Uber arguably has more eyes on it, but I wonder who would file a lawsuit over this, and how they would articulate an actionable claim.
1,113 karma · joined May 19, 2021
A security hawk, but pragmatic.
Dismissive of crypto/bitcoin/ICOs/NFTs/etc.
Often critical of larger technology companies in equal measure to what they -can- accomplish.
Obnoxiously pro-privacy.
Not likely to buy into the “we’re a family here”/“new shiny will change the world”/“our vision is a better would through…” corporate speak.
Uber arguably has more eyes on it, but I wonder who would file a lawsuit over this, and how they would articulate an actionable claim.
The SSO tax in particular is ridiculous.
Functionality like HA or SSO being gated behind enterprise licenses only makes it harder for smaller businesses to “get there”. My business is comprised exclusively of technology professionals. We tend to be really cheap customers to have because we typically only raise a ticket when something beyond our responsibility breaks.
And from the community side — I already have enough credentials to maintain in my personal life. It’s annoying when you can’t use SSO with a community edition product. I like having SSO at home. It makes life so much better, and it also makes me more likely to use a product in my business, which makes it more likely I’ll buy a license to backstop support.
/s, if not obvious. Strange times.
I don’t necessarily think that a Google Form is unprofessional either. It was accepting data into an environment that complied with their regulatory needs, which was a chief driver of the project.
I absolutely agree with you about TypeForm. Actually, if I was going to call a form service unprofessional “looking”, TypeForm takes the top slot. That’s not a criticism exactly. I just don’t think I’d use it for something that is public facing. It has a different kind of UX than I’d want to place in front of users.
I have seen Most Secret War recommended to me by basically every physical and ebook seller I have an account with, so I guess it’s time to take one of them up on the offer. Thank you!
Any other similar insights from your readings?
The comment I replied to read as if the liberal arts are predicated on producing language rather than language with utility, which is something I’ve heard before coming from people who, often, have no real exposure to those areas of academia. I wasn’t attempting to paint with a broad brush in general terms across all of history or litigate specific schools of thought.
It’s certainly true that those disciplines rely on the production of language in much the same way (at least in application) as computer science relies on the production of some kind of logical expression device (be it an electronic abacus or a web application, or a paper formally analyzing an ISA).
I also was somewhat skeptical that a git hosting platform that had a business behind it with enterprise oriented offerings wasn’t yet self-hosting in the technical sense.
The Nazis fell behind in atomic research for a variety of reasons, each with its own underpinnings. One of the most interesting in my mind was organizational failings. Although many different groups were working in this area, the regime leadership was rather disconnected and didn’t prioritize a coherent or integrated research effort. They didn’t provide much funding either. In some ways this created more room for unstructured scientific inquiry and creativity, but it also meant that no particular group could make any real progress toward usable reactors or weapons.
Contrast this with the Manhattan Project in the US (and the UK’s efforts at radar), which was supported and managed from the highest levels of government with a figurative blank check and despite immense compartmentalization also had a high degree of integration among disciplines and sites. There was one goal.
In my view this is an interesting manifestation of the foundation of the Third Reich. In Martin Davidson’s The Perfect Nazi, Davidson notes that the Nazi party was in many ways a child’s cosplay turned into a nightmare. Davidson writes that one of the key failings of the regime is that it was run by broken people who had more of an interest in catharsis than any real sense of society, advancement, or cohesion.
LLMs specifically and AI generally are not going to replace your Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran, Twenty One Pilots, Linkin Park, etc.
Speaking to the parent comment specifically - it strikes me as uninformed that “liberal arts and academic” disciplines rely only on language production. That’s absurd.
I have a hard science degree but I started my education in the humanities and spent time studying business and management in my education as well. That gave me an immense advantage that many technologists lack. More importantly it gave me insight into what people who only have a hard science education don’t understand about those fields. The take that they aren’t connected to reality is chiefly among those misunderstandings.
LLMs can’t replace any field for which advancement or innovation relies upon new thinking. This is different from areas where we have worked out mathematically articulable frameworks, like in organic chemistry. Even in those areas, actual experts aren’t replaceable by these technologies.
Farming is extremely money and labor intensive and there’s a lot of upfront investment with a lot of long-tail return, and it’s not “sexy” the way (for example) AI is, so there’s not a bottomless pit of cash to shovel into the furnace for a quick buck turnaround.
Independent farmers tend to seriously rely on good weather and a lot of advantageous tax treatment.
Of course massive agri-business would very much love to continue to fill more and more of the void left by the shrinking independent farming population. That has its own problems.
I witnessed far more personal political pressure and cajoling than corporate/future employer. Where I went to school the pressure on schools was usually from parents, students, and local groups concerned with civil matters. I had (until recently) indirect (and sometimes direct) exposure to this because one of parents was an educator and a senior member of their department in an adjoining district to the one I attended.
Where I went to college, it was always very clear to me what was shaped by industry vs. research and academia. I went to a research university for an uncommon hard-science degree and so there was a lot of employer interest, but the university cleverly drew a paywall around that and businesses had to pay the university to conduct research (or agree to profit sharing, patent licensing, etc). There was a clear, bright line separating corporate/employer interest from the classroom.
I’ve run into this too.
I had a client that needed to collect HIPAA protected data. Putting their marketing site into scope for HIPAA was not a sane choice. Their EMR vendor didn’t have any options that didn’t require migrating to a new EMR offering in order to create/publish/accept forms. All the other options were clunky and required a lot more work and niche expertise or training in those applications.
So we went with Google Forms. They already used Google Workspace and had executed the HIPAA addendum to the terms.
That lasted less than a year. The physicians and patients were both put off by the fact that it was a Google Form and it looked unprofessional.
They’re back to posting PDFs on their website.
I’ve watched Github Copilot do the same thing. I’ve also seen it doubling down on ridiculous things and just spewing crash-laden messes. There seems to be a low upper ceiling on how “competent” it is, which makes sense.
That isn’t an indictment of Brave’s entire user base. I tried it, and tried to like it, several times. Always kept going back to Firefox.
Which Mozilla makes increasingly hard to do from a philosophical perspective, but that’s another story.
And then there’s “launch whatever an SVP dreams up” followed by “kill that old SVP’s thing” at Google.
Perhaps slightly exaggerated. Google product reveals and sunsets have frequently followed executive movements in/around/out of the company. Two big examples that had widespread impact are in the later Google Wallet/Pay changes and some of the later insanity around multiple self-canabalizing IM/chat/conferencing services.
There seems to be no long term vision or strategy at Google, and Pichai is notoriously averse to making decisions of consequence. It’s not surprising that Google is rudderless.
We just renewed our 365 licenses at my company for one more year. I’ve been mentally sketching out an exit strategy. I inventoried what we use in 365 and Azure, and there’s not a single thing we can’t replace with an alternative we run or a different provider that’s a bit less hostile to third party ecosystems/standards/etc.
There are a lot of Apple services that get contacted because they can be contacted, not because they need to be. For example, I don’t use Home/HomeKit but it phones home to Apple several times a day if I allow it. The same with Apple News, Weather, etc.
You can prevent this in various ways but not out of box.
It’s possible to run macOS without an Internet connection. I value this, but it’s impractical and unnecessary for most people and most environments.
Here we’d be talking about “the corporate name” in pistachios. That’s a very different thing from what “a” typical pistachio farmer needs. I submit the original comment is cherry-picking to make their argument.
A pistachio tree needs something like (on average) 60 gallons of water a day.
For one 365-day year that is 21,900 gallons/tree/year.
That’s a lot of water, of course. But most farms do not have in excess of 5.39 million pistachio trees (using the 130 billion gallon number).
This is often the case, although I’ve very rarely seen environments as restrictive as what you describe being enforced on developers.
Typically developer user accounts and assigned devices are in slightly less restrictive policy groupings, or are given access to some kind of remote build/test infrastructure.
Of course companies need the option to control what software is run on their infrastructure. There are an endless stream of reasons and examples for that. Up-thread there’s a great example of what happens when you let folks install Oracle software without guardrails. Businesses are of course larger and more complex than their developers and have needs beyond their developers.
What matters here is implementation and policy management. You want those to be balanced between audience needs and business needs.
It’s also worth mentioning that plenty of developers have no clue what they’re doing with computers outside their particular area of expertise.
Do you mean a particular farm, or “any” farmer in the abstract?
This isn’t unique to the genocide of Palestinians. This is happening repeatedly in multiple contexts across essentially all very large organizations.
It is, I submit, a manifestation of collectivist actions. Usually that doesn’t intersect politics inside a business, but as more and more horrific things are being perpetrated or aided by the businesses that employ politically interested people, it’s happening more and more.
It was easy to miss that in the due diligence.
And it was really frustrating to experience. The development company cut so many corners that our own neighborhood had to engage several times with the city council and development bodies because their water management was threatening our properties. During construction of the water infrastructure they backflowed a toxic concentration of chemicals into the water supply. Their retention pond design is absolute garbage and while it was inspected and approval has already caused problems. They forgot to account for water going downhill while making assumptions about water volume that a week of heavy rain already invalidated.
We need the housing though, so it’s good we have that. I’m not sure we need more housing in the form of townhomes that cost $700,000+ each but at least it’s higher density than single family residences, which are killing the housing market in their own way.
Would just be nice if home building firms weren’t such a menace.