I suspect there have been a couple of down votes with people just getting tired of the whole thing and wanting HN to be more about actual hacking. But mostly it's just been several hours now.
22,823 karma · joined November 18, 2008
I'm interested in math, programming, physics, science, engineering, technical communication, and cool stuff. I travel a lot in the UK and elsewhere, and it would be cool to meet up.
Happy to receive emails anytime.
I suspect there have been a couple of down votes with people just getting tired of the whole thing and wanting HN to be more about actual hacking. But mostly it's just been several hours now.
I would suggest that you would benefit from learning how to ask questions. Here's a start:
http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html
However, there's more advice than that, and that, although a good start, is not to be taken as gospel. You probably also should read the site-specific commentary, and suggested alternatives:
https://mikeash.com/getting_answers.html
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2911381
The point is this - you said:
Well, TCP is a very simple protocol so I can't imagine
what the OP means by "all of TCP" unless he's talking
about IP and it's associated services.
Here's an alternative: I'm not sure I understand what's been left out of this.
Could someone provide a synopsis, and a pointer to more
details?
Your comment comes across as "Well I know everything, so the only thing that's left out must be all the internet." The second admits that you don't know what people are talking about, and asks for more information.And just as a final question - why do you think you've been hell-banned? Are you sure? In particular, I've turned on "Show dead", and you don't seem to have made any comments that have been auto-killed. The evidence suggests you are not hell-banned.
There's another point here, though. It seems that you're learning PHP (although in your "About" page you claim that it's one of your skills) so there's no shame in getting things wrong, but aside from learning that you really do need to test even apparently trivial things, it's also good practice to acknowledge other people's contributions, even if only by saying "My thanks to those who pointed out errors in the original." I wouldn't want explicit credit by name, but acknowledging other people is good practice. Look at PG's essays - he regularly thanks people for their feedback.
Not to stop you from trying to find connections, but you seem to be certain that there must be, and I was wondering why.
What would be interesting would be to have a site that solved the problem of puzzle sharing and cooperation. Has anyone done that?
So I and others have tested it and it worked for us. That means the sending system does correctly send emails to at least some addresses.
You say that when you created the testing account you checked the email you supplied quite carefully, so that means that you most likely did enter the correct email address.
The problem is either that
1. HN fails to send to a small subset of addresses, and yours is in that subset, or
2. the email that was sent to you has been hidden from you by your email system.
Option 1 seems unlikely. I would investigate using Yahoo or something to set up a temporary email address and create another test account. If you have two known addresses that fail to get reset messages then you definitely have a case for emailing PG again.
If that other test email address does receive the reset, then the problem is with your true email address, either in the receiving in general from HN, or with HN specifically getting it wrong for that particular address.
Search diligently for the email among your various folders. I don't use gmail so I have nothing to suggest, but I know others who never received emails because gmail silently decided they were spam and put them somewhere unexpected.
Good hunting.
End debug mode.
1) You triggered the voting ring detection code, and/or
2) You got several downvotes.
I do feel that there is a sizeable collection of people here on HN who, for whatever reason, don't like discussions about philosophy of consciousness and similar. If you get 10 or so downvotes and only 10 or so upvotes, your item will sink to the 1000s. I have seen it happen. (based on surmise about flags - they are not explicitly visible.)
This discussion happened recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3890565
The item was flagged dead, but the discussion is still there.
HN remains a remarkably civil forum, and perhaps the occasional apparently draconian measures are part of the price to pay.
I have no trouble believing that the University didn't see him produce anything. No papers, no teaching, nothing of obvious and/or apparent value. When Conway left Cambridge, there was really no one for Norton to be supporting, and hence no one to fight to keep him on.
So they didn't.
I'm pleased and relieved that he has a reasonable life on his own terms and seems to be happy. I just wish there were some way his abilities could more obviously benefit others.
I ought to complete it.
In case you're interested, it was here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1383169
I'm not accepting more submissions.
I think any solution will require the identification of individuals whose actions are "more trustworthy," and giving them greater weight, or more powers.
Anything else can and will be swamped by the majority, whose intentions you have no control over, and no reason to trust.
Mutating them into something that does work is more important, interesting and useful. There's more discussion here:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403696
Enjoy!
Giving flags more weight is not necessarily the answer. Punishing people for making bad comments is, I think, more important. Equally important is punishing people for upvoting bad comments.
But now it's late here, and starting tomorrow I'm really not going to be here for a while. Good luck PG, I hope you can find a way to reduce the mean-spiritedness fluff, and make HN more pleasant again.
* http://www.solipsys.co.uk/rss.xml
Cheers!
Upvoting a comment that's mean-spirited, unhelpful, or otherwise of negative value should carry a visible cost. But who makes that decision? You can't rely on the community to do so, because that puts you in the same position. Perhaps you need 10% of your community to be "trusted elders," and they have the right to declare comments to be of negative value. Then any upvotes such a comment accrued, count as negative karma for the upvoter. There might be other, simpler and more visible ways to achieve the same net result.
I know good hackers are interested in many things besides hacking, but "intellectual curiosity" is being interpreted very broadly. Any definition will lead to people playing the lawyer game on the words, so that's a hard one to try to narrow down.
Perhaps bands of karma, expressed as a percentage of the population (or something) could be used to grant and deny more access to features. Making someone's position is the ranking visible will help that be more transparent. The idea would be that higher ranks get to decide if the decisions by lower ranks are right or wrong, and hence those of lower rank can advance if they behave in a manner you choose to reward.
Or something.
These are quick "toss in the air and see what happens" ideas. They won't work, but perhaps suitably clever people on HN can find mutations of them that will. A few ideas were being tossed around here:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2387873
... although that was more specifically to try to solve the "submission race" problem that jacquesm had identified. But some of those ideas, mated with some of the above, might produce more fit children.
Thanks.
PS: Also attempting to set up an RSS feed on my "blog".
I've tried not to let this turn into a rant. I may not have succeeded ...
Anyway.
The front page does feel a little worse, but there's still stuff that does belong there. There's still a lot that's good, and perhaps my perception that it's worse is simply because I've grown. I talked with Ward Cunningham once about this - any good community helps you to grow, but after a time you outgrow it. Perhaps they should be like a book - you read them, and then after that you dip into them for a bit, then less often, and eventually you don't pick them up again.
So maybe the front page isn't that much different. Later this week I'll try to get the time to compare some of my snapshots from two years ago. If I have thoughts, where do you want me to send/put them?
But the comments, they definitely feel worse. There are still brilliant and insightful comments, and there are many, many good and valuable comments. But there are also many valueless comments that nevertheless get upvotes, and there's definitely a more snarky feel. I've felt myself being dragged into that at times and had to pull myself back. That didn't used to happen.
I also hang about on the "New" page because I think the longer-standing members should do that, and I'm really, really tired of the apparently endless repeat submissions of the same stories, endless re-submission of older (although admittedly valuable) items, and the rise in content-free gossip. But if the experienced members don't read it, how will "the right items" get upvoted, and inappropriate items get flagged?
You can't do much about how people vote, but people seem to be upvoting things that they find amusing or entertaining, and confusing that with "gratifies intellectual curiosity." People down-vote things they don't agree with, even when they are genuinely valuable.
Er ...
That's it. I hope that helps.
Certainly anyone who helps will get personal replies.
http://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/ColinsBlog.html?HN
There's nothing there yet, and I won't be posting every day.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2399565
I wonder if people don't think it's entirely appropriate for HN.
It's not at all clear what the mechanics are, and I find it hard to locate tags I'm interested in from the tag cloud - that problem will get worse.
But I'm interested in the experiment.
Added in edit: Won't let me login with my username - it claims it's too long.
Added in edit: Not sure if it has a point, or a focus. To get traction I suspect you will need a subject.
Added in edit: Are we supposed to post links, text, or something else?
Added in edit: What's "Entropy"? The mechanics are completely unclear. Many people won't care - I do.
Added in edit: OK, found the FAQ. I'm going away and will read it later.
Added in edit: I don't think the v_i are in S^1. Aren't the v_i in [-1,1] ?? That's not S^1. I guess I need to read the paper, but I can't now.
I'll wait for your replies.
ADDED IN EDIT: I see patio11 got there before me - I'll let this stand, though.
It looks and feels trite - I know - but there are lessons here that are worth taking on board. In particular, many of the comments are reflected in the more recent advice often given to entrepreneurs and hackers.
Make of it what you will.