HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Zimahl

1,480 karma · joined August 19, 2011

submissionscomments
Zimahl··on Jeff Bezos Is Playing Chess
but you do have to break a few eggs to throw the baby out before it's hatched.

"If we hit that bullseye, the rest of the dominoes will fall like a house of cards. Checkmate!"

- Zapp Brannigan

Zimahl··on Taken
Hardly a chance, if you have a device that is used for criminal activity don't be surprised if that gives cops a reason to scrutinize you.

This article is so biased and reeks of agenda. There are no other more sympathetic people to do news stories for? My BS radar just off the charts. If you can look past the fair amount of cash in the car and the drug paraphernalia then there is a need for outrage. However, I can't.

While I might see a reason for seizure laws I could easily see them being abused. That said, the example given in the article isn't going to win over any opponents.

Zimahl··on Did Goldman Overstep in Criminally Charging Its Ex-Programmer?
I know what you are getting at, but that recent SCOTUS decision didn't implicitly say that. However, it did make it clear that you can't talk with police (thus waiving your right), refuse to answer a question, and then answer other questions. In essence, it's not the police's job to figure out whether or not you're invoking your right.
Zimahl··on How We Created a Fake Vodka Brand to Promote Our Startup
From my chemistry background I know you could extract anything with solvents but I didn't realize that you would use that method to get a potable alcohol! I don't doubt you would be able to taste the difference.
Zimahl··on How We Created a Fake Vodka Brand to Promote Our Startup
Vodka is a pretty unique beast with respect to alcohols. It's defined as 'colorless, odorless, and tasteless' alcohol. While the tasteless part is not necessarily true, other alcohols are specifically designed for taste, which means that the different tastes of wine, whiskey, tequila, etc., are important aspects and can require more time and cost to make - and thusly cost more.

Bottom shelf tequila is bad, no blind taste test is going to prove otherwise. However, if you are just going to be mixing it into a margarita to get people lubricated, it's probably fine.

Whiskey is generally just drank chilled over ice or stones (or nothing), so flavor matters greatly.

Zimahl··on How We Created a Fake Vodka Brand to Promote Our Startup
I suspect the testing grandparent is thinking of would show that price does not correlate with quality

Correct. Of course there was a difference in taste, but it was clearly within statistics that there was no correlation between favorite to least favorite and most expensive to least expensive (top-self vs bottom-shelf).

That said, I am not a Vodka drinker although my wife is. She has tried them all and prefers Svedka currently for it's taste and price.

Zimahl··on How We Created a Fake Vodka Brand to Promote Our Startup
At a minimum it might make a good defense in federal court.
Zimahl··on How We Created a Fake Vodka Brand to Promote Our Startup
Here's a couple articles that are talking about blind-tests either they did or from someone else. I've seen better articles with more test details but I can't seem to find them again.

The New York Times similarly blind taste-tested 21 vodkas. Grey Goose and Ketel One failed to finish in the top 10. The winner? Smirnoff. The lowest priced vodka placed highest. [1]

[1] http://spectator.org/archives/2013/05/24/vodkavodkavodka

[2] http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-05-23/worlds-best-v...

[3] http://abcnews.go.com/2020/Consumer/storynew?id=3201973&page...

Zimahl··on How We Created a Fake Vodka Brand to Promote Our Startup
A little off-topic but in blind taste tests (I'll have to find the link) people weren't able to tell the difference between top and bottom shelf vodkas.
Zimahl··on Kathy Sierra: Your app makes me fat
Sure my last line was somewhat facetious but still a valid point - I'd love a link to the paper to draw real conclusions. I think the blog post is a little underwhelming as far as insight into the experiment.

As for the puzzle-solving dog study, I still don't think that implies a willpower/cognitive task difficulty link. It certainly doesn't help prove human decision making. I think we can both assume that humans are slightly more complex.

Finally, I also think linking this to app design is silly at best. But that is completely biased, personal opinion.

Zimahl··on Kathy Sierra: Your app makes me fat
I'm with foobarbazqux.

The experiment randomly assigned people to groups and then increased the cognitive load on one group. Then it found a statistically significant difference between groups in a particular measurement.

This sentence is true. So as cognitive load increased, there was a significant difference in the choice of the two groups. What it doesn't seem to justify is whether or not it was related to willpower.

We also don't know how many chose cake in group A (2-digit group). If it was two in group A and 3 in group B (the 7-digit group), then there's your 50% increase.

Zimahl··on Kathy Sierra: Your app makes me fat
The problem I have is that 'willpower' is completely subjective and arbitrary. Exerting your willpower is not the same as me exerting mine. Also, your definition of a willpower choice might not be the same to me.

Like I said, in my 20s, food was meaningless. Calories/fat/cholesterol weren't even something I considered. I wasn't overweight due to my high metabolism, so the choice between fruit or cake would be arbitrary. It wouldn't depend on using my brain, it would depend on any number of other factors. To put it simply: if I felt like the fruit, I'd eat the fruit, otherwise cake.

You felt that playing a specific game was a waste of your time and you felt you'd have difficulty in quitting so you made it significantly hard to start again. Someone else might be able to just shut it down, leave it all installed, never go back to it, and, maybe, never even think about it again.

So, unless you know that a person has some reservations about eating cake, it's hard to say whether choosing cake over fruit is a willpower decision. There's an even worse example in the article:

Spend hours at work on a tricky design problem? You’re more likely to stop at Burger King on the drive home.

Once again, it makes the assumption that stopping off at Burger King is somehow taboo to the person and because they blew a ton of cognitive cycles their willpower is blown. And all this completely inferred by a flawed premise (or at least flawed in how it is presented to us in this blog post).

Let me give a reverse example. I chew my nails, sometimes very badly, and this can get to the point of the skin around the nail as well. It can be pretty painful. I've tried just about everything to quit, yet I've been doing this for at least early middle school. I find that if I can keep myself busy enough, either through work or non-stressful activities, I do not chew my nails (or at least it's minimized. My willpower is low when my cognitive functions are in excess - the exact opposite of what this research and accompanying blog assumes. That is one reason I find it to be somewhat questionable.

Zimahl··on Kathy Sierra: Your app makes me fat
It assumes that cake to all participants is decadent and requires willpower. As a college student in my 20s, no amount of food was off limits and therefore I wouldn't have batted an eye at choosing the cake.

I read the results as more of "I completed a hard task therefore I feel it's appropriate choosing the greater reward."

Zimahl··on Cost of storing all human audio-visual experiences
Man, this brings up a lot of privacy questions. Especially around who gets to look at what. I mean is this a personal archive that only unlocks after your death? Is it open to anyone? Is it available to law enforcement?

This about this:

Your entire sex life is replayable. This includes being with someone or solo action. Do you want you grandkids watching that?

No longer are we contemplating whether someone committed a crime, we would just watch the replay. Would you even commit a crime if you knew it was being recorded? You wouldn't need witnesses, just their feeds. Heck, you don't need forensic evidence really - if you never find a murder weapon who cares? It's on video! The innocent always have an air-tight alibi. It's on video!

Would not allowing law enforcement to look at your 'life feed' automatically make you a suspect?

Zimahl··on How A Police Officer Threatened A Yelp Reviewer
His actions don't appear to be illegal, but do the police have the right to not investigate something that was reported as illegal? I mean, if harassment is claimed by someone should the police just shrug their shoulders? No, they should probably investigate and determine if a crime actually happened. In the meantime, telling someone what could happen if they were doing what was claimed is not what I'd call 'threatening'.

I guess don't really see the problem with the phone call from the police either. It's just a subtle 'I don't want to have to come back out here' warning that they give every day to prevent things from getting to the point that they have to intervene. It does seem like a bored police department, but I didn't hear any threats in the phone call. This article jumps the gun a little bit by inferring collusion between the police and the pizza restaurant.

Zimahl··on Facebook earnings beat; shares jump nearly 20%
I would guess it's because the context is relatively obscure whereas with Google it's not.

Yes, they can uniquely identify you by your profile more than Google can, but for many who don't 'like' everything left and right (or like everything they come across) how would you determine what ads to show them? Just because my friends like something doesn't mean I will. And that's a wasted impression.

Google on the other hand knows what you want - you're actively searching for it. It's pretty straightforward for those who want to serve ads to target what they want to target.

Zimahl··on Nate Silver Went Against the Grain for Some at The Times
I'm not sure if people understand that Nate Silver likes sports. Under the tweed blazer and spectacles, the guy loves baseball. There are very few topics of study with more data points than baseball. Besides, there are sports 100% of the time during the year, and a US national election once every 4 (Senate and house races are boring).

Seriously, it may not have been about money or fit. If someone came along and said that you could continue to code software and get paid to do it, but didn't have to work for CrushSoul, Inc., anymore AND it was in something you found insanely fun and interesting, wouldn't you do it?

Zimahl··on The 2005 screenwriting book that’s taken over Hollywood
All I have to say about this is maybe. I mean, tropes are used, overused, and come and go - that's how the industry works. Writers are who they are just like directors. You aren't all of a sudden going to turn Zack Snyder into Scorsese or Abrams into Tarantino.

But then again, Scorsese and Tarantino aren't making movies like 'Pirates of the Caribbean 7: Wet, Hot Caribbean Summer' that can be absolute shit, but as long a Johnny Depp is playing Jack Sparrow it's a billion dollars globally.

Zimahl··on Google Glass has new rival in GlassUp smart specs
You could say this about a lot of tech that just wasn't quite right, failed, and then someone tried something at a later date and it took off. Google wasn't the first search engine, Skype wasn't the first attempt at consumer-level video over the internet, World of Warcraft wasn't the first MMO, the list goes on.
Zimahl··on Your Startup’s Office Is Missing a Room
Not to disparage the idea but this can be expensive to set up and time consuming to use. Also, it can take a while to get the process down and/or have someone who can properly interpret what the user is actually doing.

I have found that in early stages of a startup that one or more subject-matter experts who are hopefully involved with the space can give much more direct feedback in the early stages.

Zimahl··on New NSFW content restrictions enrage Tumblr users
The market seems to be voluntarily making a massive hole for an adult-content-friendly blogging platform to fill

There is so much euphemism in that sentence when referencing porn that it's almost palpable.

That said, I agree. Doesn't everything on the internet start with porn?

Zimahl··on J.K. Rowling and the Chamber of Literary Fame
I think you are missing the point. There's no argument that new authors can sell a ton of books given the right inputs. What the article is saying is that you can sell a lot of shit to people with a fanbase. The point is proven with an overlooked book that was critically acclaimed but ignored by the public, but once tied to Rowling is now a best-seller.

Off the top of my head, in the book world, Stephen King is one of those people with that type of fanbase. I think a lot of people agree that he's a fine writer but there's a lot of junk mixed in with his good stuff - yet even the junk still rockets up the best seller list just because[1]. Stephanie Meyer can do this as well, and critics have said she's not a very good writer at all (ironically Stephen King said this too).

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6TRVXG4kQE

Zimahl··on Ouya console review: "Pass on it"
I can't speak for the OP but the main reason for me would probably be nostalgia. The second reason is that I could probably download every single ROM ever produced for these systems and store it on an average sized flash drive. Finally, I don't know much about pirating on the 360 but I'm personally not inclined (read: lazy) to mod an XBox.
Zimahl··on Ouya console review: "Pass on it"
where will you get legal ROMs for those consoles?

You don't. You put on your eyepatch, grab your cutlass, and raise the Jolly Roger.

Zimahl··on Detroit files for Chapter 9 bankruptcy amid staggering debts
In Oregon, the highest paid state retiree is a former football coach that was paid millions[1] during his career. Agreed, the system is broken.

[1] http://www.statesmanjournal.com/article/20111122/NEWS/111220...

Zimahl··on Why I'm Returning Google Glass
I don't know if anyone has asked this yet but why does it have lenses if those lenses don't actually do anything? I mean, why not just the display portion in some sort of headpiece instead of including the glass?
Zimahl··on Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic Income
I never said any of those wouldn't exist, but I'm a firm believer in rewards. Right now a janitor is rewarding himself with a paycheck so he can do what he wants otherwise the flip side is poverty.

Here's the thing. Let's say you made $100k per year working 40 hours/week with benefits. If I were to pay you to not work but get a smaller wage (keeping your benefits), what percentage would be acceptable to you? 90%? 80%? 50%? What is it worth to you to not have to work?

There is a number that most janitors would probably accept. I think a fair number of retail employees too.

Zimahl··on Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic Income
Do you think he wants to be scrubbing toilets for a subsistence wage?

Thanks for proving my point. No, I highly doubt he wants to scrub a toilet for a subsistence wage. I think a janitorial job would go empty for a long, long time. So now, instead of me focusing on my job, I have to take time out of my day to do something I'd pay someone for.

It would be better if you get your basic livable wage but still have to work (exceptions made for childcare, students, disability, etc.) and depending on the job you get what the market deems as extra. So, if you get $20k per year as a livable wage (figure just chosen for easier math) and a job would've paid $25k, you get the $5k difference in your paycheck. This would help keep the low-interest, but easy, jobs staffed.

Zimahl··on Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic Income
The question is: how many people currently working would stop working if they didn't need to? (particularly in the areas vital for the basic functioning of society) That question is so impossibly difficult to answer that I don't think any system we come up with won't have potentially disastrous consequences.

I don't think it's all that difficult to answer. When I leave the office building I work at the end of my day, the janitors are just showing up. They probably already only get paid the basic livable wage (probably less), so why would they show up to work if they were getting the paycheck anyways? I can think of 100s of other jobs that someone wouldn't show up for because they aren't worth the time, they aren't fun, or even remotely interesting.

Zimahl··on Restore the Fourth
The unfortunate reality today is that we are living in a country where you really have to be afraid of the consequences of exercising your Constitutional right of free speech and assembly.

I never thought I'd have this thoughts in the US. Never.

Then you either haven't been in the US very long or aren't a student of history.

Not that it makes it right, but this has always been the case. Whether you were a suffragette, a unionist, a war protester, a civil rights protestor, an anti-abortion/pro-life protestor, occupy, etc. The list goes on and will always go on.

When you fight 'the man' you can (and should) expect him to fight back - sometimes unfairly.

← PreviousPage 8 of 21Next →