23 karma · joined October 23, 2026
My theory is you either a) don't understand the words "signal reconstruction" or b) don't accept reconstruction to be as philosophically pure as "sampling".
So, to fix your final blocker, tell me, how many times do you think you'd have to listen to a 1 minute track of white noise before you could reliably identify any part of it, or generate it on any instrument, using your human faculties and skills?
Now answer the same question for one piece of your favourite music.
Is the white noise use case even remotely interesting to humans? Basically no, except in random number generation. But, is the music case analogous to anything interesting? Basically, yes, it's analogous to everything we do. From weather forecasting to LHC to James Webb to digital compression to fusion reactor control to...
...and in conclusion, signal reconstruction is extremely useful and interesting, and we no longer ever need to sample at 2x the frequency, ever again, in many, many cases, for imperceptibly perfect reconstruction at that frequency!
I'm having the best luck dude, I get to chat to a cyberdildo! Who has more fun, me or the dildo?
I suppose it could make actually worse at taking instructions and redirection mid-task, but that could be easy to work around too. Just hold back a bit of the spec and drip feed it in later?
I don't mean cheat on it, I just mean optimize for it harder!
A 100kW Earth based solar array and a 500kWh grid scale battery that will last ~20 years is already a tiny fraction of the cost of even one Starlink satellite. That's today. Commercial. No assumptions.
It doesn't matter even if it was free to put a satellite in orbit, as it only lasts five years once it's up there.
Their radiator assumptions are also laughable. 13x-28x better than ISS with carbon wizardry entirely on paper. TRL level what exactly?
Most of your comments have been like this, it's bizarre.
Almost all real world signals have more discernable structure than noise, almost by definition. So, for any signal you might actually want to sample and reconstruct, you probably have some prior knowledge of the structure, and thus if you can find a sparse basis, can reconstruct with higher fidelity sampling below the frequency the Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem would suggest.
Fixed that for you.
That's not how single pixel cameras work at all. They use things like coded aperture masks, structured lighting, and take many samples of a scene to reconstruct any possible high resolution image.
Is this the core of our disagreement?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed_sensing
Compressed sensing (also known as compressive sensing, compressive sampling, or sparse sampling) is a signal processing technique for efficiently acquiring and reconstructing a signal by finding solutions to underdetermined linear systems. This is based on the principle that, through optimization, the sparsity of a signal can be exploited to recover it from far fewer samples than required by the Nyquist–Shannon sampling theorem. There are two conditions under which recovery is possible. The first one is sparsity, which requires the signal to be sparse in some domain. The second one is incoherence, which is applied through the isometric property, which is sufficient for sparse signals.[1][2] Compressed sensing has applications in, for example, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) where the incoherence condition is typically satisfied.[3]
It's not compression. Look it up, it's really cool. Random sampling in a sparse basis. Using the prior. Single pixel camera can reconstruct a 10MP image, etc.
A more approachable example is not needing Nyquist limit of 44.1kHz to reconstruct any frequency up to 22kHz, if the sound is sparse in some basis and samples are random.
For example, if you know a signal is only a solo trumpet, you can probably reconstruct a perceptually perfect recording from just a few kHz of random samples. But, a solo piano would need many more random samples, as there are more harmonics and the hammer strikes, greater complexity and broadband hammer click isn't sparse in frequency.
Well, fewer problems!
No, our data is barely even safe with ourselves. It's definitely not safe with anyone else!