HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ZachPruckowski

1,432 karma · joined July 29, 2008

submissionscomments
ZachPruckowski··on Artist trademarks 'Pi' symbol, enrages the web
Generally I think it's a sort of two-step the patent/trademark trolls do. They go to USPTO and apply for IP based around a narrow reading of their application, and then they attempt to enforce based on a broad reading of their IP once they have it.

The narrow case here (that a trademark can be "pi" plus some additional character) is not super far-fetched (though maybe the period isn't enough). But then the broad case (that anything using "pi" infringes) is the excessive bit. It may have appeared totally clear to the guy granting the trademark that "pi dot" wouldn't grant any claims to "pi", but its not clear to enforcement authorities.

This is compounded by this sort of stuff almost never seeing the inside of a courtroom. Patent trolls push for settlement so they never have to litigate their broad claims on their patent, and they can move against trademarks with a cease-and-desist or DMCA claim, which basically every company folds to without reading, on the advice of their lawyers.

ZachPruckowski··on A Diamond Market No Longer Controlled By De Beers
Wait, but most of the competing diamonds are from Canada, Russia, or Australia, right? Wouldn't those be conflict-free more or less automatically? If De Beers tried to set prices at which you could sell certified diamonds, couldn't those competitors make their own certification that the majority of the diamonds would use?
ZachPruckowski··on YouTube to Acquire Videogame-Streaming Service Twitch for $1 Billion?
There aren't many barriers to entry in this field though. It's not a situation like a utility/ISP where you can only feasibly have one last-mile connection due to permits or limited radio spectrum. It's not even something like a nuclear reactor which costs $10B and a decade before you can flip the switch.

I'm not saying I could build a streaming site in my closet this weekend, but it's not impossible for competitors to enter the space (or existing competitors to grow in the space) so long as Google/YT doesn't too anything too anti-competitive.

ZachPruckowski··on YouTube to Acquire Videogame-Streaming Service Twitch for $1 Billion?
They grow out of playing video games perhaps, but there's a whole world of content for folks who still like video games but don't play them as much anymore.
ZachPruckowski··on Can This Web Be Saved? Mozilla Accepts DRM, and We All Lose
>Perhaps if FF had Chrome's current marketshare, they would have been in a position to say no

It still would have accomplished nothing, because websites would just have a "this site doesn't work in Firefox, try switching to Chrome or IE or Safari" block page. And no amount of Firefox marketshare could make them not have that block page, because if they let Firefox access the content DRM-free the sites would lose their licenses on the content.

ZachPruckowski··on Can This Web Be Saved? Mozilla Accepts DRM, and We All Lose
The problem is not that there's no DRM-free alternative, it's that major content owners would prefer no HTML5 solution to a DRM-free HTML5 solution. There is literally nothing Mozilla can do about that. People who want to do DRM-free HTML5 video already can, but that's not the problem.
ZachPruckowski··on Talk of an Internet Fast Lane Is Already Hurting Some Startups
Well if you're talking about stuff that's used at physical checkout counters, you need really fast transactions. Nobody wants to sit there for an extra 20-30 seconds holding up the line. Even if customers can tolerate it, businesses will be much less inclined to support such a feature.
ZachPruckowski··on Poll: Would you take $10M now or start your own company?
$200,000 for 5% of the company is only a $4M valuation (assuming not contract hijinks).
ZachPruckowski··on Stephen Hawking: AI, Potentially the Worst Thing to Happen to Humanity
Assuming its a constant linear progression, which it's probably not. We could see speed ups as we go, or breakthroughs. I'm not suggesting someone'll have a Eureka moment tonight and we'll have Skynet next week, but it's not like we sit on a computer for a predictable number of years and suddenly get more research progress.
ZachPruckowski··on The Case Against ISP Tolls
A majority of the people who can pick ISPs (37% of the country) have only two choices. I'd bet in most cases those two choices are Comcast and Verizon. The odds you'll have a neutral ISP as an option are pretty tiny.
ZachPruckowski··on The Case Against ISP Tolls
There are two issues with this. There are also MASSIVE incentive issues with this (lobbying, etc) but in this comment I'll only discuss legal issues:

The first is that a legislature can't easily bind its future self - laws passed by a majority can be repealed by a majority or circumvented by a majority in the future. So even if we pass Law 2014-003 saying what you said, there's nothing stopping a 2015 (or 2020 or whenever) law from saying "Law 2014-003 is hereby repealed" or more narrowly "Law 2014-003 doesn't apply to this law". There are some edge cases where you can pull it off but by and large it'd take a state/federal constitutional amendment.

The second issue is that the federal government can only regulate "interstate commerce". While you'd think that anything involving the Internet would automatically apply there, you couldn't stop a state law that covered only a local business dealing with in-state customers. So such a law could be used as a shield for Verizon/Comcast/etc while state laws restricting ISPs would only apply to smaller in-state competitors. My parents and a number of my friends are served by a local Wireless ISP because that's the only alternative in their neck of the (literal) woods. Under your system, their ISP could be subject to innumerable regulations that Verizon/Comcast would be immune to.

ZachPruckowski··on F.C.C., in ‘Net Neutrality’ Turnaround, Plans to Allow Fast Lane
The problem with that is that the only folks qualified for these jobs are folks with some sort of recent related experience, and the only future job that this is revenue-boosting for is in related domains.
ZachPruckowski··on The New Deal
Most likely, your kid's startup you dropped $120K into is going to fail. Make sure you consider that case very carefully - what are his chances like at 26 with a less prestigious degree and a failed startup under his belt compared to a Harvard/MIT/Stanford degree plus 5 years in a salaried job that those can get you?
ZachPruckowski··on How Being a Doctor Became the Most Miserable Profession
I'd say that a prevalence of rich kids is alarming, and not from an equality perspective or anything. It's alarming because an advanced and specialized economy like ours is at its most efficient when people are doing the jobs they're best suited for. If I'm well-suited to be a DBA and I'm instead doing something I'm much less well-suited for (like sales) then it's a societal net-loss[1]. Unless we assume there's a reason that the people who are best-suited or at least well-suited to be doctors are disproportionately rich, then we're probably winding up with poor/middle-class folks who'd make excellent doctors doing some other job they're less good at.

[1] This is not and should not be read as an argument that DBAs > sales or anything to that effect.

ZachPruckowski··on TurboTax Maker Intuit Funnels Millions to Lobby Against Easier Tax Returns
I don't have experience with BPMN/BPML but I'd still be interested in helping out if you get something started.

I'd recommend targeting the folks with relatively simple taxes (salaried/wage employees with limited and structured investments, nothing super fancy) who make more than the Free-File cutoff, and then work your way out from there. The "I own 4 businesses and have 17 different investments all structured differently with various business expenses that are different degrees of write-off-able" group isn't your target, and there's already FreeFile options for folks making poverty-level wages.

The toughest part here business-wise is probably the liability - TurboTax and HR Block and whoever have armies of lawyers and PR and insurance to handle cases like a user getting audited and blaming them or catching flak for clients over-paying. Those armies are there to protect Intuit, not the end user, but they're fairly important nonetheless.

ZachPruckowski··on TurboTax Maker Intuit Funnels Millions to Lobby Against Easier Tax Returns
Maybe you could sell it to a smaller/medium player who does mostly corporate work as a way of undercutting his larger competitors who do consumer and corporate taxes. Plus it'd be a heck of a branding opportunity.
ZachPruckowski··on Facebook Refused No-Poaching Agreement With Google
Why wouldn't you call it recruiting?
ZachPruckowski··on Feinstein Publicly Accuses C.I.A. of Spying on Congress
Well Feinstein's not up until 2018 (if she runs again, I guess), so you have time. But really trying to run for Senate is a multi-year process. You ultimately have to convince hundreds or thousands of people to volunteer for you, and round up millions (if not tens of millions) in cash. Especially in California - it's literally a tenth the size of the country population-wise, so you're basically running a race that's a tenth the size of a Presidential campaign. In the Primary alone you're going to need 600K or so votes at least.

To do those things (recruit volunteers, bring in donations, get attention) you need to start in advance by networking, building contacts and gathering favors. You should get involved now in the local House race or a county/statehouse race to start that process or at least to get familiar with the political process or how people commonly run campaigns. A lot of people sort of subscribe to the notion that politics is or should be simple, but the reality is that you have to know what you're doing to be effective. Charisma and ideas only get you so far.

ZachPruckowski··on Need for Speeders Puts Tiny Florida City on Brink of Erasure
Once you've got all 3 town employees, the police force/posse and half-to-all of the town council in on it, it's not like it's impossible to get a particular judge elected. Get an extreme hard-ass, a crook, or just someone's lawyer cousin on the bench in a lightly-contested non-partisan election, and it'll be basically impossible to get a ticket thrown out.
ZachPruckowski··on Tomorrow's Apps Will Come From the Bitcoin Protocol
Have they solved the "you need the whole blockchain" bit? Like do blockchain-based apps still require you to download the whole she-bang to participate? I know for bitcoin the blockchain is like 14GB or so, and that's for (only most of the) financial transactions for a small (on a global scale) community. If you want to do something with a bigger target audience or more complex data needs, are you going to wind up needing a separate hard drive to participate after a year or two?
ZachPruckowski··on Mt. Gox Files for Bankruptcy Protection
No, because nobody knows for sure. The most common theories are stupidity, fraud, and theft (or some combination thereof).
ZachPruckowski··on MtGox's Bitcoin price drops to $260 (others at $600+)
I'd be fairly impressed if they survived - they seemed like they were already on the ropes in terms of solvency with it taking months to payout for BTC after the US government froze their accounts or fined them or whatever in May. I'm not really sure how many serious dick-punches like that a company can take.
ZachPruckowski··on How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds
Sometimes they do - for instance money used in stings and busts by law enforcement might have its serial numbers recorded. If you're subsequently searched and found to have money used in a drug bust, there are gonna be some tough questions and the money might get confiscated.

If someone uses a fraudulent credit card to buy something from you online, you're not going to be able to keep that money when the fraud's reversed.

If you (unknowingly) buy stolen property you can be forced to give it back, and then it's up to you to go after the guy who sold it to you. If you knowingly buy stolen property you're in trouble.

Given that BTC serial numbers are in plain view as opposed to stolen goods or dollar bills where you need a warrant, it's a lot easier to demand the BTC back.

ZachPruckowski··on Ask HN: My industry's becoming commoditised and I'm scared
Productivity increases (including robotization/automation) mean that the US economy can produce the same goods with less work or more goods with the same work. If we're in a situation where the prospect of being able to produce more goods or work less is "pretty scary", then we're doing something wrong as a society. These sorts of changes should be Pareto-efficient.
ZachPruckowski··on Why I Did Not Go To Jail
The CEO in the linked piece didn't need to get down into the weeds of the accounting laws, he just needs to know to get a second (outside/unbiased) opinion on anything that smells even faintly and remotely fishy that he's signing off on, and he needs to keep a general eye on principal/agent problems or conflicts of interest in the people he manages.
ZachPruckowski··on Why I Did Not Go To Jail
Fundamentally you as CEO are quite literally signing your name to a heck of a lot of policies and financial statements. You don't need to know the exact details of a situation to want to get a second opinion before signing your name on something official and legal that you're mailing into DC.
ZachPruckowski··on The Unpaid Bill that Launched a Thousand Starships
I think it varies in terms of what a given viewer is looking for, but generally having a voice I can listen to for long stretches, some amount of humor, and competence at the game you're playing. You also need to be able to commentate on it in an interesting manner and do interesting things - nobody wants to watch a Let's Play when they don't understand what's going on, and nobody's going to sit through an hour of you strip-mining some mountain in Minecraft.

GeopLP's Assassin's Creed series is to me the gold standard in a lot of ways: http://www.youtube.com/user/GeopLP/videos?view=1&flow=grid

But people like different degrees of all that stuff - I generally find YogsCast to be too silly, but thousands of subscribers obviously disagree with me, and I'm sure there are Starcraft or LoL watchers who hate all the contextual strategic commentary that I find absolutely vital in those videos. Similarly, different people and different formats like differing amounts of audience participation - I usually watch stuff on YouTube or Twitch weeks after it was recorded, so Q&Aing with your chatroom means I'm missing half the conversation, but for guys watching it live that's pretty awesome.

ZachPruckowski··on The Unpaid Bill that Launched a Thousand Starships
A lot of that is passive time though - it takes a year to train the skills, but if you've already bought the skill books that just means logging on every few days to rotate the skill you're training according to an optimized plan you pre-determine. Similarly it takes months for a Titan to build, but that means moving components between the factory and the CSAA and the storage every once in a while and re-fueling your tower-stations weekly or something. It's not someone working 40/hours a week to build a Titan.

The hard part of that is the infrastructure - you need to own a star system and put up a bunch of towers and fuel them and haul/build/mine the components and minerals to your (hopefully out-of-the-way) system, and you need to have firepower on call to defend your operation if you're attacked. And the character training to pilot the Titan needs implants that are expensive and mean he can't be risked in combat (so you need a second account). Most of that (owning star systems, on-call firepower, maintaining towers, hauling/mining minerals, having spare/secondary accounts) is stuff that large alliances have to do anyhow for their other strategic needs (equipping sub-capital players, paying bills, constructing jump bridge networks, etc.) so for them it's just a bit of extra load on the logistics team, and they usually have economies of scale (they have so much money and space they can have 3 Titans in the hopper at once).

ZachPruckowski··on The Unpaid Bill that Launched a Thousand Starships
>Only the largest and most powerful organizations in the game, alliances, can actually build or fly titans, and they tend to jealously guard them. That really underscores just how big a loss 75 of them is. Such losses cause tectonic shifts in the balance of power.

Additionally, War in EVE is largely about sapping the opponents' morale - it could take months of fighting for hours every night to take a defended region, but if you get the enemy's pilots discouraged and not logging in or avoiding the fighting or even switching to another group then you can win a lot faster. This is called a "fail-cascade" and it's how GoonSwarm (the infamous lead alliance of CFC) won a lot of early wars - key wins cause players and leaders not to log in which makes future fights easier which causes a "rats fleeing a sinking ship" effect.

That's also why the unpaid bill was such a big deal - it would have taken a week or more of victories for CFC to otherwise capture the system.

That said, it's unlikely in this instance that the losers (Pandemic Legion and friends) are going to fall apart as a result - they've gone from "most Titans in the game" to "second or third most Titans in the game", and they've survived and rebuilt from considerably worse losses before - both GoonSwarm and Pandemic Legion have at various points lost everything and been down to a few hundred demoralized pilots but clawed their way back up.

ZachPruckowski··on The Unpaid Bill that Launched a Thousand Starships
Well Time Dilation only matters in fights with hundreds or thousands of people which would have otherwise been so laggy that skill was irrelevant anyhow.

The "in-the-moment" skill that matters in EVE isn't accuracy (FPSes) or mashing the correct 6-step ability rotation every 9 seconds (WoW), but rather tactical skill like teamwork/coordination or laying clever traps or straight up situational awareness. There's also knowing your opponent's build and responding accordingly - you want to try to out-range some shorter-range weapons and you want to try close-range fast orbits against others.

← PreviousPage 2 of 16Next →