HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

QuantumChaos

130 karma · joined March 29, 2014

submissionscomments
QuantumChaos··on Silicon Valley Tech Entrepreneurs: Behind the Stereotype
I don't follow your logic.

The more you work, the more you get paid and the less affected you will be by this sort of thing, so I would assume this sort of risk motivated people to work harder.

QuantumChaos··on Silicon Valley Tech Entrepreneurs: Behind the Stereotype
The disruption that people experience due to sudden price changes certainly has a negative affect on them, but this is simply the reality of demand for these resources.

It would be nice if the government or private industry could insure people against this kind of disruption, but I don't see it happening soon.

In the meantime, people are constantly affected by all sorts of circumstances out of their control.

Unless you don't believe in the free market at all, I don't see how the case of renters is any different.

QuantumChaos··on Silicon Valley Tech Entrepreneurs: Behind the Stereotype
I think most people have an intuitive understanding of free market principals. If a person can pay more for an apartment, they not only have the legal right, but the moral right, to outbid someone else.

In order to deal with inequality, we have progressive income tax and welfare. These mechanisms are the fairest, because they don't favor people based on their individual preferences.

Now a poor person who lived their whole life in SF doesn't really have an inherent preference for living in SF. And they probably are made worse off by the tech industry. But it is still the government, if anyone, who should compensate such people for their changed circumstance, and it's also practically impossible to figure out if that person is really worse off than, say, a person with the same income who lived in Detroit their whole life.

So there is no valid principal by which people should hate people in tech, and I think most people actually understand this.

However, people dislike nerds, and they like to rationalize their beliefs. I remember people called me arrogant in school, not because I was, but because that way they could enjoy the moral indignation. I think something similar is happening here.

QuantumChaos··on India’s Toilet Race Failing as Villages Don’t Use Them
I hope they can figure this issue out. As a westerner who never considered not using a toilet, I'm having trouble understanding the pros and cons of using toilets at all.

What happens if a person defecates in the fields? Does this spread bacteria to other people living nearby, or people who eat crops grown in those fields?

What are the beneficiaries of me using a toilet instead of the fields? My family? The people living nearby? Hopefully providing accurate information on these matters will help villagers make better choices.

QuantumChaos··on Jesse Jackson: Tech diversity is next civil rights step
They would be an even bigger percentage if not for discrimination.

The US used to have quotas for Jews in many universities, as did the Soviet Union. The unofficial quota system for Asians is no different.

QuantumChaos··on Jesse Jackson: Tech diversity is next civil rights step
So why do you believe that achievements of Blacks in basketball is a result of their higher ability, but not the same for Whites in tech?
QuantumChaos··on Camels and humps: a retraction [pdf]
where does he say that specifically? He refers to statisticians helping to do further analysis on the data, but I don't see where they showed that the main claim (that the test is predictive of success in the course) is refuted by statisticians.
QuantumChaos··on The Scientific Problem That Must Be Experienced
The articles main thesis is that an intuitive, artistic understanding of turbulence can help inform mathematicians.

And yet none of the historical evidence that was presented supported this claim. The pure mathematicians made progress and discovered interesting patterns. Those who focused on art and philosophy (Schauberger and Schwenk) contributed nothing to the understanding of turbulence.

QuantumChaos··on The voodoo of lobster economics
>As broken down above, most of the money from that lobster ultimately goes somewhere else.

You can't have it both ways. The only affect that the market has on the local market for lobsters in Bangladesh, is via the price in Bangladesh, i.e. the price the fishermen pay.

So to the extent that they are affecting the market in Bangladesh, they must be paying higher prices, and therefore the parent comment applies.

>But unless you're an economist, you have to posit that the enjoyment from a lobster dinner is the same whether you're a Bengali villager or a yuppie in San Francisco. In a sense they're giving up $60 of enjoyment to get a couple of dollars of cash.

The economists are in fact correct. You cannot measure enjoyment in dollars, because $60 will buy a lot more additional enjoyment for a Bengali villager than a San Francisco yuppie. So the villager would be willing to give up the enjoyment of a lobster dinner for much less than $60, which is precisely what they are doing.

QuantumChaos··on Camels and humps: a retraction [pdf]
The reasons were in my post:

He has no real criticism of his original article. What he says about it is incoherent, not merely hard to read, as I point out in my comment.

And he makes reference to nature vs nurture, which is completely irrelevant to the actual issue, and only makes sense in the context of a political apology.

QuantumChaos··on Camels and humps: a retraction [pdf]
That article didn't seem very coherent. E.g. on the original test he says:

"His test is not a very good predictor: most of those who appear to use a model in the pre-course test pass the end-of-course exam but so do many of those who do not."

How many pass, how many do not? That is the information needed to determine a predictive test.

Reading between the lines, I would guess that he got in trouble because his original article wasn't politically correct. One line in the retraction reads "We hadn’t shown that nature trumps nurture. Just a phenomenon and a prediction." I would guess he came under political pressure, and felt pressured to write this article in order to avoid further problems.

QuantumChaos··on Linus Torvalds gives a tour of his home office
he looks healthy and beautiful to me.
QuantumChaos··on Thanks, HN: You helped discover a disease and save lives
I see two separate phenomena.

The article describes researchers being rewarded for their publications, and therefore not sharing data with their competitors, who could create a publication with that data which the researcher who shared the data would get no credit for.

You are describing people favoring graduates from top universities, which therefore charge higher tuition since their degrees are more valuable.

I can't see any relationship between these two things, maybe you can clarify.

QuantumChaos··on What's the scariest thing in the world? Ask your teenage daughter
I think the vitriol arises from the stranglehold progressives have on the use of "science" in public discourse. The only allow "science" to be used is used to demonstrate that women are in some sense more oppressed or less fortunate than men, or that women are more capable or good than men.

There is a double standard when it comes to evidence and argumentation. In one direction, it is ok to use "science" and even "biology". In the other, it is only ok to use sociology or feminist theory.

QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
What you are missing is that you are focusing entirely on edge cases. No sociological category is so airtight that you cannot "deconstruct" it. E.g. it is also true that Jewish Americans have more in common with non-Jewish Americans in terms of language and culture than Jewish Israelis. Does that mean that, like Whiteness, Jewishness is simply a category that has been invented to serve some political purpose?
QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
The European diaspora has more than 2000 years of shared religion, language and culture.

This is far more significant than some trivia about the word "White" that is making the rounds in progressive circles.

QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
They certainly have much more in common in all these areas than they do with non-Europeans.
QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
>What is wrong with that? Do the Jewish people somehow not deserve existence? Why should we not celebrate our culture and religion the same way Christians, Croats, and Italians do? (for example.)

If Jewish people deserve existence (as a group, not individuals), then White people deserve existence as a group.

You say that White people are allowed to celebrate their culture and religion, and yet these are precisely the actions that are demonized as racism or at best ignorant provincialism, by the same liberals Jews I am describing.

You simply cannot have it both ways. My first post described how supporting Israel's existence as a Jewish nation was contradictory to liberal Jew's attitude towards White identity. You now concede that Jewish identity is in fact very similar to White identity. But now you are trying to change the argument, as if I was the one saying that Jewish identity was unacceptable. I'm not. I'm saying it is no more or less acceptable that White identity.

>Killing someone is unacceptable. Killing someone for their race is even less acceptable.

I disagree, but that isn't the point here. The argument against genocide I'm referring to is that it is more wrong because it wipes out a particular race or ethnicity, not because of the mindset of the perpetrator.

>So now you're getting very Stormfronty.

>That I have to explain this to you makes me think I might be dealing with anti-semitism.

You are clutching at straws.

QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
I'm familiar with holocaust as a reason for Israel's existence, I just don't accept it as the primary reason. There are simply to many occasions where American Jews and Israelis celebrate Jewish culture and identity for its own sake, and not merely as a reaction to being singled out by other Whites.

Even the narrative of the holocaust suggests that Jewish identity and culture is valued for its own sake. The concept of genocide implies that wiping an entire group of people is worse than simply killing the same number of randomly selected people. If this is true, then it follows that there was some inherent value in that group's identity, beyond their worth, and right to exist, as individuals.

QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
First, people certainly will begrudge Croats their national identity, when they get around to it. I'm sure you're familiar with the battle against English identity or Swedish identity (at least when they are defined in the same way as Jewish identity is).

Furthermore, I think that you are simply defining anyone who talks or thinks about White identity as a "neo-Nazi". Jews are given space where they can think about and consider their identity. Whites are only permitted to feel shame about theirs.

The onus is on you to explain why people with common appearance, ethnic background, language and culture, do not form a well defined group simply because they are more numerous than Jewish people are as a group. Or why, the European disapora, having intermingled in the US for 500 years, must completely give up their identity and accept anyone from the world as like them, simply because they don't originate from a single country.

QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
>No, they don't. Don't legitimize their nonsense.

I share this critique, and I outlined it in my post, so I'm not legitimizing them, but rather outlining what things I think they are correct about.

I simply do not believe that Israel as a Jewish state is a "security measure". Almost no one thinks of it in these terms, neither Israeli Jews or American Jews (Einstein did, but he was in a minority). Israeli's (and American Jews) typcially describe Israel is existing for the protection of Israel identity, religion and culture, not the physical protection of individual Jews.

You say that most Jews support the inclusion of other people in their communities, and yet the Prime Minister of Israel said "If we don't stop their [African asylum seekers] entry, the problem that currently stands at 60,000 could grow to 600,000, and that threatens our existence as a Jewish and democratic state ... This phenomenon is very grave and threatens the social fabric of society, our national security and our national identity."

>Please don't bring Stormfront to HN.

I will bring my own beliefs to HN, feel free to deal with it however you like.

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/may/20/israel-netanyah...

QuantumChaos··on The Data of Hate
Even though they take their views to ridiculous extremes, sites like Stormfront do have a valid critique of the hypocrisy of liberal American Jews.

Exactly the same people and groups who claim that White people desiring to live among other White people is stupid and immoral, also believe that Israel being a Jewish nation is non-negotiable. Only the far-left (e.g. Norman Finkelstein and Chomsky in some moments) are consistent in criticizing Jewish identity and White identity in the same terms.

The mainstream claim that these two concepts are completely distinct and incomparable, and yet there is no obvious difference. The only way that this discrepancy can be seen as something other than hypocrisy, is if either (1) Jewish identity is entirely defensive, i.e. a reaction to prejudice from the society in which Jews happen to live, or (2) Jewishness is an entirely separate category, incomparable to race or ethnicity (I don't include religion because I don't think that the concept of Jewish identity solely as a religious identity stands up to scrutiny).

In response to (1), I don't see this as the full picture as Jewishness is allowed to be celebrated in its own right. The idea that Israel should be Jewish merely for the physical protection of Jews, rather than the protection of Jewish identity, is not consistent with how Israelis or their liberal supporters describe Israel.

In response to (2), the only way that Jewishness can be rendered incomparable to Whiteness, is to accept that the most extreme views against Whites are true. Namely that (unlike every other cultural or ethnic identity), Whiteness is an identity of racial supremacism and oppresion. Some people (again, on the far left) truly believe this. But I find it a ridiculous assertion, and most people simply are too brow-beaten to dig this deep in to anti-racist discourse.

QuantumChaos··on Goldman says client data leaked, wants Google to delete email
Putting aside the issue of whether there is any legal basis for ordering Google to delete something that was accidentally disclosed, I also take issue with their claim that the request is in itself reasonable.

They are not only requesting Google to delete this email, but also provide information to Goldman Sachs about who accessed that information. This violates the privacy of the person who received the email. What right does a company have to know how you accessed your own email, or who you shared it with, just because they accidentally sent you an email?

QuantumChaos··on Social Psychology Is A Flamethrower
That is pretty shoddy, but bear in mind this is an undergrad thesis, and so (apart from teaching very bad ethics to future researchers) this has no bearing on research that will ultimately be published.

As an aside, I first misread your post and thought you were describing the process of taking your own survey, while putting your self in the mind-frame of the person filling it out, in order to imagine what goes through someone's head when they fill it in. This seems like an extremely good idea.

QuantumChaos··on Teaching college is no longer a middle-class job, and everyone should care
Why should paying teachers be considered good in itself? Are you familiar with the First and Second Welfare Theorem in economics?
QuantumChaos··on The Highest-Paid CEOs Are The Worst Performers, New Study Says
People need to take the efficient market hypothesis seriously when using stock prices for things like this.

The announcement of a new CEO (or more realistically, the rumors preceding the announcement) already given the market a chance to adjust based on their expectations of the CEO. So what the study really shows is that highly paid CEOs tend to perform less well than the market would expect. This might be because they perform worse. It might also be because they perform better, but not by as large a margin as the market expected.

QuantumChaos··on The hidden cost of Gangnam Style
Surely the Economist writers, of all people, can imagine that being entertained is worth something, and might possibly be worth the opportunity cost of the time people spend on entertainment. After all, by watching the video people have revealed their preference for spending their time this way.
QuantumChaos··on We Need To Talk About Depression
would you be able to point to how specifically this video addresses my points?

I would be much easier to have a discussion if you did this, since otherwise people who don't have time to watch a 1 hour video will have to take it on faith that this video really addresses the questions I asked. And assuming it did, it would probably be useful to have the points summarized here so we could discuss them.

QuantumChaos··on We Need To Talk About Depression
I think you have not read my post carefully. I was clear in separating believing in discrete categories (both their objective existence and their usefulness), vs believing that symptoms can be treated.

>Labels do serve some use. But many people hate having the label and they hide it. Stigma is still very strong. For all the people who are open about their diagnosis there are many who keep it secret -- or who do not seek treatment because they are scared of the stigma.

You've ignored my argument regarding why people seek out labels, apart from their therapeutic usefulness. I did also state that these labels have a stigma associated with them, but I made a claim, that you haven't addressed, that the stigma of the symptoms in the absence of diagnosis, may be greater than the stigma of the label.

>Depression is not just sadness. Imagine your favourite show going off TV. You may be sad for a while. You probably won't feel as if it's your fault it's come off air, nor that there is never going to be anything else worth watching, and the feelings won't be constantly with you throughout the day and probably won't last long.

It is this sort of claim, that I was asking for evidence for. I agree that a person might feel all these things, and that it might be reasonable to label this cluster of symptoms as "depression". But you are taking it much much further, and claiming that this is in contrast to ordinary experience, and not an extreme part of a spectrum. I can guarantee you one things: every person on earth has experienced much more significant sadness than their favorite TV show going off the air, and when they experience these things, the result is going to be much closer to the symptoms you associate with depression, than to "being sad for a while".

>I find it vaguely offensive when people suggest that feeling bad enough to overcome the human inante desire for self-preservation is somehow a normal part of the human experience. A broken leg is not shameful, happens to many people, but is not normal.

If you are offended because you thought that I was implying that nothing should be done to help people who were in a state of mind that was so terrible to be in, that they preferred suicide, then you misread my post. If you are offended because I didn't draw a line in the sand separating such people from everyone else, because you find it offensive to the human spirit to suggest that, absent a very specific disease, a person would ever find themself in this state of mind, or anything resembling it, then I would answer that human nature is what it is, not what we want it to be.

>You also call cancer "real". That kind of attitude (here's a list of real illnesses, and here's a list of psychological illnesses) is really harmful.

That is not what I said. I never claimed that people should not seek help, or otherwise try to address the symptoms of mental illness. What I said is that cancer is different from depression because cancer is a discrete category. People don't fall on a spectrum of having cancer, and whether or not a person has cancer is not at all subjective.

QuantumChaos··on We Need To Talk About Depression
Where is the evidence that depression is qualitatively different from being unhappy, or feeling downtrodden and apathetic? All I ever read on the topic is (1) scientific studies that associate certain diagnoses, with the effectiveness of certain treatments, and (2) the claim by people with these conditions, that they are qualitatively different.

Is there any evidence against the following hypothesis:

What we call mental illnesses are (with possible exception of Schizophrenia and Bipolar disorder), not qualitatively different from ordinary experience. But in order to provide treatment (e.g. various kinds of therapy) it is useful to assign labels to people. But this usefulness doesn't make mental illness as "real as cancer", in the sense that it is a discrete category that we can definitively assign people too.

One reason people prefer a diagnosis is that they prefer a label (even if it does come with some social stigma) to the greater social stigma associated with the same symptoms absent a "mental illness". Assigning such a label allows people (both the individual with the mental illness, and people around them) to view their symptoms in a different and more compassionate light. Most importantly, it allows people to think rationally about the best course of action for the person.

My claim is that if society could be more compassionate, without needing to first assign a label in order to remove "blame" for people's symptoms, we wouldn't need the category of mental illness as much. E.g. instead of saying "I thought I was just a loser, but then I found out I suffered from depression", a person might say "I thought I was a loser, but then I realized that what society calls a loser is a person with certain characteristics, thought patterns, and patterns of behavior, and I decided that instead of judging myself for having these things, I would find the best approach to changing them".

There is one more corollary to this, which is that "professional" help, in the form of drugs or therapy, may not be the only or best approach for such people.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →