HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Kednicma

185 karma · joined June 2, 2020

submissionscomments
Kednicma··on The view that the scientific process is “red tape”
I don't know what my favorite part is. I'm torn between the part where co-authors were unable to access datasets for months (and never did get them in the end), the part where "trolls and Stanford University professors" were cast as villains who attack the noble science of criminology, and the part where the journal editors avoided following journal policies and instead launched a corrupt hunt for a whistleblower.

> "I never worked with (or even saw) any version of the data," Dr. Johnson wrote about Johnson et al. (2011).

That's not good scientific method, is it? Criminology is already on extremely poor philosophical foundations, and now we see that it's also a poorly-practiced science with nepotistic and corrupt methodologies.

Kednicma··on DOJ – International Statement: End-to-End Encryption and Public Safety
Please, use more words: How do we vote them out of office? How do we recall them or call for votes of no-confidence? You seem to think appointments by elected officials are themselves elections, but there's several hundred years of constitutional democratic history suggesting otherwise.
Kednicma··on Portland passes broadest facial recognition ban in the US
Your entire argument rests on the premise that somehow governments cannot do multiple things at once. However, part of the responsibility of the government is to always exist to serve and protect the people.

That need does not abate merely because the president is a fascist. He already marks himself clearly by positioning himself as diametrically opposite antifascism. No amount of propaganda can disguise that fact. And further, we know from history that appeasement does not work on fascists; we cannot merely sit back and let him have his way now while we plan for a future where he has mysteriously vanished.

The mere existence of Portland is offensive to their political ends; it frustrates them that people might want a better society, and vote thusly. Good! Let them be frustrated; we have no obligation to be nice or pleasant to fascists. I will enjoy seeing them cry when we elect a female antifa mayor soon.

Kednicma··on Portland passes broadest facial recognition ban in the US
I'm embarrassed that you live in my city, too. Get off the fence already. By framing the problem as whether the police need tools to do their job, you've accepted the idea that heavy-handed police-driven violence is a necessary part of our society.
Kednicma··on DOJ – International Statement: End-to-End Encryption and Public Safety
It's too bad none of these fascists are elected; we can't simply vote them out of office.

Edit: Use your words; your downvotes just tell me that you support nepotism and corruption in bureaucracies.

Kednicma··on Memory safe ‘curl’ for a more secure internet
A TCB should be dozens of lines, not thousands. More code means more places for more bugs to hide.

My experience in Safe Haskell was that, if you have to ask each module individually whether it has a safety property, then you've already created too much work for yourself. Instead, require every module to structurally encode the desired invariant.

Or, in fewer words: If you want memory safety, don't have `unsafe` blocks.

Kednicma··on Portland passes broadest facial recognition ban in the US
This is the sort of regulation that our industry has earned. We wanted to build this sort of thing, and it turns out that what we wanted to build is harmful to society.
Kednicma··on Going Viral as a Woman in Tech
I think that ignoring abuse oriented towards men is a common blind spot in our society.

My first upload to Youtube received a comment, "You're nothing but a big fat Jew!" I think that this is quite representative of the hate of the Internet at large.

This sort of blindness towards abuse towards men is not just here on the Internets. In real life, progress made against ritual genital mutilation is happening for women but not for men.

Kednicma··on You don’t have free will, but don’t worry
> In quantum mechanics some events are truly random and cannot be predicted. Does this mean that quantum mechanics is where you can find free will? Sorry, but no, this makes no sense. These random events in quantum mechanics are not influenced by you, regardless of exactly what you mean by “you”, because they are not influenced by anything. That’s the whole point of saying they are fundamentally random. Nothing determines their outcome.

This is wrong, sorry. Rather, QM is contextual; the response to a measurement is both influenced locally by the measurement's orientation and non-locally by its causal history.

QM gives us indeterminism. Further, if we have free will, then so do subatomic particles. It is neither good or bad, but it is how it is.

Kednicma··on Bye-Bye, Apple
Well, yes, but also, the arguments are much shorter when we're honest.

Apple is an overpriced fashion company. Ten words or less, end of fucking argument, nothing more should have ever been considered. The entire rest of the thread brings no useful details or counterarguments. If you want practical hardware, buy it from literally any other vendor for a substantial discount and possible improvement in quality.

Okay, that was rough and brutal. I don't know if we can have discussions that are so honest! Let's go back to whining about Finder.

Kednicma··on Some idiot is using your tool to mass scan our network
As another security professional, I'm laughing my ass off. Imagine wondering what targets might be nice, and reading the comments in this file. How nice of them to email and tell us exactly which IP ranges are sensitive!
Kednicma··on Recycling was a lie to sell more plastic, recycling industry veteran says
It varies by area. Here's the guidelines for Portland [0]; it seems that "Home" "FOOD SCRAPS" bins may have pizza boxes in them, as long as wax paper and other inserts are removed. Incidentally, mentally traversing the pizzerias I go to, I think that the only inserts that any of them add are pizza savers [1].

[0] https://www.portland.gov/bps/garbage-recycling/compost-what-...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizza_saver

Kednicma··on Lisp and Haskell (2015)
Are you sure? https://lobste.rs/s/yyhu4w/real_problems_with_functional_lan...
Kednicma··on Lisp and Haskell (2015)
And Python provides readable syntax. Your example has an easy-to-spot bug, just from reading the code and knowing Python's semantics. Haskell's "programmable semicolon" ends up being a problem here because, thanks to typeclasses, the programmer usually does not know which semicolon they are programming under!

"Python provides many tools that can be used to solve programming woes. One such tool is its strong and readable syntax." Do you see how empty this sort of platitude is?

Kednicma··on Vermont becomes 11th state to legalize recreational marijuana market
Prepared cannabis can't be taken across state lines legally yet, in general. However, you certainly can imbibe many milligrams of edible oil and be extremely stoned on Amtrak. (This isn't legal advice.)
Kednicma··on Recycling was a lie to sell more plastic, recycling industry veteran says
And lest this sound myopic! At least in Portland, the pizza boxes can be put into composting bins, including the plant-waste bins that we put out next to garbage bins.

So the paper does, eventually, go to the landfill and become sequestered in the typical fashion.

Kednicma··on Swift Algorithms
Worse nomenclature than any other big language I can think of, including Go and Python. Why should this package be called "algorithms"?
Kednicma··on Google and Oracle's decade-long copyright battle reaches Supreme Court
Careful there. Source code to a program is also a fact; it's merely the proof of some statement in some theory. This is one way to view the Curry-Howard-Lambek isomorphism. So, then, what is it about source code which would make it copyrightable again? Are systems like Metamath and Opentheory eligible for copyright or not?

To me, the current copyright regime is what's "absurd" and "plainly ridiculous"; I am merely drawing conclusions based on what exists.

Kednicma··on Karma? Peter Thiel bombed his IPO with dystopian cyberpunk Palantir
The article's title has changed; I think that they're doing one of those strange plays where the article title is different for different people.

This flop, losing a quarter of their value overnight, is one of the expected outcomes from the middle class placing their hopes and dreams on the stock market; they demand more ethical options from index stocks and ETFs, and this reduces the upstream demand for groups like Palantir.

Kednicma··on Google and Oracle's decade-long copyright battle reaches Supreme Court
> Google argues that no one should be allowed to claim ownership of this kind of code.

Imagine if we took Google's argument seriously and extended it. What if code were inherently less copyrightable when it is more structural and boilerplate-filled? That could be a great thing, but Google themselves might be surprised at how little of their proprietary code qualifies for copyright under this standard.

For example, would Google's protobuf schemata still be copyrightable? They're needed for interoperability, after all. Would Google's client-side code for Youtube and Google Docs still be copyrightable? It's delivered in textual form to the end-user. Would Android's interface code be copyrightable? Probably not, by exactly the same argument that Google has been making before the courts!

If Google wins, then not only does Oracle lose, but the institution of copyright might also lose, which is an exciting proposition.

Kednicma··on Hootsuite employee fired after speaking out about company's ICE deal
Human rights violations weren't a problem; only optics mattered. The contract was a boon initially, and only became a liability because of the media attention. Shameful but typical corporate behavior.
Kednicma··on Predictive policing algorithms are racist. They need to be dismantled
You're literally just making excuses for why it's okay for people to be bigoted based on misunderstandings of genetics.
Kednicma··on Algorithm discovers how six molecules could evolve into life’s building blocks
And yet we are here today. Feel free to propose a better explanation.
Kednicma··on Predictive policing algorithms are racist. They need to be dismantled
I know that what you think you're saying is innocuous, but what I'm reading is that you think that racism is excusable because society is broadly racist. Moreover, racist beliefs are excusable on an individual level if they don't lead to harmful racist stereotypes.

However, it's still incorrect to stereotype people based on skin color, even if it's polite stereotyping. To think of people with different skin color as different is missing two points: First, that everybody is different from everybody else, and second, that everybody is human! We shouldn't promulgate or tolerate worldviews which get this wrong, because they're deeply prone to fundamental attribution error: Your aunt may well believe that her dark-skinned neighbor does things a certain way because he is an immigrant!

Kednicma··on Algorithm discovers how six molecules could evolve into life’s building blocks
Yes, soap arose from mixing ash into animal fats; after a meal cooked over a fire, we would scoop up alkaline ash and pour it into the pot with the rendered fat, creating a natural soap.

Similarly, in the beginning, we had hot oceans where monoxides, dioxides, and carbon were pressed against volcanic rock, creating chains of fatty acid. When those fatty acids broke off from the rock and floated in the water, their ability to repel water altered the chemistry around them, leading to protocells.

For more details, watch the video I linked. It's not long and it should be accessible for all ages. It's got great animations, too.

Kednicma··on Concatenative Programming; the Free Monoid of Programming Languages (2019)
You're not wrong. Categories have an inherent monoid on their arrows which composes them, and so concatenative programming is extremely close to categorical programming.

The two main ingredients that are missing in the ecosystem are (1) a good intermediate compiler target, and (2) a way to write programs categorically so that we don't have to retype them in each different programming system's syntax.

Kednicma··on Predictive policing algorithms are racist. They need to be dismantled
I believe that ethics is pragmatic: What you believe shines through in what you do. You claim in (2) that there exist racists who never act on their racism, effectively; could you show me where those people are and explain some of their beliefs? I don't think that they exist.

Merely to draw the line between people is already enough of a divisive action.

Kednicma··on Predictive policing algorithms are racist. They need to be dismantled
There is no such thing as race. That's what makes this entire affair so frustrating; merely believing that races exist is racist.

If you can show me a society that is racist but that nonetheless ensures equal rights for all races, then I'll retract the point. However, from what I've seen, every government which thinks that race is real has enacted racist policies, so I think that the burden of proof will be hard to meet. CIMO, caste, aboriginals, reservations, blood quanta, and more; governments enshrine whatever hateful bigotry their people demand.

It is worth pointing out that, even if race did not exist, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 also bans discrimination based on national origin. This covers Central American foreign nationals being neglected and experimented on in our concentration camps; it covers Indian-Americans being rejected for jobs because of the caste of their last name; it even covers African-Americans being pulled over for driving-while-black. Ultimately, most racist practices are netted by the national-origin clause and the concept of race does not need to be invoked.

Kednicma··on Algorithm discovers how six molecules could evolve into life’s building blocks
"Nowhere in nature" is pretty rich, considering that it happens every time we use dish soap to scrub grease off of pots and pans. Protocells [0] likely formed from basic fats which formed along the lines mentioned in the original article. Hydrophilia, hydrophobia, and lipophilia do the rest, coercing clumps of fat to form into little walled-off regions where chemistry becomes isolated.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocell

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRzxTzKIsp8

Kednicma··on Predictive policing algorithms are racist. They need to be dismantled
Predictive policing is racist by either of your definitions, isn't it? What are you so animated about?

There's a third, simpler definition, for what it's worth: Racism is the (erroneous, falsified) belief that there exist multiple human races/species today. This third definition leads to your first definition, because the false belief in races leads to separating people according to those false beliefs, which leads to groups of people harboring prejudice towards each other, which leads to social constructions which embed those prejudices. It also leads to your second definition, because the false belief in races leads to false emphasis on skin tone, facial features, and other innocuous differences between people.

The point isn't to make "racism" or "racist" bad words. The point is to end racist effects in our society. It's inhumane, wasteful, and at odds with science.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →