HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anikan_vader

960 karma · joined January 10, 2020

submissionscomments
anikan_vader··on War Starts
I see. That makes sense.
anikan_vader··on War Starts
Hmm. The guidelines say to avoid unrelated controversy, but possible military conflict in Eastern Europe does seem to be of some relevance to the topic at hand.

After all, the name of the article is "War Starts," and it begins by clearly hinting at the tensions between the US and China. The build-up of military assets on the border of Russia with Ukraine may merely be posturing [1], or it may be preparation for an invasion (which doesn't seem impossible a priori, given that Russia has invaded Ukraine in the past decade). In either case, it seems to me that this sort of international posturing/brinksmanship is very relevant to the article's discussion. A key question the article seemingly poses is whether war will die out, or whether it remains an essential part of society.

[1] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/12/3/how-real-is-the-thr...

anikan_vader··on Obsidian mirror used by Elizabeth I’s court astrologer has Aztec origins
It's slightly misleading to the reader to refer to the Byzantine Empire as the Roman Empire. Sure, the people living there considered themselves Romans, but they also referred to their country as Romania, which also today is not typically used to refer to the Byzantine Empire without giving further context.
anikan_vader··on Why Some Infinities Are Bigger Than Others
> You might say that the infinite set of real numbers between 0 and 1 is ad big as [N]

No, I would say that it is much bigger, since [0, 1] is uncountable.

> there are not infinite frequencies between 0 and 1.

Personally I think time is continuous. It sounds like you believe it is discrete. But such a debate is entirely irrelevant to the set theory.

anikan_vader··on Why Some Infinities Are Bigger Than Others
> If sizes were sensible then…

Sorry, but they simply don’t meet your (non-standard) definition of sensible. Both of the sets you mentioned can be interpreted as the set of even integers. This set is in bijection with itself (trivially), and thus is not considered to be strictly smaller than itself.

anikan_vader··on Why Some Infinities Are Bigger Than Others
The original construction did though, if you look at the writings of Newton/Leibniz. But their work was totally hand-wavey. Cauchy discovered limits in the 1800s, and it wasn’t until the 20th century that the original idea of infinitesimals was formalized. In some sense we have come full circle.

I do think that infinitesimals are a much more intuitive way to understand calculus. It’s a shame it took so long to find positive numbers less than any real.

anikan_vader··on Why Some Infinities Are Bigger Than Others
Many of the comments here are critical of Cantor or his proofs… it’s reminiscent of the reaction that the poor guy received from his contemporaries, who basically shunned him for many years.

It’s a fundamental mathematical fact that there does not exist a bijection between the naturals and the reals. This is what provides genuine distinction between the discrete and the continuous, the countable and the uncountable. It certainly is a mind-blowing fact. But many facts blow the human mind, and it isn’t Cantor’s fault that he was brilliant enough to discover one such.

anikan_vader··on A vegan diet could affect your intelligence (2020)
Funny you mention Ramanujan… It’s thought that his dislike of English food greatly contributed to his poor health, as he couldn’t find any good vegetarian food in England. This culminated in him dying of TB at a very young age.

It’s hard to imagine what math would be like today if he had made it another 40 years.

anikan_vader··on Stockfish 14
It's generally thought that beginners improve most quickly by playing slower chess (e.g. 15+10 or even 30+20). If you're a 1000 and you only play bullet, you may end up cementing some of your bad habits. Whereas with slower time controls, one has time to calculate some deeper lines and really try to understand the position. And if one spends a year getting to 1400 in rapid, one will find that one's gains from slower time controls will quickly bare fruit in the lower time controls (once you learn time management).

Generally speaking, players playing bullet are more interested in having fun and less interested in gaining elo (which of course is totally fine).

anikan_vader··on Stockfish 14
I think reaching 1400 elo after a year of decent study after learning the rules is not too unreasonable. To reach 1400 in a year you would need to be either talented or hard-working. Climbing the elo ladder does get much harder though, as you mentioned. To reach 2000 in two years you would need to be both hard-working and talented. To reach 2850 in a lifetime you have to be hard-working, talented, and a particular Norwegian GM.
anikan_vader··on The 'Fuck You' Pattern
Thanks for this comment. I've been annoyed by the fact that click-baity articles don't load Instagram content in the past, but re-framing the issue as a bullet dodged and time saved is a surprisingly powerful shift of perspective.
anikan_vader··on 80% of orgs that paid the ransom were hit again
Looks like ransomware criminals are going for the subscription model.
anikan_vader··on We’re no longer naming suspects in minor crime stories
> we now will no longer name suspects in brief stories about minor crimes in which there is little chance AP will provide coverage beyond the initial arrest .... We will continue to identify suspects by name in stories on significant crimes, such as murder, that would merit ongoing news coverage. In these cases, naming a suspect may be important for public safety reasons. These guidelines also do not include stories about active searches for fugitives.

The article suggests major crimes typically receive follow up articles, hopefully including whether a suspect was acquitted.

anikan_vader··on The Mandelbrot Monk (1999)
My comment is a joke as well. If you frame Buffon's needle game as a Martingale, playing until you get an answer that agrees with Fibonacci's previous work does not meet the preconditions for the optional stopping theorem. Intuitively, it's equivalent to starting with $1 and making fair bets with infinite credit until you have $2. Sure, it's possible, but it's not a "fair" betting game.

I just thought the quote from the article was unbelievably good -- "choosing his stopping point judiciously" is such a well-done understatement.

anikan_vader··on The Mandelbrot Monk (1999)
>> (I say 'lucky' because Buffon's Method converges extremely badly, and it's well possible that Udo achieved this good result by choosing his stopping point judiciously - perhaps influenced by the 3.1418 quoted by his contemporary, Leonard of Pisa, otherwise known as Fibonacci).

Udo was truly well ahead of his time [1]. Martingale theory wasn't discovered until the 20th century, but Udo finds a way to subtly apply martingales in a way that many of us would struggle to understand even today.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optional_stopping_theorem

anikan_vader··on Why the ransomware crisis suddenly feels so relentless
General purpose computing seems to be the real issue here. Might as well ban it while we've got the chance. If people want to compute something, they can use their brains!

In seriousness though, banning cryptography would appear to have many more serious consequences than the elimination of Bitcoin. Free speech would take a big hit for starters.

If the concern is regarding the waste of electricity, then why not apply a tax on energy equivalent to the associated negative externality? That way everyone who wastes electricity will be charged equivalently, and the government won't have to determine which use cases are "useless." (Personally I think mining gold for jewellery is almost as useless as mining Bitcoin -- both certainly have an aesthetic beauty to them.)

anikan_vader··on Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side
Small arms have a ceiling of around 10,000 ft, so aircraft flying at 5,000 ft would definitely be vulnerable. And 300mph is fairly slow compared to a small arms projectile traveling maybe 1700mph. Even today, fighter jets will often try to stay above 10,000 ft, roughly where small arms and flak peter out.

I could easily imagine WWII rifles having some success damaging helicopters, which were (and compared to modern fighters still are) low and slow.

anikan_vader··on The origin of Covid: Did people or nature open Pandora’s box?
Since this is a common misconception, I'll note that humans didn't evolve from apes or chimpanzees. We share a relatively close common ancestor with them.
anikan_vader··on Why Governments Fail
> What you're saying is that rain causes rain.

It's a little ironic to use that as an example, because rain actually does cause rain. Falling water droplets induce a down draft which causes other water droplets to fall out of the sky as well. This is why water precipitates rather suddenly rather than as a constant gradual drip.

anikan_vader··on Mars has right ingredients for present-day microbial life: study
It becomes much more difficult to determine whether the planet contains indigenous life once you've introduced life from Earth.
anikan_vader··on Bitcoin is not a Battery – it is a Sink
I would think the mining of gold also has massive negative externalities, including carbon output.
anikan_vader··on The Queen has more power over British law than we thought
Not as poor countries, but as poorer countries than the ones the parent comment mentioned. The GDP per capita of Saudi Arabia is around $23k - approximately half of that of Sweden, the Netherlands, or the UK.

Qatar is absurdly rich, but the wealth is inequitably distributed (unusually so). Although the GDP per capita is ~60k, the median household income (and the median per-capita income) are considerably lower than the countries the parent comment mentioned.

anikan_vader··on The Queen has more power over British law than we thought
I would point out that Sweden is unique on that list, as although they do have a monarchy, the king hold no legal/political power, not even in a "symbolic" sense.

A potential explanation for the phenomena you've observed is that it's uncommon for new monarchies to be started in the 21st century, so the countries that still have monarchies are all countries that for the most part have had stable forms of government for many decades if not centuries.

Also there are plenty of poorer countries with monarchies: Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, North Korea, Thailand, Cambodia, Bhutan, Lesotho, Oman, Qatar, etc. (I'll admit it's a bit suspect to label North Korea as a monarchy).

anikan_vader··on Color blindness
>> Maybe I can help you understand how that impairment—and it is an impairment, however mild...

This is actually a slightly controversial claim. While r/g color-blind individuals do have difficulty viewing colors, they seem to have an easier time seeing through camouflage:

A study on the ability to distinguish tones of khaki:

https://www.discovermagazine.com/mind/in-combat-stick-with-t...

There is strong anecdotal evidence that color-blind men specifically recruited during the world wars to see camouflage: (I have personally heard such an anecdote).

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/a32spn/color...

And a short YouTube video on the ability of color-blind monkeys to forage for insects, whereas the monkeys with color-vision are better able to find ripe red fruit:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9NrmH039ffI

I suspect that if we lived in a world where the color-blind were the majority, it would be those with color-vision who wrote about their 'impairment'. Perhaps with a note about how video games often contain almost-impossible tasks to discern camouflage. (In the real world, video games often contain tasks that require the ability to discern colors that I find difficult due to my r/g colorblindness).

anikan_vader··on The Hard Problem of Breakfast
>> The stubborn fact remains that, no matter how deeply we probe into the nature of bacon, eggs, oatmeal, and avocado toast—to say nothing of shakshuka, grits, bear claws, or dim sum—or the interactions between these fundamental building blocks and, say, orange juice or coffee and the morning paper, we simply have no convincing theory to explain how such disparate, seemingly inert components give rise to the phenomenon we subjectively experience as “breakfast.”

That's the best sentence I've read in a long time, despite the fact that the pandemic has me spending too much time surfing HN.

I think the author makes a very solid, implicit, argument regarding the problem of consciousness. The "problem" is hard to pin down. It doesn't seem any more implausible to me that consciousness is an emergent property from our brain bio/chem/physics then that hurricanes and diamonds and stalagmites naturally emerge from their respective environments. Or that massive spaceships emerge from Conway's Game of Life. Of course humans claim that we're special - "My consciousness is more important than a darned stalagmite!" - thinking of ourselves as more important than rocks and hurricanes, as more special, gives us a desire to survive. Our predecessors who genuinely thought they were no more "special" than a stalagmite were ineffective at passing down their genes.

So I claim that the hard problem of consciousness is not such a hard problem, but rather just a case of us humans being obsessed with ourselves.

anikan_vader··on Cardboard theft
They only take the cardboard though - leaving the city waste department the unprofitable job of hauling away the non-cardboard recyclables.
anikan_vader··on The evidence which suggests that Covid-19 is not a naturally evolved virus [pdf]
It is interesting to think about the origins of Covid-19 with Bayesian statistics in mind. We believe that the virus originated in Wuhan, and the two competing "mainstream" theories are whether the virus came from a wet market or a bio lab.

I don't know exactly how many wet markets exist in China, but I would guess that there are thousands spread across China. A wet market is simply a place where fresh produce/meat is sold (think farmer's market). "In Hong Kong, for example, there is a widespread network of wet markets where thousands of locals shop everyday for their meat and vegetables. There is one in almost every district and none of them trade in exotic or wild animals." [1] Of these $\Theta(1000)$ wet markets, probably a few are located in Wuhan.

Notably, there is only one level 4 bio lab in China, and it happens to be located in Wuhan. [2]

You can't conclude anything with absolute certainty doing this kind of probabilistic analysis, but this line of argument swayed me to seriously consider the possibility that the virus originated in the lab.

And, of course, note that we do not have to assume any malicious intentions. It's easy to imagine a virus accidentally escaping the lab, regardless of whether it evolved naturally or with some human intervention to facilitate research. A State Department cable from 2018 wrote that the lab "has a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory.” [3]

[1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/04/14/asia/china-wet-market-coronav...

[2] https://www.livescience.com/china-lab-meets-biosafety-levels...

[3] https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/state-depar...

Footnote: Yes, I know that $\Theta(1000)$ just means "some constant" from a mathematical perspective. But I think the idea is clear, even if the mathematical statement taken at face value conveys no information.

anikan_vader··on The stable marriage problem and modern dating
>> The first graph demonstrates the O(n²) complexity of the algorithm. We can see that as the community grows larger, even by a small amount, the amount of iterations it takes to solve the matching problem grows exponentially.

This statement is contradictory. Probably the author is using "exponentially" to mean quick growth. I suppose this is alright in common parlance, but I find it disturbing when people describe a function as exponential just because it is a superlinear polynomial.

anikan_vader··on How Prosperity Transformed the Falklands
The 2013 Falklands referendum was quite decisive. As the article mentions, only 3 people (0.20%) voted against retaining their status as an overseas territory of Great Britain.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Falkland_Islands_sovereig...

anikan_vader··on Many Covid Patients Have Terrifying Hallucinations and Delirium
It sounds like you no longer have Covid, which is good. I hope you're feeling well.

I worry a little though that comments by people who had coronavirus suffer from survivorship bias - the ones who died rarely log onto HN.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →