HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Koshkin

7,800 karma · joined January 28, 2016

submissionscomments
Koshkin··on NixOS is not reproducible
> Yes, it isn't.

It took me some time to get used to the way native speakers of English express agreement or disagreement with a negative statement.

Agree: “No, it isn’t.”

Disagree: “Yes, it is.”

Koshkin··on Axiomatics: Mathematical thought and high modernism
https://www.landsburg.com/grothendieck/mclarty1.pdf
Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
I wouldn't call "niche" something some big companies have been spending billions of dollars on.
Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
Fascinating.

More on the topological data analysis:

http://outlace.com/TDApart1.html

Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
Historically, Category Theory was developed to formalize and better understand some deep methods used in mathematics. Like much of mathematics, it "automated" some types of reasoning, opening possibilities that did not (practically) exist before. There are some areas today that cannot even be properly understood without thinking in categorical terms.
Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
Sorry, the word "territory" was merely an (unsuccessful) attempt at a pun on the notion of "atlas" used in the theory of manifolds. (In your example, the straight line segments are the "pages" in such atlas, and the circle - the manifold - is the "territory.")

It would seem to me that the properties of the circle are not emergent properties of a bunch of line segments; rather, the circle is something else entirely, whose shape is forced upon it by its own nature. Another example that comes to mind is the so-called "fiber bundles," whose own topology in general can be much more complex than that of a "trivial bundle" (simply the product of two spaces - the "base" and the "fiber"), although locally they all do look "trivial."

None of this, I am afraid, has much to do with what you said you are working on. In the realm of software development, the only emerging properties (or non-trivial topologies) are bugs.

Koshkin··on 19th-century photography technique employed in novel data storage method
Depends on the context, I guess. In some, a method can involve multiple techniques; some of these techniques can be borrowed from other, unrelated, methods. (You could say that a photograph is kind of data storage, but still.)
Koshkin··on The future of software is Nix
The future is not what it used to be.
Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
Sure; it's just that doing calculations with the Roman numerals takes longer.
Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
> CT is about structure

No, this is exactly what CT is not about. (It is about morphisms.)

Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
A circle is a 1-dimensional manifold (which, indeed, could be embedded in a space that has more dimensions). This follows exactly from your own (correct) image of it as being created from (i.e. being locally homeomorphic to) straight lines. But the entire thing ("the territory") always turns out to be more than the set of parts it is "built from," and if you ignore this, not only you are bound to lose the forest for the trees, your understanding of the whole may end up being completely wrong.
Koshkin··on Category Theory Illustrated: Logic (2021)
Not such a bad idea TBH
Koshkin··on The $9B James Webb Space Telescope Runs JavaScript
I don't know what you are talking about. (What I meant was, the need for pointer arithmetic can be avoided by using iterators, and use-after-free, by using smart pointers.)
Koshkin··on Official Raspberry Pi NVMe SSD Review
OK, "socket". (ODROID-N2+, for example, uses eMMC as a faster, better alternative to an SD card.)

https://www.hardkernel.com/shop/odroid-n2-with-4gbyte-ram-2/

Koshkin··on The $9B James Webb Space Telescope Runs JavaScript
In C++ (specifically) one can limit oneself to using safe constructs provided by the standard library. (C is a different story, of course.)
Koshkin··on The $9B James Webb Space Telescope Runs JavaScript
I doubt that a dynamically typed interpreted language can be "safer" than a statically typed compiled language.
Koshkin··on Official Raspberry Pi NVMe SSD Review
One example: https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2024/07/radxa-x4-cheap-intel-n10...
Koshkin··on Official Raspberry Pi NVMe SSD Review
Well, not an NVMe maybe (yet), but at least a built-in eMMC slot.
Koshkin··on Using AI Generated Code Will Make You a Bad Programmer
I mean, things seemed a little different 30 years ago.
Koshkin··on System76 Thelio Astra: High-End ARM64 Developer Desktop
A Mac wouldn't run Ubuntu (would it?)
Koshkin··on Using AI Generated Code Will Make You a Bad Programmer
Yeah, no, things have changed in the last 30 years...
Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
You believe that your definition of the word "science" is actually correct. (I have my doubts.)
Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
A statistical hypothesis is an assumption about a population parameter. A hypothesis in physics is something else entirely. (Incidentally, there are hypotheses in mathematics, too, called "conjectures"). You may disagree, but I see statistics as a science, akin to physics; which, perhaps, is why we also have "mathematical statistics."
Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
> - In math things can be proven.

Some things can, some cannot (be either proven or shown to be false).

Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong
Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
> So actually high confidence is just an assumption.

This one is actually a funny statement. Not all assumptions are born equal :)

Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
> I literally said Computer science is NOT a science.

But the point was that this entirely depends on one's definition of what the word "science" means - and that depends on the context and the language. I can say, for example, that math is science - simply equating "science" with "knowledge" and "research".

Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
I don't think that physics (for example) uses the word "hypothesis" in the same sense, even though there are, indeed, parallels between the two sciences.
Koshkin··on What is theoretical computer science?
> You can make a statement and the actuality of that statement is either true or false.

It can also be "not even wrong."

Koshkin··on Keeping Teeth Healthy
One can go to what seems to be infinite lengths, in terms of time, effort, and attention, caring about their health (in general). I’ve always wondered whether it is worth it.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →