HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anindyabd

216 karma · joined December 27, 2014

submissionscomments
anindyabd··on Amazon vs. Jet.com
> Yep, even Ballmer made fun of the new OS

Well Ballmer also made fun of the iPhone when it first came out. Best not attach too much weight to his opinions.

anindyabd··on Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive
> It's still in the best interest of Wikipedia to keep up traffic.

That interest is clearly not "making more money". Can you explicitly explain what those interests are? I may be naive in believing that Wikipedia's goal is "making all the world's information freely available to everyone". But if they have some other ulterior motive for expansion, I would like to know what that is.

anindyabd··on Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive
> It's all the competing products that were never created because the barriers to entry were too high.

Are you claiming that they weren't created because of Wikipedia? If you do have evidence of that, then indeed Wikipedia was being anti-competitive. Otherwise, simply because no competition ever popped up, doesn't mean that it's Wikipedia's fault.

anindyabd··on Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive
I'm not sure how much competition Wikipedia has as a free online encyclopedia. Also, Wikipedia is a non-profit, and doesn't really make more money by having more people use the site. It's strange to claim that Wikipedia is being anti-competitive. Personally, I think Wikipedia Zero is a great program.

The article also says:

> The reason that the Chinese, Russian and Cuban governments fear an open Internet more than anything else is that it allows users to gather and speak to one another. But users of a walled-garden “zero-rated” Internet can’t even click links that go outside the garden.

It's true that users can't go out of the sites they have free access to. But services like Facebook, Twitter and Whatsapp do allow people to "gather and speak to one another". In fact, Twitter and Facebook were prominent in the lead-up to the Arab Spring.

anindyabd··on How the “Down-Vote” Leads to a Vicious Circle of Negative Feedback
The students were conforming. As this paper [1] explains, people -- especially young people -- will often answer incorrectly in order to gain social acceptance:

"...the group answered incorrectly on purpose; it appears that when we are unsure of how to perform a task or how to behave, we may take comfort in agreeing with a large number of other people."

[1] http://www.personalityresearch.org/papers/lumbert.removed

anindyabd··on The Fire phone debacle
You were on the Fire Phone team? Fascinating. Care to elaborate on some of the inaccuracies?
anindyabd··on Technical interviews and the Towers of Hanoi
I'm not sure how citing the article discounts your opinion about interviewing. All it does is say that it's common for people to make comments without reading through entire articles. I'm sure there are plenty of people who do read through articles, but I'm also sure there are plenty of others who don't, and the experiment proves it.
anindyabd··on Technical interviews and the Towers of Hanoi
Thank you. It seems that people read the title of the post, skimmed through half of it, then rushed to post their opinion. Reminds me of an Ars Technica experiment I read about in Jeff Atwood's blog [1]:

"Ars Technica ran a little experiment in 2011. When they posted Guns at home more likely to be used stupidly than in self defense, embedded in the last sentence of the seventh paragraph of the article was this text:

If you have read this far, please mention Bananas in your comment below. We're pretty sure 90% of the respondants to this story won't even read it first.

The first person to do this is on page 3 of the resulting discussion, comment number 93."

[1] http://blog.codinghorror.com/because-reading-is-fundamental-...

anindyabd··on Technical interviews and the Towers of Hanoi
It doesn't seem that the author actually asks candidates to code up the Tower of Hanoi in an interview.

> I usually start with a fairly easy warm-up question — some sort of a toy problem like an operation on lists or trees, often the kind of thing that has a neat recursive solution.

Binary tree problems and some linked list problems often have fairly obvious recursive solutions -- perhaps that's what he's referring to. I doubt anyone would consider the Tower of Hanoi problem "easy". It's definitely an interesting one to investigate in a blog post say, or for one's own enrichment -- it seems like that's what the author is doing.

Of course there's no way of knowing the author's intentions unless he himself clarifies it, but this is what I think.

anindyabd··on Self Hell in Python
Did not know this. Thought self was equivalent to this in Java. Mind = blown.
anindyabd··on Supply and Demand, Labor and Visas
> I do wonder if the West will be criticized in 50 years for its intellectual draining of the third world, not unlike the West's draining of colonies' natural resources 50 or 100 or more years ago

I do not think these are equivalent at all. When the Westerners drained the colonies of natural resources, the ones who were colonized got no benefit from that whatsoever. That was pure exploitation. (It will be very interesting indeed if you argue otherwise.) However, when educated immigrants from under-developed nations are hired in a developed country, the immigrants can 1) have a much better quality of life; 2) send money back home to their families; 3) can use what they learn to go back to their home countries and start businesses there (if they so choose). Thus, the immigrants, and their countries of origin, are being helped. Most people from the third world will tell you the same. But (hopefully) no one is going to say that the Scramble for Africa was a good thing. And I doubt that the Africans thought it was good thing when it was going on.

But going back to the argument you're making -- "people have various ideas floating around in their heads. They remember outsourcing, where American programmers ended up with no power and no money. This didn't do much for the prestige of the career. They think of nerds, obviously, who aren't too great on social norms." Hmm, maybe. But this [1] article argues, with some interesting charts, that interest in CS education is increasing. The Chair in Computer Science & Engineering at the UW argues that "Kids are waking up. Every field is becoming an information field, and if you can program at a level beyond an intro course, it’s a huge value to you." The CS department chair at Harvey Mudd College says "Students feel that computing is socially relevant and even hip."

[1] http://www.geekwire.com/2014/analysis-examining-computer-sci...

anindyabd··on Make Your Own Programming Language
Yes, I came to the same realization. One of the problems I had with the pdf version was that the flags given for compiling the program did not work correctly for my version of GHC.
anindyabd··on Do elite software developers exist?
> this is a weak statement

The author admits as much:

"I might be on thin ice here. I need an example of a profession which does not have the same kind of enormous talent differentials that we see in sports. I could choose something like lawn mowing, but the comparison to software will work better with a field that typically requires college education. I mean no offense to accountants or bookkeepers. And if there actually is a Peyton Manning in the world of "assets=liabilities+capital", I'll be happy to stand corrected."

> All of this doesn't necessarily undermine the entire point of the article, of course - maybe accounting is not a good example, but some other field could be.

Yes, exactly.

anindyabd··on Make Your Own Programming Language
Interesting... I'm on Ubuntu 14.04 too, and Firefox fails for me, but Chrome succeeds.
anindyabd··on Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)
I am not Muslim, but I was born and raised in a Muslim country, and almost all my friends are Muslim. As you note, in the month of Ramadan, Muslims fast from dawn to dusk. Right before dawn, they eat seheri, and after dusk, they eat iftaar. During the month of Ramadan, no one seems to lose any weight, mainly because everyone seems to overcompensate during iftaar. Where I come from iftaar food is much oilier and richer than the food people usually eat, and also people tend to eat much more during iftaar than they would otherwise. My friends all regularly report gaining weight at the end of Ramadan. This is probably a cultural thing in my country of origin, but from what I have heard, things are same in other Muslim countries.

p.s. Do you mean that your evidence is anecdotal as opposed to empirical?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anecdotal_evidence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empirical_evidence

anindyabd··on Make Your Own Programming Language
Great post. Recently I wrote an interpreter for Scheme using Haskell using the guide "Write Yourself a Scheme" [1]. It was great fun, and it seems that it will be fairly straightforward to write a new domain-specific language using Haskell, using the same principles. That said, it was never clear to me how something like that would work in a non-purely-functional language, and so the fact that the OP used Rust is very exciting.

[1] http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Write_Yourself_a_Scheme_in_48_H...

anindyabd··on Supply and Demand, Labor and Visas
>> People choose careers for social reasons as well as for money. Adding a significant fraction of third world immigrants to a career lowers that career's prestige, meaning that talented natives who might have joined the field are less likely to, since they have options.

First of all, as someone born in what you term a "third world" country, I do find your argument morally outrageous, but apparently I'm not allowed to argue morality.

But let's see: "Foreign-born entrepreneurs helped start one-fourth of all new U.S. engineering and technology business established between 1995 and 2005, including Google and eBay. In high-tech Silicon Valley, California, more than one-half of business start-ups over that period involved a foreign-born scientist or engineer; one-fourth included an Indian or Chinese immigrant" [1]. Is being a founder of a multi-billion or multi-million dollar company no longer considered prestigious?

What is prestigious? Being a doctor? "Of the roughly 853,000 health care professionals employed as physicians and surgeons in 2010, more than one-quarter (27 percent) were foreign born. ... Persons born in India, the Philippines, and China accounted for 34 percent of employed foreign-born physicians and surgeons." [2]

[1] http://www.prb.org/Publications/Articles/2011/usforeignborns...

[2] http://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/foreign-born-health-c...

anindyabd··on Supply and Demand, Labor and Visas
>> it's often an uncomfortable fact that we pay taxes to the government who willingly allows companies to outsource or externally hire our jobs

I think your argument is weakened by the fact that H1B holders pay the same taxes as US citizens. It does stand when it comes to outsourcing, though.

>> The effect of this does cap/limit salaries for all involved

Do you have evidence for that claim? Research seems to point otherwise [1][2].

[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/05/06/i...

[2] http://economics.ucdavis.edu/people/gperi/site/papers/peri_s...

anindyabd··on Supply and Demand, Labor and Visas
Great post. You summarily rebut every single argument against immigration made regularly in Hacker News threads on immigration.

You cite a great article: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/05/06/i...

From one of the research papers cited in the article [1]:

"We find that H-1B-driven increases in STEM workers in a city were associated with significant increases in wages paid to both STEM and non-STEM college-educated natives. Non-college educated show no significant wage or employment effect."

[1] http://economics.ucdavis.edu/people/gperi/site/papers/peri_s...

anindyabd··on Supply and Demand, Labor and Visas
America is a country of immigrants, that, throughout its history, has hated new immigrants [1].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nativism_%28politics%29#Nativis...

← PreviousPage 3 of 3