HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

archgrove

2,454 karma · joined March 31, 2009

Adam Wright (http://www.archgrove.co.uk)
submissionscomments
archgrove··on Retina.js: Retina graphics for your website
As high DPI displays become more common, it seems like the time has come for more advanced file formats (or just using the more advanced features of existing formats). For example, PNG already has an interlacing mode that progressively adds detail to the image (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam7_algorithm). It could easily be co-opted such that a normal image contains 6 layers of detail, with an additional "retina extension" image that high DPI browsers grab to refine the quality. This avoids the waste of downloading a low DPI image, then throwing it away to replace it with high DPI.

Even more interesting is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JPEG_2000, which has "truncatable" bitstreams. You can stop getting data at any point, and depending on the encoding choices, you'll just lose fidelity in colour, resolution etc. Encoders can reorder the bitstream to deliver whatever is most useful for the image first. Browsers could then just stop when "enough" has been downloaded to satisfy the demands of the device; high DPI devices would just continue to grab more of the bitstream. It's really useful for devices on low bandwidth links, as you start getting visual results with very little data.

JPEG 2000 hasn't been widely implemented outside of specialised devices, mostly because it's computationally heavy compared to JPEG, and the patent situation is unclear. Although this does mean that it could be implemented in a targeted way, designed to solve these problems (the spec for the entire format is huge). Moreover, one of the patent holders is, IIRC, Apple.

archgrove··on Between a rock and a hard place – our decision to abandon the Mac App Store
Wait, what? Who claimed that signed applications won't come to OS X? Windows has had them for years. People said that OS X would never be limited to App Store purchases only and that's still the case. In fact, lots of people expected the default to be "App Store curated only, with an off switch. Instead, we got the comparatively surprising "Signed only with no checks on what's signed, with easy to use off switch" (i.e. app by app exemptions even for full lockdown mode).

Apple's money comes from selling a cohesive experience. That, on iOS, that's been helped by a "walled garden" approach does not indicate that the same approach will make OS X better. Some people have been crying wolf since iOS 1.0 about the demise of the open Mac platform. They were wrong about Snow Leopard, they were wrong about Lion, and they're wrong about Mountain Lion. It's beginning to sound like a certain boy and a certain wolf.

archgrove··on Between a rock and a hard place – our decision to abandon the Mac App Store
Or, far more accurately, "You can get these all apps from the developers directly. We don't support them on the Mac App Store at this time, and we don't discuss future product directions".
archgrove··on Mountain Lion: John Gruber's personal briefing
Only if one accepts the slippery slope fallacy that they'll eventually remove the "No unsigned code" option. The odds of this happening are, in my estimation, extremely low - it would make Mac software development basically impossible, and the use of Mac in educational establishments (with a lot of custom software) very hard. Heck, Apple are still sponsoring the OpenJDK port for OS X, which I doubt they'd be doing if they planned to entirely eliminate unsigned code from the platform.

The "No unsigned code default" has been coming for a while in mainstream computing, thanks to most users ability to blindly click anything attached to a random e-mail or downloaded from their favourite wallpaper site. Out of the options ("App Store Only" or some other signature system), I think they chose the right one. As long as the opt out is there, not only do I not have a problem with this, I'd suggest it's a positive step forward. The only change I'd want is to remove or massively reduce the cost of getting a developer certificate.

archgrove··on Valve: Piracy Is More About Convenience Than Price
How about this alternative: "Until this insanity stops, I don't purchase their product, and instead buy indy games or games from publishers that support my policies". Voting with your wallet will encourage these policies in developers.

If you don't adopt this approach, you look more like the normal "entitled, rationalising pirate", a story I see regularly going something like:

1) I want games that aren't just fancy graphics! Give me gameplay, and I'll pay! 2) Oh, so there are these games now. Well, now I want easy access! Give me downloads, and I'll pay! 3) Hold on, I can download? Well, now they're too expensive! Make them cheaper and I'll pay! 4) So iOS games are about $4.99 for a high quality title? Well, that's still to expensive! Make them cheaper, and I'll pay! 5) Oooo, $0.99. Well, that was published by EA, sooo - use a publisher that doesn't use DRM on any title, ever, even back in time and I'll pay! n + 1) Insert new demand here, then I'll pay!

The result here being that, actually, said person didn't actually want any of these things. They just want excuses to rationalise away their taking the work of a group of people that they evidently do want (otherwise, why bother pirating it) without any kind of remuneration so they can do those crazy greedy things like feeding their family and raising their kids.

archgrove··on Android Overtakes Apple with 44% Worldwide Share of Mobile App Downloads
If true, this has been a while coming, but I'm taking the source with a grain of salt. It makes no mention of methodology for data gathering. Apple don't, in general, share their data. Nor do Google. It doesn't mention of what a "Mobile App download" is. Are iPod Touch and iPad included in the stats (which make more > 50% of iOS installations)? In app purchase data? What about Amazon App Store?

Of course, the only way to get the even skimpy details is to cough up a price (that isn't even available until you log in). The rest of their site seems to indicate that "Mobile" means phone handsets, which are not the only source of installs for iOS and Android.

Edit: I had a small rant about "analysts", the plague of our industry, but decided it didn't add anything (I hope I'm preaching to the converted).

archgrove··on Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody
Right click, "Icon and Text". Done.

Click "Attach a document" rather than "Photo Browser" - it's literally 2 icons to the left, visible by default, and uses the universal "Paperclip" motif. Done. The other is even called "Photo Browser" rather than "Attach Photo" because, you know, it uses the system wide photo browser (i.e. iPhoto).

Mac Power User? Power troll, perhaps. Sigh.

archgrove··on dom3d: Rendering 3D with CSS3
So the "throw it at the wall and see what sticks" strategy is the new "standards" vogue? As I tried to say, isn't this what we got up in arms against Microsoft for? Its a minor improvement as people tend to at least write up the new "standards", but the problem with IE wasn't that their additions were unreplicable - it was that they were not replicated.

Also, your example is a false dichotomy. I can be concerned about the "standardisation" process usage I'm seeing without demanding a glacial and purely theoretic process.

archgrove··on dom3d: Rendering 3D with CSS3
If only. It also uses chunks of WebGL (ArrayBuffer etc). Removing these dependencies makes it mostly work in Safari (the 404 example, for example, renders fine when using fallbacks to the standard JavaScript arrays).

My big problem with the state of web programming at the moment is that people are generating these examples which, despite being based on "standards", are virtually worthless to anyone much outside of nightly build users. Some of these "standards" (i.e. WebSockets) are so ill-concived that they get rolled into one browser release, before being rolled out of the next when found to be flawed. These things are not "standards" - they're browser makers playing around with ideas. Similarly, this example (whilst cool) is not CSS3 - it's CSS 3 plus selection of other supra-bleeding edge stuff that wasn't needed to demonstrate the issue.

Whilst I generally applaud using cutting edge technologies, the entire point of the web (to me) is interoperability. As we seem to move more and more towards "This works fine if you're in Chrome, others may vary", I'm claiming that this is not the web any more than "You need Java 1.X.Y" or "Viewed best in IE 6" was. It's a custom delivery platform for content that happens to piggy-back on HTML, draped in a guise respectability via rushed out and hacked together concepts that many will never implement (as by the time someone's finally got around to doing it, they're onto v(X + 3) of the "standard").

Sigh, I sound about 30 years older than I am. However, having been involved in real standardisation where we strive to create something stable and reusable, these types of examples make HTML 5 look a melange of disparate and barely interoperable concepts. This is not intended as specific slight to the creator of this stuff - it's a cool and admitted hack. It's more a mild rant on the state of web development and the disconect between the technorati and people who actually try and create; not even things for the IE6 users - things for users of browsers less than than 6 months old (and possibly more than 6 months into the future of the browser it currently works on).

archgrove··on dom3d: Rendering 3D with CSS3
FYI, this demo silently fails on the current Safari version in OS X 10.6.7. On Chrome and Firefox it renders a mesh in the top right hand corner of the page. Whilst I acknowledge the authors says "Various browsers will have glitches with this hack, as it's really a severe and gross hack", I'm getting rather tired of these examples that are, at best, domain specific browser kludges rather than general interesting cases of HTML/JS usage.

By these standards, the much derided IE specific features were a great thing for the web. Welcome to HTML 5, where "Best viewed in XXX" is the old new rage. I thought we'd left this behind in 2005?

archgrove··on What App Developers Want: Letters To Steve Jobs And Larry Page
Not that I like TL;DRs, but I can give you a quote which will save you time:

"On the whole I like Android even more than iOS. [Mention of Java, and less polished dev tool chain]. I can live with those quirks, though, and otherwise it’s mostly a developer’s dream: powerful, flexible and open(ish)."

So, as you might expect, the Apple "requests" are "Please be more like Android". Having done a lot of iOS dev, Garbage Collection isn't even in my top 10 wants (his claim that it adding it would halve iOS dev times is bunkum). An Android like multitasking model is also not in my top 10 (widgets + the ability to do preemptive content downloads would cover ever use case I've ever wanted, and basically every other need I've seen). His repeated use of "fanboy" also gives the article -20 karma: Apple, and Apple developers never said multitasking is evil, just that unrestricted desktop (i.e power unlimited device) multitasking was a poor fit - a position that's still true.

For iOS, I do want: Better notification system. The ability to silently respond to pushes (i.e. Update my databases without showing any UI). Better system wide connectivity notifications. Better inter-app connectivity (something like Androids intents, I guess). Cocoa data bindings. A sync service API (desktop to iOS or web service to iOS).

I do not want iOS to become OS X, or a desktop OS. That is not helpful to me, or my users. A phone is not a tiny laptop, and frankly, nor is a tablet.

archgrove··on "Maybe it’s time to move on from the Commodore 64 software"
It rather doesn't matter. The X11 that Apple ships is effectively http://xquartz.macosforge.org/, so if they drop it (which I doubt), it's one short download away.
archgrove··on Xcode now costs US$ 4.99
I believe Apple's version of binutils is cctools, which is at http://www.opensource.apple.com/source/cctools/cctools-782/ . It includes ld and as. As you mention, the standard GNU source for binutils won't build, as it doesn't understand Mach-O, but MacPorts would seem to be free to use cctools for linking/assembling.

If this turns into a "real issue", such that XCode 3 was rescinded and XCode 4 remained paid only - as opposed to some stupid accounting problem which might mean it would be bundled free with Lion, with XC3 hanging around for (Snow) Leopard - then I suspect we'll soon see MacPorts or their kin come up with a downloadable toolchain based on this existing Apple open source work that would allow them to continue virtually unchanged.

archgrove··on VeriFone Takes The Gloves Off, Accuses Square Of Serious Security Hole
I guess they didn't notice that all smart phones have this ability as standard, and call it "Camera". One quick snap, and boom - I've stored your CC number. No need for fancy hardware!
archgrove··on Live from Apple's iPad 2 event
For live update, you might prefer Ars Technica's AJAX driven liveblog : http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2011/03/ipad-2-event-liveb...
archgrove··on Apple responds: we want a cut of Amazon, Sony e-book sales
Good point - with a bit of re-parsing, I can see this ready. Still, it's a stupid decision:

"Dear Amazon, Sony, Spotify etc,

Please make your Applications less useful to our users. We're sure they'll still love our devices when your apps are crippled compared to the Android version!.

Thanks, Apple".

Unless there's back-door negotiations going on, they must know no big name will ever go for this (indeed, any size name at all that sells content and can process payments for less than 30% of the price). I'm a pretty strong Apple defender (see my comment history!), but this is just user hostile, through and through - in any reading.

archgrove··on Apple responds: we want a cut of Amazon, Sony e-book sales
I can make no possible reading of the App Store guidelines that results in this policy - it's clearly new. I guess if Google can't make the Android App Store attractive to developers, Apple sure can. Surely, this cannot be "official" policy, or if it is, it can't be one that lasts more than a couple of weeks. It's not one of those geek-annoying App restrictions that 99% of the iOS target market wouldn't care about even if they knew it - this one affects every end user, and you can bet will be widely publicised by every non-Apple tablet maker.

Realistically, three things can happen to people with App under this policy. Take, e.g., Kindle.

1) They withdraw the Kindle application 2) The add In-App purchasing 3) The add In-App purchasing, but with a 30% price hike

Frankly, 2 is very unlikely - 30% is probably their entire profit margin on the sale. 3 is possible, but makes every Android tablet look vastly better to new purchasers ("The same apps from iOS, but with content 30% cheaper!). 1 is also quite possible - they just EOL it and say "For future Amazon purchases, please grab a Kindle or Android tablet), thus showing a huge chunk of Apples target market a big banner for the competition.

I suppose there's another alternative: that this becomes one of the annoying "Not for big player" rules that they just have a sub-rosa agreement with B & N/Amazon to never enforce. That in itself is pretty underhand.

Overall, my favoured interpretation is this is a re-run of the "Nothing but Objective C Apps in the Store" debacle. Masses of bad press, a dent in developer confidence, and a rescinded policy within a month or two. Apple really are their own worst enemy with this stuff.

archgrove··on Supposed change in Apple policy has e-book fans worried about their apps
Insufficient, and certainly one sided information is all that's so far available. I'm taking it with a large grain of salt but if true, it's a monstrously stupid move. Unlike most Apple App "restrictions", even the most tech-unsavvy iOS owner will notice this one. You can bet it'd feature in upcoming ads for other tablets.

For these reasons, I'm suspicious. It's either just wrong, a silent test of the waters that will come to nothing, or a policy that won't last until Spring (much like the "Only Obj-C" attempt). If it's anything else, I worry for the future of the Apple App platform.

archgrove··on Why Android will win the tablet wars
Indeed. This is exactly why they're unlikely go as "open" as, e.g. Windows with OS X, or Android with iOS. Once they start damaging the "premium" experience they're selling, they lose a key differentiator and will, eventually, slide off into nothing.
archgrove··on Why Android will win the tablet wars
Oh, I'm sure they'd love to hold 100% of every market. The point of my comment is they don't need to do this to be considered a big "winner". Unlike e.g. Dell which only makes money on huge amounts of shipments due to low margins, Apple can ship comparatively few units and make large profits.

They must know that their dominance in the smartphone area was always a temporary thing - they were never going to persuade the entire world to buy one of two iPhone models available at any time. Their lack of any attempt to create an entire iPhone ecosystem to cater for the spread of users (i.e. the "free, just about adequate phone" that dominates most peoples choice) shows this. This is entirely separate to their iPod strategy, which scales from those with only a handful of dollars (the shuffle), all the way up to the "Smartphone without a radio" iPod Touch. In the phone space, they seem to have chosen the same battle as their computing space - the high end, high margin, "people willing to pay for the experience" market share which contains vast profits. If no serious competitor had appeared (as, bizarrely, happened in the MP3 space), then they might have eventually released an iPhone Nano etc. But given that other players are now in that space, they've just surrendered it, rather than fight a battle they can't win. Were they to open up iOS or release a spate of iPhones covering enough of the usage/price spectrum to compete, they'd lose a large amount of the Apple "experience", damage their premium brand, and risk losing the entire game.

Their battle is to maintain enough market share to ensure development for iOS, and to ensure that Android devices end up being (mostly) the choice for mass market, race to the bottom, cheap at any cost devices. If Android starts to seriously infringe on their premium space, then they should be worried and can be considered to be losing. Until then, as far as I can see, they're winning the battle they're fighting.

archgrove··on Why Android will win the tablet wars
Define "win", please. I'm quite sure Android will eventually dominate in terms of market share, much like Windows does to OS X. However, if you look in terms of customer satisfaction and profits generated in the markets they compete in, Apple tend to be so far in front, they subsume the rest of the competition put together.

I'd wager that every company out there would love to "lose" the way Apple is/will.

archgrove··on Apple Reports First Quarter Results
From the conference call highlights at macrumors.com:

"Music products: 19.45 million iPods. iPod touch sales grew 27% year-over-year. Now over 50% of iPod sales."

Over 50% of 19.45 million must be around 10 million.

archgrove··on Apple Reports First Quarter Results
One interesting figure is: 16.24 million iPhones versus 7.33 million iPads + around 10 million iPod Touches. That's around 17 million non-iPhone iOS devices versus around 16 million iPhones, and illustrates why increasing Android sales don't seem to dent iOS sales/usage statistics as much as the phone OS debate might suggest. Most iOS devices being sold are, in fact, not iPhones!
archgrove··on Steve Jobs To Take ‘Medical Leave Of Absence’, Stays On As CEO
Unless, of course, the people he's hired follow the same hiring practices, and train them in the same way. As the saying goes, A players hire A players (and in this case, one hopes A* players hire A players, then make them into A* s). I don't buy that companies are built around one person, and then revert to the mean - it's more about setting up a culture and following it. Does Google do well because Sergey is wandering the halls and jetting around the world shouting out inspiration? Or is it the culture that was created, covering it's many offices, that delivers the goods? If that is allowed to die, then yes - the company stagnates. But there's no reason to believe that the executive team can't keep it alive if they're as good as they should be.

That's not to say that Steve's absence isn't a big deal - it's just not a "Dump your stock, it's all over" level deal.

archgrove··on Steve Jobs To Take ‘Medical Leave Of Absence’, Stays On As CEO
Don't forget that the majority of those things would have been setup on his watch - the Mac Pro, for example, came out only a few weeks after he left on leave. Also, I don't recall iOS 3 being particularly "ugly" - all in all, I remember it as a big step up in usability and reliability over iOS 2.

App rejections were silly pretty much right up until September of last year when they released more guidance - well over a year after he came back from medical leave.

Were he to quit tomorrow and never talk to an Apple employee again, we wouldn't see the damage done/advantage gained until at least 6 months, if not 12+. Product design and direction is set a long way before release, and though he might veto early products, I doubt anything hardware related within a 3/6 month window of release has ever been killed (nothing would have been allowed to get that far).

archgrove··on Steve Jobs To Take ‘Medical Leave Of Absence’, Stays On As CEO
Steve Jobs will eventually leave Apple. This is a fact. The question becomes "When he does leave, will Apple be damaged by it"? The press will undoubtedly claim its demise (as they have been for decades), and 10 years ago I think this might have been true - the corporate ethics that have made Apple successful were not in place. Now, with the executive team he's built and trained, I suspect his presence is vastly less important. The design team with Ives, operation team with Cook, etc. know what's making things work. He's been "absent" a lot in the last few years, yet it's been the strongest period for the company - clearly, something works when he's not at his desk.

The damage will be in PR. He's an almost unrivalled corporate showman, and few companies are as associated with their CEO as Apple. Whoever gives keynotes in the future would be wise to develop their own style rather than copy his. There may also be collateral damage in ruthlessness and vision - we constantly hear how he drives new products, and kills off "failures" early. However, the more I read recent interviews with anonymous Apple employees, the more I see he seems to have reformed the company in his image. It's impossible to gauge how much actual presence he's had over the last few years, and it seems quite likely the press have over-egged his effect. As long as his successor is not a radical corporate reformer, and is willing for a few years to be seen as an "Heir to Jobs", it seems likely to me things will roll on quite successfully.

I suspect Jobs will "retire" either this or next year. When they replace him, if they don't promote from within, then any CEO should: absolutely not engage in a massive expansion/race to the bottom; introduce change slowly rather than play with Apple like a new toy and; rely on the corporate team that's been built until they deeply understand what's working and what's not.

In many ways, Job's eventual departure (hopefully based on choice, rather than necessity) could be good for Apple. I firmly believe a little of his control freak nature could be sanded off the company to their advantage. They should drop the "Control for control's sake" direction they've been taking recently, and stay focused on the core corporate ethics that have bought them success - a high degree of perfectionism, technical risk taking, user focused design through everything, and a great marketing team. It won't be exactly the Apple of today, but given some of the…hostile decisions over the last 3 years, it might actually be an improvement.

archgrove··on IPhone v Android debate 'not important'
You've not considered any possible piercings ;)
archgrove··on Ask HN: What software do you use for your startup?
I agree, and I very much doubt they'd ever do something like this. My argument is just one of prudence - if you wouldn't leave your business plans and private data lying around in a competitors house, why would you risk even the 10^-7% chance that doing so with Google would damage you when running your own e-mail server (or, if you don't want the maintenance, encrypting e-mail through G-mail) is relatively trivial?

Looking back in time and given what's happened, would Google the Startup have been wise hosting their e-mail on Hotmail?

archgrove··on Ask HN: What software do you use for your startup?
Perhaps not, but it's more than enough to find out strategy, preempt potential competitive advantage, reconstruct development patterns, cherry pick staff members, and gain a huge upper hand in takeover negotiations (potentially driving down acquisition price based on unfortunate private data).

Would you write down everything you're doing, and post it to a competitor? Because if you work in an area Google's interested in then that's what you're doing, modulo a privacy policy you'll never find out they've violated (and has happened at least once before - http://articles.latimes.com/2010/sep/16/business/la-fi-googl...).

archgrove··on Ask HN: What software do you use for your startup?
Wow. All these startups, making potentially game changing software, all sending their private data and communications around via an uncontrollable 3rd party e-mail system managed by the admins of an company known for its aggressive consumption of startups.

Call me paranoid, but though Google's public motto may be "Do no evil" they're like every company and are after profit at the end of the day. Are you encrypting your e-mails? Is running your own mail server that hard, or does Google Apps offer that much benefit? Would you host your e-mail with Microsoft? Oracle? What really make's Google that different?

I am genuinely curious - Google seems to be treated by large portions of the startup community as if it were some charitable organisation, working for the benefit of man-kind in an open and free manner. Sure, they've done great things - Search, G-Mail, Android and loads of open source work. But they're still a company beholden to their shareholders, selling adverts based on mass data collection. At the end of the day, in my eyes, they're not fundamentally different from Apple, Microsoft or any other hugely funded mega-corp. I wouldn't store my secret sauces with those companies and their ever evolving market plans and TOSs. Am I overly cautious?

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →