HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alexanderchr

585 karma · joined June 7, 2013

alexander.christiansson@gmail.com
submissionscomments
alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
Exactly, and in the US no sales tax is prepaid? So there is nothing to return upon export.

You seem to be saying that having a tax that is refunded gives a different result than not having the tax at all, which sounds like nonsense to me.

alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
The bill looks like it is split because VAT is collected at each transaction, but in the end it nets out for everyone but the end consumer.

So in your case the raw material producer would collect €1 of VAT from you, but this is entirely fictional, because you can immediately claim it back. Only when you sell the goods to an end consumer would VAT that cannot be claimed back be due.

alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
> Even though VAT refunds seem analogous to US sales tax exemptions, the key difference is that VAT refunds remove tax burdens from exports in a way that US sales tax exemptions do not.

I’m sorry, I fail to see the difference. In one case the tax is added during production and then returned when the good is exported, and in the other case it is never added at all. In both cases you end up with zero net VAT/sales tax paid. Where exactly does the difference lie?

alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
Yes, you are indeed repeating yourself. Unfortunately, that does not make what you are saying more right.

VAT countries export VAT free. Sales tax countries export sales tax free.

When you import something to a VAT country, the end consumer has to pay VAT. When you import something to a sales tax country, the end consumer has to pay sales tax.

Maybe we can make some progress if you could explain how these situations are not completely analogous, and what precisely is it that gives VAT countries an unfair advantage?

alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
Not true, see for example

https://comptroller.texas.gov/taxes/publications/94-124.php

alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
VAT returns ensure that exports leave the country VAT free, just like exports from the US leave the country free of sales tax. It is entirely analogous. How do you mean this gives VAT countries an advantage?
alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
Makes me wonder if those also applies to professional chefs and cleaners. And do daycare staff need to declare time spent taking care of their own children?
alexanderchr··on The European VAT Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
You are misunderstanding. Both VAT and sales tax are only paid by the end consumer. The main difference is that VAT is progressively collected at each production step whereas sales tax is only collected during the final transaction to the end consumer.

If a good is exported, no VAT nor sales tax is due in the export country. But because some VAT has already been collected in the earlier production stages, that VAT needs to be returned to the exporter. No sales tax will have been collected at the time a good is exported, hence there is none to return.

In both cases, the end result is that no VAT or sales tax is paid in the export country. Hence the situation is completely the same.

Corporate taxes are orthogonal to this discussion. Both US and EU have them and they apply to corporate profits, independently on if they derive from exports or domestic sales. So no reason to complicate the discussion by bringing them up.

alexanderchr··on The European Vat Is Not a Discriminatory Tax Against US Exports
In practice, when you buy something with VAT reverse charged, you normally declare the VAT to be paid and immediately claim it back on the same declaration. So in the net you pay nothing, but the VAT is of course still there.
alexanderchr··on Why hasn't commercial air travel gotten any faster since the 1960s? (2009)
I think only their definition of ”acceptable ID” is changing. The section for ”Don’t Have Your Acceptable ID?” stays the same.
alexanderchr··on To buy a Tesla Model 3, only to end up in hell
Backup sensor suffices, unfortunately.
alexanderchr··on How to Inspect React Server Component Activity with Next.js and OpenTelemetry
Just got handed a next app that is currently just beyond toy stage. In what way am I about to get burned? Genuinely curious for opinions
alexanderchr··on Spain proposes 100% tax on homes bought by non-EU residents
What make you think it would apply retroactively? Taxes rarely do, I can’t even think of a single example (but would be happy to learn about one).

Putting someone else’s name on the deed is a very bad idea for several reasons. I really can’t imagine anyone doing that, unless it’s a trusted family member or something like that.

alexanderchr··on Meta's memo to employees rolling back DEI programs
Have you never noticed that you were left out of an important conversation, without hearing the conversation itself?
alexanderchr··on React 19
Yeah I'm just going to choose to not take you seriously if you claim that any React version bump is as bad as moving to a completely new framework (which is effectively what angular 1->2 was).
alexanderchr··on React 19
Yeah they deprecated those three methods a long time around (sometime around 16.3 I think) yet they are still around in 19.0 (with an UNSAFE_ prefix).

Regarding class components in general, what is the problem with maintainers choosing to encourage devs to use their new APIs while keeping the old APIs working?

alexanderchr··on React 19
Yeah, as I said above I don't disagree. The ecosystem has lots of issues but React gets all the hate, unfairly in my opinion. It's a pretty well maintained piece of software.
alexanderchr··on React 19
The numbers are high because they jumped directly from 0.14 to 15.0, but the cadence is not particularly high: 18.0 was released early 2022, 17.0 late 2020 and 16.0 late 2017. That’s three major releases in seven years.

React is stable, upgrading it is painless as long as you don’t ignore deprecation warnings. What can be annoying is other (abandoned) dependencies holding you back from upgrading.

alexanderchr··on Dependency management fatigue, or why I ditched React for Go+HTMX+Templ
To be fair the first major release was 15.0. So there has been there major revisions since then, not 17.
alexanderchr··on If not React, then what?
React was never intended to solve browser inconsistencies. Of course it developed hand-in-hand with the tools that solved those (transpilers, polyfills, bundlers), but that was not the main reason it was invented or became popular.

The original motivation was to describe UI as a function of state. It sounds trivial, because it is when server rendering, but once you start sprinkling enough interactivity it can get messy. It's of course not the solution to everything, but above a certain level of complexity I really think you should let someone else handle the problem of syncing state with UI, and JS on its own will never do that for you.

alexanderchr··on A common urban intersection in the Netherlands (2018)
Yeah there is not really space for these eleborate intersections in central Amsterdam. Most are signal controlled or pure spaghetti with trams coming from four directions with almost absolute priority, like this one https://www.google.com/maps/place/52%C2%B021'49.1%22N+4%C2%B...
alexanderchr··on Passport Photos
If they already have your picture the agent will usually know who you are before you have even handed over your passport. The tech has gotten eerily good.
alexanderchr··on Learning not to trust the All-In podcast
Sure - it's an easy mistake to make if you are dealing with data that don't mean anything to you. But anyone with even a tiny bit of experience reading macroeconomic data should be able to tell that something is very off with that number and question it before parrotting it in a podcast.
alexanderchr··on Jaywalking legalized in New York City
From the article ”It also allows for crossing against traffic signals and specifically states that doing so is no longer a violation of the city’s administrative code.”
alexanderchr··on A modest critique of Htmx
I’m not sure what makes you think I’m talking about browsers, because I’m not :)

My point is just that the React ecosystem has become surprisingly stable. Of course if you are going to continuously rewrite things into the current flavour of the month framework, you are going to spend a lot of time doing that, but keeping up with upstream changes in dependencies is not something I have found particularly burdensome.

To take the project I mentioned above as an example, currently it’s running on React 18.x, most dependencies are on the latest major version et.c. Still, much of the code is as it was written 8+ years ago, because the core APIs of React have been stable.

alexanderchr··on We shrunk our Javascript monorepo git size
Google docs certainly haven't changed much the last 5-10 years. I wonder if that's an intentional choice, or if it is because those that built it and understand how it works are long gone to work on other things.
alexanderchr··on A modest critique of Htmx
> It is unavoidable to have a truly gigantic amount of (transitive) dependencies, and its rare you go a month of updates without it breaking your app.

I've maintained a sizeable react app for 8 years, and this has not been my experience at all. Maybe 10 years ago things would break monthly but nowadays things are quite stable, with very reasonable deprecation schedules and upgrade paths. I have lots of code running that I haven't touched in 5+ years and it is not causing any problems even when I'm keeping the main parts of the appliaction up to date with modern practices.

alexanderchr··on What commercial flight route needs the most (min poss.) stops from A to B?
You are looking for the airport pair with the highest number of minimum hops required to get between them.

Guam and Honolulu both have direct flights to Seoul so it’s not a great example.

alexanderchr··on The Engineering of Landfills
So would most of us, but somewhat impractically, Sweden tends to be at its coldest when it’s dark and windless.
alexanderchr··on Ryanair – when every page is a dark pattern
When you book the ticket they make it quite clear that normal sized trolley bags are not included in the cheapest fare. Most LCCs in Europe do something like this nowadays, even some legacies…

Closing online checkin 2 hours before departure and then charging lots for airport checkin is crazy though.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →