HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Emma_Goldman

1,588 karma · joined August 17, 2017

submissionscomments
Emma_Goldman··on The effects of sleep debt
What about the compound effects of a sleep surplus?

I sleep 9 hours a night, sometimes slightly more, and I often worry that I might have conditioned my body into accepting more sleep than it needs - with potentially negative long-term consequences. But when I sleep less I feel off. I think of the quantitative length of my sleep as offsetting the qualitative hit it suffers from my daily caffeine.

Emma_Goldman··on MIT scientists think they’ve discovered how to fully reverse climate change
The problem of climate change is not one of generic 'overconsumption and waste' but of bringing greenhouse gas emissions to net zero. Most of the electricity, transport and industry currently dependent on fossil fuels can be greened. There are important exceptions, like aviation, and in those cases reducing consumption would be helpful. But for the most part it's a question of substitution, not reduction.

We are also living through an ecological crisis whose causes are far more entwined with over-consumption. But that's because it has causes additional to climate change.

Emma_Goldman··on Amazon spending $465M on season 1 of The Lord of the Rings series
>"They are happy with is precisely the problem. Amazon has cranked out a lot of mediocre tv shows that don’t have any significant greatness."

This - the fact that this is an Amazon production already tells us a great deal about what to expect.

I have a low expectations for TV, but the Amazon catalogue has really plumbed new depths. It is an artistic wasteland. Just reading the title of this thread I therefore thought, 'How is this going to work out?' If you add to that the concerns of the OP, it does not look good.

Emma_Goldman··on Steelmanning: Discover the truth by helping your opponent
>"But steel-manning really helps break out of that pattern and meaningfully connect with what others are saying."

Steelmanning means that you ignore the argument your interlocuter makes, in favour of the argument you think they should have made. It runs diametrically counter to trying to 'meaningfully connect with what others are saying'.

If someone says 'X because Y', and you respond 'I think you mean X because Z but that's wrong', you have simply spoken past your interlocuter. Perhaps they actually meant 'X because Y2', but you didn't give them time to expand upon what '2' is. Or perhaps there's some other subtlety or depth that they have yet to expatiate.

There are lots of associated problems:

1. It is very difficult to say what a different version of the 'same' argument is. Perhaps you reason from different premises to the same conclusion. Perhaps you reason from the same premise to a better conclusion. Perhaps you use a similar style or tradition of argument. Really, only your interlocuter knows what 'their' argument is.

2. What you think is the strongest version of an argument is, may not be what a second or third person thinks the strongest argument is. In some realms - moral and political - there are no mind-independent facts in reference to which one argument can be objectively justified over another. 'Strongest' is therefore relative.

3. If you default to talking about an argument your opponent did not make, that is liable to create enormous confusion. If they did the same thing, you would end up never actually talking to one another. It would be like Chinese whispers, each rationally reconstructing the other's last statement.

What you really want to do is both 'interpret and understand' another's point of view, and then argue it through. The OP's link actually does a pretty good job of describing just that, but I think describing that as 'steelmannanning' is a misnomer. It's just philosophy as it has been understood for millennia. Steelmanning is supposed to be something more original.

Looking it up, this is claimed to be the original coinage of the word:

'Then we would be steelmanning, the art of addressing the best form of the other person’s argument, even if it’s not the one they presented.'[1]

[1] https://themerelyreal.wordpress.com/2012/12/07/steelmanning/

Emma_Goldman··on Sue Big Oil
I think the case for activism like this is fairly simple:

(1) We need a managed decline of oil that does two things. One, achieves cost-effective emissions reductions on pace with limiting the rise of the global average temperature to 2C. Two, retains enough production for those activities that are difficult to find carbon-free substitutes for, like the kind of heavily concentrated thermal energy key to a lot of industrial processes.

(2) We are veering far past that trajectory. The policies of the governments of the world currently put us on course for an average expected 2.7C warming. [1] Current production plans suggest that in 2030 the world will be producing something like twice the oil it should. [2]

(3) We should use whatever sensible means possible to push oil production down towards the decarbonisation slope consistent with 2C (and ideally towards 1.5C), including - if and where it works - litigation.

[1] https://climateactiontracker.org/global/temperatures/

[2] https://productiongap.org/2021report/#2021downloads

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
That blindingly obvious fact is why I wrote 'implied deficit' in the parent comment. Scotland has public expenditure and tax intake figures. There are things you need to apportion - like oil revenues and UK debt obligations - but even with generous assumptions, if it became independent it would be running a large deficit. This isn't just a random figure.

This is a good overview:

https://www.economicsobservatory.com/what-might-the-public-f...

Emma_Goldman··on How James Patterson became the world’s best-selling author
> You can somehow just tell they're garbage without even taking one off the shelf.

For better or worse, I honestly think I just blank out these kinds of books. Still, I would have thought that the existence of a living author selling in the hundreds of millions would trickle down to me through one cultural tributary or another. Maybe through articles like this, through a blockbuster film adaptation, through word of mouth, etc.

Emma_Goldman··on How James Patterson became the world’s best-selling author
The title is misleading. Patterson is not the living author to have sold the most books. JK Rowling has sold more, and perhaps others (Akira Toriyama, Danielle Steel). [1] I think the claim is that he is currently selling the most per year.

Oddly, I had never heard of Patterson. How is that possible given his apparent cultural dominance?

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_fiction...

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
I am going to keep my comments to a minimum because I think this is becoming an unproductive exchange.

> But that's contradicting the original point

You have said there's a contradiction, but have not said what it is. I have no idea what you think it is.

> Scotland consistently votes to the left. And there is no way we can get a left-wing government, because England votes to the right.

It is obviously possible for the UK to elect a left-wing government. I don't know why you think otherwise.

> This isn't a randomly selected bloc

My point is that there is no reason to expect a bloc of 59 constituencies to consistently decide the outcome of general elections. That is not in and of itself necessarily a problem. You need further, independent arguments to show why it is a problem for Scotland.

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
>Whoever England votes for, Scotland gets. We could've sent 59 Scottish Labour MPs to Westminster in each of the last three elections and it wouldn't have changed a thing, because England wanted a Conservative government.

In 2017, if Scotland didn't elect 13 Conservatives to Westminster then Theresa May would not have been able to form a government with the DUP. If it also didn't elect 4 Liberal Democrats then Theresa May would not have been able to form a government even if she somehow managed to establish a three-way power-sharing agreement with the DUP and the Liberal Democrats. In that event May probably wouldn't have been able to form a government, and there would have been new elections. And remember, May was in abysmal straits at the time.

> You're very carefully dodging the main point

Well, the 'point' wasn't a response to the existing conversation. It was a random interpolation, and I didn't find it very remarkable. In a Parliament of 650 seats no randomly selected bloc of 59 constituencies is likely to play a deciding role in the outcome. It will happen sometimes, but not often. But why would it be otherwise? Of course, if you start off with the belief that Scotland is an independent entity that merits complete self-determination, then that will be a problem. But that begs the question, again.

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
>"In the few exceptions where England voted Tory but got Labour because of Scottish votes, how was that fair on England?"

You can always say that if one region that voted for the winning party in a close election hadn't, the outcome would have been different. I don't understand how that's unfair, it's inherent in the arithmetic of majoritarian democracy. You could say the same thing about London or the northwest, which both err leftwards. Unless you're starting off with the idea that Scotland and England are fundamentally different units? Which begs the question.

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
Reserves have fallen severalfold since the basin was opened in the 1970s. Oil and gas cannot be produced on the same scale for the same returns as in the past. Most of the best wells have dried up.

The UK and Scottish governments are both committed to net zero, which means the managed decline of the North sea oil and gas industry. Sturgeon has publicly taken a harder position on this than Johnson since COP26.

If Scotland became independent nothing would change. Unless you think the SNP will confect new reserves out of nothing and abandon their climate pledges?

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
Scotland's deficit is persistent. Between 2014-15 and 2019-20 it averaged 9.2%, compared to 3.2% for the UK as a whole. [1]

Infamously, the SNP's envisioned post-independence budget was based on their forecast for annual oil and gas revenues: £10bn. In reality they have averaged an order of magnitude less: £1bn.

Oil and gas are volatile commodities so there will be year-to-year fluctuations but the secular trend is clearly downwards. The best wells have run dry, and the UK is committed to net zero by 2050 and Scotland to net zero by 2045.

[1] https://www.economicsobservatory.com/what-might-the-public-f...

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
Sure, but that is politics. Given the overwhelming view of the EU will be to admit Scotland, there would likely be a quid pro quo. Spain would drive its bargaining position to extract concessions from the rest of the union in exchange for its consent.
Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
Scotland's implied deficit in 2020-21 was £36.3bn, or 22.4% of GDP. [1]

When the SNP set up the Sustainable Growth Commission before the last independence vote it advised that public sector cuts would be necessary to reduce the country's deficit to sustainable levels. [2]

You can't just make things up because you wish it was so. It is not sensible.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/aug/18/scotland-soa...

[2] https://ifs.org.uk/publications/13072

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
I have no idea what you are talking about. In the UK general election citizens of all realms of the UK vote, meaning that Scotland being more left-wing has led to comparatively more left-wing UK governments than would be the case in its absence. So 'if you want rid of the Tories', Scotland is a great asset.
Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
The formal criteria are that a country is a stable market democracy, other than that accession is really a political matter (see Ukraine and Turkey). Clearly there would be a groundswell of support for incorporating a Scotland fleeing from Brexitland. It would be a coup for the EU.
Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
> "Note that it's an open question if the Scots economy would remain worse per capita, not disagreeing there is/was pain ahead in transition"

"Remain" is doing a lot of work here. Scotland runs a sizeable deficit with the rest of the union and with the decline of North Sea oil revenues that will only increase. Of course that might not "remain", but leaving the UK and then joining the EU is going to create a 5-10 year period of turbulence as well.

Still, there's more important things than GDP.

Emma_Goldman··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
Because Scotland is a part of the United Kingdom and their secession is therefore of great consequence for the rest of the union - how is that not obvious? I live in Scotland FYI.

I am undecided on independence, but clearly part of the calculus is how it effects matters of concern to the rest of the UK. Consider what is to me, the following con and pro:

(1) Scotland is more left-wing than the rest of the UK and its secession would condemn the rest of the union to indefinite right-wing government.

(2) The UK's nuclear subs would have to be restationed, but there isn't a suitable harbour anywhere in the rest of the UK, creating an opportunity for it to be scrapped.

Emma_Goldman··on New CRISPR-based map ties every human gene to its function
Churchill had some virtues of leadership, but he was an abominable racist and colonialist, even by the standards of his time.

>"Churchill is on record as praising “Aryan stock” and insisting it was right for “a stronger race, a higher-grade race” to take the place of indigenous peoples. He reportedly did not think “black people were as capable or as efficient as white people”. In 1911, Churchill banned interracial boxing matches so white fighters would not be seen losing to black ones. He insisted that Britain and the US shared “Anglo-Saxon superiority”. He described anticolonial campaigners as “savages armed with ideas”.

Even his contemporaries found his views on race shocking. In the context of Churchill’s hard line against providing famine relief to Bengal, the colonial secretary, Leo Amery, remarked: “On the subject of India, Winston is not quite sane … I didn’t see much difference between his outlook and Hitler’s.”"

https://amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/mar/17/why-ca...

>"He referred to Palestinians as "barbaric hordes who ate little but camel dung." When quashing insurgents in Sudan in the earlier days of his imperial career, Churchill boasted of killing three "savages." Contemplating restive populations in northwest Asia, he infamously lamented the "squeamishness" of his colleagues, who were not in "favor of using poisoned gas against uncivilized tribes.""

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2015/02/03...

Emma_Goldman··on The children of atomic bomb survivors: A genetic study
>"The biggest single indicator that something terrible happened is simply the life expectancy chart for Russia which shows a profound dip for about 5 years after Chernobyl. (This gets blamed on soaring alcoholism post collapse, which isn't particularly credible.)"

Why not? That there was endemic alcoholism is well known and easily explainable. Not only an entire empire collapsed, but an entire lifeworld. Some of the best Russian testaments as to what happened after the end of the Soviet Union, like Svetlana Alexievich's Second-Hand Time and Andrey Zvyagintsev's Leviathan, place great emphasis on it. I mean look at Yeltsin - he was drunk non-stop, and it almost killed him during his presidency.

Emma_Goldman··on Mental illness, mass shootings, and the politics of American firearms (2015)
Sorry I meant to add this statistic (updated now):

"The most recent statistics show that on a per-capita basis Czechs own about one-tenth the number of guns Americans."

The Czech Republic has 10% the per capita gun ownership of the US, and some moderate controls on ownership, and suffers from occasional mass shootings. That seems to me consistent with the idea there's a relationship between gun ownership, and its lax regulation, and mass shootings.

The Czech Republic has less ownership, a bit more regulation, so has less mas shootings. But it still has them because those values are not 0.

Emma_Goldman··on Mental illness, mass shootings, and the politics of American firearms (2015)
Yeah just imagine "mass arrests" of an armed population in the United States...

Meanwhile 1 in 3 black men are imprisoned over the course of their lives.

http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.1525/sp.2011.58.2.257?uid=3...

Emma_Goldman··on Mental illness, mass shootings, and the politics of American firearms (2015)
Do you really think that the US has oppressed its population less than comparably well established European democracies? Given its history of slavery, Jim Crow and mass incarceration? Given the militarisation if its police, the war in drugs and it's all-watching surveillance state? Given McCarthyism and the Patriot Act? And you're citing COVID?

I am frankly astonished by your claim. It's so obviously wrong.

Emma_Goldman··on Mental illness, mass shootings, and the politics of American firearms (2015)
Those are not like cases. The picture in Belgium and the Czech Republic does not seem inconsistent with the thesis that lax gun rights, and mass gun ownership, are heavily related to rates of mass shootings.

Belgium:

"Until 2006, Belgium had surprisingly lax gun control laws. After a man shot two innocent people, however, the nation become increasingly concerned with the illegal flow of firearms. The 2006 legislation requires gun permits to be renewed more frequently and sought to prevent the impulsive purchase of guns by requiring prospective gun owners to go through a three-month process which includes an extensive police screening. Six years later, in 2012, the European Union passed regulation aimed at interrupting the transportation of guns across borders by requiring exporters to obtain a special license.

Today in Belgium, it's not easy to own any type of gun, unless it's a rifle or shotgun. The nation prohibits the private possession of fully automatic weapons, and permits ownership of semi-automatic weapons only in certain case scenarios. Furthermore, the private possession of handguns is only allowed after obtaining special permission from the government. In the country, long guns, such as rifles and shot guns, are the only guns not prohibited by the state. According to GunPolicy.org, these regulations categorize Belgium as a country that has "restrictive" gun control laws."

https://www.bustle.com/articles/149385-what-are-brussels-gun...

Czech Republic:

"The most recent statistics show that on a per-capita basis Czechs own about one-tenth the number of guns Americans.... Still, owning a gun in the Czech Republic isn't so easy. Permits are for 10 years and are reviewed after five years. People have to pass a written and practical test, as well as a medical check that includes mental health, and a clean criminal record...

Mass shootings are rare in the Czech Republic, but not unknown. In 2019, seven people plus the gunman were killed in Ostrava, and in 2015, eight people plus the gunman were killed in Uherský Brod. There was also a case in 2009 with four victims plus the gunman."

https://www.expats.cz/czech-news/article/how-does-gun-owners...

Emma_Goldman··on I'm quitting my PhD
> "Aiming to produce PDF files that would be accepted at conferences (which seems to be easy-going if you sprinkle some fancy quantum vocabulary over something and hand it in to a non-quantum conference). I felt less and less comfortable in a setting that apparently expected me to pick some low-hanging – let’s call it fruits – and call it a day. After all, science is all about the pursuit of knowledge, even though the incentives of research funding might not be entirely aligned with that"

This is broadly similar to my experience. The priority of most academics is not to produce deep, novel, and creative work. It is to churn out sausages in the shapes favoured by journals, at a factory production rate. That's what they have to do for their career. After a while, though, they start to be unable to tell the difference between the two.

Emma_Goldman··on Why is the nuclear power industry stagnant?
I agree that use is more important than installed capacity, but I don't think whether the fossil fuel share of electricity generation today is the same as in 2010 or 10% lower makes any difference to my point. Saying that 'coal/gas' fell when coal fell, and gas rose, is unhelpful. And renewables did not substitute for nuclear while gas did not, because both were used to get generation back to meet 100% of Germany's needs. Basic arithmetic tells us that if you need to reach a certain proportion of renewables in your energy mix, and you take away 5% of your capacity which is renewable, you have made it harder and not easier to reach your goal. And the less renewables, the more fossil fuel generation. Hence the rise of natural gas, and the drawn out coal phase-out.
Emma_Goldman··on Why is the nuclear power industry stagnant?
Difference might be accounted for by capacity versus actual factor use - though 2021 might not be a representative year because of COVID if you are referencing the latter. But I can only guess. Your statistics are useless without a source. Mine:

https://www.cleanenergywire.org/sites/default/files/styles/p...

Emma_Goldman··on Why is the nuclear power industry stagnant?
> "If you take coal and gas together and look at overall fossil based generation, it declined and continues to decline."

In absolute terms the combined capacity of coal and gas is the same now as it was in 2010. It has fallen as a share of the total because output has increased.

https://www.cleanenergywire.org/sites/default/files/styles/p...

> "The unspoken implication of nuclear proponents is that Germany started putting out more CO2 because they shut down nuclear. The reality is that there was a continuous decline in fossil fuel related emissions related to electricity production."

I am not a partisan in this argument. But clearly that's a strawman. The argument is that if Germany hadn't taken its nuclear capacity offline then it would have been in a better position to more rapidly decarbonise its energy mix. In one simple sense that's true: nuclear energy is clean, and so by getting rid of it you need to add more clean energy that you would have otherwise to decarbonise. That is, Germany would not have had to increase gas imports at the rate it did, and would not have had to drag out its coal phase-out.

Showing that fossil fuels have decreased in relative terms as a share of the energy mix does not show that it would not have fallen faster with nuclear online.

> "There are no international deadlines other than what was agreed at Cop 26, which thanks to China and India avoids any big explicit commitments."

I was writing in a hurry. I meant that the most respected models of the pathways to net zero tell us that coal needs to be eradicated across advanced economies by 2030. The IEA's Net Zero scenario, which is widely taken as a benchmark by policymakers around the world, says just that. Everyone in Germany knew their original 2038 phase-out date flouted their responsibilities.

Emma_Goldman··on Why is the nuclear power industry stagnant?
> "Actually, Germany did not have a long term increase in coal/gas due to the nuclear shut down but a decrease"

Arguably this is semantics. But that's because the semantics of your claim is unhelpfully ambiguous. In absolute terms coal and gas make up approximately the same share of Germany's capacity as it did in 2010. In relative terms, because the total output has increased, it's share has fallen. But I say it is unhelpful because one has fallen, the other increased.

> "Gas production did grow but mainly to offset declines in coal"

I don't think this is semantics. For the reasons given, it's just wrong.

The statements together make it look like you're trying to misrepresent the facts to support a particular view about nuclear energy.

← PreviousPage 5 of 17Next →