HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CharlesColeman

2,502 karma · joined February 4, 2019

submissionscomments
CharlesColeman··on U.S. Says Accused Apple Secrets Thief Had Patriot Missile File
paywall bypass: https://outline.com/EMvchc
CharlesColeman··on Google under investigation for ‘Thanksgiving Four’ firings, discouraging unions
They get those amenities because the people employing them are making so much more money off of them that the cost is easy to swallow.
CharlesColeman··on Google under investigation for ‘Thanksgiving Four’ firings, discouraging unions
> Do these people even understand how the rest of the country lives? Perhaps some of those well compensated but eager to organize tech workers should focus their organization efforts where it can actually help people.

Unions (or some type of effective worker organization) should be an all-workers thing, not a some-workers thing.

> For example, setting up a union for the gig economy workers that deliver their food, drive them around, pack their amazon packages, or run their errands

Tech workers can't "set up" a union for gig economy workers, that would be patronizing and ineffective. The gig economy workers need to do that for themselves if their union is to have any teeth. What tech workers can do is have a union that can give support to the gig worker union.

Also the tech workers who bask in the gig economy are probably a different group than the tech workers who are trying to organize, and it's misleading to conflate them.

CharlesColeman··on For Sale: The Only Bar in a 14-Person Montana Town
> Spending a quarter million dollars on a four wood walls and a door in a podunk Montana town that is about a 100 mile drive to the nearest town

From the OP:

> The Jersey Lilly was the town’s first brick building, built in 1914 as the first bank of a very different Ingomar.

> The nearest town, Forsyth, is “only” 44 miles away. “That’s really close in Montana, trust me.”

If you want to write a dismissive comment, go ahead, but at least get the facts straight (which were clearly stated in the first three paragraphs of the OP).

CharlesColeman··on The unending quest to explain consciousness
> How is random memory relevant here?

Because memory can be filled with random data, so that's a case that needs to be handled if a computer is to "perfectly simulate itself."

>> That's easy to disprove. A calculator isn't sophisticated enough to simulate itself, but a modern computer can perfectly simulate itself.

> Today we can run entire Linux in a web page and we can surely run a simulation of IBM PC.

You said "a modern computer can perfectly simulate itself." If you think "running Linux in a web page" is an example of that, I don't think you understood your initial statement. A modern computer can simulate a less-capable version of itself, but it cannot "perfectly simulate itself," as I showed in my comment.

It's not a good look to come in with an "easy disproof" that itself contains a pretty obvious falsehood. Also I'd wager your implicit statement that the OP's "to understand" is encompassed by your "to simulate" would be generally considered pretty controversial, at a minimum.

CharlesColeman··on The unending quest to explain consciousness
> That's easy to disprove. A calculator isn't sophisticated enough to simulate itself, but a modern computer can perfectly simulate itself.

What you say is pretty obviously false: a computer with finite memory cannot simulate itself in a general case because that would require more memory than it actually has or a compression algorithm that's effective on random data, because its memory would need to contain the emulation program plus a full memory image. Computers with infinite memory do not exist and random data is not compressible, therefore modern computers cannot perfectly simulate themselves. QED.

CharlesColeman··on The unending quest to explain consciousness
> Indeed. To go even farther, I suspect that there is nothing other than consciousness. There are no particles and forces, only awareness and will.

I believe the word for that is idealism.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idealism

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/berkeley/

CharlesColeman··on China Stockpiles U.S. Chips as ‘Silicon Curtain’ Descends
Paywall bypass: https://outline.com/EYGAS6
CharlesColeman··on The Great Cannon has been deployed again
> This should be mitigated by browser vendors by integrating HTTPSEverywhere as a core functionality of the browser that needs to be explicitly turned off (instead of the current state of affairs where we have a tiny minority on the web who are familiar with installing security add-ons).

We're talking about China, so that's probably not going to work: Chinese users are using Chinese browsers [1] to access Chinese websites. I don't think Chinese browser-makers and website operators are going to take action against their government like that.

[1] https://www.fastcompany.com/3058432/the-top-3-web-browsers-i...

CharlesColeman··on A Week in the Life of a McDonald’s Cashier
And a Potemkin village still has real people in it. The point is: TLC [1] reality TV programs exist to entertain. They'll choose the most entertaining examples, not the most typical or illustrative. That bias means that's it's especially problematic to use them to show how "these people are."

[1] The network of "Here Comes Honey Boo Boo" fame

CharlesColeman··on Are Black Holes Actually Dark Energy Stars?
My guess is they meant to post this link, but forgot to actually enter the URL.

http://nautil.us/blog/are-black-holes-actually-dark-energy-s...

CharlesColeman··on A Week in the Life of a McDonald’s Cashier
> By tech fantasy are we talking about the kiosks which are already providing a value-add to customers?

No, we're talking about the making and packaging diverse types of food to order. That's why people go to McDonalds, and it's something that's surprisingly difficult to automate. McDonalds workers will be able to strike effectively as long as that's true.

Also, I don't consider ordering kiosks a value add for a customer. I've used them, they've been little to no benefit over ordering in person. It's just futzing around with yet another flaky touch screen, and who knows if the last person who used it had a cold or something. Their handling of process exceptions is like Google's customer support: non-existant. They're just a cost saving measure for business owners. It's not about "providing a value-add to customers" at all.

Remote ordering is a small value add, since it does permit some level of customer multi-tasking.

CharlesColeman··on A Week in the Life of a McDonald’s Cashier
>> "Pan frying an egg and some veggies (using food item examples above) takes less than 5 minutes."

> Which includes: 1) Owning a pan 2) Owning a cooking surface 3) Selecting, cleaning, and cutting vegetables 4) Dishes, or owning a dishwasher

It's also worth noting that food deserts are a thing, and they make it much more difficult to eat healthily.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_desert

CharlesColeman··on A Week in the Life of a McDonald’s Cashier
> If you watch any episode of My 600 Pound Life, you will realize just how unwilling some of these people are to help themselves

Please don't use point-and-gawk trash TV shows to make generalizations about the world.

See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9al-mpqXjc

CharlesColeman··on A Week in the Life of a McDonald’s Cashier
> They will be replaced by machines and the consumers are going to see a value-add.

This is tech fantasy, like Musk promising that Teslas will be fully self-driving any minute now.

CharlesColeman··on A Week in the Life of a McDonald’s Cashier
>> I'm probably going to catch some flak, but I see some optimizations she can make.

> This woman is literally living paycheck to paycheck, and your suggestion is to... put money into a 401k? That simply isn't an option for people living in poverty like this.

Another optimization she could make is to save the money she spends on food for herself and her family. It won't be easy, but after a few years of not eating she could probably save up enough learn to code and pull herself up by her bootstraps. /s

CharlesColeman··on Why Taxpayers Pay McKinsey $3M a Year for a Recent College Graduate Contractor
> it's the political cover to make changes they knew they should make all along

Or the political cover to make the changes they wanted to make all along.

CharlesColeman··on Why Taxpayers Pay McKinsey $3M a Year for a Recent College Graduate Contractor
The actual article title is "Why Taxpayers Pay McKinsey $3M a Year for a Recent College Graduate Contractor," don't know if it was edited or the poster just chose something different.
CharlesColeman··on Spain planning on going ahead with ‘Google tax’ despite US tariff threats
> People always look at it differently once it's their money being taken away.

Yeah, they tend to take on a more selfish attitude. People will also believe all kinds of dumb or awful things if they think it justifies their self-interest (hence the cliched quote I won't repeat).

That's why I think moderation rather than ideological purity is probably the way to go.

> Anyone who thinks running a business is easy or more profitable than it should be should try to run one.

Making ends meet isn't easy for a lot of people, either. For them, their hard work doesn't have as much of an upside at your hard working business owner.

CharlesColeman··on Wikipedia Has Cancer (2017)
Would de-indexing the clone pages from the start help, so only the improved pages are indexed?
CharlesColeman··on Wikipedia Has Cancer (2017)
> It's generally terrible or controversial on current events or recent history.

Or any person with any kind of ideological charge, especially a boogeyman to some group or other.

The problem with Wikipedia is the fanatics with infinite time, which it accumulates because they're the ones who never give up. The other issue is it's inability to actually deal with problematic users, as the moderation doesn't teach the fanatics to be good, it just teaches them to not be so bad they'll be banned.

CharlesColeman··on Economists Are Rethinking the Numbers on Inequality
> If everyone had the same amount of money, these things would still be allocated on the basis of who's willing to pay the most for them - that is, who's willing to give up the most other things in order to get that thing.

Though that's arguably a better situation from the equality perspective. Right now we have people who are allocated everything they want and others who are allocated none of what they need. Taking redistribution to a monomaniacal extreme is probably a bad idea for well understood reasons, but that doesn't mean that redistribution doesn't have its place.

CharlesColeman··on Economists Are Rethinking the Numbers on Inequality
> Exactly. Tax the capital that those other bastards have. My house? Oh, that’s totally different.

So, progressive taxation, basically?

CharlesColeman··on Economists Are Rethinking the Numbers on Inequality
> I'm fairly well acquainted with the literature on this topic

How so, exactly?

> and I think the opposite; the fact that most people don't understand why these "nitpicks" actually seriously undermine the premise and totally butcher the prescriptive suggestions

Personally, I'm inclined to withhold judgement until the dust settles, yay or nay. The topic is technically difficult, and there are a lot of actors with political interests in the outcome of the discussion that muddy the waters.

CharlesColeman··on Economists Are Rethinking the Numbers on Inequality
> It means [a billionaire] has more power than me in a capitalistic system, sure. But is that really so wrong or unfair?

Where does that leave democracy?

> I think it’s actually kind of a good thing: most people would just consume like crazy and ruin the planet if they came into that kind of money...

That bears a striking resemblance to some anti-democratic rhetoric I've seen. For instance, one of the rationales the CCP gives for the lack of multi-party democracy in China is that the Chinese people would use their political power irresponsibly, so it's better for everyone that the [insert positive adjectives here] party have a monopoly on political power.

CharlesColeman··on Economists Are Rethinking the Numbers on Inequality
> note that i'm not taking a position on the conclusions of Piketty and Saez, just pointing out that re-stating their claims does not say anything about the papers that argue against them and calling such papers nitpicky seems like a particularly weak critique in this instance.

There's another angle: in a general-interest publication like the Economist, over-emphasizing nit-picky flaws that fail to effect the core arguments of a work can have the effect of giving general-interest readers the impression the work has more serious flaws than it actually has.

CharlesColeman··on McKinsey and Company: Capital’s Willing Executioners
> capitalist realism

I've never heard this term before, but it's perfect. The implicit assumption that certain capitalist economic theories are literally the real world (rather than limited and imperfect models) is something I've been noticing more and more, but never had a term for.

CharlesColeman··on Singapore's fake news law should be a warning to American lawmakers
Context matters, though. A law may have a beneficial effect in a democratic country with a strong culture of distributed oversight, but the exact same law may have an adverse effect in an authoritarian country.
CharlesColeman··on The Plain Text Project
Simple is always better, the problem is that "simple" isn't the same for everyone because different people have different needs. Simple is often simplified into "one one size fits all," which often just ends up being limiting.
CharlesColeman··on Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" to identify phone users
> My wife has had a few messages "disappear" from WeChat (the Chinese Facebook), and that were not removed by group admins. It seems that at the low end, at least, they're content do just censor, and not take action against the speaker.

Is she in China or overseas? WeChat has different censorship policies for domestic vs foreign accounts, and silent blocking sometimes occurs when foreign accounts communicate with domestic accounts about sensitive topics [1]. It's also not encrypted, and it appears messages are automatically getting forwarded to the local (Chinese) police for investigation [2].

[1] We (can’t) Chat “709 Crackdown” Discussions Blocked on Weibo and WeChat: https://citizenlab.ca/2017/04/we-cant-chat-709-crackdown-dis...

[2] Over 300 million Chinese private messages were left exposed online: https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/4/18250474/chinese-messages-...

← PreviousPage 4 of 26Next →