HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

andbberger

1,774 karma · joined January 2, 2014

submissionscomments
andbberger··on Why are U.S. transit projects so costly? This group is on the case
no it's not at all obvious and your take is way off the mark.

the first TGV line opened in 1981... france had quite a bit of infrastructure then, it wasn't some freshly cratered hellhole.

> Major transportation revolution that enables mass transit without infrastructure, think flying cars

no, please god no. steel on steel is a modern, mature and extremely effective technology. the only serious attempt to "innovate" in recent memory, the chuo shinkansen, an ongoing effort by the world's second most competent builder and operator of rail systems has been a massive shitshow. in addition to being far more expensive than conventional HSR, it has an order of magnitude less capacity.

there's a word for this: gadgetbahn. just say no to gadgetbahns

if steel on steel sounds too simple to you and isn't scratching some techy itch for technological complexity it's because you're not looking deep enough. there's an entire journal devoted to studying the dynamics of the wheel-rail system [1]

[1] http://interfacejournal.com/

andbberger··on Why are U.S. transit projects so costly? This group is on the case
the technology is irrelevant, it's purely mismanagement and lack of coordination amongst agencies. modern main line EMUs are perfectly capable of matching BARTs performance.

there are many, many problems with BART's SFO extension (courtesy of quentin kopp), redundancy is not one of them. there was no BART to caltrain connection prior to the SFO extension, and caltrain is a completely unserious transit agency running hour headways.

genuine problems with the transit system in the bay area abound, you should pick one of those to complain about instead of some weird fixation on incompatible gauges

andbberger··on Why are U.S. transit projects so costly? This group is on the case
the case against BART expansion is that the urban core is underserved, as a direct result of BART hoovering up all transit funding and available ROWs

what you're describing is a you problem. SF residents who are well served by transit overwhelming favor transit expansion, it's the residents who are underserved (sunset, outer richmond) who oppose

andbberger··on Low Energy Chest Fridge
or, hear me out, chest fridges
andbberger··on Why mathematicians study knots
always relish a chance to share one of my favorite papers ever

https://www2.math.upenn.edu/~ghrist/preprints/silnikov.pdf

andbberger··on Solarized
> but now I’ve moved on to newer themes

care to share?

andbberger··on Tesla faces U.S. criminal probe over self-driving claims
except that "tax" is paid for with the lives of innocent pedestrians
andbberger··on Tesla faces U.S. criminal probe over self-driving claims
we've fallen a long ways from formal verification in the first fully automated metro (paris line 14) to this clowns shit being allowed on the streets.
andbberger··on Ask HN: Nuclear plants in war zones: A valid reason not to build more
it is in fact objectively the safest base load power source. and economical when financed properly.

but you're right, you can't run paxos on an AP1000

andbberger··on Ask HN: Nuclear plants in war zones: A valid reason not to build more
containment buildings are built to withstand missile strikes and airlines crashing into them. it would take a deliberate effort to breach one.

and since nuclear weapons exist, this is a ridiculous reason to not build nuclear power plants. if russia wanted to do area denial with a radiological weapon they would just set off a dirty bomb.

andbberger··on Even after $100B, self-driving cars are going nowhere
> but if actual fully autonomous cars are the end goal, then the behavior of learning/beta models doesn't really matter

i didn't sign up to be killed by some idiot tech bro testing a class project where they plumbed alexnet into the steering wheel of a 2000kg vehicle and took a couple of steps downhill

the streets are already dangerous enough for pedestrians

andbberger··on Sweden’s incoming cabinet says new nuclear reactors will be built
fuel synthesis
andbberger··on Students break acceleration world record for electric vehicles
i have an ultracentrifuge in lab that can do 100,000gs sustained for hours
andbberger··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy
$2B is the cost to decommission diablo canyon. energy austerity is planning to use less energy when we know for a fact we're going to need more.
andbberger··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy
energy austerity is incompatible with climate change mitigations. eg thermal industrial processes currently powered by fossil fuels need to be moved to grid power.

their proposal was to spend $2B to lose 2GW of carbon free baseline power

everything in my statement is true and based on documents in the public record

andbberger··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy
there's a reference I can't find discussing the financials of hinkley point C, a wildly expensive reactor and concluding that even with the extreme cost overruns, the levelized cost would still be superior to renewables if not for aggressive interest rates by financiers.
andbberger··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy
"environmentalists" in california have succesfully prevented at least 6GW from coming online, and were directly responsible for plans that shutter california's last operating reactor. They lobbied PG&E with a study they paid for that, under the insane assumption that california's energy use would _decrease_ in the future, concluded renewables would be cheaper. Meanwhile CAISO issued increasingly urgent press releases warning of the catastrophic consequences to grid stability were diablo canyon to close. A disaster which was narrowly avoided a few weeks ago by newsom.

don't underestimate the negative influence of "environmentalists"

andbberger··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRIGA
andbberger··on Number of States with High Rates of Adult Obesity More Than Doubles
semaglutide has FDA approval as a weight loss drug and is quite effective
andbberger··on How one of America’s last piano manufacturers stays alive
used to work at an institution with more money than sense. had a model D in a practice room. there's no recovering from that.
andbberger··on How one of America’s last piano manufacturers stays alive
but if you've ever actually played that $100k+ grand you're pretty much spoiled for life
andbberger··on Wildfire smoke is exposing millions of Americans to extreme pollution levels
box fan
andbberger··on How mechanics keep 50-year-old BART trains running: Windows 98, eBay, and scraps
> Now this is reasonably well understood, but it wasn't when BART was designed.

absolute nonsense.

nevermind that the shinkansen opened a decade before BART, the pioneer zephyr hit 112 mph in _1934_. while the dynamics of the wheel-rail system are complex and still the subject of active research, the need for conical wheel profiles was well-known when BART was designed. the choice of cylindrical wheel profiles was purely a symptom of not-invented-here syndrome, and BART being designed by aerospace engineers. the best excuse they could come up with for that decision is, uh, muni did it first.

andbberger··on How mechanics keep 50-year-old BART trains running: Windows 98, eBay, and scraps
like i said, they do what they can with the cards that they were dealt. the initial design of the system was flawed in many ways, one of them being the cylindrical wheel profile
andbberger··on How mechanics keep 50-year-old BART trains running: Windows 98, eBay, and scraps
believe it or not, BART is actually competent and does what they can with the cards they have been dealt. name another US transit agency implementing a takt
andbberger··on High-speed rail board completes environmental clearance in northern California
the ridership will be very high. the capacity will be shit because it's managed by a consultant mafia and criminally incompetent politicians who have gone out of the way to deliver the least train for the highest amount of dollars. the transbay terminal is nigh unusable as a train station [1], and instead of leaving the caltrain right of way as soon as possible (ie south of redwood city across the dumbarton through altamont) it's going to run in mixed traffic for caltrain's entire route, operationally crippling both caltrain and CAHSR and requiring huge investment in unnecessary quad tracking to claw back some of the capacity that would have come for free if altamont was built. all because san jose politicians have an inferiority complex and demand that diridon is served on the mainline, when it isn't even important enough to be served on a branch.

a great idea, ruined by the transit industrial complex

building pacheco instead of altamont is going to go down in history as the greatest failure of all time in bay area transit, surpassing even the impressively cursed BART SFO extension

[1] see richard mlynarik's writing on this

andbberger··on High-speed rail board completes environmental clearance in northern California
no, palmdale is insanity. at 550km SF-LA is already marginal for high speed rail, that plus going out of the way to go through every single town in the central valley on the way down and then doing a huge zig zag to hit palmdale is going to cripple service. and also cost a lot of money. should have just followed I-5
andbberger··on High-speed rail board completes environmental clearance in northern California
the main problem with the alignment is palmdale/pacheco, which are going to cripple the project operationally and add a lot of unnecessary travel time. running through the downtown's is comparatively less of a shitshow (still a giant shitshow though). nobody runs HSR at full speed through downtowns.
andbberger··on How safe are nuclear power plants?
the anti-nuclear folks throw around "long tail" and "black swan" a lot, but if you're turning your nose up when met with the hard data of "operated for 5000 years with no incidents" then we're truly doomed.

> civilians couldn't possibly operate reactors safely inane, but ok simply make the navy operate the power grid

andbberger··on How safe are nuclear power plants?
extremely safe. the US navy has operated old reactor designs with less inherent safety features than modern designs for over 5000 reactor-years with no major incidents. [0]

[0] https://www.mofa.go.jp/region/n-america/us/security/fact0604...

← PreviousPage 8 of 32Next →