9,364 karma · joined July 27, 2007
Site: http://www.mobilefolk.com
Blog: http://www.alexc.me
Twitter: http://twitter.com/purrp
Email: alex@mobilefolk.com
My takeaway is that this kind of new development looks better (“movie set”) than what you describe, but it does not meaningfully change how people use and interact with the space and with each other.
The hard part is building a living, breathing, functional and healthy community on a continent that’s been built from the ground up around cars. There are so many examples everywhere in Europe and Asia, but I can’t think of many (any?) in North America.
As a kid I read Jules Verne translated in my native language, and loved it. Not sure where I would start to acquire his work in English.
http://www.ttc.ca/WheelTrans/index.jsp
All regular buses are still wheelchair accessible, but in practice I cannot remember the last time I saw a wheelchair user on a bus.
On a typical day I would walk in around 9:30, ask my supervisor if there is anything to do, usually the answer was no, back to my desk and sit around, leave around 3:30.
Computers were completely locked down, I did not even have Internet access. And yes, it was completely miserable. I read a lot of e-books that summer.
This might be where our views diverge. If you don’t think it matters whether a US company punished a Hong Kong national, in Taiwan, for political speech in support of democracy out of fear of potentially offending China, then I don’t think we’ll find much common ground.
>that seems very American to worry about
It is, and that’s the whole point. If this were a French company punishing a Romanian caster for potentially offending the Bulgarian government, no one would care (other than mild confusion, probably).
This is one very small battle in a global struggle between the US, where democracy and political speech are supposed to be sacred, and China, where they are supposed to be taboo. Blizzard brilliantly got themselves caught right in the middle.
By the way - I’m not American either, I’m watching this from the sidelines just like you.
1) Strictly because Blizzard did not want unauthorized political statements on its video game stream - perfectly understandable, or
2) Partly because Blizzard feared retaliation from China, and acted more harshly than it normally would.
We can't know for sure from the outside, but context suggests 2 is more likely.
This is where the LGBTQ thing comes in. It's not central to the controversy but it is one small piece of the puzzle. It's an instance, in the past, where Blizzard has calculated it is worth it to take a public stance on a non-gaming related topic.
Now we would not normally expect Blizzard, out of nowhere, to take a public stance on the HK protests. But Blitzchung has forced them to consider the issue internally at least. We now know they have calculated, unlike LGBTQ, that it is not worth it to take any public stance on HK even though it might be the only way to disprove 2) and repair PR damage at home. Their silence doesn't prove anything but it is one more clue.
Also, regarding skeletons:
https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-deal-with-skeletons-being-ba...
It's a silly example, and I don't have a big issue with localized versions of games or movies customized for local norms. But it becomes interesting when US content starts to self-censor at home to avoid losing money in the Chinese market. For years American entertainment has been some of the most effective propaganda globally, now American citizens are indirectly starting to be exposed to Chinese propaganda (by avoiding content or topics) in American entertainment. It's only tangential to the Blizzard situation but I think it's part of why it struck such a nerve.
This is why I find this mess so fascinating - it goes far beyond just the statement on the stream and it ties together so many different threads into a perfect storm for Blizzard.
Context #1: there has been a years-long trend for Western entertainment media (movies, games) to cater to the Chinese market. This ranges from voluntary censorship that seems odd in the West (no skeletons?) to more sensitive topics like sexuality.
Specifically, last year Blizzard disappointed fans by announcing a mobile Diablo game that no one really asked for and that many felt is squarely aimed at the Chinese market.
Context #2: the trade war and Hong Kong protests have brought a lot of attention to China in general. The Hong Kong protests seem to be particularly popular with younger people online.
Context #3: Blizzard's reaction seemed particularly swift and heavy-handed, giving the impression that it was more about not offending China than about discouraging political statements on streams. Blizzard's announcement on Chinese social media supported this impression, and their delayed and lukewarm non-apology statement in the US didn't do much to change that perception.
Further, Blizzard's support for LGBTQ suggests that it's not just about political statements on the stream, but the content of the statements is important. Put another way: would Blizzard's response be the same if the unauthorized statement was pro-LGBTQ rather than pro-HK? There is no way to know for sure, but if the answer is "no" that means Blizzard is indirectly picking sides.
Combine all that and Blizzard put themselves in an impossible situation with no good way forward.
My personal opinion: it probably was about China, it probably was a decision made locally further down the corporate ladder, and US HQ is now stuck with something they can't fix.
And there is still due process - flawed as it might be for governments - which Google does not even need to pretend it does.
What the author is willing to accept is irrelevant - the question is what is China willing to accept.
“What you’re seeing and what you’re reading is not what’s happening” seems lifted straight out of 1984.
A few years ago I agreed with you. Now I’m not so sure.
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-us-canada-44959340/donald-...
Based on my tangential experience with this part of the industry... it absolutely is not.
If the initial idea was way off it might be hard to pivot within reasonably short time/cost.
If the plan is self fund - launch - show traction - get funding, then the "get funding" step probably won't happen so the next step is folding.
Interviewing (prospective) users would actually be a good start. Some of the B2C projects I worked on did not do this until after launch.
B2B - I've worked on projects that did not have a single prospective client lined up before development started (let alone before MVP launch). I think there is a certain optimism entrepreneurs have in the face of rejection - sometimes it takes the form of "no one is interested right now, but we just need to have an MVP to show them and then they will become interested!"
Startup #1: we did not recognize the need to bring in the talent we lacked (graphic design). We had an interesting but ugly product in a space where looks were important - had some traction but not nearly enough.
Startup #2: we did some market research, got some interest from prospective clients, got excited and started building our MVP before fully validating the requirements. Spent a lot of effort on a feature that ended up much more complicated than we expected, that in retrospect did not belong in the MVP. Ran out of money / energy and we gave up (too early, I still think).
...around this point I switched to freelancing and let others take the risks.
Client startup project #1: did not do much/any market validation before starting, and had no clear marketing plan. Built and launched, failed to get traction, folded.
Client startup project #2: did not do much/any market validation before starting, and had no clear marketing plan. Built and launched, failed to get traction, folded.
Client startup project #3: did not do much/any market validation before starting, and had no clear marketing plan. Built and launched, failed to get traction, folded.
I can keep going but it's getting a bit repetitive :)
There is always some resistance to change at first, but over time I’ve only grown more frustrated with it rather than getting used to it, to the point where I’m starting to evaluate alternatives now.
I might have to fire up Dune I again. Unlike Dune II, I suspect it is still quite playable today, even if much less known.
Here's another example:
"Man makes $2500 in a day by buying a lottery ticket".
That is a weird sentence, because buying a winning lottery ticket is a discrete, non-reproducible event - so why include "in a day", unless it is to suggest something to the reader?
Or another one:
"Man makes $2500 in a day by winning competition after preparing for months" - you can see where I'm going with this.
"Man made $2500 doing X once, never to be repeated again" or "Man made $2500 in a year doing X" might be equally true headlines, but a lot less attention grabbing.
The whole point is all that stuff costs much less than any meaningful pay raise.
I've been interviewing a lot of developers lately, and while I'm fairly happy with my process (I've managed to avoid bad hires so far), I always have to wonder if I'm turning down people I shouldn't.
Why? Dumb phones are more or less a commodity - margins are tiny, and volumes are likely small.
If Blackberry lost at the high-end smartphone game, then switching to enterprise security or whatever they're working on makes way more sense than shipping a few hundred thousand units of $100 dumb phones.
A case in favor of the acquisition might go something like this:
1. Microsoft was far, far behind in mobile, with little hope to catch up through internal efforts alone. "Winning" mobile had the promise to unlock a lot of new revenue across Microsoft's other business units, "losing" mobile threatened to restrict Microsoft to the stagnating desktop market.
2. The industry was already consolidating (Google buying Motorola), there was a looming patent war, Nokia was sitting on a ton of patents, and was one of the few (if not the only) good target left for acquisition.
3. CEO of Nokia was ex-Microsoft, so Microsoft likely had a good idea what they were getting. (Conversely, this could mean Nokia CEO knew exactly how to apply lipstick to a pig to get it sold).
In short, limited time window to act, potential for dramatic growth for Microsoft if it works out, relatively small downside if it doesn't (IIRC the cost was something like 10% of Microsoft's cash reserves at the time). I'd take that bet to be honest.
All of this is speculation of course (I have no inside knowledge), and it was clearly not worth it in the end, but I can understand why a decision like this might have been made.