HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

amazingman

839 karma · joined October 1, 2010

submissionscomments
amazingman··on Google Can't Seem to Tolerate Diversity
Honestly we don't need this kind of drivel right now, either. The discussion we should have been having this whole time is way more complex than you're making it, and you appear to be oversimplifying on purpose to make a political point. If you are, kindly stop.
amazingman··on Google Can't Seem to Tolerate Diversity
I am fond of the immune system analogy, myself, when it comes to putting environmental (i.e. social) pressure on bad ideas in real time. Like anything else, however, striking the right balance and behaving ethically are vital companions to the application of this pressure. There was no balance here, and the vitriolic mob response was full of unethical behavior.

I’m usually at least somewhat amenable to the “but the bad actors are mostly just the outliers” position, as well. In most cases, that’s true. Again, however, not here. Anyone who read the manifesto and the “response” post by Zunger while practicing even a nominal amount of epistemological integrity would have immediately recognized that Zunger’s post was wildly dishonest, did not deal directly with the content of the post at all, and apparently even thought that fantasizing violence against the manifesto author was an acceptable way to respond. It wasn’t.

I was and remain extremely disappointed in Bay Area tech culture right now. This “manifesto” —a ridiculous and politically expedient moniker— was a crucial opportunity to have a culture-wide teaching moment and we blew it spectacularly. We could have had a nuanced, intelligent discussion about an extremely personal and difficult topic while also demonstrating to Mr. Damont why his application of the very real, widely accepted science he cited was wrong-headed and possibly even oppressive[1]. But no. We didn’t want to acknowledge the facts at all, and our aversion to doing so was so strong that a witch-hunt was executed instead. Meanwhile, we still seem largely oblivious that we made Mr. Damont’s broader point for him. And for the alt-right. They’re having a field day with this, and it’s all the more infuriating because they’re not wrong this time.

[1] e.g. https://contemporarysex.tumblr.com/post/163876071377/doing-a...

amazingman··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
So you still haven't read it, then? And you still think it prudent to label it dismissively?

This is the kind of behavior that woke me up (in my early teens) to the dangers of adopting my values from my religious background/peers. I never thought I'd have to deal with witch hunts for wrongthink in tech.

amazingman··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
>I didn't even read the document in question

Then why are you assuming you know what it said?

amazingman··on On managing outrage in Silicon Valley
Again, I failed to find this claim. The one instance I found of this phrase arises explicitly within a claim about a specific hiring practice being discriminatory:

>Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate

Is this what you're referring to?

amazingman··on On managing outrage in Silicon Valley
I looked for claims in the manifesto that women and/or minorities are inferior, and I failed to find them. Would you mind providing an example of what I seem to have missed?
amazingman··on Apple’s refusal to support Progressive Web Apps is a detriment to the web
Slack for Mac: Want to right-click a word to look it up like nearly every other Mac application? Nope, you don't get to do that. Want to turn off smart quotes or something similar using the standard method of right-clicking the text entry field? Nope.

These things _used_ to work in the Slack app. What happened?

amazingman··on Remotely Compromising Android and iOS via a bug in Broadcom's WI-FI Chipsets
I already updated my phone. Is the iOS update that patches this available over a cell network? If not, as is usually the case, isn't that Not Good?
amazingman··on Remotely Compromising Android and iOS via a bug in Broadcom's WI-FI Chipsets
How, specifically, is iOS "security by obscurity all the way"?
amazingman··on Transmit 5
I don't understand the allergy that so many developers have (in my experience) to subscription software. Software is never finished, golden master style distribution ends up orphaning huge swaths of customers across major updates, and most of the cost of software maintenance is continuous. Continuous income via subscription services goes a long way toward solving these issues.
amazingman··on Bitcoin Is Having a Civil War as It Enters a Critical Month
> for Bloomberg to use a 'civil war' hyperbole signals fear from the establishment. Established capital more specifically.

That may or may not be true, but it's definitely a non sequitur narrative. In this situation, it doesn't matter whether or not "the establishment" is fearful of Bitcoin. All that will ultimately matter is whether or not the "winners" of this debacle end up killing Bitcoin in the process, and that will necessarily play out in terms of markets.

>And really, that is bitcoin's biggest threat.

Only if it survives long enough to truly compete at the level of "established capital".

amazingman··on Did the Intercept bungle the NSA leak?
Blaming the leaker is failing the argument.
amazingman··on Threadless is shutting their iOS app down next week
Only if it's applied to you after building your business model and releasing your product.

If you're not factoring the platform cost into your product pricing, well, that can really fuck with a business.

amazingman··on Kill Google AMP before it kills the web
And how would you characterize Google's decision to ship it in this state, knowing that the behavior was broken in iOS Safari?
amazingman··on Kill Google AMP before it kills the web
Indeed, that's in alignment with what I had seen. It seems obvious at least to me that the actual character of Gruber's statements and @julianmarq's portrayal of those statements do not agree.
amazingman··on Kill Google AMP before it kills the web
>A hypocrite (Gruber, as evidenced in another thread) calls the AMP team hacks who do terrible work

I must have missed this. When did Gruber call the AMP team hacks?

> Turns out their "terrible work" is actually Apple's bug and the AMP team points this out both to Apple and to Gruber.

This is flat out disingenuous, unless you're talking about something other than the originally submitted DF article. There were multiple examples of why Gruber thinks AMP sucks. Are you claiming that all of them are "Apple's bug"?

amazingman··on Instead of containers, give me strong config and deploy primitives
> What if you're in the ground-zero scenario: there is an application but practically no infrastructure? > I'm in that situation now (with a SaaS product), and my approach so far has been: > * set up tests > * set up Docker images > * set up docker-compose for easy local deployments

In my personal opinion, this is all good work to do. One minor nit: You probably want to get out of the habit of thinking about `docker-compose up` as a deployment, and just think of it as a much cleaner, much more "prod-like" local development environment.

> * do lots of work to make the app behave inside Docker

I'm curious about this. What was the overall nature of the work? Things you would have had to figure out in a distributed platform anyway, or container-specific issues?

> * take control of AWS and IAM using CloudFormation, making it easy to set up and roll back permissions

This is amazing, I applaud you for your foresight. I wish we had known about this pattern much earlier.

> * bootstrap KOPS/K8s with CloudFormation

This is where there's going to be another giant time sink, unless you're already pretty familiar with Kubernetes' resources—Deployments, Services, PersistentVolumeClaims, Secrets, etc—how they work together, what they enable, what their limitations are, and so on. Not to mention picking a network overlay plugin, deciding on a service discovery model, and understanding how Kubernetes works. BTW I am currently working on this very knowledge, and at least for me it's been pretty heady stuff at times.

>Future work: >* set up Jenkins CI on top of K8s >* K8s deployments of the app for CI >* staging K8s deployments >* K8s in production

Everything here seems relatively sane, in broad terms. I mainly caution against moving too quickly and also against spending engineering efforts on this if you are also an IC for the applications your teams are writing.

>This has been my first venture in operations and it's been very interesting and rewarding, but at times it gets very intimidating to "be" operations with no senior guidance.

Honestly, you seem to have the right mindset for this and so far you haven't mentioned anything that I see as a huge red flag.

>I enjoy the freedom and responsibility and I feel like I at least have a significantly better grasp on this than anyone else in the company, but I wish I knew of a way to feel like my work was good in an absolute sense, like "definitely good enough".

Welcome to ops! There will never not be an operational issue that either needs to be fixed or is silently waiting to strike at 3AM on Monday morning.

amazingman··on Is Quantum Theory About Reality or What We Know?
"Pre"-determination is a misleading term in this context. The wave function collapsed, and the result was what it was because that's what the result was.

TLDR of my opinions in this space: the cosmos is simultaneously deterministic and probabilistic. There is no free will. Nor are all things predetermined in the sense that most people use the word.

amazingman··on Is Quantum Theory About Reality or What We Know?
> You end up going into hyper-determinism, which is almost all about negating free will.

You seem to think this is a bad thing. Why?

amazingman··on Instead of containers, give me strong config and deploy primitives
What makes containers in general, and Kubernetes specifically, compelling to me are the following:

- the deployment artifact is a "fresh" instance that's "booted" in a fraction of the time—as in a couple of seconds vs a few minutes—than a new EC2 instance would be

- since the deployment artifact is a fresh instance, there is no need to manipulate an existing instance already running your application as part of your deploy process (e.g. scp, ssh, unpack, run commands, restart/reload application)

- if you design your build pipeline appropriately, the actual data needed to be shipped is effectively just a diff from the previous image. In my org, that could mean the difference between shipping a 300MB vehicle to ~300 instances and shipping a 300KB vehicle to almost certainly less than 300 Kubernetes nodes

There are other things as well, but I wanted to stay roughly within the parameters of your examples.

If your organization doesn't already have a continuous integration story, I'd say it probably isn't ready for containers in production. If your cloud footprint isn't costing you let's say >= $50k/mo or so, I might argue that the engineering effort to Kubernetize your things is probably better spent in more direct ways on your product.

If you do have a CI/CD story, and you do have a very wide, expansive, and expensive cloud footprint, containers and Kubernetes are extremely compelling possible solutions.

amazingman··on Apple's Achilles Heel
Throwing money at problems doesn't magically solve them. In fact, much of the time it just gives you more problems.
amazingman··on Ops in the serverless world: monitoring, logging, config management
>That makes for a great conspiracy theory but AWS has never done anything remotely like that.

Just last year they changed the support model to be a percentage of your AWS spend, as opposed to the previous flat rate. They even had the audacity to dress it up as a straight-up price drop.

https://aws.amazon.com/about-aws/whats-new/2016/07/aws-suppo...

Imagine you're an organization spending 100k/mo on AWS and your monthly support line item goes from $50 to $3000. Oh and by the way, the free support tier cannot create technical support requests.

amazingman··on Discussions with Apple regarding license agreement
>But even if the API is the same, it doesn't mean it will have the same performance? Something that was not a problem with previous GPUs could become a bottleneck and vice-versa? And since you need to support both GPUs or else you drop older iPhone support, it might get annoying.

If "in certain cases, the performance profile can be annoyingly different" is the outcome of a tectonic shift in the underlying hardware, it would be a significant and praise-worthy achievement.

amazingman··on Uber is facing the biggest crisis in its history
Good. I'm tired of there being so many positive feedback loops for individuals and companies practicing bad/malicious ethics, and/or failing at even the most basic compassion/egalitarianism.
amazingman··on Uber is facing the biggest crisis in its history
>How quickly history is rewritten. This is the same company that presented at Startup School several years ago to significant applause.

This is completely unrelated to Uber's cultural and ethical problems.

amazingman··on SkipTheDishes Canceled Woman's Job Interview After She Asked About Pay
I could do so, but unfortunately I can no longer read your comment. If you're seriously interested in figuring out what's faulty in your approach, let me know and we can try to reconstruct this discussion.
amazingman··on Author of ‘Sapiens’ on how meditation made him a better historian
Is there something that happens in your life every day that you can anchor a meditation habit to? For example, my personal anchor is the fact that I take public transportation to work every weekday morning. Overlaying my meditation practice onto my daily commute gives me 15-30 minutes of meditation time* 4-5 days a week.

* eyes open or closed, standing or sitting, breath or open or metta or body scanning, all are doable

amazingman··on Author of ‘Sapiens’ on how meditation made him a better historian
I think this phrasing works for certain kinds of people, but turns off other kinds of people, and worse even misleads another category of personality.
amazingman··on SkipTheDishes Canceled Woman's Job Interview After She Asked About Pay
This comment really captures the essence of Poe's Law. I don't want to believe you are serious, and yet ... you really seem to be.
amazingman··on A defense of Christianity helped unlock the secrets of the brain
That Templeton Foundation funding, though.
← PreviousPage 13 of 15Next →