HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Mediterraneo10

8,206 karma · joined April 16, 2017

submissionscomments
Mediterraneo10··on FBI subpoenaed Apple for data of Sci-Hub founder
FWIW, I wasn’t talking about providing a manuscript in LaTeX and the publisher providing "end-control of the typesetting". (LaTeX is generally used for journal publications only in certain STEM fields, and not in my own field.) Rather, I was referring to cases where the for-profit publisher expects e.g. a Word document already fully typeset, and then the publisher does not contribute anything at all to typesetting except its own copyright page.
Mediterraneo10··on FBI subpoenaed Apple for data of Sci-Hub founder
In a way, you are lucky if the journal has outsourced typesetting to some low-quality shop. Some for-profit publishers demand that the unpaid editors do all the copyediting, proofreading, and typesetting, and just provide the publisher with a camera-ready PDF. The for-profit publisher no longer provides any of the added value it once did. (Only distribution is left, and that isn’t a big deal, because even old-school non-profit learned societies manage to distribute their journals to libraries around the world.)
Mediterraneo10··on The Sovietisation of the Mongolian language and challenges of reversal (2020)
No, the Turkic languages of Russia often have very similar phonology, but the Stalin-era language planners intentionally chose different ways to orthographically represent identical features across the languages.

For example, Turkic languages typically feature front/back vowel harmony where stops are velar before front vowels and uvular before back vowels. This is represented differently in the Stalin-era Cyrillic orthographies for Karachay Balkar (к/къ), Kazakh (к/қ) and Tatar (just к with the following vowel letter showing the distinction). Bashkir neighbors both Tatar and Kazakh and is mutually intelligible with them, and it doesn’t differ at all in this feature, but its orthography was given к/ҡ just to make it different from the other two.

Mediterraneo10··on Directory of Open Access Journals
This depends on the field. What I get sent as a peer reviewer is generally in pretty good shape already, and the author has simply missed a relevant publication here or there, or got a factoid wrong. So, the paper was already nearly publishable as it was, and it didn’t take me more than a few minutes really to make it even better. Often my work in these cases is its own reward.

I actually got sent my first outright awful paper recently, and there wasn’t in the end much of an onus on me. The flaws of the paper were so blatant that I could simply tell the editor that the entire premise was unsound without having to go into much detail, and the editor understood.

Mediterraneo10··on The Sovietisation of the Mongolian language and challenges of reversal (2020)
Roughly, latinization was a Lenin-era policy. However, when Stalin came to power he had different goals and philosophy than the preceding regime of Lenin. For one, Stalin abandoned the idea of spreading world revolution in favour of "socialism in one country", which in large part was about keeping the USSR (and, as its satellite, Mongolia) walled off from the outside world for the sake of tighter control.

For speakers of the USSR’s Turkic languages (Kazakh, Tatar, Crimean Tatar, etc.), latinization was therefore seen as harmful, because these languages are often fairly mutually intelligible with Turkish of Turkey, and a common-ish Latin alphabet would mean these peoples would be susceptible to anti-Soviet ideas coming from Turkey. Therefore, the Stalin-era language authorities not only gave them a new Cyrillic orthography, they gave each language a different Cyrillic orthography than the rest to fragment them even further.

In the case of Mongolian, Cyrillic helped better separate Mongolian of Mongolia from the mutually intelligible dialect of Mongolian spoken across the border in China.

Mediterraneo10··on Reddit aims to double in size as social news site invests for growth
For example, the old interface shows more of the discussion, while the new interface hides things unless clicked on. So, readers actually have context before they give their own input. Less chance of kneejerk reactions to the post immediately above.
Mediterraneo10··on Directory of Open Access Journals
I feel like a clearer distinction needs to be drawn between open-access journals that are offered by non-profit learned societies (often no charge to publish), and open-access journals that are offered by the for-profit publishers (often high charges to publish).

I don’t have a permanent post in academia and am often away from funded positions while I do other things with my life, but I remain interested in my field and I publish the occasional paper. I can do that because I don’t need to pay to publish in my field. But OA journals that are pay-to-publish discourage contributions from those who aren’t lucky enough to have a grant-soliciting apparatus behind them (or lots of money to pay out of their own pockets).

Mediterraneo10··on Reddit aims to double in size as social news site invests for growth
A new small community getting critical mass is more difficult nowadays, because so many people are accessing the social internet primarily through mobile phones. That means that a lot of people expect a ready-made app, and navigating through a web browser to e.g. a phpBB forum and signing up for an account there seems too burdensome.

Then, because of the limitations of phone keyboards (even for those who boast of their touch-typing skills), discussion tends to get shorter and less information-dense. If you look at Reddit posting on some special-interest from six years ago, people were typically offering a couple of solid paragraphs. Now, most people there are writing one-line comments, and if you write the length I’m writing now, you look out of place. (People might even say "lol wall of text bro").

Mediterraneo10··on Reddit aims to double in size as social news site invests for growth
The problem with you choosing old.reddit.com, is that it doesn’t fix the general culture of the site where everyone else is using the new interface. Everyone else is asking the same questions again and again because the subreddit’s sidebar (which might have a FAQ and general rules) is hidden in the new interface. Everyone else is engaging in inane one-line comments and meme posts because the new interface does not encourage substantial, nuanced discussion.
Mediterraneo10··on Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger life cycle assessment (2018)
This rhetoric only convinces those people who already feel sympathetic to animal-rights arguments. But for example, a significant slice of the world’s population are adherents of religions that downright ordain slaughtering an animal at times, and they will only be alienated by your argument.

Consequently, I feel like health and environmental arguments are better ways to get people to limit their meat intake.

Mediterraneo10··on The Grim Secret of Nordic Happiness
People do not typically talk to their neighbors in Finland in blocks and I have not seen any major change in this regard in the last couple of decades. Indeed, in Helsinki it is becoming a common behavior, before opening the door and leaving, to first look out the peephole to make sure that there isn’t anyone in the corridor – not running into one’s neighbors at all is seen as a common courtesy.

Obviously people living out in Junttila might talk to their neighbors, but these are comparatively so few people that they aren’t representative of the country.

Mediterraneo10··on The Grim Secret of Nordic Happiness
I can think of some other problems with Finland from my years of experience with the country. One is nepotism: Finland has a reputation as a low-corruption country, but that is simply because it is swept under the rug that often jobs and state funding go to the people with the right connections.

Another downside is a society that is rather hostile to those who want to work only seasonally. In Eastern Europe populations are comparatively poorer, but it isn’t at all unusual for a young person to work his/her ass off for a while, then backpack the world or live off savings. In Finland, I found this challenging because rental contracts on flats are very long as a rule, and because the high cost of living makes it difficult to live off savings.

Mediterraneo10··on A fringe Japanese religion built a pro-Trump social media empire
Indeed. Western European leftism of recent decades has largely been the legacy of May 1968 (and its failure). What is noteworthy about the ideological debates of May 1968 is what they were not about: no interest in trans rights – even gay liberation and a new wave of feminism were only dawning at the time – and racial conflicts were not understood in the same way as they currently are in the USA. Thus not only does American leftwing politics have a distinctive set of concerns, but it is even imported into Europe as a new kind of leftwing politics different from the old. (And it is a bit surreal to see the occasional suggestion that people dedicated to the May 1968 ideals are "fascist", when that whole movement saw itself as a battle against fascism.)
Mediterraneo10··on A fringe Japanese religion built a pro-Trump social media empire
BLM as an organization (as opposed to the more nebulous BLM popular movement as a general desire to end police violence) has been vocal about trans rights, for instance. People in other countries who oppose trans rights might therefore see BLM as an ideological opponent. I can’t speak about Japan, but BLM is certainly discussed as a bearer of inimical ideas among some Europeans.
Mediterraneo10··on Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe workforce shortage
It is a mistake to assume that those living on UBI and not working in formal employment would be "never productively contributing to society". Sure, a portion of UBI recipients might be entirely idle, but others would contribute to things that are seen as a social positive even if they don’t neatly fit into profit-generating, paid-salary-position-creating activities.

For example, if I didn’t have to work myself, I could finally do some of the more ambitious contributions to OpenStreetMap that I have been dreaming of: adding all the missing house numbers for my county, for instance. Then society as a whole benefit from that libre resource even if I as a contributor was not paid a salary for it. By the same token, some of the most active Wikipedia editors are able to dedicate such enormous time and effort because, for whatever reason, they do not work. Yet all of us here benefit day in and day out from what they do.

Mediterraneo10··on A fringe Japanese religion built a pro-Trump social media empire
The popular stereotype of Japan is one of a multireligious society that has combined Buddhism and indigenous belief (Shintoism), without most of the population being particularly dogmatic. But Japan has some quirky minority religions[0] that one might only come across by being in the right subculture.

I used to dabble in Esperanto, and Japanese Esperantists are often followers of the religion Oomoto, which regards Esperanto’s creator as a saint. On one hand, I’m grateful to the opportunity to learn more about Japan. On the other hand, when you meet Japanese people through Esperanto, you have to remember you are meeting a rather non-representative fringe. (Something similar happens with Brazilian Esperantists, who are often involved in the Spiritism quasi-religion founded by Allan Kardec.)

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_new_religions

Mediterraneo10··on A fringe Japanese religion built a pro-Trump social media empire
The phrase "MAGA" became a marker of Trump affiliation. That in turn made it odious to people on the other side of the polarized political spectrum (few Americans have a problem with the literal idea of improving the USA, of course, but in human language signifiers can become associated with signifieds beyond their supposed literal meaning).

Then, when some people sympathetic to Trump internationally saw that MAGA hats were 1) a marker of the "Trump tribe", and 2) annoying to their perceived ideological opponents, they too took them up. Thus things like QAnon and MAGA spread memetically to some of the protests seen in the last few years in Europe.

Mediterraneo10··on Réunion: the postmen of the peaks
I read this article a few days ago, and the question I was asking myself was: how do people in these isolated communities support themselves? The article mentions people even moving back to these communities from the developed parts of the island. Is there some industry there to keep them employed, or do they live purely from benefits?
Mediterraneo10··on UFOs shows government competence as either surprisingly high or low
He made his argument into a novel because he is a writer, novels are what he does. But he tends to write around the scientific ideas he has been reading and his work often serves as convenient summaries of those ideas for a broad audience – mentioning a KSR plot is standard fare on "news for nerds" sites like this one.

Also, my post above intentionally says "akin to" and not "identical to".

Mediterraneo10··on How Cities Will Fossilise
They often aren’t OK. In many of those whole towns in Eastern Europe, the municipality is gradually pushing to move people out of the socialist-era concrete buildings and into newer ones. Their design means that, even if the structure itself does remain physically sound, they often struggle with ventilation, so mold forms.
Mediterraneo10··on UFOs shows government competence as either surprisingly high or low
I recommend reading the novel. The key line in it is “Life is a planetary phenomenon.” Basically, the argument is that at less than planetary scale, you would be confronted with things like waste products building up too quickly to sustain human life. For example, the generation starship struggles with an excess of salt (which in turn affects food production). The limited confines of the ship also produce deleterious effect on successive human generations akin to those found among species in isolated island ecosystems.
Mediterraneo10··on UFOs shows government competence as either surprisingly high or low
Generation ships may not be possible, at least for biological lifeforms. Kim Stanley Robinson wrote his novel Aurora in large part to argue this.
Mediterraneo10··on Ask HN: Is Google Search Dying?
> Sites that literally just copy a random version of the docs are ranked higher...

Recently I put something together in Common Lisp, a language I’m a novice at, so I often had to search. The first result returned in all my Google searches was a copycat website. Someone had clearly taken some previous high-quality Lisp reference and extensively rewritten it to avoid copyright violation, then loaded it with SEO. However, their English was rather poor and so this rewrite was a pain to read.

I would love a search engine that would allow me to zap certain domains and hide them permanently from results, but at the same time without retaining information about me for advertising purposes.

Mediterraneo10··on Awk is the coolest tool you don't know
While "most *nix folks over a certain age already know it well", IMO it would be a shame for it to limited to them. I regularly encounter younger developers unfamiliar with standard tools like sed, tr, cut, etc. that I use often to solve everyday personal tasks.

The world took a wrong path when *nix tools were no longer seen as appropriate things for ordinary people to learn. (Yes, in the 1980s clerical staff in some companies were taught awk or even Emacs.) Productivity of the labour force would only rise. When my spouse moved to my country and didn’t yet know the local language, she worked for a multinational outsourcing firm. The job turned out to be little more than glorified data entry and it could have been easily automated with *nix tools piped. Hiring educated people to sit 8 hours a day and do everything manually was a waste of money and human potential.

Mediterraneo10··on Why are there so many unfinished buildings in Africa?
Indeed, this is the theme of Ousmane Sembène’s film Mandabi that recently got a nice release from Criterion: a Senegalese man gets sent some money from a relative working in France, but his family, neighbors, and local officials all demand a slice of it, and ultimately he not only loses the money order, he loses everything.
Mediterraneo10··on I Used to Write for Sports Illustrated. Now I Deliver Packages for Amazon (2018)
Embracing activism isn't necessarily a shooting oneself in the foot, it can be a way of trying to ensure greater profitability. A case in point is The Guardian which took a huge turn in the last decade ago from traditional British working-class themes to trans issues and the specific kind of race debates originating from the US. By doing so, the newspaper could, firstly, win the allegiance of self-identified "woke" readers (who are often affluent and thus a target for advertisers). But even for other readers, culture-war-related reporting can get people all fired up and thus generate views and ad impressions.
Mediterraneo10··on Will Linux phones stay around this time?
Even LineageOS hardcodes calls to Google servers (location, network portal detection). To get around that you can install LineageOS with MicroG, or use a true Linux phone.
Mediterraneo10··on The 'Great Wave' has mystified art lovers for generations (2019)
Japan itself has a homegrown industry of claiming it is utterly different from all other nations. This has led Japanese academics to e.g. claim that the Japanese cannot eat imported rice because only local rice is compatible with their anatomy. Or another example (common through the 1970s, less found today with the larger amount of immigrant labour): foreigners should be taught only a simplified and artificial form of Japanese, because no way could foreign brains ever grasp the real Japanese language.

So, when foreigners speak of Japan as weird, this only plays into Japanese own attitude.

Mediterraneo10··on The Slackware Way (2012)
Of course Slackware is supported in the sense we are talking about here: security updates are provided for packages when needed.
Mediterraneo10··on Excess Deaths in 2020
The public may not have significantly supported that in the first lockdown last year, but there apparently has been support in later waves. In my country during the third wave, the health minister has pleaded that hospitals are being overwhelmed, yet at the same time the data he’s getting from mobile operators show that the public has returned to 2019-levels of mobility. The broad public, not just some outliers unwilling to observe the lockdown. The general attitude now seems to be that vaccination has arrived, so restrictions are no longer appropriate, and if you die before you can get vaccinated, tough luck.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →