HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
> It might only be a matter of years before a genetic test for tendency towards “transgender” will be created.

Do you recognize that you're about five years behind in "the message"? Trans is purely self-id, to declare yourself trans in the "progressive" countries like NZ and Canada you don't need to even suggest that there's anything physical involved. Specifically you're even allowed to keep changing your identity, something that couldn't happen if trans had a physical nature. Also, you're allowed to claim non-binary but use the women's washroom without even explaining why this would be appropriate.

In Canada you'd be called a trans-medicalist, which theoretically is advocating conversion therapy - to talk people out of their felt experience of gender or gender identity. It's borderline 'hate speech'.

> The science is still new, but has solid foundations.

What is the contention? Not the evidence, just the premise?

Do you suggest that males, like William (Lia) Thomas and Boyd (Fallon Fox) Burton are no stronger than women the moment they transition or that they rapidly become female-like by taking estrogen and losing testosterone as a consequence of their genital surgeries?

In these studies, is Caster Semenya treated as female despite fathering a baby?

> That’s the scary part - the facts are readily available, but so few take the time to understan the current state of it.

What facts? Be specific. Because many studies in the subject area would have failed a second-year student recently in any other specialty. Specifically the small sample size and self-selected nature of the trans athletes who have a motive to sandbag and return worse times in order to "prove" that they belong in women's sports, etc.

If that isn't what you meant, then please list these good studies because the space is crowded with academically blessed nonsense.

LawTalkingGuy··on A mutual aid auto shop in Alabama
> My take-away - multi-path teaching doesn't work in the typical American classroom (25+ students per class, all the same age, but vastly different skills).

Well yeah, do something badly and it won't work. Each student deserves teacher time even if they get further on that time. Instead they generally try to teach the slowest students more as if they'll ever catch up.

> My son didn't have anything quite so obviously awful. [...] In gifted classes, he excelled.

Well yes, that's small-class tutoring and we know it's almost the ideal. The trick is to replicate that in normal classes, by teaching to the people who will benefit while the others work on exercises, etc.

> It might work in a more controlled environment, where the classes are smaller and the range of skill isn't quite to broad.

My contention is the opposite, that you want a range of skills from newb to expert, and ideally across ages.

You were surely closer to the 6th grade advanced students than the bulk of the 7th grade students who were just getting by. And you may not have been far enough ahead of the 7ths in age and bearing as well as math, and thus not as helpful in teaching as older students would be. Student teachers are a very big part of one-room schools and I think the teaching itself provides invaluable skills in childcare and providing instruction to near peers.

LawTalkingGuy··on A WiFi color eInk picture frame
I think it's nice. It's about the same form factor as the existing paper-holders it replaces and in this context the wood border is aesthetic and clutter-reducing.

My work went with LCDs which don't match the calm wood and earth colors decor of our meeting and privacy rooms.

Not that you asked, but what I'd tweak would be a way to run the cable back into the wall.

LawTalkingGuy··on A mutual aid auto shop in Alabama
It's a fact. It's the reason gifted classes were created.

From my own mixed-age classroom experience, and stories I've heard about one-room schools, it's not the mixing of skill levels that holds the advanced class back but the structure of the class.

If you're all doing the work at the same speed it has to be the speed of the slowest student so by definition everyone else is held back. This is so obvious that I can't take people seriously when they deny it. It's literally how "the manual" says to teach.

But in a multi-path environment where everyone is working at their own speed, this isn't a problem. Even if the advanced students are tasked with some teaching of the slower kids the dynamic changes and they're not being kept down. The maximal form of this is a one-room school where the older and gifted kids are working on their high-level tasks right next to younger and lower-achieving people. This encourages personal accomplishment by creating an environment full of learning opportunities and decoupling your advancement from your age-group.

LawTalkingGuy··on US Presidential Hopefuls Rally Against a Digital Dollar Ahead of 2024 Elections
>> the other has a mathematically demonstrably finite supply.

> The argument I always hear against this point is that you can simply continue to subdivide the currency infinitely. We just get into smaller and smaller fractions of "satoshi's" or whatever the base unit may be.

That's a different problem, that's the market-cap / # of coins issue. You don't spend an integer number of bitcoin, you spend the fraction you need, so it's not really a problem.

The PP was talking about how Bitcoin was devised to not allow anyone to arbitrarily make more coins. (Some BTC forks have different minting policies, but BTC itself can't be changed.)

Our central banks on the other hand, were devised precisely to allow the government to create money when needed.

There's no way the USA would adopt BTC as its central currency for example because it would lose that ability.

LawTalkingGuy··on Ask HN: Is prompt engineering just snake oil?
> software engineering really isn't real engineering

Most people who call themselves software engineers have not studied engineering at all, let alone passed an engineering course.

I think there are two broad classes of benefit a real SE can provide.

The first is an understanding of how software can be proven correct, and the limitations of that vis-a-vis the real world - power failures, etc. They can help understand what portion of the software needs what level of performance, understandability, correctness, etc. Your core trade-pricing engine's needs are different than the webserver showing the status pages - both are required but the standards for both are not the same.

Second is an ability (and this is what apprenticing and is for in a real engineering career) to judge and design entire systems. We "devs" often get treated as fungible work units and tasked with various little subsystems. A professional engineer entering such a space would be required to obtain a pretty good understanding of the entirety of the company's systems and very good of what they integrate with, such that they can characterize the cost, risk, etc, of the solution space before even beginning to plan the technical solution. Engineers often tell clients that they've envisioned the wrong solution. They're trained to break down silos and integrate solutions where possible. (Not that they all succeed, but that's in the training.)

> if these LLMs are so intelligent and have so much deeper understanding as their emergent capability - why is prompt engineering needed in the first place?

Because they're language models and people are trying to solve things that aren't pure language problems with them. So you need to map the problem to something it can represent and where a solution can be formed, even if that solution may not use an LLM call. A simple example is taking a mathematical word problem and solving it. Currently the LLMs do not model math well so you'd use the LLM to separate out the clauses of the problem and turn it into variables and write an equation from it and then you'd evaluate that snippet of code for the real answer.

And then, depending on what part of what system this was, you may need to verify the parsing and other parts of the pipeline so you would need to build a chain where the results from one call are handed to other systems, maybe just back to the same LLM, with a bunch of examples, for multiple instances of more detailed checking, and then if those answers aren't the same, to another round where it tries to explain the difference and feeds that explanation into a round where you try to reprompt the initial layer and try again. Token limits often constrain how good the instructions and examples can be so you often have a few levels of prompts, nearly bulletproof ones, and shorter ones which are cheaper and allow other use of the token budget but may have more failure cases.

Building with non-deterministic tools isn't impossible, all ropes are different and yet we have rope bridges, but you have to know how they work and how they fail.

> But who's a prompt engineer? [If] I'm a GPT-3.5 prompt engineer do we need to have a job openings for Alpca or StableML prompt engineers?

No, just like architects learning different materials during their career. But all those LLMs are different and you need to experiment (scientifically) to find their characteristics in your area before building on them.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
Canadian. And we generally have results in under an hour after the polls close.

I've actually gone to viewing parties at pubs for the last two US elections. Your media dominates ours.

LawTalkingGuy··on Mullvad VPN was subject to a search warrant – customer data not compromised
Meh, police get the address wrong sometimes. I could totally see them either not understanding of not believing a 'no logs' policy.

So they get a warrant for 'servers with client connection logs' and when they arrive they discover that there are no servers - nothing with a HD and certainly no storage systems, and then they contact their boss and are more willing to re-examine and maybe decide to trust that the company was being honest.

Mullvad don't say they weren't searched, just that nothing was taken. They informed the police that what they wanted didn't exist and demonstrated it to the police/prosecutor's satisfaction. Cops have access to technical consultants if they need expertise to verify this.

Good code and wiring probably helped - if there's a rat's nest of cables running into the ceiling it's hard to trust, but if there's a really clean patch panel and short direct runs between equipment it's easier to demonstrate that what you see matches the device map and how it's configured.

LawTalkingGuy··on Shutting down my legal torrent site after 17 years
Could you have spun off the placement part of the business into a separate identity (which didn't bill itself as "adult") and kept the profits there?
LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
> Wouldn’t republicans believe more in ‘...’ where democrats would be more ‘...’

With only two parties I don't think the parties themselves are good proxies for the views of the people who end up voting for them.

I think generally most people would want 1) each to their own 3) success of the hardworking 3) equality for everyone. With only two parties for the whole political spectrum neither group is actually that distinct. Many people vote on the key issues that impact their day-to-day and so there's generally no real difference on issues that aren't in the news.

Anyways, being on the west coast I assume that most of the Americans I'm talking about are Dems, and in Canada, probably 'Liberals'. I think their (perfectly reasonable) hippy distrust of government and corporations makes them doubt the "benefits" meaning they had no reason to do it for neighbors either. (This was 2+y ago now, who knows where they are now.)

A community meeting I went to a few years ago spent twenty minutes or so discussing microwaved water, and if the venue used a microwave and whether some people were "safe to drink the tea", and went downhill from there in a science sense. Everyone was very eager to help but it wasn't a terribly well informed group.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
> Take the contentious issue of transgender human rights [...] tended towards right-wing principles of distrust of intellectuals

There's a weird form of "intellectual"ism going on these days.

I've gotten insanely mad pushback on my contention that we simply cannot know if Covid leaked from Wuhan. (Or, back in 2020 we couldn't - who knows where we're getting now.) It could be easy to show there was a leak, but would be almost impossible to show there wasn't. Note that I wasn't saying "we shouldn't take the vax" or anything, just the leak issue. Total rabid culture war.

Similarly, there's a huge push that "trans women are women" and that there's science for this, gender spectrum and so on, but there's no ability to look behind the curtain. The studies don't show what they purport to, and don't match the claims they're being used to defend. Nobody has attempted to show a midpoint on the sex spectrum, and even if they did - the argument has moved on and now trans is an issue of self-id that doesn't require any physical issue. Bring this up and you're "literally saying trans people shouldn't exist", etc.

In both cases there's no depth to the argument, despite that it apparently comes from the best scientific minds in the world - it claims to be a factual claim but when you ask to see the facts it becomes a purity issue where you're then shamed for not simply believing. I was told I was a Covid denier because of not simply accepting the no-lab-leak story.

> perhaps the latest stage of right-wing politics could be defined as the replacement of democratic law-and-order with righteous authoritarianism

One side makes "facts" a matter of righteousness and the other side simply eschews facts for their religion.

LawTalkingGuy··on Autonomous Agents and Agent Simulations
I think Langchain is currently broader, containing those text-splitting and indexing tools as well as summarization and memory, 'Tool' integration, etc.
LawTalkingGuy··on French publisher arrested in London for refusal to tell police his passcodes
Scotland's problem is that mentioning a "protected characteristic" is enough to get you arrested if someone feels upset. The problem isn't the intent of the law but the incredibly low bar for injury and lack of sanctions for false and unreasonable reports letting the law itself be used for harassment.

I think I should be able to tell a joke "Two catholics and a jew ..." as long as it's not a veiled way to call for harm to anyone, and I don't think a joke about the sexes in a similar vein should be a problem.

But, if you physically attack a catholic because they're a catholic, or a woman because she's a woman, then that is a hate crime - where you're just looking for someone of a class you don't like to inflict punishment on. A sentencing modifier doesn't seem like a bad idea.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
> Is it perfect? No,

The problem is that it introduces all these failure cases.

Pen+Paper's only drawback is that it's said to be slow, in practice it can be finished same-day by booking enough elections volunteers.

> but it is better than having no paper record at all

That's a weird standard. "Sure, it costs a lot and introduces all these weird and nigh-undetectable failure cases but the other machines were even worse! ..."

> the option of a manual recount

Which will be fought, of course. They always are. So in the end only some areas will ever have a human audit.

The public deserves that every vote be hand counted by a bipartisan team.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
So? Respond to people with reasoned arguments and it doesn't matter who they are.

Trolls win when people think they have to achieve purity of thought - to drive away anyone who believes wrong-think even at the cost of the forum itself. Triggering forums to play purity games and cull the insufficiently aligned is a troll victory.

That doesn't mean you should let politics bleed into every other thread, but in a politics thread just move past the idea of needing to censor people to win.

LawTalkingGuy··on French publisher arrested in London for refusal to tell police his passcodes
Modern PCs are as secure as a loaf of bread in a mob of seagulls.

Use malware to actually install sharing software and hide it from the user and at the router. Then use actual full-disk encryption software and make a real hidden partition and dump the bait files from the file sharing into it and leave the forensic traces. Then wipe the malware and delete the password and the FDE is unopenable but the courts will never believe the user.

LawTalkingGuy··on French publisher arrested in London for refusal to tell police his passcodes
> you can be told not to reveal that you've told them the password

This is a good reason to use numbered, pre-made, one-time-passwords and require a reason when using them. "AdminX lost fob - using override to reset creds." Requiring you to lie is one step past requiring you to remain silent.

If the 'next PW to be used' number increased on everyone's override-PWs it couldn't be hidden. Co-admins could know to check an audit log of changes.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
It feels like our current political parties are the result of force-teaming and meaningless labels creating unhappy and fragile alliances ready to split. Imho this would be great as the manufactured left/right dichotomy never helped anyone.

Is a parent far-right for demanding high standards from drugs they put into their children, or a leftist for not just accepting big-pharma's word?

I personally saw a lot of people be ejected from "the left" because of questioning the medical response to Covid. Many different circumstance, but they'd all run into the mandatory acceptance of the message. Some had been vaccine "wary" before and remained that way, others were pro-vax but doubted the safety given its minimal testing time, etc. All of these people were your average west-coast hippy type and they're now being told they're allied with unite-the-right anti-jew stuff in the USA.

I can't wait until the new affiliations drop and we can ditch the legacy groupings.

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
There were a lot of promising studies into using it for Covid then - large-scale retrospective cohort studies of pre-existing ivermectin trials going on as Covid started to spread. It just turns out that it mostly didn't apply to the first world because most people don't have parasitic comordidities.

This was really annoying because the reaction to Trump's casual mention of it injected virulent American politics into everything around the world. We should have been able to discuss this and other topics without Rep/Dem nonsense spilling over, but instead any discussion of covid became nearly verboten, with even simply statements of obvious fact being banned. (ie, we haven't yet checked the Wuhan lab to see if Covid did in fact leak from there.)

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
> Each voter receives a printout with a human-readable list of their selections, along with a QR code.

This is not an acceptable design. Not only should the voter be marking their ballot by hand not doing so through a machine whose UI may have bugs, but any scanner must scan the human-readable marks, not some machine-readable marks because the voter can't check that both sets of marks match.

> The Dominion machines are good precisely because, unlike past digital voting machines, they create a human-readable paper trail that is legible to both the voter and to (re)counters, just like it was before computer voting terminals.

Intentionally obfuscated paper trails. The problem is that none of this is required. Paper works. Paper + optical vote-checkers works. Nothing beyond that works, or is needed.

> anyone who proposes blockchain as a solution should receive a lifetime ban from making any democracy-critical policy decisions.

Lol, total agreement. But ... why does that not extend to people who make black-box machines that have a ton of chances to change the vote?

LawTalkingGuy··on Fox News, Dominion Voting Systems reach $787,500,000 settlement
I just want people to remember all the previous elections where Dems were potentially hurt by e-voting bugs and to band together across the aisle to get rid of voting machines. Paper voting works for us in Canada and it'd work for you too.

The only voting machine that isn't "fraud waiting to happen" is an optical-scan under-voting detector - the thing that says "your mark for Mayor is too light and won't be counted", allowing you to take the paper and pen and correct it.

The court erred in this case, not by treating Fox's words (/unchecked republication of accusations) as a lie but by acting like the reputation of an voting-machine company deserves protection when they make something so obviously ideally suited for crime. The Flipper Zero people get accused of knowing their product will be used in crime and yet we don't apply the same logic to e-voting manufacturers.

Fox deserves the hit, but Dominion doesn't deserve the implication of honesty - their entire business is to remove proof of honesty from our elections. Perhaps the solution should have been to fine Fox but give the money to charities seeking to audit and improve the voting process.

LawTalkingGuy··on An example of LLM prompting for programming
Those topics that AI replaces the forums for won't need discussion. People won't be confused about that thing because the coding AI knows the details of it. Soon that'll be most syntax questions, soon simple to mid-level algorithms, etc.

People will move on to higher-level questions.

LawTalkingGuy··on MMC4: An open, billion-scale corpus of images interleaved with text
Lol, that's what a reviewer running on Llama13b would say!
LawTalkingGuy··on Sweden starts largest military exercise in over 25 years
Your link doesn't purport to show child kidnappings, etc. It says they recruit child soldiers, but it doesn't say those children are slaves.

Also, it's not as much who is targeted by the attacks as why. The Kurds are under genocidal attack on three sides and have a lot more global sympathy than other groups.

LawTalkingGuy··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
> personally I prefer actual people having GPUs

I think Nvidia/etc missed some serious PR by not giving out tickets to buy cards via gaming and hardware sites, to be rewarded with more tickets if those cards ended up being used for gaming. However, I think it's unrealistic and unhelpful to call prices "scalping" when there are conflicting markets for a product.

> a Nazi walks into a bar and isn't kicked out

A bar is a private entity with a target clientele and limited availability. It makes sense that the patrons can be and should be curated.

> ideological toxicity was freely allowed to spread.

Now we're talking about NFTs, literally DeFi. How would you make NFTs that would allow for pro-Tibet messages, etc, and not also allow any other text/image that people want?

The correct filter is in which markets list it, and which customers buy it. It's like a disgusting book - it doesn't invalidate the very concept of libraries.

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
The police simply count what they can - actual formal reports. They aren't lying because they aren't claiming that this fully describes the situation in the city.

The fact checkers, who I am accusing of being empty political bias machines, lie by pretending that "are the official crime statistics lower" is the question that residents and tourists need to know. Their headlines and conclusions don't match the questions they're asking and they're smarmy in their dismissals of disbelievers as politically motivated.

> if it's propaganda, it's self-defeating propaganda,

No, it's not the police who are propagandizing here. It's the "news" misusing the police data.

> making it far more likely that you're experiencing paranoia based on mass hysteria

Very tactile hallucinations.

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
> Calling me a commie is silly. I am a socialist come on.

:D Honest question though if you're serious, is socialism just a temporary goal on the way to communism or is it a worthwhile final goal on its own?

> I didn't propose jailing anyone, I am an abolitionist.

More questions. Like, as a libertarian sort of thing, or a anarcho-utopian? In a society that has the concept of property? What would the society do, or expect a citizen to do, when someone was taking their food, or harassing them, etc?

> why the conversation, already about jailing someone, is only about jailing that person

Because the word tenant implies that they need to pay ongoing rent, and evictions are generally for failing to do so. Jail may be overboard in this situation (?) but applying sanctions to a person unwilling to return your property or leave your rental unit seems required or nobody would rent anything and all potential renters would suffer.

There doesn't seem to be any reason to punish the landlord, first because it's morally wrong to punish someone without a 'crime', and second because it wouldn't provide any class benefit to anyone either.

> Y'all act like god revealed capitalism as his chosen economic system in 1991.

No, we measure from when St Reagan personally tore down the wall in 1987.

LawTalkingGuy··on Arrest made in SF killing of Bob Lee – alleged killer also worked in tech
> Why even bother arguing this question

I live in two of the drug cities and visit others, and pay taxes that support many of these policies specifically. Do you live in one of the west-coast cities in question, or is this an abstract political battle for you? If you live here, do you feel you're a representative resident?

> if all you have is anecdotes, speculation and just-so stories?

Well, there's the crux of it, these are anecdotes that have happened to me personally. Over decades of experience and watching things change. And there's tons of data collected by victims but as has been pointed out, the news often chooses to report on acknowledged crime where a police officer has been sent out and taken a report. FB groups where people log violent street interactions or businesses' windows being broken show a definite uptick that government statistics don't. I know it's true because I walk past enough of those broken windows and stabbing sites to provide a reality check for what I'm seeing published.

We know that there are vastly more actual rapes than reported rapes and punished rapes. Why it is so unreasonable that there are vastly more actual attacks and robberies than reported?

> [other cities] all of whom also have more burglaries per capita than SF, and most of which also have more assaults, murders, and rapes.

Perception of livability despite violent crime has a lot to do with the localization of that crime. If only certain areas, at certain times, are dangerous - and if those areas are ones that can be avoided - then you can generally just go elsewhere with your family and be fine. That's the liberal way SF and such used to work. Sure, there were sleezy places but the street people would even helpfully and quietly warn tourists - "Hey bud, there's a lot of drugs down here, you should really take your kids a few blocks that way."

But once it spills over into random attacks outside that area, such that you can be killed at the busiest coffee shop in the city, the entire veneer of safety goes away.

We're saying two main things: that it got bad really quickly and predictably, and it's being officially downplayed.

> Please provide a shred of evidence that this doesn't happen in any of the other other cities listed in

It's somewhat annoying that what should be an issue of local policy ends up being purity-checked by people trying to decide if we're too partisan in national politics. We're talking about our policies, not trying to claim that other cities can't fail just as hard as we are but with a different set of errors.

LawTalkingGuy··on NPR quits Twitter after being labeled as 'state-affiliated media'
> covid misinformation is a conspiracy theory

I've been personally blocked on multiple forums for saying that we don't have enough information to say that there wasn't a lab leak.

I'm not making a leak claim, but stating as an expert that it's malpractice to characterize your assumptions as facts and without a long and detailed audit we could not know what we'd need to know to make a factual statement. No audit of the Wuhan lab had been done so we could not know what happened.

The government pressured old-Twitter to ban people who pointed out this fact.

> suppressing idiocy is virtuous

Are you applying to have your account blocked then? Because what I'm saying is tautological.

> judgment my bro, it is ok if things are subjective

For your opinion, sure. For policy, no. If we can't attempt to objectively show that something is wrong we can't claim to be censoring misinformation.

LawTalkingGuy··on Arrest made in SF killing of Bob Lee – alleged killer also worked in tech
> No city census or national crime analysis categorizes burglary as a violent crime, and I'm not sure why you called SF out on it.

Most other cities aren't wallowing in it the same way, and aren't holier than thou despite their polices clearly having caused the issue. But you're right, it's not just SF. LA and Seattle are pretty much right there too.

The crime cities like SF are worth calling out in a way that other violent cities aren't though because there's a giant epidemic of what we're pressured to call "non-violent crime" like shoplifting and car theft that gets violent instantly whenever the criminal doesn't get their way. I've personally seen people get shoved out of the way of a fleeing thief, and videos of people being attacked when they come back at the wrong time and discover their car being robbed. To say SF isn't violent ignores that the residents are on the edge of violence constantly.

> SF is 55 out of the biggest 100 cities on burglary rates, by the way.

These crime rates are what's reported by the police and they refuse to take reports of anything that hasn't escalated so they ignore most of what the everyday person suffers. These statistics should be seen more as evidence of collusion in the SFPD, not used to prove the safety of the city.

← PreviousPage 4 of 19Next →