HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on My husband was right about DVDs
No, because while Dylan sometimes says that, the rest of the time they talk about the miraculous changes to their body, etc, and participate in female sexual health panels. They're trying to have it both ways as convenient.

If you feel that this is incorrect, go to Wiki and try to edit Rachel Levine's entry to remove the word female and you can personally see how the community views this.

LawTalkingGuy··on Bulgarian law enforcement raids offices of cryptocurrency firm Nexo
The same reason your cell phone fell out of your pocket in the driveway before the trip. So that it never happened.

I think this is easier with bikes because there's more repair culture and more off-roading. Off-road bikes generally have all non-essentials stripped and left in a box, blinkers, odometer, fancy fenders...

LawTalkingGuy··on Intel Launches $699 Core I9-13900KS, the First 6 GHz CPU: Available Now
Put a CPU limit on the process. I do it for gaming to keep Dwarf Fortress from pinning my CPU even in the menus.
LawTalkingGuy··on Arizona inducing the labor of pregnant prisoners against their will
We've currently got minor criminals in maximum security because there's a lack of low-level capacity. Simply building enough minimum security cells for the minor criminals already in the system would be more appropriate treatment, would aid rehabiliation, and would reduce overcrowding of actually dangerous prisoners. Further, the cost of incarceration scales with the security required, this would save money.

In addition, there'd now be a reasonable punishment for small crimes and we could start punishing people who now fall through the cracks before they become a problem.

> I think the burden of proof is on you to show that building more prisons will somehow help.

You're not using them correctly. Stop breaking the system by putting mental patients and minor criminals in prisons. Stop overcrowding, underfunding, letting sadists be guards, etc, etc, and then see if they work.

Besides, I'm not saying more, I'm saying new and appropriate ones. You can repurpose the old ones once prisoners are transferred.

This is why people are more against minimum-security prisons than maximum; minimum security prisons are an easy and obvious win and it hurts the "all prisons bad" narrative by showing the options aren't just gulags or nothing.

LawTalkingGuy··on Arizona inducing the labor of pregnant prisoners against their will
Even if we assumed the interventions would work we have a current wave of low-to-medium level crime and we need a current solution for people who are being arrested 100+ times per year, and/or avoid all arrest by staying under unwritten minimums of damage. If dealt with they have to be put somewhere and if the default is to build maximum security prisons, that's what we'll do, or maybe just over-stuff the ones we have making them more dangerous.

If we did build low-level prisons we'd not only have a solution for the interim, but it'd be an improvement over current conditions. I think they'd not only handle the new crime, but could pull non-violent offenders from the existing prisons as well - reducing overcrowding and better handling the actual danger the prisoners pose.

> Incarceration is an expensive way to not really solve the problem of crime.

Sure, and fire trucks don't solve fire. But both are part of the solution.

> addressing people's basic needs

What about crime that's not caused by poverty or need, like rape? There'll always be a need to lock people up.

I share the goal of lowering that number but I can't see how it gets to zero.

> and had better mental and healthcare we'd see less crime

Prisons aren't alone in not working as intended - that award goes to most one-size-fits-all government programs.

Those interventions aren't actually likely to solve the problem. They'll misdiagnose the problem, pick a horrible solution, and fail to execute properly anyways. I've seen this first hand with drug policy and addiction treatment. Our over-funded system is the most dangerous place to be. An addict on the streets of some poor city in the middle of nowhere has better outcomes.

LawTalkingGuy··on Arizona inducing the labor of pregnant prisoners against their will
I advocate for building more low-level prisons because they're vastly cheaper and better suited for people who've committed minor crimes. I get more pushback on this from the anti-prison crowd than when I advocate for more maximum security prisons.

It has started to feel like they're for anything that makes prisons unworkable, even if it kills prisoners in the meantime and leaves others on the street, than reforming the system because they wouldn't be able to argue against a humane and proportional prison.

Prisons suck but they suck less than it did without them. Without alternative ways to handle the preexisting problems prison abolition is a step backwards.

LawTalkingGuy··on On the insanity of being a Scrabble enthusiast
Try them all and see what they do. I got into simulating games as a kid based on arguments over what the effect of various table-rules were on games. (Spoiler: The effect of every optional rule in Monopoly is to make the game take 5x as long.)

Maybe you could spend points to pick two letter and keep the best...

Why? Because then 1) you'd know what that rule would do, and 2) maybe it'd be neat! Like, maybe you'd find an easy way to provide more balance between newbs and experts, or minimize the variation in score against a given opponent, or whatever.

LawTalkingGuy··on Police, prosecutors used junk science to decide 911 callers were liars
In a city you'd deploy them on the corner of every street and alley. Do you deploy them in the same density through rural and country areas?

Do you plan to also change fire regulations to call for an even distribution of sprinklers? Presumably you don't want to die from fire-bias either...

LawTalkingGuy··on Hard truths I learned when I got laid off from my SWE job
> This is terrible, possibly toxic advice.

[Continuing working] is the single biggest thing someone can do to avoid depression after a layoff. The best idea is a paying job because it fills both requirements.

It also keeps you ready to interview and ready to start immediately. When you're on the couch it's always easy to wait till tomorrow.

> I'd rather someone tell me they spent a year working on themselves, playing video games, hiking, etc.

If they were independently wealthy that might be okay but for most people this is self-destructive behavior.

LawTalkingGuy··on Scheduled to Die: The Rise of Canada’s Assisted Suicide Program
> I don't see any evidence [...]

I think that's the wrong standard for this - "visible evidence of failure", or "fully convincing rational". The burden of proof should be that we stop it unless we can show continual strong evidence of proportionality.

The point isn't that this is horrible now, it's that it doesn't seem to have the type of guidelines we'd posited that would keep it from getting horrible.

> it's far more important and relevant to establish [...] occurring with regularity

I don't know how many disabled veterans they've offed, but even offering it to the one shows a stunning lack of ability to judge need and a heinous disregard for that person's life.

Having a doctor recommend you kill yourself is likely to be somewhat devastating and have its own consequences even if you don't follow through.

> You could make criticisms of nearly any law if the bar for criticism is just that it's possible to push edge case X or Y.

It's not just possible, it's economically incentivized. Both at the individual and systemic level.

LawTalkingGuy··on Scheduled to Die: The Rise of Canada’s Assisted Suicide Program
> You made the claim that it's happening

No, I said 'could'. There's apparently no useful rule preventing it.

> This isn't the same as a population-based study to prove that these are not edge case exceptions that receive appropriate outcry and thereby support.

It doesn't need to be, it's an existence proof of bad policy. Even one case like this is too much.

LawTalkingGuy··on General guidance when working as a cloud engineer
> The problem the way I see it, is that people don't just experiment with new architectures within the confines of an existing system. Typically they give in to the "second system effect"

Have you tried to advise them otherwise?

> Or maybe even suggestions that have some caution codified into them

But then every suggestion is couched in a ton of warnings. Not only is this a bit useless, but if someone does start to depend on it they're at risk of a suggestion which lost its warning. Like, say the warning runs onto the next page and that page got lost.

There are an infinite number of possible suggestions and all could potentially rabbit-hole a team to death. Why not embrace immutability? Why not go serverless? Why not migrate to on-prem hardware? Why not use a memory-safe language?

It seems far better to build some sort of suggestibility-immunity by listening to others, and their suggestions, until you can understand but not feel compelled to copy their ideas.

LawTalkingGuy··on Scheduled to Die: The Rise of Canada’s Assisted Suicide Program
> Can you cite this happening?

Can you cite a rule preventing this? We'd like to keep it from happening.

> There are multiple MAiD online communities.

The Veterans community is pretty pissed off about that Paralympian athlete who was offered suicide instead of a wheelchair ramp. They don't feel this is working correctly.

LawTalkingGuy··on Scheduled to Die: The Rise of Canada’s Assisted Suicide Program
This is very real and dystopian. If they hear that you're suicidal you'll get a straight-jacket and involuntarily medicated but if they see your broken ankle they'll suicide you for free.
LawTalkingGuy··on Scheduled to Die: The Rise of Canada’s Assisted Suicide Program
Total hit piece on the journalist. Try engaging with the story before poisoning the well.

The problem with MAiD the way Canada implemented it is that there are incentives for the system to off you. In that scenario you mention with the doctor he didn't get paid to show you the switch, and he risks being charged if his healthy patients start dying. Now it's risk free, he could clear his schedule for the holidays and face no recriminations.

> is it right for someone to have the freedom to choose the time and manner of their own death

That's not the question that ended up being asked, it's can a doctor recommend that your depressed child be killed before they've put any effort into therapy.

Or, can a hospital administrator reward the nurses' pod with the most patient suicides with a bonus?

> is that a compassionate death should be an option [...] no reasonable prospect of turning around a terrible situation [...] no reasonable prospect of recovery

Yeah, that's not how it works. They're supposed to ask that sort of stuff, and you aren't supposed to want to die for lack of some food, but in fact it's not helping the people you think and not saving those you'd wish.

LawTalkingGuy··on Scheduled to Die: The Rise of Canada’s Assisted Suicide Program
No, it was intended to save a lot more.

Like Civil Forfeiture, the medical system should never see a single cent "saved" via suicide. Because otherwise, yes, we're saying we think they'd optimize for it.

LawTalkingGuy··on General guidance when working as a cloud engineer
> As long as no adopting advice at face value and no cargo culting follows, sure.

I advise you to take all advice with a grain of salt. :) It's just what someone else thinks, it's not something magic.

> I'm worried that someone senior will do that, because they want microservices on their CV

Heh. I was going to say that the only way this advice is "dangerous" is if a point-haired boss hears about it. Someone padding a resume is the danger though, not the technology they choose.

> This is something I can get behind for internal pilot projects, side projects, or hackathons and such. This is not something that I can get behind for projects with potential contractual penalties.

Just don't merge it into the main branch.

> The entire e-health system of my country is a good example of this [...]

I'll check it out. Thanks.

LawTalkingGuy··on General guidance when working as a cloud engineer
> Some people might take it at face value and end up with dozens if not hundreds of services

You're worried that someone junior enough to run with random advice is going to be able to rearchitect their entire codebase into hundreds of microservices and deploy it to production without testing its performance/stability/etc?

I think they should try. It's a great way to learn why, and why not.

> many people out there would probably agree with the claim that some general advice can definitely be dangerous.

It's just mouth noises which aren't dangerous. We need to be able to hear other people's opinions (advice is just an opinion after all) without immediately adopting it.

LawTalkingGuy··on MIT faculty adopts “Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”
A nurse helped fund an "I heart J. K. Rowling" billboard and is having her job threatened. Close enough.

https://www.newsweek.com/nurse-being-investigated-i-love-jk-...

LawTalkingGuy··on General guidance when working as a cloud engineer
All guidance assumes it's for a thinking person. You should look at what could be learned, not insist that there be one unambiguous message and that it be earth-shaking.

> I find that “microservices should only perform a single task” is a really dangerous way to phrase it because we have no idea what the article means by “task.”

First off, it's not dangerous. It's just loosely defined.

Second, it's not important to know their task size to still know that two different (to them!) things shouldn't be shoved together.

If the two tasks fit together so well that it's a mere 5% extra code to do them both, then maybe they are two sides of the same coin. But if "one simple thing" is painful to implement maybe it's really two separate things under one blanket.

> often they settle on “one microservice per bounded context” where “bounded context” means “separated however I want it separated at the time,”

Right, because sometimes 'bounded context' is what Legal tells you about data residency and sometimes it's about optimal latency.

> Don't get me started on how “strong coupling” is shorthand for “coupled in ways I don't like”

Strong coupling is generally easy to define, relative to loose coupling, in any given language/platform. The value of engineering around it depends on the value of doing the thing which requires it multiplied by how often you have to do it.

LawTalkingGuy··on General guidance when working as a cloud engineer
> the complexities of managing a fleet

These things are inherent complexities in any situation with backup/DR. You've already got to figure this out. When one machine is degraded and another is trying to recover from db logs, that's a cluster.

> This decision should be made per-project

This is one of the least project-dependent things ever, akin to source control. If you don't have scripted installs you don't know what you're running and you can't reliably test it or upgrade it.

You don't need to run a cluster, or have auto-scaling groups, just because you can.

LawTalkingGuy··on The Overlords Finally Showed Up
Reply as if you assume good intent because defeating someone's straw man as if they were serious is useful content.

Anything else is a flame war and might be fun but isn't helpful or valuable.

LawTalkingGuy··on China stages 'strike drills' around Taiwan, citing provocation
They didn't conduct "invade and colonize China" exercises. It's somewhat like the difference between carrying a weapon and brandishing it threateningly.
LawTalkingGuy··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
> Should a small bank be obliged [...]

Yes. That's the point of becoming a licensed type of entity. If you don't like it, remain private.

That lady didn't have to issue gay-marriages certificates, but if she didn't she wasn't going to keep her job at the state marriage office.

> A service like Kickstarter just won't be neutral

Sure, so they need to remain arms-length from government then.

> I'm worried about AWS, and such. The current state of affairs is such that exclusion, censorship and such are inevitable.

Yup.

LawTalkingGuy··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
My reasoning is that if they stated their policies clearly and had to do so to enforce them that we would be able to have other processors that would move into that area. The theory is that porn is has lots of chargeback and legal risks and another company focused on this area could do so in a better fashion.

I support breaking down this monopoly as well though, because I acknowledge the ground reality of where we are now.

LawTalkingGuy··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
To some degree, no. As these media outlets collaborate with government, as the twitter files are showing, they lose their right to have their own voice.

I doubt Kickstarter or Gawker has crossed the line, but it is there to be crossed.

LawTalkingGuy··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
And others are just pointing out that this isn't a grass-roots movement of hurt or concerned individuals and actually is the same manipulative media outlets that have blown everything out of proportion for years, hoping to create a backlash.
LawTalkingGuy··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
Quick policy decisions needed! Do we block or promote Rohingyan folk art? Are "Russian" nesting dolls a microagression? Are suffragette ribbons hateful now?

The idea that platforms, all of them, need to enforce the day-to-day minutia of the chattering classes is ridiculous.

Platforms need to pick a few broad policies. "No porn" is a pretty good policy actually, and stick with it. And of course actually illegal things, "anything that is obviously illegal, or that we are told to take down with a warrant".

LawTalkingGuy··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
In Somalia you can't "block" a neighboring warlord and keep living your best life.

4chan isn't designed to actually be a great forum, but the nearly-unlimited content is not the problem. A lack of user-tools for sorting through it is.

LawTalkingGuy··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
I'd be okay if Visa and Kickstarted blocked porn, for instance, but I want them to be clear about it and make any card-denied messages explain this to merchant and customer. What I don't like is this gray area where CC companies won't block Pornhub for years of CSAM scandals but then finally get the nerve when a story catches the news.
← PreviousPage 10 of 19Next →