HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ZhuanXia

1,002 karma · joined October 19, 2018

submissionscomments
ZhuanXia··on How to Steal a Billion
>distributed the wealth of the world

In the limit of a single individual wealth works in a naive fashion where such distribution is possible. But on the scale of the economy, such a thing is not possible without inventing a better distribution mechanism than capital itself. If you redistribute each peace of your car's engine to each passenger, you will be forced to walk. Even as a thought experiment, evenly distributing the wealth of the world is not possible. As the wealth is produced by the incentives inherent in gradients of inequality.

Thus the project of the modern socialist is to develop redistributive structures that maintain such incentives. There are echos of this in George and Harberger, but little in modern Jacobin-style socialism, whose proposals amount to gifting the means of production to the sorts of people that staff an HR department.

ZhuanXia··on Separating gifted children hasn't led to better achievement
>.... are we willing to sacrifice helping them do better to help the top achievers do their best? How much are we willing to sacrifice in either direction?

It is so strange reading this comment, as I know how Americans are primed to respond to it, and how precisely opposite my response is.

ZhuanXia··on Block on GM rice ‘has cost millions of lives and led to child blindness’
Absent patent rights, none of that would matter. Patents are grotesque rent seeking and responsible for all these ills.
ZhuanXia··on Solving the Rubik’s cube with a robot hand
Gwern on the luck of the last mover:

"Launching too early means failure, but being conservative & launching later is just as bad because regardless of forecasting, a good idea will draw overly-optimistic researchers or entrepreneurs to it like moths to a flame: all get immolated but the one with the dumb luck to kiss the flame at the perfect instant, who then wins everything, at which point everyone can see that the optimal time is past."

Robotics has been a money pit for startups and corporations for a long time. Think of the billions Toytoa has spent on home robotics research, to little avail.

But at some point it won't be. Some entity will "kiss the flame" at the right movement. The wealth they create will be beyond any company ever, by an almost incomparable margin.

ZhuanXia··on Experts who say we shouldn't worry about superintelligent AI are wrong?
If we had billions of dollars being spent on genetic research towards build giant Scottish aquatic lizards, than a Loch Ness expert would be valuable.

The lack of imagination on display here is astounding. Billions are being spent by DeepMind and OpenAI explicitly targeted at AGI.

ZhuanXia··on Scissor Statements: Sort by Controversial
>We can't have a rational, dispassionate debate about whether I should have rights. I can't argue for my existence, I want it.

Effective rhetoric, but that's about it. In practice, people take their self-serving policy preferences and enshrine them into their identity and then proclaim that any attack on their policy preference is attack on their right to exist

ZhuanXia··on The rise of the financial machines
If homo economicus does not exist we must surely be obliged to create him...
ZhuanXia··on Hard comp-fi reading list
Starts off like a diamond but gets progressively softer until the end is just pudding.
ZhuanXia··on California's ‘Surprise’ Billing Law Is Protecting Patients and Angering Doctors
The "free market" doesn't really exist. It is an ideal, and an ill defined one at best. What does exists are mechanisms. A law that forces prices to be visible is a mechanism that is likely to increase economic efficiency at little cost. In absence of a rent-seeking doctor's guild, it would not be needed, true, but it is certainly better than nothing.
ZhuanXia··on When the Culture War Comes For the kids
Bryan Caplan’s Selfish Reasons to Have More Kids is worth a read for anyone who is taking parenting too seriously.

Developmental psychologists have brainwashed the public into thinking children can be ruined by insufficiency dedicated parenting. But for generations developmental psychologists were Lysenkoist hacks who didn’t realize their studies were confounded by basically all mental traits being extremely heritable.

The most important influence parents have on their children is at conception. If you want a smart kid, choosing a very smart mate is far more effective than any amount of mostly ineffective enrichment activities.

If you really care so much about the social status of your future children, marry well to a person high in the traits you value, preferably from a family high in said traits. Then have a lot of kids. Chances are one of them will achieve something!

Don’t get caught in the extracurricular signalling racket/cargo cult. Let the kids do what they want within reason. Public school will be fine. If you don’t want to ferry your kid around to various enrichment activities, don’t. Your time has value too. You care for your children; you do not serve them.

In most cases the kids don’t want to to do them anyway and will develop their own interests they will be far more enthusiastic about.

ZhuanXia··on Johns Hopkins Launches Center for Psychedelic Research
Is it possible to do mathematics while on such drugs? I am working through a textbook on projective geometry and I feel like those visualization enhancements would be super useful.
ZhuanXia··on Inequality driving 'deaths of despair'
I have been reading the works of the great social reformer Henry George. A socialist literate in political economy, he advocated a land value tax, which does not distort economic incentives as land cannot be produced.

I see many angry youths, even very intelligent angry youths entranced by neo-Marxism, which seems to consider any concrete policy proposal as “logocentric”.

I stumbled across a Marxist YouTube channel, PhilosophyTube, whose solution to the housing crisis was to outlaw the housing market and distribute the houses to democratic committees. Things like incentives for production, supply and demand, the many pathologies of democracy, the sense people have that they ought to be able to express their choice as individuals, public choice theory, and the fact that no given unit of housing is fungible were presumably too logocentric to address.

I have seen the Marxist movie before and where it leads is not pretty.

I would urge people who think egalitarianism is important to read George. The space of political economy is much larger than either left or right would have you believe.

There are forms of wealth distribution that do not decrease economic efficiency, such as said land value tax. Harberger taxes are another such policy.

ZhuanXia··on Hong Kong ISP Association’s Statement on Selective Blocking of Internet Services
I used to read Dominic Cumming’s blog. He is a very bright guy, obsessed with the right tail of human capital, which Hong Kong has a disproportionate amount of.

He is in a position of huge influence in the new government, which I think some people underrate. A great admirer of Bismarck, I very much doubt he cares much for the policy opinions of the people he pandered to to get power.

Morally, the British people owe the people of Hong Kong citizenship. Economically, it makes a great deal of sense, especially as those who move will most likely be younger people.

It will be interesting to see what he does. Though no Bizmark, he has a sort of hacker mindset to politics that is unusual in this day and age.

From an outsiders perspective, I like free trade and free movement of people, but I hate stultifying bureaucracy.

Or to put it another way: I like it when governments compete for citizens and capital. I dislike it when they have the capacity to coordinate against same.

So I consider the EU as something of a mixed bag.

ZhuanXia··on Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets
Many of us do not believe IP is a legitimate property right.
ZhuanXia··on Why didn't the Romans contribute much to mathematics?
The rise of technology was not so much the birth of new capacities, but the removal of old constraints.

China, despite a much larger and more educated population, did not spark the industrial revolution. Their feedback loops were too stable, their elites too competent.

From the perspective of the old power hierarchy, the industrial revolution was a disaster.

The nobility floated on that great cruel ocean first charted by Malthus, an ocean which began to boil.

ZhuanXia··on OpenGPT-2: We Replicated GPT-2 Because You Can Too
Are you going to update your poetry engine now that we have this?
ZhuanXia··on Silicon Valley Looks North as Tech Giants Expand in Toronto
I advise anyone in Canadian tech to move to the states if they can. The rise in pay is so enormous it overcomes all objections. Move from Canada to Austin and you get higher pay, affordable housing because of zoning is not controlled by a rent-seeking gerontocracy, and far less taxes, too. Also, Canada has many indirect taxes in the form of crony capitalism. Grocery chains and phone providers have extremely cushy relationships with regulators there, increasing their ability to extract rents. Health insurance is not as big a deal as everyone says, at least for people making tech salaries.
ZhuanXia··on What If the Singularity Does Not Happen? (2007) [video]
Vinge’s definition of the singularity is the creation of human-level AI. After we have superhuman AI governments will be irrelevant. What ever the AI wants it gets.
ZhuanXia··on Chemists make first-ever ring of pure carbon
Molecular assemblers are almost taboo to discuss in chemistry and have been for decades. Sort of like the AI winter. Things feel like they are starting to thaw.
ZhuanXia··on Uber, losing billions, freezes engineering hires
I don't know what Uber thinks its end game is. Uber's "lets burn money to capture the market and own self driving" stratagem is economically absurd. In the limit of driverless cars, capital can be turned directly into labor so anyone with capital will deploy a fleet so long as it is profitable. Talk about a red ocean. The self-driving dream investors pin their hopes on is a siren. Ironically, Uber will only be able to maintain value in those futures where driverless cars don't work out.

Commodities do not have network effects. In general, if you are replacing labor with capital (in the form of automation) you will not get the network effects of a two-sided market - which is basically a market failure caused by our previous inability to convert capital into labor in a manner that scales. If you are replacing a two-sided market with automation you are going to need another moat.

ZhuanXia··on The Robot economy and the future of work
The Nordic countries are not socialist. They have not seized the means of production and handed it to a poorly-incentivized bureaucracy that claims to speak for the public.

If you have private ownership of production you are still capitalist. All the Nordic countries do this. They are not so much socialists as welfare states. If we must have a welfare state, I would much prefer the "citizens as shareholders of the country" model with a basic income, rather than the overweening paternalism of current welfare states.

ZhuanXia··on We shouldn’t take peer review as the ‘gold standard’
Is there any proof peer review has increased scientific productivity? It is relatively new, and I don't see any reason prima facie why it would work better than an editorial teaming willing to delegate when necessary. Anecdotally, I see lots of academics complain about very important results being unable to make it through peer review. Ralph Merkel's early groundbreaking cryptography work was suppressed for years by unthinking peer review. From Merklel:

>My first paper (and, in fact, the first paper) on public key cryptography was submitted in 1974 and initially rejected by an unknown "cryptography expert" because it was "...not in the main stream of present cryptography thinking...."

ZhuanXia··on Pre-Sliced Bread Was Once Banned in the United States (2010)
If only the downsides of all regulations were so transparent and causally obvious to the public.
ZhuanXia··on Insured price $2,758, cash price $521
If you are trying to make free market arguments for doctors salaries come on. The doctors guild restricts supply through the state. No free market here.
ZhuanXia··on Engines of Creation, by K. Eric Drexler (1986)
FTL and antigravity violate physical law. Drexler’s designs just don’t. Point me to a design in Nanosystems the that is physically impossible to construct.

The point of Nanosystems was to explore what technologies are feasible given our current understanding of physics at that scale. It turns out there is a lot of latent potential there.

ZhuanXia··on [dead]
It is the contention of Mr Ford of Hollywood that every science denier must be shaken out of modern politics, as one would shake moths and dust off of an old coat. What does he imagine he will have left? If you rid the pool of electable candidates of scientific illiterates you will be left holding the empty air.
ZhuanXia··on Engines of Creation, by K. Eric Drexler (1986)
I do not think you read the link. It is not about Drexler, but P. T. Barnum, which does not seem an apt comparison.

Few would claim molecular assemblers are physically impossible. Drexler made claims about what was possible under physical law. They are pretty conservative.

I don’t think he ever pretended to having technology he didn’t have.

I do think Drexler committed the grave sin of writing a book for popular consumption. He should have published Nanosystems first and waited decades before writing Engines of Creation.

ZhuanXia··on Engines of Creation, by K. Eric Drexler (1986)
Explain?
ZhuanXia··on Biology is the New Tech: Letter from a conference on CRISPR
The twins were separated at birth.
ZhuanXia··on Biology is the New Tech: Letter from a conference on CRISPR
Gould was a paleontologist, not a geneticist. Gould's reputation is zero in evolutionary biology, an industrious fool.

See this letter to the editor if you want to see what the giants of evolutionary biology thought of Gould:

John Maynard Smith, one of the world's leading evolutionary biologists, recently summarized in the NYRB the sharply conflicting assessments of Stephen Jay Gould: "Because of the excellence of his essays, he has come to be seen by non-biologists as the preeminent evolutionary theorist. In contrast, the evolutionary biologists with whom I have discussed his work tend to see him as a man whose ideas are so confused as to be hardly worth bothering with, but as one who should not be publicly criticized because he is at least on our side against the creationists." (NYRB, Nov. 30th 1995, p. 46). No one can take any pleasure in the evident pain Gould is experiencing now that his actual standing within the community of professional evolutionary biologists is finally becoming more widely known. If what was a stake was solely one man's self-regard, common decency would preclude comment.

But as Maynard Smith points out, more is at stake. Gould "is giving non-biologists a largely false picture of the state of evolutionary theory" -- or as Ernst Mayr says of Gould and his small group of allies -- they "quite conspicuously misrepresent the views of [biology's] leading spokesmen."[1] Indeed, although Gould characterizes his critics as "anonymous" and "a tiny coterie," nearly every major evolutionary biologist of our era has weighed in in a vain attempt to correct the tangle of confusions that the higher profile Gould has inundated the intellectual world with.[2] The point is not that Gould is the object of some criticism -- so properly are we all -- it is that his reputation as a credible and balanced authority about evolutionary biology is non-existent among those who are in a professional position to know: http://cogweb.ucla.edu/Debate/CEP_Gould.html

>IQ tests have been thoroughly debunked as highly dependent on cultural biases and assumptions of learned knowledge.predicted by genetics alone.

They really, truly have not been debunked. If you are willing to read a short book on the topic, I would recommend this one which has an epub version here: https://archive.org/details/IntelligenceAllThatMatters/page/...

If you are interested in the truth, I ask you to approach this subject bloodlessly, as you would a programming problem. Read the book I linked to. Then re-read Measure of Man, if you must.

But before you do, allow yourself to consider that bio-determinism is allowed to be true. There is no god or law of physics that prevents this from being the case. Imagine that these were just brute facts. If they were, your actions may change but your normative commitments do not have to.

I think if you read the literature neutrally, you will find g-factor is basically coherent and well-motivated, and intelligence is heritable. But when reading on matters touched by ideology, I think it is important to allow yourself to believe you can be persuaded.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →