HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

IAmBroom

2,759 karma · joined March 3, 2025

submissionscomments
IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
Not a dictionary, but an article from a company that sells dictionaries. It's sad that you don't even understand the definition of a dictionary.
IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
Not a dictionary. Also, your link admits democracy may be defined as pure populist voting, so you self-defeated.
IAmBroom··on Meta Ignores Brazilian Court Order to End Bolsonaro Favoritism
You DNRTFA, and ask what is in TFA.
IAmBroom··on Oregon Police Are Charging a Local News Outlet $2.5M for Records About One Cop
No, it merely raises a possibility. It does not prove any likelihood.
IAmBroom··on Birdwatching rewires the brain and slows cognitive decline
From birdwatching/neural plasticity to environmentalism/anti-Russian sentiments.

Wow.

IAmBroom··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
And while you're at it, make real change happen in the US national elections by voting for a third party! That'll show them!
IAmBroom··on Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans
Western = 1.3 billion people Asian = 5 billion people World = 8.3 billion people

How is 24% a majority in your imagination?

IAmBroom··on Local Wikipedia: Wikipedia, but only for things a half hour walk from you
I think it's an odd side-effect of our built-in prejudice to value our tribe over strangers, which is a safety feature in all social animals.

"A plane crash in <other country> killed all passengers, including 2 from <our country>" is a fairly common news styling.

IAmBroom··on Muse exposes users' personal and business secrets when they share conversations
Your argument is predicated on condemning every company without any evidence, based on "I sound cool when I neg".
IAmBroom··on Muse exposes users' personal and business secrets when they share conversations
Fallacy of appeal to worse problems.

That argument could just as equally validate them ignoring their job altogether and collecting a paycheck from the beach of Aruba.

IAmBroom··on They Fled Trump's America. Now They Regret It
Exactly.
IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
> My comment was more about how the US media/english-speaking media

So, irrelevant to the topic under discussion?

IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
All governments fail their citizens. Nothing is a panacea.

Constitutions exist to provide friction to fast-moving populist votes. They prevent the two wolves from eating mutton after the vote. They are not immutable; they are hard to change, and can limit simple-majority votes.

IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
> Democracy is not only rule of majority.

It is. Use a dictionary.

The fault is in equating "democracy" with "fair and stable governance through mostly democratic means". A LOT of people in this thread are making that incorrect gloss of the terms.

IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
Read the definition of that word. It literally is. And strict democracy is therefore a bad system of governance.

"Democracy" is not synonymous with "good".

IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
I'd like to agree with you, but what you really mean is "limited democracy".

Democracy's definition contains no such safeguards, just as pure capitalism doesn't prevent monopolies.

Pretty much everyone agrees that "50.01% of us agreed to slaughter the rest" is not a good decision, but it is technically a democratic one.

IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
There is an extralegal loophole as well. There always is; it's the explicit motivation behind the USA's 2nd Amendment.
IAmBroom··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
You are using the general term "minority" without context. That is intentionally deceitful.

A voting minority cannot by itself gain power in a democratic election.

A population minority may vote with, against, or mixed versus the eventual majority. It is not the same as active participation in voting.

IAmBroom··on Butlerian Jihad
> Vinge quite famously pointed out that you can't write sci-fi about super-intelligence because you have no idea what a super-intelligence would do

That's silly. We have no idea what a god would do; many have written fiction about them (and I'm not slyly slamming the Bible: intentional fiction).

In fact, from Colossus: The Forbin Project to Avengers: Age of Ultron, many authors have written about intelligences greater than ours and their "obvious/inevitable" decisions.

IAmBroom··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
Agreed, but Meta will never tell us if the action was deliberate, so we are reduced to guessing from shreds of evidence.
IAmBroom··on I built a drone with only one motor [video]
You are overly hopeful, I suspect.

A significant portion of Russia's attacks are purely on civilians. Even Ukraine's attacks on RU targets have civilian side casualties.

Terrorism will probably always be a thing.

IAmBroom··on Gold is now the top U.S. export
I remember that incident vividly. They did not "just" mistakenly cut a cable; they were hotdogging below allowed elevations in forbidden, populated areas.

The official story is that the maps they were given were out-dated and led to confusion in their location.

It was painfully obvious that the incident was inspired more by Top Gun than those notoriously bad maps the USAF uses....

But as you say, the USA investigated itself and assured its little buddy Italy that there was nothing improper. So sorry about those dead folks.

IAmBroom··on Gold is now the top U.S. export
You are arguing about net cost/profit.

We don't export nor import "net" anything. The definition of exports is not affected by imports.

IAmBroom··on Gold is now the top U.S. export
You've just described a large part of why Jews are so prominent in gem and jewelry trade. If a family's real estate and capital wealth are seized by Christian rulers, jewels and precious metals are the best value-by-weight to sneak a portion of it out during a pogrom.

The other reason is the Christian historically yes-and-no relationship with usury (banking).

IAmBroom··on Butlerian Jihad
> I always imagine the jihad to be a fairly benign if not peaceful exercise

"Jihad" is an Arabic word meaning "struggle", and usually used in English to mean "violent religious war". Are you unaware of this blatant plot hint?

IAmBroom··on Butlerian Jihad
It actually gets the effects of relativity backwards: stars would change in shape from circles to ovals, squishing in the direction of travel near c.

What happens for V>c is of course undefined, and practically speaking, turning dots of light into even-skinnier dots of light would be boring AF to watch, so space travel in visual media ALWAYS does the stretchy-thing.

IAmBroom··on Butlerian Jihad
Backwards. Kynes was engineering the desert planet to be greener. He was sent to study it, probably in the hopes that the Empire could replicate it elsewhere. The planet had been a desert since time out of memory.

What isn't explained is why, when their chief Arrakis-ologist went native, they didn't replace him with multiple others.

IAmBroom··on Butlerian Jihad
Weavers didn't have high-paying jobs. They were working middle-class at best, with substantial support by lower-class entry and unskilled positions.
IAmBroom··on Butlerian Jihad
Wat Tyler's Rebellion failed.

It went similar to Sparticus', which was also a movie. Braveheart is also in that class, even if William Wallace was himself landed nobility.

These are films of the underdog class trying to overthrow the ruling class... and failing. The leaders are dealt with gruesomely (IRL and movie depictions).

IAmBroom··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
Trump is a manipulator. He is totally lacking in self-awareness in one aspect, and yet very aware of how to use his speaking and actions to promote himself in another.

It's never as simple as "they are very self-aware" or the opposite extreme.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →