HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alex_stoddard

828 karma · joined September 10, 2008

submissionscomments
alex_stoddard··on Judge sentences Bradley Manning to 35 years
I can provide one example from direct personal experience.

A citizen of a country with a repressive regime was revealed by release of the diplomatic cables to have provided information to the US State Department on the persecution of church members in their country. They have subsequently had to flee the country, being separated for years from their spouse and children who have remained trapped at home.

alex_stoddard··on Glasshole
In Kim Stanley Robinson's 1993 sf novel "Red Mars" a member of the first Mars colonization mission also works for news agencies back on Earth and wears "camera glasses". I forget the exact arc of the subplot but as I recall they resign and refuse to wear the 'glasses' anymore because they were ostracized by the rest of the crew.
alex_stoddard··on Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There Are Serious Problems
A new journal http://f1000research.com/ has a really interesting new take on this: post-publication, transparent peer-review.
alex_stoddard··on Raven Software releases source code for Jedi Academy, Jedi Outcast
Earliest known version of the saying is Latin "Noli equi dentes inspicere donati" from Saint Jerome around 400 CE/AD. Most European languages are going to have a version. I agree the modern English is peculiar, it likely derives from Middle English. Would that be closer to the German?
alex_stoddard··on Scientists claim to crack brain memory code
On the contrary, this is a excellent example of the benefits of open publishing. A very dubious paper is hyped in the press and the actually published work is available to all to be read and critiqued as thoroughly as it deserves. This, in my opinion, is completely independent from issues with the benefits and problems of peer review.
alex_stoddard··on OrmHate
Can you suggest any good references for alternatives to SQL or a more general discussion of path independent data access? My background is such that practically "relational" and "uses SQL" are wholly conflated. I would be very interested to get a broader view. Does datalog fit somewhere in the discussion?
alex_stoddard··on Inadmissible assumptions underlying Internet policy
Is it helpful to make a distinction between managing and funding? I am unconvinced that most people hold that "advertising is socially neutral or good" but rather are left with the question "how else will it be paid for?" I deliberately phrase the question passively - it is easier to ignore the downsides of advertising compared to asking "How will I fund what I value?"

I hesitate to bring up the BBC licence fee because it is still a very consumptive model but as an expat Brit in the USA I often wish I could still pay it for the privilege of accessing the BBC content.

alex_stoddard··on Vint Cerf: Internet Access Is Not a Human Right
But what right is being recognized? I think there is a distinction to be made between the internet as material infrastructure and the internet as a medium of civil discourse. The former is only relevant in as much as totalitarian control of infrastructure can be used as a means of denying the latter - that is civil discourse critical of a regime.

Vint Cerf is arguing for a higher, abstract, freedom of uncensored communication which should not be confused with a civil obligation to provide a certain infrastructure. The idea of "a right to internet access" is dangerous if it is understood too narrowly, focusing on a current means rather than a properly recognized timeless end.

Internet access is a public good, as is the physical existence of material printing presses. But that doesn't oblige a government to build a certain communications infrastructure (although a wise government might well chose to encourage such).

A "higher" right to uncensored communication does oblige a just government to never censor the internet or deny access to it. A right in this sense might be better understood as a restriction on government: "Congress shall make no law ..." rather than "Congress shall ensure the provision of ..."

alex_stoddard··on Arthur C. Clarke Predicts the Future in 1964 … And Kind of Nails It
"... big cities are, if anything, even bigger and denser than they were when Clarke made this prediction."

Big cities are definitely bigger and denser, see the BBC special report on urbanisation: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi/world/06/urbanisation/...

alex_stoddard··on Results of the 2011 State of Clojure survey
Clojure is, in its own terms, an identity not a value(see http://clojure.org/state). At the risk of torturing a joke beyond breaking point maybe it should be "State of @Clojure".
alex_stoddard··on Google Invests $168MM in World's Largest Solar Power Tower Plant
That wikipedia article seems to be citing somewhat conflicting references. Further down it says "The capacity factor for power towers was estimated to be 72.9%" [35] (http://www.nrel.gov/solar/parabolic_trough.html).

A heliostat based design is going to significantly raise the amount of usable insolation. And the mojave desert is probably close to an ideal location for such a plant.

alex_stoddard··on Voyager: Still dancing 17 billion km from Earth
http://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/spacecraft/instruments.html
alex_stoddard··on Clojure: if-let and when-let
Also appears to be available online: http://www.bookshelf.jp/texi/onlisp/onlisp_15.html#SEC99
alex_stoddard··on An Aussie in NY
Again I could be mistaken and would really appreciate correction from someone who knows better by I am much more cynical about the SS trust fund.

As far as I can tell the really scary thing is that that "trust fund" has been largely "invested" in treasury bonds. That is the source of the massive "intragovernmental holdings" portion of the national debt. i.e. the excess income from SS tax has actually been spent on other government needs. http://www.dailyfinance.com/story/retirement/social-security...

alex_stoddard··on New cave found in Vietnam: "A skyscraper could fit"
And yet that majesty and serenity only really exist when we can see it and access it. As others have said it would be bad to turn it into a theme park but simple exploration demands some "invasive" measures.
alex_stoddard··on Tablets
It looks like there is some confusion over whether the correct term is etherialization or ephemeralization.

The wikipedia article on ephemeralization is somewhat more complete and what is linked from the page on Fuller. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ephemeralization

Other internet sources seem to indicate that ephemeralization is the term he used.

alex_stoddard··on University of Glasgow gives away software, patents, consulting
I am not so sure, at least for properly tangible patents.

There are considerable risks and costs to developing a technology from a demonstration in a university department to something marketable.

If companies especially of small to medium size, or their investors, don't have patent protection they may consider the investment not worth the risk of being "beaten to the punch".

A university granting royalty free IP may be the best of both worlds in terms of openness and practicality. IP is free to anyone willing to take the risk but then they get to take a crack at it knowing the idea is protected.

alex_stoddard··on Is It Time to Retire the Football Helmet?
I played rugby all through school in Scotland. Starting at eight years old they had us spend months on tackling drills, and a lot of it was how not to hurt yourself in making a tackle. I wince just about every time I see an American football hit now I live in the U.S., just from the risk the tackler is taking with their body.

However there are other significant differences between (union) rugby and American football which make removing protection dubious. There is no blocking in rugby so only the ball carrier faces being hit and is almost always aware the hit is coming. Also a man on the ground must release hold of the ball so there is no need to go all out to force a fumble.

alex_stoddard··on Is It Time to Retire the Football Helmet?
A very poor analogy. You never deliberately initiate a collision in a car. Also being surrounded by a car body gives you a false sense of invulnerability.
alex_stoddard··on Thanks For Paying Taxes. Here's A Receipt.
Maybe for an independent investor. But how can a t-bill be an investment for the government itself?

I am naively assuming that what backs the value of a t-bill is the US government's ability to accrue future tax revenue to pay it back.

What is it that makes a t-bill owed to Social security an investment rather than a tax deficit when it comes time to cut a social security check?

alex_stoddard··on Eric Fischer maps the top 40 US cities by race, using 2000 census data
I am trying to find out a bit more about the methodology he used. Best I can find so far is page giving a bit of description about Bill Rankin mapping Chicago which Eric says inspired him to do other cities: http://www.radicalcartography.net/index.html?chicagodots

Looks like the dots are at the block level.

alex_stoddard··on Why vertical farms are a crock.
I am genuinely interested in references for available arable land in Africa vs China & India.
alex_stoddard··on My short history of Engine Yard and my Resignation
I would argue the presumption that college is critical to developing higher critical thinking is a damning indictment of pre-college schooling.
alex_stoddard··on Reality: Old Spice sales are down since ad campaign began
You seem to have missed the point of the question "After all, how do you know that sales wouldn't be down 14% without the ads?".

The commercial is not the only thing affecting sales. If there is some other factor driving sales down strongly the sales may still fall overall even if the commercial is successful (i.e. attracted a large number of sales).

alex_stoddard··on The truth about cold water
It has been a long running debate which way viscosity would affect swimming. Higher velocity increases resistance to forward motion but also allows for more propulsive force from the swimmer - which will dominate?

It turns a research group at UMN actually was crazy enough to do the test - it looks like the effects balance for a human swimmer.

http://it.umn.edu/news/inventing/2004_Winter/goingforthegoo....

http://www.cems.umn.edu/research/cussler/pool/

alex_stoddard··on Chess rating system provides the best predictor of World Cup success
A big variance is going to occur in any direct elimination competition (which the world cup is after the group stage).

(This has always bugged me regarding the baseball playoff system. It is a big boost for teams economically but for purity I would prefer to see just a NL and an AL league table).

alex_stoddard··on The Pattern-Seeking Fallacy
Great adage. It is attributed to economist Ronald Coase.

(I also enjoyed seeing it quoted here grammatically correctly, the word data is plural, datum being the singular. Wikipedia has it grammatically incorrect but as Coase never published the phrase who knows if his grammar was as good as his maxim).

alex_stoddard··on World's first plastic antibody works in mice
I think the term antibody here is mostly hype. The plastic nano-particles don't act as antibodies beyond being specific for binding the toxin protein. It is still a cool technology demonstration but "antibody" overstates the case. To quote the article:

"However, Holliger doubts whether they could perform other important functions of natural antibodies, such as priming the body's immune system to fight future infections. Unlike natural antibodies, they are not equipped to communicate with other cells and components of the immune system"

alex_stoddard··on The bitter truth about fructose alarmism
A sucrose molecule is just a glucose and a fructose chemically bound as a compound (so it necessarily has a 50/50 composition). But the fructose is HFCS is free, not bound to glucose. This is an interesting hypothesis for why HFCS might have such an effect compared to sucrose.

From the article:

"Second, as a result of the manufacturing process for high-fructose corn syrup, the fructose molecules in the sweetener are free and unbound, ready for absorption and utilization"

alex_stoddard··on Science fails to face the shortcomings of statistics
Absolutely true, but this is more a criticism of experiment design than statistical methodology.

Also it is bias in uncontrolled variables that is most concerning. (More than uncontrolled noise although that will reduce the power to detect real differences).

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →