in the First Island Chain.

CapricornNoble··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
>Russia has the economy of a medium-sized EU nation. The EU is vastly more powerful.

This is why GDP is a useless metric. Last year it was reported Russia was manufacturing 3x more artillery shells than the US and whole EU combined.[1] Billion-dollar cosmetics and luxury goods industries don't translate well into battlefield success.

>If the EU wants to, they can give Ukraine everything they need to win.

Except manpower, which Ukraine needs and doesn't have.

[1] https://edition.cnn.com/2024/03/10/politics/russia-artillery...

CapricornNoble··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
>Says who?

Says Ukrainian soldiers, reported by Western and Ukrainian media outlets.

https://archive.is/Pzxl2 (Economist, Feb2025)

https://english.nv.ua/nation/generalsyrskyi-says-he-banned-t... (NV Ukraine, Jan 2025) However, certain categories of Air Force personnel, after preliminary training in training centers, are reinforcing the Ground Forces and Air Assault Forces due to a shortage of personnel on the front.

https://archive.is/YGR00 (WSJ, Oct2024)

https://archive.is/WKqxz (Financial Times, Oct2024 but updated) The commanders estimated that 50 to 70 per cent of new infantry troops were killed or wounded within days of starting their first rotation.

So if they don't have manpower OR enough weapons, maybe when their head of state comes to ask for support from their biggest benefactor, he should, I dunno....not piss off his host? Wouldn't that help him get what he wants?

CapricornNoble··on US Forest Service firings decimate: entire generation of talent and passion lost
> and anyone who cares about being able to escape civilization and enjoy communing with the nature we have left.

Shouldn't that elevate property values in rural areas? Being able to buy a get-away property with a large tract of land and its own forest/lake/mountain/whatever.

CapricornNoble··on Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads editor to quit
I've been arguing that nations already concluded that nukes were the only defense against regime change. The major impetus was the 2003 invasion of Iraq.
CapricornNoble··on Jeff Bezos exerts more control of Washington Post opinion
That was close to the question many were asking when her remarks broke: "She said 'we' lose control.....who is 'we'?" Nobody on HN seems interested in digging deeper on that. It's only when the despicable shady scumbags are aligned with Trump that it becomes a problem.
CapricornNoble··on Jeff Bezos exerts more control of Washington Post opinion
> But it's very telling that more oligarchs are trying to control the _flow of information and ideas_ to the masses. A key requirement of fascism.

People only notice this problem when the oligarchs that they don't agree with are doing it.

https://abc3340.com/news/nation-world/hillary-clinton-warns-...

When Hillary outright said as much last year it wasn't even a blip on HN's radar.

CapricornNoble··on DOGE's only public ledger is riddled with mistakes
>NATO is a defense pact.

Oh lordy. I only ever hear this on the internet and I always find it bizarre. Who is telling people this? University professors? Where and in what subjects? Prime time news programs? Again, in what countries? I've been in the military for 20 years and I've never heard an NCO or officer utter these words. Because it's nonsense. Defense pacts don't conduct totally-offensive air campaigns against countries that none of their members are at war with.[1] There is no formal legal mechanism for NATO as an organization to act as an enforcement arm for UN Resolutions, by the way. If there was, NATO probably should have been bombing Israel since UN Resolution 497 in 1981.

[1] https://www.nato.int/cps/ic/natohq/topics_71652.htm

CapricornNoble··on DOGE's only public ledger is riddled with mistakes
> First off, youre misquoting me. Thats just despicable.

The purpose is to demonstrate that the complaints have no morally universal application. Despicable actions by Ukraine are given a carte blanche. I find it bizarre that people hold it up as some sort of beacon of liberal democracy.

>Second, you have shown us three examples of Ukraine fending off Russian aggression.

So the ends justify the means? Anyone who feels they are "fending off aggression" can kill civilians with carbombs and fatally abuse American citizens in their prisons? That's your position?

>I dont know why you are advancing Russian propaganda

Are you saying that NPR and the Helsinki Times are Russian propaganda outlets? That strikes me as completely irrational, but nevertheless a very common viewpoint among European warhawks. It's no surprise that Europe wasn't invited to the peace talks in Saudi Arabia.

CapricornNoble··on Stargate Project II? Declassified US Government Research in RV and Psi [pdf]
>A bunch of unexplainable stuff could be quantum phenomena somehow showing up at macro scales. The result is often like magic if we don’t know about it

Occult YouTuber "Foolish Fish" touches on this in a video on Quantum Mechanics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20ru6E3cuqc

CapricornNoble··on Stargate Project II? Declassified US Government Research in RV and Psi [pdf]
>Thought control Power is far beyond these hokey accounts that surface. True mastery requires decades and in the meantime your mind swims in delusions and lies.

Curious if there is any reading/study material that you consider reliable for developing mastery? Crowley's Magick: Book IV, Carroll's Liber Null & Psychonaut, or perhaps something completely different?

CapricornNoble··on War rooms vs. deep investigations
I'm not familiar with the "War Room" in the context of computer network operations specifically, but I have deep experience running military operations centers and I'm reading this through that lens.

>People figured out that yes, they had run the machines out of memory, specifically with the push - the distribution of new bytecode to the web servers. Other people started taking steps to beat back some of the bloat that had been creeping in that summer, so the memory situation wouldn't be so bad. I suspect some others also dialed back the number of threads (simultaneous requests) on the smaller web servers to keep them from running quite as "hot".

Cross-functional information exchange. Who is coordinating or directing all these disparate actions? Who is fusing the knowledge gained from these actions? Who is disseminating a clearer picture of "what really happened"? Who is using that updated picture to frame new taskings for all the people doing these independent investigations? The answer to all those questions should be "the staff in the War Room", and the leadership in the War Room in particular. My take-away is that the author is arguing that their ability to pursue single-function actions within their domain of expertise was optimized in their work environment, and was degraded in the War Room. They aren't wrong.

>I guess a "war room" might work out if you have a bunch of stuff that has to happen to deal with a possible "crisis" and then it's just a matter of coordinating it. You don't have people doing "heads-down hack" stuff nearly as much in a case like that.

Exactly. Coordinating a bunch of stuff for crisis management = put those people in the War Room. Focused heads-down tasks = put those people where they can ...focus. Now that said....one thing I've come to HATE about working in a military headquarters is open offices for everyone who isn't the G-shop lead and his/her deputy. Everyone else is shoved into a cubicle farm, probably with ESPN blaring in the background on top of a half-dozen conversations and people constantly dropping by your desk to BS about cover sheets for TPS Reports. So even if you're NOT in the War Room, you can't focus.

CapricornNoble··on Minuteman III test showcases readiness of U.S. nuclear force's deterrent
> Then the Russians can decide whether they still want to try and the US can decide between being collateral damage or helping Europe.

You left out one option in the the US's decision space: a surprise attack against Europe. I don't think the UK & France combined have enough nuclear warheads to cause an Extinction Level Event without US assistance. But still, if they think the destruction of human civilization is the correct position to take, might be best if we help extirpate them while they aren't sufficiently armed.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →