HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JamesMcMinn

1,830 karma · joined November 8, 2012

submissionscomments
JamesMcMinn··on Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation
Haven't experience coil whine myself from my XPS 13 9333, or my XPS 15 9560. Dell seem happy to replace the entire device or mainboard if you do get one that has an issue though.

I was under the impression the reason not to get a butterfly keyboard was because they are prone to failure due to dust and crumbs?

I'm not even sure what you mean by the brightness cannot be manually adjusted? The screen brightness obviously can be manually adjusted, and every XPS laptop I've owned has at least 3 levels of keyboard brightness controllable via F10, software, and can even be set in the BIOS.

Precision isn't really better, just different, since you can get one with (older) Quadro GPU rather than a GTX card, and a Xeon rather than Core CPU. The chassis, display, support, build quality is otherwise identical.

JamesMcMinn··on Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation
Dell's XPS range, for example.

Can be configured with more memory, a better display, better port selection, is user upgradable and is still very light and compact...

JamesMcMinn··on Ask HN: Does Apple slow down old Macbooks as well?
So it was literally impossible to run the device at full load for extended periods? Presumably the battery eventually hit 0 and the devices was then power limited? That's insane. I assume thermals prevented it before the battery did, however for premium devices, it seems like a profit protection measure for Apple, rather than a cost saving feature for uses.
JamesMcMinn··on The math and algorithms behind a search library
This is a an interesting way of doing text search over a collection of documents, that I suppose makes sense if you only have a small number of documents to search.

Generally, an inverted index [1] is used rather than a trie, and collection-based term weights are calculated using something like IDF [2]. You could then use something like cosine to compute length normalised rankings for documents.

There are of course many different approaches to text search, but this is the first time I've personally come across this one.

If anyone is interested in an in depth look at how text search works, an Introduction to Information Retrieval [3] is available for free and is a fantastic book.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_index

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tf%E2%80%93idf

[3] https://nlp.stanford.edu/IR-book/

JamesMcMinn··on Caddy 0.10.10 Released Along with New Pricing Structure
> Those "quick surveys" that we all either skip (if possible) or just enter random bullshit into so that we can just download the damn file and get on with our work?

They've already got something built into the download page to configure plugins. All it would have taken was an additional question and a few radio options:

   I plan on using Caddy for:
     [ ] my personal website   [ ] my startup  [ ] other commercial
> Those blog posts that 95%+ of customers never read or, if they do, won't bother commenting on?

People already follow their social accounts etc. to be notified of updates. Plenty of people will read a post "We're thinking of charging for Caddy", and even a 5% response rate would be in the hundreds or thousands.

Plenty of people have done it in much more difficult markets with fewer resources. It's never easy, but Caddy had some good options they never used.

Welcome to the world of market research. It's how you avoid launching a bad product at the wrong price. The alternative is getting it very publicly wrong and having to backtrack.

JamesMcMinn··on Caddy 0.10.10 Released Along with New Pricing Structure
> To be fair they had no idea about their potential customers and assumed most of which were hobbyists.

That's kind of the point though - a quick survey at download time, or a post on a blog describing proposed pricing and the caddy-sponsors header would have given them a lot of the information they needed to make an informed choice. Instead they made assumptions and got it very wrong.

Unlike most commercial launches, they already had a large userbase to gather information from, they just chose not to use it.

JamesMcMinn··on Caddy 0.10.10 Released Along with New Pricing Structure
So, launching a product or service 101: speak to your potential customers first to gauge their response and limits.

This is a good change. I'm glad they listened to feedback on pricing and removed the header. Had the commercial licence lunched like this, would there still have been unhappy people? Probably, yes, people like to complain and don't like to pay, but I don't think it would have even been on the same scale. Instead, I think the majority of people would have understood that developers need to live.

The pricing change seems great - the startup plan looks good (you can pay monthly!), and the price per instance for other commercial use looks much more reasonable.

JamesMcMinn··on AMD Ryzen – 6 cores for the price of 8. Some got really lucky
Title should probably ready: 8 cores for the price of 6.
JamesMcMinn··on Ubuntu 17.10 Final Beta Is Ready For Testing
As I understand it, the version of Gnome they're shipping is vanilla Gnome with a few extensions enabled by default, all of which can be disabled using Gnome Tweak. There's no need for a separate session.
JamesMcMinn··on Announcing Caddy Commercial Licenses
I do love the HN community sometimes, that's two people who've told me my startup will fail because I've decided Caddy's commercial licence isn't a sensible option for me, yet neither has actually understood the details of the change.

It's $100/month for 2 instances, you can only pay annually, so $1,200 is the minimum you can pay and it nets you two instances, not 24.

If it was $100 for a year and included 5 license to cover live and dev environments, I'd probably have just bitten the bullet and paid for it. I don't really care for the "basic email support" being offered, I just want to serve web traffic.

JamesMcMinn··on Announcing Caddy Commercial Licenses
The startup has extremely limited resources, it's a bootstrap, as I explained. The licence prohibits us from using the personal licence, and there is a time cost involved in building and maintaining our own version. $1200 a year is not good value for us when NGINX will do the job for free.

I never claimed that no one should pay for anything, and I wish the people working on Caddy the best of luck. I think it's a fantastic piece of software and, as I have said several times, I am very grateful for the effort that has been put into making the project what it is.

However the change means that I have to act or be left with an out-of-date internet facing server. If you cannot see why I am annoyed at being given no choice but to spend time or money on solution because Caddy has introduced a new commercial licence, then I will not convince you of anything.

JamesMcMinn··on Announcing Caddy Commercial Licenses
Because it feels like a bad investment.

In terms of cash, $1200 a year is a lot to me personally, I'm a student, I have no income, and I'm trying to bootstrap a startup. $1200 could feed me for a year. Even when I had my PhD stipend, $1200 was a months stipend.

I originally chose to use Caddy over NGINX because it made https easy: just download, configure, run. If I have to remove the sponsor code and build it myself, it loses the advantage it had over NGINX because now I've got to spent time creating a build script and updating it whenever Caddy makes changes. With NGINX, sure, I'll have to configure it and letsencrypt, but I'll only ever have to do that once.

JamesMcMinn··on Trello Desktop for Mac and Windows: Get More Done Without Distractions
No Linux version is disappointing, especially considering it's an Electron app. Other than global shortcuts, it doesn't seem to offer much over using the web version as a Chrome app with its own launcher and window.
JamesMcMinn··on Announcing Caddy Commercial Licenses
Or perhaps I'm a student with no income trying to write a thesis at the same time as bootstrap a startup, and can't afford to spend $100/month on a reverse proxy? The new EULA states I'm not allowed to use the personal build, so I have little choice in that matter.

Your "worldview" doesn't seem to extend past the end of your own nose.

JamesMcMinn··on Announcing Caddy Commercial Licenses
Matt, I really do appreciate the work you and others have put into Caddy - it's a fantastic piece of software which has served me well for the past year and a bit.

Having said that, this change has put me in a position where I have to invest either time or money into a solution for a problem which I didn't have yesterday, and switching to NGINX seems like the path least likely to cause issues in the future.

Having to build my own version of Caddy for every update is a cost I'm not willing to pay. Since I'm being forced to invest in something, it may as well be NGINX, and I suspect I'm not alone in this.

JamesMcMinn··on Announcing Caddy Commercial Licenses
Well, I guess I'm moving switching from Caddy to NGINX then.

I like Caddy, it's been great, but I have no interest in paying for support, and I'm certainly not going to pay to remove a HTTP header.

Yes, I could spend time setting everything up to build custom versions of Caddy without the header, but it'll be quicker and easier to switch to NGINX.

Whilst I really appreciate all the work that has gone into Caddy, I am extremely annoyed that it's now going to cost me at least an afternoon to move away from.

If you're an existing Caddy user and don't want to (or can't) pay, your options are either don't upgrade, server ads for Caddys sponsors, or spend a significant amount of time configuring your own build process/switching to something else.

I can't help but feel this move is going to be bad for Caddys adoption.

JamesMcMinn··on How I, a woman in tech, benefited from sexism in Silicon Valley
I usually avoid commenting on these sort of posts because frankly I don't believe I have a lot I can add to the discussion, but this is an interesting read, and I think the final paragraph is probably correct in how it frames the current situation - neither "side" will be happy until both are happy. The question isn't "should we be doing something?", it's "how do we do it?" and how do we have that discussion without it turning into something else?

At the same time, we've also got to remember that this isn't just an issue in tech, it's an issue across the whole of society, and as an industry we should be looking at the broader picture, because this isn't an issue that technology can face alone, but it is one that affects tech more than many other industries.

I really hope this is something we, as a society and industry, can improve upon. I'm lucky enough to work with a lot of people from a lot of different backgrounds and cultures, and they're all great at what they do, but very very few of them are female. I'd love to think that I was above any bias (both positive and negative) that this introduces, but the fact is, I'm probably not because I'm only human. Until we can make tech more balanced, it's a bias that I will have to consider and try to overcome.

JamesMcMinn··on Spotify preps to go public with 60M subscribers
I have a USB DAC, that's exactly how it works for me...it'll happily switch between the builtin audio and USB DAC while playing, too.
JamesMcMinn··on Spotify preps to go public with 60M subscribers
I'd rather Spotify went public than got bought by Apple, Google, Microsoft or Amazon. The competition is good for everyone.
JamesMcMinn··on Dell XPS 15 9560 Review
I've had the XPS 9560 since February. I mostly run Fedora (26), but have also run Solus and various versions of Ubuntu. I have a Windows 10 install which I use for Photoshop, Lightroom, and some mobile gaming.

Specifically, the version I have comes with a i7 7700HQ, 32GB RAM, 1TB SDD and 4K screen.

Hardware wise, the laptop is lovely, and the build quality of mine is good, although it hasn't been perfect as I'll get to later. The screen is honestly the best I've ever used, although I do sometimes notice ghosting due to slow response times, I understand in that regard it's comparable to the retina displays used in MBPs.

Performance wise, the hardware speaks for itself. It's a very powerful machine. I haven't experienced any of the lag or video issues that others are reporting. It'll happily play games and crunch whatever data you throw at it, without any thermal issues.

My model was a very early version, and came with which I can only describe as a mushy keyboard which often did not register key-presses. I contacted Dell support, who after a short over the phone test, agreed it was not satisfactory and arranged for an engineer to be at my house the next day to replace the keyboard. This fixed the issue, and the keyboard has been fine ever since. Compared to the new MBP keyboards, I much prefer the 9560 due to the extra travel.

I've also had the GPU fan replaced due to it developing a grinding noise. Again, after a short phone call, Dell agreed to send an engineer to replace the fan the next day. The issue has since re-appeared, and although it's not a critical issue, I'll be getting Dell to replace the fan again. This does seem like a somewhat common issue, although I can't find any recent reports which would hopefully suggest it has been fixed on the manufacturing side. On the topic of noise, my particular machine has no coil-whine.

The webcam position is frankly bad. It's not an issue for me personally, but I do tend to place the laptop somewhere higher if I'm doing a video call - I can't be trimming my noise hair for every call I do.

I did try macOS on the 9560, as a bit of fun more than anything else, and it seemed to be usable after some effort. However I generally dislike macOS, so I'm back to using Fedora 26 which runs perfectly. Some older apps have slight scaling issues with the 4k screen, however nothing has proven to be unusable (yet). I haven't had any issues running a clean version of Windows either.

Overall, I'm very happy with the 9560.

JamesMcMinn··on Dell XPS 15 9560 Review
Well, yes to a TV with a cheap USB-C -> HDMI 2.0 dongle.
JamesMcMinn··on Dell XPS 15 9560 Review
The XPS 9560 shares the same thermal design as the 9550, both of which are considerably better than the 9530.

I'm able to game for hours on my XPS 9560 with no thermal issues.

JamesMcMinn··on Dell XPS 15 9560 Review
I've been using the XPS 9560 full-time since February, and have experienced precisely 0 of the issues you describe whilst running a number of Linux variants, including several Ubuntu variants, Fedora and Solus.

> So I don't even have a way of getting a working version of Ubuntu on this laptop if anything happens to my hard drive.

You could simply download Ubuntu directly, or any other distribution. Dell isn't doing anything special to the version they distribute.

> For example, updating BIOS to a version that fixes an important CPU bug causes the computer to freeze and shutdown every few minutes at random.

Have you tried talking to Dell about this issue? Their support, particularity around BIOS issues on their XPS and Precision range has been fantastic in my experience, and they often supply pre-release BIOS versions if they believe it will help, otherwise they tend to replace the laptop.

JamesMcMinn··on Why I’m Frustrated with Go
No, YOU are still talking about immutable data structures, where as I am talking about the need to write boilerplate code in Go due to lack of Generics.

The blog posts topic was not "immutable data structures", rather the need for boilerplate code in Go because of the lack of generics. The particular example was one of immutable data structures, however that was an example rather than the topic. The author themselves notes that "generics would solve all of the issues above".

JamesMcMinn··on Why I’m Frustrated with Go
No, Generics make it possible to create a generic immutable data structure which can be used instead of re-writing the same boilerplate for every data type, which is the authors complaint.
JamesMcMinn··on Why I’m Frustrated with Go
Worth reading the comments where someone points out a much simpler and more elegant solution, although it's still not an ideal situation.

As noted in the post, generics could solve this, so I'm looking forward to Go 2 if indeed generics is included. There's a few QOL issues I'd like to see addressed in 2 which would make Go a lot nicer to work with, and I say that as someone who spends most of their time working on Go codebases.

JamesMcMinn··on $4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3
You can drive a Scooter with a _very_ limited power and top speed at 16. They're safer because they don't go any faster than someone with a road bike can cycle.
JamesMcMinn··on $4k Renault compared to Tesla Model 3
> Also, if we think of other road users, less safe cars might encourage the driver to drive more carefully and less likely to endanger others.

I really hope you intended this as satire. Over a million people die each year in road traffic accidents because people aren't perfect and have accidents. Feeling safe in a car has very little to do with how safe the car itself it, and more to do with how "normal" travelling in a car feels.

JamesMcMinn··on UK has best health system in developed world, US analysis concludes
I don't think anyone, in the UK at least, thinks the NHS is free. Most people in the UK who describe it as "free" really mean "free at the point of use" (i.e. no invoice after treatment), but that's a bit of a mouth full.
JamesMcMinn··on Why Some Men Don't Work: Video Games Have Gotten Really Good
> You may purchase this paper on-line in .pdf format from SSRN.com ($5) for electronic delivery.

> You are eligible for a free download if you are a subscriber, a corporate associate of the NBER, a journalist, an employee of the U.S. federal government with a ".GOV" domain name, or a resident of nearly any developing country or transition economy.

I am none of these things.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →