HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

George83728

544 karma · joined April 27, 2023

submissionscomments
George83728··on Don’t store cash in Venmo and PayPal, US regulator warns
The defense (lie) is here: "These accounts are safe and transparent,"

Safe: No, people lose their money to these companies all the time.

Transparent: No, these companies stonewall people after stealing their money. They claim this stonewalling is legally required by AML laws or to deny information to criminals, but no matter which way you slice it, 'transparent' is a lie.

George83728··on Red Hat dropping support for LibreOffice
> It is a miracle to me how anyone can think that packing for a specific distro is their job? It is not. The job is documenting how to package the software and allow redistribution.

I think the mentality of authors who package their projects for a specific distro comes from their familiarity with Windows, where there is only one distribution (more or less) and packaging for it is naturally the responsibility of software authors. They mistakenly apply their windows experience to the new task, probably entirely unaware of the faux pas.

Often, knowing that there are a myriad of Linux distros, they mistakenly assume that the community of linux users are expecting them to support dozens of distros individually, testing on each one, and they become reasonably upset with that (mistaken) obligation. So they stamp their foot down and say "I support Ubuntu 13.04 specifically but if you use another distro then you're on your own!!" Then they go on to complain about fragmentation and say that linux users need to pick one distro and stick with it. Really, nobody expected them to support any specific linux distro in the first place but that is poorly communicated to otherwise experienced programmers who are new to linux.

George83728··on Red Hat dropping support for LibreOffice
Exactly, one has nothing to do with the other. Or maybe people think that the Red Hat employees presently tasked with packaging LibreOffice also happened to be graphics stack specialists with the experience needed to bring HDR to Linux. That seems unlikely to me.
George83728··on This site is no longer solar powered for now
The worst case scenario with a lead-acid battery is some manner of electrical fault leading to electrolysis in the batteries, releasing hydrogen and oxygen gas which subsequently may cause a very violent explosion.

I've never heard of a house blowing up like this, but it has happened with submarines.

George83728··on How the CIA used Crypto AG encryption devices to spy on countries for decades (2020)
Sometimes the HN crowd champions something so often and so enthusiastically, it starts to set off alarm bells. Signal, Mullvad, and Tor all seem a little bit too good to be true, and the amount of messaging I see to the contrary makes me suspect these might be honeypots targeted specifically at people who think they're too savvy to fall for honeypots. Not a strong suspicion, but greater than zero.

Maybe I'm just being paranoid. I pay for Mullvad anyway, if my worst suspicions are true then it will still be good enough to hide my petty torrenting from MPAA lawyers (which is beneath the concern of the CIA/etc anyway.) There's no way I'd trust it if I were in Snowden's shoes though. For anything that might plausibly interest the CIA/NSA/FBI, I would not trust these tools (or others) to keep me private.

George83728··on Scan iPhone backups for traces of compromise by “Operation Triangulation”
The fact that you think you can just handwave away legal obligations like this with common sense is certainly telling. It says you don't know what you're talking about. You could reasonably assert that the government's ban of Kaspersky's software is motivated by FUD. However the ban itself is very real, violating the ban can get you into a world of trouble, so warning people to stay out of trouble for violating that ban is not FUD.

Explained by analogy: Them: "Smoking marijuana can get you into trouble with the government." You: "That's just FUD, it's a harmless plant from my garden, it's not going to hurt me."

George83728··on How the CIA used Crypto AG encryption devices to spy on countries for decades (2020)
You've brought up Snowden twice but I'm unfamiliar anything Snowden revealed about the relationship between the Washington Post and the government. Can you expand on this point, ideally with some specifics?

Usually when people talk about the CIA being involved with American media, it's in relation to things like Operation Mockingbird, but as far as I know Snowden didn't reveal anything about programs like that. Snowden revealed things like the existence of PRISM, and the Washington Post (along with The Guardian) was one of the first newspapers to publish such revelations.

George83728··on US Air Force colonel ‘misspoke’ about drone killing pilot
This isn't the first time there's been a BS story with this plot. A few years ago I was hearing it about a supposed AI artillery system in Japan that went wild and killed its creators. Never happened.

People keep falling for fake news ripped off from Ghost in the Shell.

George83728··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
The local political / NGO class are corrupt and in bed with the local construction companies. They all live in the same nice gated neighborhoods, go to the same clubs and schools, intermarry each other, etc. And so they all profit from this cycle of developing land on the taxpayers dime then letting it get trashed by the homeless. All the while the homeless continue to terrorize the general public, providing the impetus to keep this grift going.

The general public gets terrorized by the homeless and vote for any politician that offers a solution. The politicians offer 'solutions' that only enrich themselves and their NGO/developer friends (more money for more housing!), while not actually addressing the problem of homeless terrorizing the general public. The homeless just keep doing what they do, enabled by the politicians who seek to keep them locked into their destructive lifestyles while pretending to help. The homeless are given de facto permission to continue harassing regular people in the street, vandalizing and stealing from shops, wander through working class neighborhoods screaming in the middle of the night, etc.) They are permitted to do all of this because it keeps the pressure on the general public to vote for the corrupt politicians who profit from it.

The only way to break this cycle is to clue the public into the dynamic, but most people who figure it out will move away for greener pastures, instead of sticking around and trying to reform local politics.

George83728··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
Prince George as non-failing? Have you been there? I've never seen so many zombified homeless junkies wandering aimlessly than I have in Prince George. Not in Vancouver, San Francisco, Portland, or Seattle. Not in any other city. Prince George is horrific. Honestly the worst town or city I've ever had the displeasure of visiting. All of the 'normal' people inside businesses had thousand yard stares, shell shocked, and asked why I would even visit their town.
George83728··on Scan iPhone backups for traces of compromise by “Operation Triangulation”
Do you think you would enjoy the process of trying to convince a court that their laws don't apply to python scripts? (they do, btw)
George83728··on When photography “produces something other than photographs”
So I take it you're a conceptual artist?
George83728··on Rarbg Is No More
Stack Overflow seems to still be running well.
George83728··on Rarbg Is No More
> I guess he meant what he wrote

Radical notion these days. Everybody has an ulterior motive, probably one you find offensive, and you have to read between the lines and make uncharitable assumptions about their motives to find them out.

George83728··on Rarbg Is No More
Streaming is a content ghetto. 9 times out of 10, none of the streaming websites have the media I'm looking for. When I visit friends and family and am made to sit down with their streaming services and find something to watch, it always turns into a disaster of everybody sitting on the couch browsing the various catalogue on their phones, discovering that no service has whatever movie somebody just thought of and suggested.

If you treat streaming like old cable television; you turn it on then decide what you want to watch from what is available, I guess it might seem fine to you. But if you try to decide what you want to watch first, treating streaming as a means to an end rather than the end itself, then streaming is unmitigated trash.

George83728··on Ask HN: Is it just me or GPT-4's quality has significantly deteriorated lately?
Quite a few of them work just fine. Dissolving styrofoam into gasoline isn't exactly rocket science. Besides that, for every book that tells you made up bullshit, there are a hundred other books that give you real advice for how to create mayhem and destruction.
George83728··on Ask HN: Is it just me or GPT-4's quality has significantly deteriorated lately?
> The percentages thing was what made me realise this. When I talk to highly intelligent people, I use percentages to estimate probabilities. When I talk to typical people in a normal workplace setting, I dumb it down a bit and avoid using numbers. I've noticed that average people don't like percentages and it confuses and even angers them.

10% of people are comfortable with comments phrased as my comment here is, using percentages as a quick shorthand for communicating gut intuitions and suspicions about complex subjects. When on similar intellectual footing as the interlocutor, they can easy distinguish numbers invented on the spot to communicate intuitions from serious claims about the data. Nobody in this 10% would make the mistake of thinking that I assert 10% to be the real number. 10% is too round and generic, if I claimed 9.7% then things would be different but "10%" obviously isn't meant to be taken literally.

90% of people balk at this imprecise rhetorical use percentages because they're pretty sure the person doing it is trying to pull a fast one, fabricating data out of nothing to make themself sound authoritative.

George83728··on CPR's true survival rate is lower than many people think
When the American Red Cross trained me in CPR, they told me this statistic, and told me that the reason they told me this was so that I wouldn't blame myself if the victim dies anyway (the most likely outcome.)
George83728··on As rising oceans threaten NYC, study documents another risk: The city is sinking
> The crust of the earth is floating on liquid rock.

This is a common misconception. Molten magma under the crust only exists in a few places, the crust by and large rests on the mantle, which is solid. The mantle is extremely thick, but below it eventually is the outer core, which is liquid.

George83728··on On the Reign of Cleopatra
I read the article, I know she has been slut shamed throughout history, but that isn't the sort of story I said netflix should tell. It is possible to depict Cleoptra as a privileged narcissist and a powerful sex-positive person simultaneously. Sexy powerful women are popular. What isn't necessary, or evidently popular, is portraying Cleopatra as a empathetic and effective leader dedicated to the Egyptian people, which the article informs me, is what the Netflix show did. The show is, by the way the article describes it, flagrant monarchist propaganda.

> As far as I know, the only controversy around the series was in the portrayal of Cleopatra as black

Refer yourself to the beginning of your own comment.

George83728··on On the Reign of Cleopatra
Shaming?

Anyway, whatever it is that people are looking for, the ratings say that monarchist propaganda wasn't it. I think Cleopatra as a sex-icon, like Elizabeth Taylor's version, would sell.

George83728··on On the Reign of Cleopatra
So I take it the new show depicts Cleopatra as a respectable and honorable monarch? Rehabilitating royal reputations seems like a strangely right-wing take for a modern netflix show. Why would they even do this? Wouldn't the traditional telling of Cleopatra as a seducer of powerful men who tragically snakes herself in the end get more people interested? I think that's the version of Cleopatra that has captured public attention for so long.
George83728··on Killer whales wreck boat in latest attack off Spain
Birds I bet. Parrots can kind of, sort of, talk to humans. And besides that, I bet many species of birds can effectively communicate with others. There are dozens of species of crow, I bet many if not all of them can understand at least some of what the others are saying.
George83728··on George Takei recalls his childhood in an internment camp
I've never met anybody who thinks FDR was a "perfect god". Abe or Washington, sure, but no such personality cult exists for FDR. So what are you even responding to? I have not criticized anybody for pointing out FDR's flaws (which were numerous and are widely acknowledged.)
George83728··on George Takei recalls his childhood in an internment camp
> Hawaii, not a US state at the time, was largely occupied by the US military prior to Pearl Harbor. After Pearl Harbor its residents were subject to martial law and their civil rights were suspended. The situation there was not analogous to the situation on the mainland, so I wouldn't use it to draw any conclusions.

This isn't the reason relatively few Japanese-Americans were interned in Hawaii. Compare it to Alaska. Like Hawaii, Alaska was an incorporated US territory. Japanese-Americans were ordered out of Alaska or interned.

The reason general internment didn't happen in Hawaii is because:

> "The powerful businessmen of Hawaii concluded that the imprisonment of such a large proportion of the islands' population would adversely affect the economic prosperity of the territory.[74] The Japanese represented "over 90 percent of the carpenters, nearly all of the transportation workers, and a significant portion of the agricultural laborers" on the islands.[74] General Delos Carleton Emmons, the military governor of Hawaii, also argued that Japanese labor was "'absolutely essential' for rebuilding the defenses destroyed at Pearl Harbor."[74] Recognizing the Japanese-American community's contribution to the affluence of the Hawaiian economy, General Emmons fought against the incarceration of the Japanese Americans and had the support of most of the businessmen of Hawaii.[74]"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America...

Japanese-Americans were a third of Hawaii's population, so interning them all would have been a disaster for Hawaii's economy and harmful to the war effort. That's why it didn't happen in Hawaii. German-Americans, unlike Japanese Americans, were a very large portion of the population in all states and territories, not just Hawaii. The needs of economy and war obviously wouldn't tolerate the internment of all German-Americans, so it didn't happen.

If you think general internment of German-Americans would have been implausible regardless of population size, because the Germans were white, you need to remember that perception of race has never been a rational matter. During WWI, Germans were racially 'othered' in the UK and US by assertions off Germans being "asiatic Huns" and similar nonsense. Nevermind that you couldn't visually distinguish an average German from an average Anglo, racial othering is obviously not bound to rationality. This inclination to racially other the enemy is only tempered by substantial ethnic overlap between the two warring parties. Where there is substantial ethnic overlaps, discrimination will be officially discouraged and resisted because it impairs the war effort (e.g. Executive Order 8802). Where there is little ethnic overlap, racial or ethnic discrimination often become convenient to the government and becomes officially sanctioned.

George83728··on George Takei recalls his childhood in an internment camp
It was nonetheless the first time the Federal Government prohibited racial/ethnic employment discrimination, and was the first civil rights executive order since Reconstruction.
George83728··on George Takei recalls his childhood in an internment camp
I believe that the only reason most German-Americans were not interned is because they were too large a portion of the population to intern without seriously negatively effecting the war effort.

My evidence for this belief is the fact that Japanese-Americans represented a third of people living in Hawaii, more than 150k of them, yet in Hawaii only ~1800 Japanese-Americans were interned. About 1%. This, despite the fact that Hawaii was closer to the war than the rest of America, and despite the fact that the Niihau incident occurred in Hawaii. Interning a third of the population of Hawaii simply wasn't practical, so in Hawaii they had to exercise much more discretion.

Furthermore, some people believe that Executive Order 8802, which forbade ethnic and racial discrimination in defense industries, was intended more to prevent discrimination against German-Americans and Italian-Americans than against African-Americans. Supposing that is true, it evidences the perception of FDR's administration that discrimination against German-Americans, despite their skin color, was a plausible scenario and would harm the war effort if permitted.

Further evidence for the plausibility of ethnic discrimination against Germans, despite their skin color, is easy to find during WWI. Across America and the UK, German families (including the Royal Family..) changed their names to conceal their German origins. Schools stop teaching German, businesses were renamed, sauerkraut became "liberty cabbage" (freedom fries, anyone?) The Red Cross even forbade people with German last names from joining.

tl;dr: The federal government recognized the potential appetite for discrimination against German-Americans, but forbade this because German-Americans were a very large portion of the population and excluding them would harm the war effort. At the same time the federal government perpetrated discrimination against Japanese-Americans, except they exercised more discretion in Hawaii where Japanese-Americans were a very large segment of the population.

George83728··on George Takei recalls his childhood in an internment camp
The same FDR signed Executive Order 8802, forbidding ethnic and racial discrimination in the defense industry and federal government.
George83728··on 12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric cars revealed
Unsprung mass doesn't slow you down per se, it just ruins your ride quality and makes the vehicle harder to control. It's simple kinematics.
George83728··on Whistleblower drops 100 GB of Tesla secrets to German news site
!!!! 2 meters separation at 70 km/h gives you a tenth of a second to react to anything the car in front of you does, that's flatly insane. Where in the world do people drive like that?

Seriously, that's objectively insane. Try the ruler drop test for reaction times if you don't believe me, a 10th of a second to even initiate your response isn't realistic and obviously gives no time for the response itself to have effect. What I'm saying is that at a tenth of a second, you can't even start to press the brake pedal in time, let alone have enough time to actually slow down.

In America, with only 2 meters between vehicles the traffic would be inching forward at a snails pace, under 20 km/h at least. "Stop and go", as in people would stop their car and then drive forward slowly when a larger gap ahead of them appears.

← PreviousPage 6 of 13Next →