HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamzochowski

651 karma · joined November 19, 2009

submissionscomments
adamzochowski··on The music classifying nightmare
I can see few issues with this that wouldn't work with me:

1) How do you deal with songs that have multiple genres?

It is a standard part of the TCON (content type / genre tag) to separate multiple values through either coma, slash.

For example this allows you to select songs that are tagged as both 'Ambient' and 'Rock'.

2) how do you deal with album that has songs of varying styles?

For example: "Prodigy - Music for Jilted Generation" has a dance track like "Voodoo People", and a chillout track "3 Kilos"

http://www.last.fm/music/The+Prodigy/_/Voodoo+People/+tags

http://www.last.fm/music/The+Prodigy/_/The+Narcotic+Suite:+3...

3) Compilations

Let's say we have a compilation made by a group called 'Air'. This compilation is called 'Deck Safari'. Do you use Album Artist instead of artist if it is a compilations (aka: if TCMP flag exists, use TPE2 instead of TPE1?)

Checkout the album:

http://www.discogs.com/AIR-Deck-Safari-Part-1/release/215068

4) I don't understand how you handle singles.

Let's say you have a single ""Wamdue Project ‎– King Of My Castle"" released in 1999 by Urban (563 891-2). Your formatting doesn't store album at all?

http://www.discogs.com/Wamdue-Project-King-Of-My-Castle/rele...

And then, how do you combine it with the fact that a year later was a different mix released by Avex Asia Ltd. (AVTCDS-235) with different set of songs?

http://www.discogs.com/Wamdue-Project-King-Of-My-Castle/rele...

To me it looks like your singles folder is intended for random songs, not to handle actual CDS/CDM style singles.

adamzochowski··on The music classifying nightmare
Some artists re-record or alter their song on secondary release. Or if it is live performance.

Deduplication should be done by algorithm that detects that it is same binary copy -- not through tags.

adamzochowski··on The music classifying nightmare
This isn't something that relational database fixes. It is about schema and data tagging. It can all still sit in ID3v2 tags, as long as people use all tags properly.

The problem is that most tags are badly written, and most software that displays songs only displays bare minimum. Typically tags I miss seeing: Style / Moods / Genres / Composers / Performers. Even Album Artist or Compilation tags are bad. Same with some misspelled tags, or inconsistent (is it 'D&B' or 'DnB' or 'Drum-n-Base', etc).

adamzochowski··on The music classifying nightmare
Discogs tracks Alternative Nicks that artists use, and can help you link songs together. Here is Aphex Twin example:

http://www.discogs.com/artist/Aphex+Twin

Also, discogs will track which albums were released under different artist tags. Foobar+discogs tagger combination lets you pick, if you want to use most common general name (so all tracks are Aphex twin), or the alternative name that songs were released under (aka: AFX songs stay as AFX).

---

This is same issue as a book ''Running Man'' (yes, followed by a movie with Arnold). Was it written by Richard Bachman, or Steven King? How does your public library list book?

adamzochowski··on The music classifying nightmare
I agree that year is screwed up, but some taggers (like the picard-lastfm tagger) reads also decade feel tags. So music that sounds like 90s is tagged as 90s music, even if it isn't recorded in 90s.

For example, ""La Roux -- In It For The Kill"" will get the song tagged as sounding 80s like:

http://www.last.fm/music/La+Roux/_/In+for+the+Kill/+tags

adamzochowski··on The music classifying nightmare
Addressing points

  --
  [[ Albums have artists too ]]
Albums often have a person that mixes songs together. In ID3v2 series we use a tag "TPE2". Early ID3v2 adopters used "TXXX ALBUM ARTIST" and "TXXX ALBUMARTIST" as originally TPE2 was reserved for Band definition. iTunes and WMP both standardized on TPE2 for album artist.

Armin Van Buuren - State of Trance v561- #2 - Artsy - Open Space

  TPE1 (song author) - Arsty
  TPE2 (album author) - Armin Van Buuren
  TALB (album title) - State of Trance v561
  TRCK (track number) - 2
TPE2 typically comes in use with TCMP designating that a song is a compilation. (Before TCMP became standard, people also used "TXXX COMPILATION").

  --
  [[ You need multiple versions of songs ! ]]
Most programs automating software will ask which version of album it is.

For example, Pendulum band released album "Hold Your Color" in 2005. http://www.discogs.com/Pendulum-Hold-Your-Colour/release/494...

However, in 2007 the rereleased the album, http://www.discogs.com/Pendulum-Hold-Your-Colour/release/134...

The last two songs differ. You need to pick right year to ensure you tag them properly.

Alternatively, the year could foretell how remastered the song is. Is this original compression, or the new louder version? See Loudness war article. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war

  --
  [[ date/year is screwed up -- agreed ]]
We have to differentiate three types of dates:

When song was recorded -- aka: This song was released in 1994

When album compilation was released -- aka: the best of 90s was released in 2005

What decade the song is trying to recapture -- aka: the song feels like music from the 60s

  --
  [[ Genres / taggins is a solution -- although at time blunt ]]
Genres were terrible in old ID3v1, where we were locked to 127 genres.

In ID3v2 we can enter whatever we want into genre, and store multiple of them. Good taggers read data off Last.fm / discogs / music brainz enter complete information about songs. This includes tags detailing genre, instruments, style, moods, decades. Certain players, like XBMC can use style and moods. Some systems like discogs even support hierarchal tags (see their style vs genre).

adamzochowski··on Collapsible comments for Hacker News
One suggestion, can you move the collapsible-minus to be left of username? Like on reddit?
adamzochowski··on Paul Oakenfold crowdsources a beat on beatlab
All flash blockers let you cherry pick which flash you want to unblock. This means you can unblock content, but keep spam or other cpu wasters blocked.

This website does not let me do that. It redirect to a different page, and forces me to white list everything. Something I rarely do.

adamzochowski··on NaNs Just Don't Get No Respect
This looks very much like NULLs in the SQL world.

A null (and NaN) is like an unknown. One can't compare unknowns because they are exactly that, unknown.

Let's construct a language that on division on zero returns unknowns.

   a =  5 / 0;
   b = 10 / 0;
Now, both a and b are set to unknown state. If one were to compare a to b, should the expectation be that they hold same value?

I wish all languages would have nullability like SQL does. Where a great care has to be given to deal with nullable data, lest nulls nullify everything.

adamzochowski··on Nielsen: More Teens Now Listen To Music Through YouTube Than Any Other Source
Hydrogen Audio treats Lame -v4 setting (~165kbps) as perceptual transparency. Meaning loss, but transparent.

Youtube doesn't use MP3s, but AAC for hd content, which provides even better quality. There are numerous tests that compare AAC at 64kbps to MP3 at 128kbps.

Often artists upload music attached to HD still picture, to ensure that high quality encoding is available.

The low quality is not an issue with Youtube audio bitrates, but problem stemming from people uploading low quality sources. Audio re-encoded multiple times. It is common to find a mono music with 12khz cutoff.

adamzochowski··on Important Security Update (Battle.net user information compromised)
How does this affect users with Key Fobs?

http://us.blizzard.com/store/search.xml?q=authenticator

adamzochowski··on How To Write Good Log Messages
> I don't understand this? A tab is a tab?

I think the parent meant that a problem could be if data itself contains a tab character, causing an offset during parsing.

adamzochowski··on Reverse-Engineered Irises Look So Real, They Fool Eye-Scanners
That is what a password is.
adamzochowski··on Bring Google Fibre into Canada
This is correct. Please read about Egyptian Wind Mobile having issues entering market because they didn't have enough Canadian ownership.

http://www.techvibes.com/blog/wind-mobile-violates-laws-on-f...

adamzochowski··on Show HN: Jeff Atwood's "Effective Programming" on Hyperink's new Crowd Reader
Hi Michael.

The scroll is different from OS Scroll. It is much slower, moving at a pixel per scroll wheel event. Also [space] doesn't do page down. Running Chromium 18.0.1025.168 (Developer Build 134367 Linux) Ubuntu 12.04, with smooth scrolling enabled (in about:flags )

adamzochowski··on "Don’t waste your time in crappy startup jobs."
Reddit discussion http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/wan60/dont_wast...
adamzochowski··on Show HN: Listener Approved - Reddit for music all in node.js
Few issues

* no way to bookmark or forward a link to song or filter to a friend. If this is to help sharing, then it fails that.

* clicking a song moves the rest down, making it less consistent

* no way to put filter in url bar. Reddit is great with their concatenation of two subreddits in one address: reddit.com/r/programming+technology . Please do it so I can see top songs from /m/Goa+Psychedelic

* no way for curators. A lot of art industry follows a system of 'stamps of approval' through publishers / producers or labels. I am a fan of music from Ninja Tune label who represent artists like Amon Tobin and Skalpel. I don't see a way to discover other music from same label. I understand this could be done through playlists maybe?

* registration requires a lot of information that I am not fan of giving out. Redit creates account with just username/password. I hate giving out personal information. Location is created with 'undefined, undefined'. Location is required. Location doesn't even accept my default places like Kualalumpur. It did find Warsaw.

* registration doesn't go forward. I click 'Lets do it', nothing happens

as I can't register couple other points of interest:

* A lot of people like to add own tags to music, like decades (sounds like 80s), or moods (cheery), or languages (Polish).

* how are comments differentiated from general song comments vs 'at 1:45 the drop is massive' (soundcloud way)

* linking with other data sources: please think about reading last.fm / musicbrainz / discogs to get list of known genres/styles/moods.

* as you are starting, the reddit way is to add stuff yourself as tons of users. Try to link content from elektoplazm , and other places where you can find out the public / create commons status

cheers

adamzochowski··on Twitter hash tags and UTF8
>> the ą sounds very similar to a

Nope, ą is more similar to 'o' than 'a', and this is seen very often in how kids write words like 'mówią' as 'mówio'

From wikipedia:

Originally ą was a nasal a but in modern times the pronunciation of this vowel has shifted to a nasal o sound. It is most commonly pronounced as /ɔw̃/, /ɔn/, /ɔm/.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%84

Kind regards

adamzochowski··on Now That's What I Call Social Proof
But that is exactly how both Replay Gain and EBU R128 behave.

Initial set of conditions:

  - we want music to have uniform volume
  - we want louder parts be slightly louder
  - we want quieter parts be slightly quieter
In the end, over compressed songs are penalized. Songs that are recorded too quiet are pumped up. But it is a per song setting, leaving song to song progression on same level.

Here is a discussion on comparing how Replay Gain and EBU R128 algorithms http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index.php?showtopic=8642...

adamzochowski··on Show HN: Ginger: Better Team Discussions
When I click \\Pricing// I am scrolled to seeing the green text ''Eliminate Meetings , Get a Pulse , Never Forget''. It tells me nothing of price. So I look for largest text closest to middle. There I see ''What do our Customers Say?''. Also totally irrelevant to what I want, the price.

Please make sure that bottom item scrolls high enough. I know that this is partially because my screen is 1900x1200, so just pad the last item.

adamzochowski··on Ask HN : Where Does VC Money Really Go?
Are you a stripper?
adamzochowski··on Show HN: BestSFBooks, Mashup of the Best SF/Fantasy Books
Awesome job. It is similar to existing https://www.worldswithoutend.com/
adamzochowski··on This is what happens when one guy practices art every day for nine years
But atelier is already a perfect valid English word. Sure, it came from French, but it is now part of English language. Complaining about it would be like complaining that word 'Robot' is a Czech word for work/worker.
adamzochowski··on A curated catalog of iOS frameworks
Of a framework? As in API? I am not sure if I understand, how would one make a screenshot of ROR? or Django? or jQuery?

Unless you mean top application using a given framework, but then, it is not indicative of the framework, but the amount of time one spent on graphics on top of the framework.

adamzochowski··on Google Quietly Rolls Out The Chrome Extension To Bring +1 To The Entire Web
I don't understand the problem. There are two ways that I know to handle this.

1) on secondary account setup imap/pop3 access. Setup primary account to read that. Grant access for primary account to use secondary email address (allows to change the from email)

2) in the app settings of your second domain, setup mailing list that has your primary email as the only destination. Enable the mailing list to accept any incoming email. Grant access for primary account to use secondary email address (allows to change the from email)

There are probably more ways, I know of few people that have 5 email addresses all setup to route through one core account.

adamzochowski··on Why Arabic is Terrific
> hungarian is not related to finnish

"" The Uralic languages ( /jʊˈrælɨk/) (sometimes referred to as Uralian languages) constitute a language family of some three dozen languages spoken by approximately 25 million people. The healthiest Uralic languages in terms of the number of native speakers are Hungarian, Finnish, Estonian, Mari and Udmurt. ""

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uralic_languages

adamzochowski··on Soft32 Updater Stay up-to-date with your software
How does it compare to File Hippo Update Checker ? http://www.filehippo.com/updatechecker/
adamzochowski··on Psychologist James Pennebaker reveals the hidden meaning of pronouns
Minor nitpick (correct me please).

'szła' is closer to "she was going"

'poszła' is closer to "she went"

adamzochowski··on Windows 8 Will Have A Dedicated App Store For Downloading Apps
Windows will improve greatly once we stop having each application run random auto update, but have it all centralized.

I don't want to deal with 20 different auto-updaters, plus just in case running both

Secuinia Personal Software Inspector -- notifies you about known vulnerabilities in software, and about updates. http://secunia.com/vulnerability_scanning/personal/

File Hippo Software Checker -- notifies you about updates to software you use, especially if said software doesn't have own updater http://www.filehippo.com/updatechecker/

adamzochowski··on Windows 8 Will Have A Dedicated App Store For Downloading Apps
Didn't linux do the same with apt-get / yum install / urpmi management tools? Just a decade ago.
← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →