HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DoughnutHole

1,418 karma · joined April 9, 2022

submissionscomments
DoughnutHole··on Not all TLDs are Created Equal
Ireland is an unusual case because we grant citizenship based on your connection to the island rather than the country, ie pretty much anyone entitled to British citizenship on the basis of being from Northern Ireland is also entitled to an Irish citizenship.

Specifically you can be entitled to citizenship from birth if either of the following conditions are met:

- at least one parent is an Irish citizen or entitled to be one and was born on the island of Ireland

- you are born anywhere on the island of Ireland (including Northern Ireland) and at least one parent is an Irish or British citizen, a permanent resident of Ireland or Northern Ireland, or has been domiciled on the island of Ireland for 3 of the past 4 years

You're no longer automatically entitled to Irish citizenship via a grandparent born in Ireland if your Irish parent was born overseas unless the parent's birth was registered with an Irish diplomatic mission.

DoughnutHole··on Deleting and destroying finished movies
Many animals are extremely social - they'll attack you for taking the group's resources, they won't necessarily have any individual resources. At the extreme end you have things like ants with no individuality, but you also have social mammals that are more group-oriented than individual-oriented.

If you look at anthropology pre-modern humans were extremely family/tribe oriented. Resources were generally the property of the tribe as a whole. I don't think that the modern understanding of personal property would translate well to someone from such a culture, which makes me sceptical of the idea that personal property is an innate element of human nature.

DoughnutHole··on Pakistan cuts off phone and internet services on election day
Other countries have managed economic miracles without mass suicidal tendencies.

Plus, that explosive growth has ended. South Korea escaped poverty and now its growth rate is comparable to western countries with much better suicide rates.

DoughnutHole··on Pakistan cuts off phone and internet services on election day
It’s not even remotely the same, it’s nearly 50% higher than the US (which isn’t doing that great either).

South Korea has the 10th highest suicide rate in the world.

DoughnutHole··on How to hire low experience, high potential people
Well he seems to advocate getting rid of the stupid and industrious.

The stupid and lazy can be put to work and will probably get something harmless done, they just can’t be trusted with anything challenging.

The stupid and industrious are an active danger wherever you put them in the hierarchy.

DoughnutHole··on Final Decision on Chromebook Case in Denmark
The existence of pre-internet distractions doesn’t negate the potency and pervasiveness of post-internet distractions.

Yea bored kids have always found ways to entertain themselves in class. But this is a matter of scale.

Kids being able to covertly play battleship on pen and paper is many steps removed from every kid in the class being constantly plugged into a network where the wealthiest companies in the world are spending billions of dollars competing for their attention.

Kids with unfettered access to the internet in the classroom might as well be sitting in a casino.

DoughnutHole··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
Even an “ad-free” Netflix plan is infested with promotion of their in-house productions.
DoughnutHole··on How AI is changing gymnastics judging
Great point on competition in schools. The competitive focus of sports in schools rewards those that are already athletically gifted while shaming and discouraging the mediocre.

That's great if the purpose of PE is to create elite athletes. If the point is to encourage a healthier population by instilling an appreciation for sport and physical activity in kids it's an abject failure. Kids that are already good at sports love PE, while less gifted kids develop a disdain for sport and by adulthood have often dropped all sports and exercise.

DoughnutHole··on Dana-Farberications at Harvard University
Today's high school grads wouldn't do well because their education covers entirely different topics. They don't learn Latin and Ancient Greek, and history and geography don't focus almost entirely on Ancient Greece and Rome (unlike 7/9 of the questions on that section of the test).

The math section has some hard wanky arithmetic and by-hand computations using logarithms. Modern students would struggle because that hasn't been a focus of math education since the invention of the calculator. Your average physics professor would struggle with that because no one needs to do that stuff by hand any more. A modern Harvard applicant would ace that algebra section. The geometry section is 50/50 - there's still plenty of geometry in modern education but it no longer involves memorising Euclid.

On the other hand there's no calculus/analysis which is probably the biggest focus of higher-level high school math - something an applicant of that era would be flummoxed because it wasn't part of classical math education. There's also a complete dearth of any of the natural sciences which was again neglected in a classical education.

I'm telling you that that's not an intrinsically difficult exam, it just covers areas that were the focus of an upper class classical education of the time. You're confusing a different educational focus with intrinsic difficulty. If your math education up to the age of 18 was 90% long-form manual computations and memorising Euclid's Elements you'd ace that section too.

DoughnutHole··on Dana-Farberications at Harvard University
> and those were the sort of people applying.

Those were a tiny minority of the people applying.

Nothing in that entrance exam requires an academic outlier. All it requires is a classical liberal arts education (Latin, Greek, classic literature, history, geography, geometry)

Most people who attended higher education could do so because wealthy children received such an education above and beyond what the poor received (and because the could also afford college thanks to that wealth).

DoughnutHole··on Culture Change at Google
That's a weird distinction you've constructed to make it sound more okay to be offended if you feel you hold the more traditional position.

> take offense (idiom) : to become angry or upset by something that another person has said or done : to be offended by something - Merriam-Webster

That's all it means. If you're upset because someone says something different to what you consider the natural default you're still offended.

People take offence to changes to and transgression against cultural norms all the time - offence at public gay affection, offence at interracial relationships, offence at not respecting christianity and religious norms, offence at use of swears, offence at the normalisation of talking about sex etc etc.

Taking offence to certain changes to language isn't necessarily wrong, but it's still taking offence. "Taking offence" is what happens to you when something transgresses against your belief system, it's not just what the bad people do.

DoughnutHole··on How a software glitch at the UK Post Office ruined lives
At the very least qualifications and licensing should be required for anything critical, or for any engineers writing software that does work that would otherwise be done by a legally liable licensed professional.

Components at every stage of the design and manufacturing of a commercial airplane are signed off by licensed engineers who are legally liable for negligence, and yet Boeing could outsource the 737 Max's software to $9/hr programmers in India. Obviously physical engineering failures still happen, but it's ridiculous that there's no liable professional responsible for software that keeps a plane full of hundreds of people from falling out of the sky.

If a licensed accountant was caught lying about hundreds of people stealing from their employer to the point of getting some sent to jail he could easily do jail time for negligence or perjury. Instead some seemingly anonymous dev wrote shoddy software that ruined hundreds of lives and the Post Office gets to just say that the computer did an oopsie.

DoughnutHole··on Rethinking Diabetes – interview with Gary Taubes
Potatoes have a GI of about 70, comparable to white rice or white bread (pure glucose is 100). So pretty bad.

The “potato diet” will only lead to weight loss if you’re eating fewer calories than you’re expending, same as anything else. You could eat nothing but bacon grease and you’d lose weight if you were eating below maintenance.

The effect of food on blood glucose if a matter of how easily it is converted to glucose. Starches like those in potatoes, flour, rice etc are basically converted nearly as easily as straight sugar.

DoughnutHole··on Rethinking Diabetes – interview with Gary Taubes
Leaving starchy foods to rest for a decent amount of time after cooking results in some amount of the starch converting into “resistant starch” which the body can’t convert into glucose. So a given portion will be less blood glucose spiking than a portion that hasn’t had that rest.

The overall effect is modest though, the whole thing doesn’t turn into resistant starch. It makes it better, but I don’t think it would make a big portion of potatoes suddenly safe for a diabetic.

DoughnutHole··on Microsoft overtakes Apple as most valuable company
What have you added with this comment?

He’s offered a short opinion on the behaviours of two companies and made something of an ethical judgement.

Why disparage someone for daring to have an opinion?

DoughnutHole··on 95% of container ships are now going around the Southern Tip of Africa
It was an entertaining story that could be followed minute-by-minute.

It was funny that a single ship could get stuck with such a huge impact on the global shipping industry, so people were tuned in. And you could follow day by day with the plans and attempts made to dig out the ship. Great, simple fodder for the 24-hour news cycle, and memes probably made people more engaged with the story.

With the Houthis it's a big, complex geopolitical mess, and all the oxygen in the room is being taken up by the war in Gaza. No big countermoves have been made so all there is to be done is report on the strikes when they happen, the threats made by various powers, and speculate if the US is going to intervene in some significant way.

The Ever Given was an acute issue, and acute issues are attention grabbing. The attacks in the Red Sea are a progression of a war that the average person in the west doesn't really understand that's been going on for 9 years.

DoughnutHole··on Apple Vision Pro available in the U.S. on February 2
The Mac Pro & Mac Studio made up 10% of Mac sales, which are in turn only 10% of the business. What percentage of those users bought the Pro Display? And what percentage of those bought the pro stand? It's an overpriced peripheral for an already incredibly niche $5,000 monitor.

It's already established that smartphones are a huge market, and people are willing to pay a lot for what for most people is their main computer. Android manufacturers like Samsung are also selling $1,000 flagship smartphones.

No one's claimed that no one is going to buy the vision-pro. But there's no demonstrated huge existing demand for an extremely high-end VR headset. It's unlikely that a product nobody asked for costing $3,500 is going to give the technology mass market appeal or kick off widespread adoption.

DoughnutHole··on Are roads the biggest driver of ecological destruction?
I don’t think vast suburban single family home housing developments, big box store parking lots and Wendys drive thrus are the drivers of technological development you’re making them out to be.

The overwhelming majority of environmental degradation is not being caused by cutting edge technological development. Wasteful and destructive development patterns are not what’s driving technological growth.

DoughnutHole··on Give Us Something to Look At: Why ornament matters in architecture
The floor space of an actual Dublin Georgian townhouse is frankly enormous - the houses seem narrow but they’re very deep. We’re talking 5000 square feet between the 4 floors in a country where the average house is 1000 square feet. And that’s in the densest part of a dense, old city.

These things weren’t built for mom, dad and 2.4 kids, but much larger families (6? 8 kids?) who were rich enough to have their own staff living alongside. Many were eventually subdivided into tenements and by the 20th century one street managed to fit 835 people between 15 houses.

There’s a reason well maintained Georgian houses sell for approaching €2 million euro. These new Georgian-style builds are targeting the very wealthy rather than trying to be practical city centre housing, in Ireland at least.

DoughnutHole··on Researchers discover physical cause of long Covid tiredness
I wouldn’t characterise 1% as an “extremely small chance”, especially considering the prevalence of the disease, especially if it’s possible to develop it on your second or 3rd infection. Would you play Russian roulette with a gun with 100 chambers?

Compared to new-onset arthritis from the vaccine - the biggest lit review I can find found 45 confirmed cases across 31 studies. [1] For comparison there are over 730,000 (self reported, admittedly) cases of long covid lasting more than 104 weeks in the UK alone. [2]

[1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10055862/

[2]: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...

DoughnutHole··on "No inventions; no innovations" A History of US Steel
Just because the US got a useful ally in the long run doesn’t mean that the military objective was met. That wasn’t the objective of the war.

The objective of the US once they pushed back the initial invasion in the Korean War was to destroy the DPRK, force communism out of Korea, and unify the country. They failed. The war became a stalemate once China got directly involved.

If Vietnam becomes a stalwart ally of the US over the next 20 years that won’t mean the Vietnam War was a success just because the US ended up eventually having a useful interest in the region.

DoughnutHole··on Gas utilities used tobacco tactics to avoid gas stove regulations
But if the costs can be passed on then that’s a means for emitters to differentiate on cost. If manufacturer A emits more and passes the tax onto the consumer, manufacturer B can undercut on them on price if they’re more efficient.

Right now there’s minimal financial benefit to being more carbon efficient. If anything it’s disincentivised because efficiency is itself costly, so it’s cheaper to just emit.

DoughnutHole··on Gas utilities used tobacco tactics to avoid gas stove regulations
The target is really industry. If no one has to pay the cost of emissions no one has any incentive to change.

Look to the oil crisis of the 70s for examples - it was a bad time but the cost of fuel spurred a surge in sale of small cars because fuel efficiency finally mattered. On another front it spurred the cycling culture of the Netherlands - they didn’t take up cycling and build infrastructure to support it out of altruism, they did it because their fuel supply was nearly cut off entirely.

Innovation only happens when there is a reason to innovate. If carbon emissions don’t cost the emitter anything then there’s no reason to invest in ways to emit less.

DoughnutHole··on Gas utilities used tobacco tactics to avoid gas stove regulations
If there’s a negative externality to the fuel it should be priced-in, which is really all carbon tax is intended to do. You can still use gas but you have to pay for the environmental cost upfront. The carbon footprint of electricity usage would be taxed as well, but if it’s overall more efficient it would have a lower carbon tax.

Even electrical resistance heating is more carbon efficient than burning gas at home. This doesn’t even require a high-renewable grid - it produces less CO2 burning gas for electricity to run an electric stove than it does burning gas at home due to the efficiency of a modern gas power plant and the dreadful waste heat of a gas burner.

DoughnutHole··on Gas utilities used tobacco tactics to avoid gas stove regulations
They’re just trying to muddy the waters.

Just shouting that someone has an “agenda” is enough to make some people uncritically drop any facts that are uncomfortable.

In this case it’s honestly silly. News publications started widely publishing articles on gas stoves when research papers came out a couple of years ago indicating they posed health risks. They didn’t all simultaneously develop an anti-gas stove “agenda”. At worst you could argue that they’re being sensational for clicks.

This compared to gas industry publications. They actually have a pro-gas agenda because when people buy gas they make money. They and the people they lobby have an actual financial stake in making sure people use gas stoves.

DoughnutHole··on Ask HN: Share your favorite software blog posts of 2023
Probably the most pompous drivel I’ve read all year.

This isn’t a software blog post. It’s a juvenile political screed with some tech buzzwords.

DoughnutHole··on Did English ever have a formal version of "you"? (2011)
English became the lingua franca of science because of the decline of German science following the world wars. English became the language of commerce due to the commercial dominance of first the British Empire and then the United States.

So still not really due to some intrinsic merits of the language.

DoughnutHole··on Why do programmers need private offices with doors?
Blaming extroverts/introverts is a red herring - it’s down to the nature of the work.

Whether they’re introverts or extroverts a programmer’s job tends to require a lot of solo focus. There’s collaborative aspects of course but it always requires windows of deep work that are deeply frustrated by distraction, introvert or not.

Many other areas of work (including much work in upper management) don’t require that focus. The work is often deeply collaborative and communicative, and it‘s work that can be dropped and picked up on a dime and iterated on without much loss of productivity. In a way it’s work that actively benefits from a “distracting” environment, because it’s often full of rapid-fire blockers best resolved by grabbing someone nearby.

The friction comes from the fact that the people who do either type of work don’t understand the other type if their whole career has only involved one type.

DoughnutHole··on Commission opens formal proceedings against X under the Digital Services Act
The speech culture of France and Germany is very different to the US as well, it's not just the dictatorships of the recent past.

Nazism as an ideology is illegal to promote in Germany. Use of Nazi symbols outside of an artistic or educational context is illegal in Germany and France (most European countries really). Several neo-nazi, neo-fascist, and communist parties have been banned since the founding of the modern German state. Far-right parties in Germany are always walking a fine line - if their membership flirts too much with nazism or fascism they are very much liable to be banned.

Several European countries with strong democratic traditions in the modern era remain very wary of extreme ideologies. Their proponents murdered millions and burned the continent to the ground less than a century ago. Most people are comfortable with the state killing these movements in their infancy.

DoughnutHole··on Commission opens formal proceedings against X under the Digital Services Act
> For me it was at best a slight help if I was trying to find a celebrity that had impersonators.

That's exactly why it was useful. Major institutions and public figures have impersonators, some satirical and others intentionally misleading. The check made it easy to sift what actually came from someone and what was either lies or satire.

On that front it hasn't gotten too bad because the grey and gold checkmarks exist.

Now blue checkmarks are a sign to ignore the tweet because it's someone who's just paid to boost their signal. Of course this has rendered the thread of replies to a given tweet unusable since the top posts are all posts by people who have paid to be seen rather than posts with more likes or retweets (actual signals of value/popularity).

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →