890 karma · joined January 17, 2023
> That's probably the nature of the business. But doesn't that mean it more or less evens out on average? I mean, you gotta start somewhere with an appraisal like this.
Not sure, but yes it might even out on average! But that still doesn’t help you answer the question of the market value of one specific item.
One thing I didn’t mention is that there’s another factor at play in this specific case, which is that total the number of items (97) is likely as large or larger than the current number of collectors in existence who would actually buy them at current market prices. I’ve seen this before with other niche/high end collectibles. This means that if you put all of them on the market at once, you’re likely to crash the price of this item and possibly others related to it. So if you want to maintain the current price, you need to trickle the items out into the market slowly.
One thing that’s interesting is that the blog post just admits how many total items were found. This is information that collectors don’t always have in other situations like this, and simply knowing that there are 97 out there may be enough to keep the market price lower than it otherwise could have been. There are other items in this field (Nintendo PlayStation prototype hardware and accessories, first-run pristine sealed copies of classic games like Mario and Zelda, etc) where the total items in existence are thought to be in the single digits.
Answers to your questions below:
> After reading TFA, did you not wonder, just a bit, what the box could be worth?
No, but admittedly I have a lot of experience selling rare collectibles of several different kinds myself. So I knew enough to know that the only remotely accurate way to estimate the value of something like this (rare, not previously known, possible collector base is very small but dedicated) is to put it up for auction. I recognize that not everyone may understand this, though.
If you browse auctions for collectibles, and dig up the rarest of the rare items, you'll notice that even if the auction house provides an "estimate," they are usually wildly off compared to the actual hammer price, despite coming from the presumable experts in that field. Sometimes the estimates are high, sometimes low; it just depends on the whims of the market.
> Would you have taken the time to respond to my post if I hadn't told the source and just said it's "probably" worth x, instead of saying "might, according to"?
Yeah, I quite possibly would have, and I likely would have responded with an answer similar to my answer to the previous question.
Yes, you did, implicitly, by adding additional qualifications to your original assertion: that it’s ok to reply “no” when the person may have written a detailed reply but you just want to answer a question asked in the post (and ignore the rest of the post).
There are many other similar situations where I would likely agree with you that replying “no” is OK and not rude. I hope this clarifies things.
I'm happy that you agree that your assertion, as originally written, is false. I'd encourage you to think more about nuance before making blanket statements in the future.
> If someone writes a detailed reply, replying ‘no’ is rude.
You’re an amazing caricature of an internet commenter.
His statements about this incident are laughable; he claimed in a statement recently that the harassment of the couple was “deliberately done in secret and without my knowledge.” Yet the emails/texts made public as part of the case show him making statements like “take her down… do whatever it takes.”[0]
Absolute scum of the earth. I still have some hope that he’ll be charged criminally, given the renewed publicity this case is getting.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/28/technology/ebay-settles-s...
Are you saying that I've been uncivil in my discussions with you? If so, please do not falsely accuse me of something I didn't do. I've been civil this entire time (and just in case you missed it, I am not @Supermancho, the user who originally replied to your comment). Note that civil/uncivil and blunt/sensitive are two different axes. My posts may have been blunt but they have been civil.
I am loathe to accuse others of logical fallacies, especially since, as I stated previously, this is not a formal debate, but "Your account is also new, so I (and it seems others) don’t think you should be giving advice about how to interact on HN" is the most textbook ad hominem fallacy I've read on the internet in some time.
And FWIW, your comments are full of unsupported accusations of logical fallacies and unsupported assertions like “If someone writes a detailed reply, replying ‘no’ is rude,” so I was replying in kind.
I agree. My point is that I believe the comment you got upset about was in fact not as rude or childish as you’re making it out to be, and perhaps looking at it through that lens would mean you’d come off as less reactionary in the future. Have a good day.
It doesn’t make sense to me why someone would see the numbers in a case like this and decide not to act.
100% disagree, and that’s not what happened here anyway.
> Straw man arguments are incredibly disrespectful, and most people would do better if they had participated in a high school debating class.
HN is not a formal debate, and even if it were, I’m not sure that what the other poster said is a strawman. My unsolicited advice would be to dial back your expectations of the level of discourse you’ll get from others on this site (I had to do the same, a while back!)
What? The person you're replying to didn't use any harsh language or insult you in any way. How thin is your skin?
I would absolutely delete/abandon my Google account before voluntarily giving them my facial data.
No, that’s not what the article/talk said. It said AI _risk_ is inaccessible (as the poster you’re replying to correctly includes in their quote). The point in the original talk is clear if you read it; that everyone coming up with their own pet theories for how superintelligent AI could destroy us as a species is building their theory on speculation on top of speculation.
Note that the talk is from 2016, before transformers and LLMs were invented. Though I would argue that the vast majority of it, including the parts we’re discussing here, are still completely valid.
> PCI-DSS (enforced by banks/payment processors) means the EMV token store on your Android phone must be in an isolated uncompromised location (usually the TEE).
Do you have a citation for this? My understanding is that the whole point of EMV tokenization is that it masks the sensitive cardholder data that would otherwise have to be protected in a PCI compliant way. In other words, I don’t think the data that is stored on your phone is covered by PCI-DSS.
And as another poster already mentioned, I don’t think the EU law you’re citing works the way you claim it does.
Please cite the laws or regulations you’re referring to, because I don’t think there are any.
I guess this statement is correct, but my point is that the most important thing to me is that I have the game on the cartridge.