HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adwn

6,109 karma · joined November 5, 2013

submissionscomments
adwn··on Can we replace a $150k Looker with a bucket of HTML files?
Criticize the content, not the means of creation.
adwn··on It's still ok to enjoy programming
> one thinker and 5 minions

Your error lies in thinking Opus 5.5 is equivalent to a "minion". The "5 software developers" in my example were meant to stand in for "reasonably competent, above-average developers", and not that the architect is the only one on the team who can "think".

Of course, it may well be the case that you are working in an elite sector of the industry where even the bottom rungs are filled by the top 20% of software developers. Possible, but unlikely, so I'm still leaning towards "you're holding it wrong".

adwn··on It's still ok to enjoy programming
No, not "hand holding". If you insist on anthropomorphizing the AI, "guiding it on a high level" would be more fitting. In a team of 1 architect and 5 software developers, Opus 5.5 + Claude Code replaces the 5 developers, not the architect. You don't have to "hold its hand" anymore than you have to hold the hand of a competent software developer — though you will have to figure out a workflow that suits you personally, including configuring Claude Code to follow that workflow (through skills, for example) so you can work ergonomically with it.
adwn··on AfD Leak: What 421,179 Hacked Emails Show about the German Far Right
No, article 20 of the German constitution forbids this, and article 79 forbids changing article 20 in the way you suggest.

Edit: There is a loophole, though. Article 146 allows the German people to replace the constitution in its entirety.

adwn··on It's still ok to enjoy programming
If you can't get Opus 5.5 to pass more than 80% of your test suite, then you're probably holding it wrong. Not "holding it wrong" as in Apple's "we designed a defective product and try to put the blame on you", but as in *"this is an incredibly sophisticated tool which takes skill and practice to use to its fullest extent".

LLMs, even in a good harness, are deceptively simple, but in reality rather complex tools. They're good at grasping intent, but they can't read your mind, they might not have access to the full context of your business, and they require learning how to use them properly.

adwn··on "I'm on a war footing": Terry Tao and the crisis in math
> so far it's been programming and math, the two fields most people would naturally assume computers would be good at :P

If that is true, then only because "most people" have no understanding of what differentiates programming and math from "computation". Computers (as the term suggests) have always been extremely good at the latter, and useless at the former. It's only 2–3 years ago that computers, by way of LLMs, have started being good at the former.

adwn··on Gemini 4 Argon
> Given LLMs are generally good at basic maths, im surprised they get this wrong.

1. Modeling and analyzing spinning, three-dimensional objects goes far beyond "basic maths".

2. The prompt was for an SVG of a realistically impossible situation (pelican riding a bicycle), which together already implies a stylized depiction. Why on Earth would you expect it to generate a 3D model of a bike, do a physics simulation on it, iterate until it satisfies certain contraints which are only hinted at in the prompt, and then project it down to a simplified 2D cartoon drawing? That's not how LLMs work, and that's not how we want them to work.

adwn··on AI is a tool and using it well takes skill
Thank you for empirically testing the claim. So many people who really should know better, simply assume what AI can or can't do, write that down on HN, and then believe that their assumptions have been validated when they read similar claims from other people doing the same thing.
adwn··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
I was obviously talking about the Democrats' choice of candidate. If they hadn't tried to force-feed the worst two of the plausible candidates to the electorate, Trump wouldn't have stood a chance.
adwn··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> But the opposition had NOTHING to do with Trump being chosen for POTUS. The Right had a perfectly decent choice […]

So did the Democrats. They clung to the worst possible choice, and in the last minute replaced him with the second-worst possible choice. Absolving them of fault and putting 100% of the blame on Trump voters is the fantasy of the Left.

adwn··on Why isn't the industry freaking out about DeepSeek 4.1 Flash?
Well, maybe, for certain programs, yes? Maybe I don't want a million SLOC behemoth with 1000 features that has a huge attack surface, when a slim 10k SLOC tool that does exactly what I need (and nothing more) will suffice? A tool that I can modify and extend on a whim? A tool that does one thing, and does it well — you know, the Unix philosophy?
adwn··on I gave Opus 5.5 one prompt and six hours to visualize Invisible Cities
Intuitively I'd say that just-for-fun AI projects emit orders of magnitude less CO2 than what just-for-fun road trips or air travel emit.

So unless you can show that it approaches all the other frivolous consumption that humans love to waste resources on, maybe we can get back to experimenting with cool technology and talking about it, on this website called "Hacker News"?

adwn··on Dots: Always-on agents
They already are to many people. Maybe not to you, but that's okay — no tool has to be useful to everybody. It's therefore a valid assumption.
adwn··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
> CRT vector displays (Vectrex) to this day get better effective refresh rates, brightness, and glow effects than existing displays (OLED) and peaked in the 1980s

Except that they're absolutely huge and heavy for any halfway decent screen size and resolution. If I were to replace my two 24-inch screens with CRTs, I'd need a second desk for them alone.

adwn··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
Are you suggesting to plant trees in such a way that they can tap into the water stream they're meant to protect from evaporation? Doing the calculation on which of the two effects will outweigh the other would surely be a fun exercise.
adwn··on AI-generated posters don’t have to be horrible
Are you being intentionally obtuse? Try reading their comment in its entirety, and not just as individual fragments taken out of context: They most likely didn't have the budget to hire a professional designer and no one else would do it for free, so they had to do it themselves. They didn't enjoy it, and they would've gladly passed that work to an AI, had one existed back then.

It's not that hard to understand. Here, I've linked it for your convenience: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49765890

adwn··on AI-generated posters don’t have to be horrible
They said: "I volunteered and designed a good amount of posters for student organizations." What do you think how many student organization have the excess money to hire a professional designer for a one-off poster? Of course they needed someone to do it for free, or else it wouldn't have been done at all!
adwn··on The scourge of x86 emulation
No, that's a myth. It's true that the instruction decoder in a CPU core translates from ISA opcodes to micro-ops for the backend, but those micro-ops are in many cases functionally very close to the ISA instruction and decidedly not RISC-like. For example, the ADD r/m64, imm32 instruction (read from memory, add constant, write to memory) is translated to a single micro-op on several Zen architectures [1], which is far from anything you could call "RISC".

[1] https://uops.info/html-instr/ADD_M64_I32.html

adwn··on Suspected sabotage causes major Netherlands rail disruption
Russia wants an excuse to justify mobilization in Russia, not in Europe.
adwn··on DeepSeek v4.1 Flash
> Norwegian state through its participation in NATO murdered millions of people in the middle east

I'll file this under "blatant lie" unless you can provide at least three reliable sources for your claim.

adwn··on The UN challenges five centuries of cartography
Both the world's population (with 88% to 12%) and landmass (with 68% to 32%) favor the northern hemisphere, so it makes sense to favor it in a general map as well.
adwn··on Just Bury Your Trash
A plastic bag protects against water and dirt, and it has handles for carrying. I'm not necessarily defending the practice, but it has its reasons.
adwn··on Where did all the public bathrooms go?
Please elaborate. Where does my comment leave the "right direction"?
adwn··on Where did all the public bathrooms go?
> they just want volunteers for the hard-to-staff weekday shower-cleaning shift

This may sound like a loaded question, but I assure you, that's not my intention. If you want to provide for those "invisible" homeless, who aren't drug addicts or mentally ill, shouldn't the primary volunteer pool consist of exactly those invisible homeless people? Or in other words, once you have organizers, why do you need external volunteers for cleaning the showers?

adwn··on Xiaomi: New CPU matches Apple cores single threaded, much faster multithreaded
This attitude, if followed without qualifications, is dangerously naive and shortsighted, as the last few years of geopolitical events have shown.
adwn··on Why aren't smart people happier? (2022)
Off-topic: I have absolutely no idea why my comment got downvoted. I shared a personal anecdote that's directly relevant to the discussion at hand and which counters the claim of the comment I replied to. Does someone think I'm lying? Was my comment too controversial? I don't get it. What is wrong with this site?
adwn··on Why aren't smart people happier? (2022)
> […] I don't think anyone who grew up in a bigger family under one roof could agree with that.

I do. I grew up with 5 siblings, and having brothers and sisters is very, very different from having your own children. My relation with and my emotions towards my children is very different from my relation with and my emotions towards my siblings, both now and when I was still living with them in the same house.

adwn··on OpenRouter is joining Stripe
> The idea being that getting your tokens from Provider A is no different than Provider B, especially if they both offer the same model.

You're describing a commodity. However, the commodity isn't the tokens, but the compute capacity, i.e., serving a model. And compute capacity isn't a currency — at least not, until you can acquire compute capacity from one party and exchange it with another party.

dgellow is absolutely right: tokens aren't a currency, nor can you trade them, nor are they fungible. The original claim that "tokens are just a type of currency" [1] makes no sense.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49364984

adwn··on Asus Bike Booster
> Step 1 could be not turning the world into a an Orwellian nightmare and outlawing mass surveillance, from both government and private corporations.

That would make society better, I agree, but I don't see how that would lead to a reduction in theft, or crime in general.

> And if you are still worried about theft in the mean time, you could try looking at wage thefts […]

I'm not worried about wage theft, no. I am worried about theft of my personal property, though. And I notice that you haven't proposed any credible path to reducing it, beyond an incredibly generic "make society better", whatever that means and however you want to achieve that.

adwn··on Asus Bike Booster
> Theft is solved by making society better, not worse.

Phew, good to hear. Here I thought it would be a hard and complex problem, with lots of unknown unknowns, difficult political compromises, a generation-spanning efforts and many potential solutions with uncertain outcomes, partially contradicting each other.

Instead, we just have to make society better. So, what's step 1?

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →