HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arjie

10,978 karma · joined January 30, 2013

Roshan George

roshan@arjie.com

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/roshangeorge; my proof: https://keybase.io/roshangeorge/sigs/6EQyu7jh7oa-KjkTAQBoJJ61fE2RBiZ546abgZc6zsM ]

Blog: https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog

I use https://overmod.org to manage highlight/block

submissionscomments
arjie··on Job loss and cortisone mania
As in I need to either purchase a home or receive a state-allocated one? I don't think it will stop water from being piped but my experience is that state-allocations have inferior quality and result in a parallel black market where the allocators take the surplus. Overall, I am quite happy with being able to pay a landlord for a service because I find navigating black markets hard.
arjie··on Who Cares Whether Academics Use AI to Write?
> But given that we collectively believe it is a good thing our taxes go to academics, I fail to see how removing that would be a good idea

For the same reason that we collectively believed wooden sail ships were a good thing to have and now almost none of our ships are made of wood or powered by sail.

Things changed. The top mathematical results of the last decade did not come from academia. It came from machine intelligence labs. In the last month.

arjie··on Blaise Pascal invented fixed route public transport (2024)
It isn’t that X goes down if you do Y that matters but whether the utility from X going down is commensurate with the cost of doing Y. There is a cost of reducing traffic which I am happy to pay and a cost of reducing traffic which I am not going to pay. So just telling me something will reduce traffic will not induce me to pay. You also need to handle the other side of the sheet.
arjie··on Blaise Pascal invented fixed route public transport (2024)
This argument has to face up to the fact that all of the best systems have high farebox recovery and all the American systems have low recovery except for NY (which is still lower than the good ones). Essentially, if it’s so great to have low farebox recovery why does the Tube, HK MTR, and Taipei MRT have high farebox recovery?

Theorycrafting is all well and good but if you claim that some metric X (farebox recovery) is negatively correlated with some outcome Y (frequent good transit) then you do have to explain why all the good outcome Ys actually have high X. Reality has to meet the theory.

arjie··on Blaise Pascal invented fixed route public transport (2024)
It’s not an American idea. It’s a pretty normal concept that public transit is not a charitable program and must yield benefit commensurate with spend. The view that public transit should have low farebox recovery is predominantly American and the opposite of the majority of successful public transit programs everywhere in the world.

If what you said was true then it would be the inverse - operating costs would be mostly paid out of government subsidies in the areas with most ridership. But in fact, it is (and predictably so) the case that good transit systems have high farebox recovery - the HK MTR, Taipei MRT, and the Tube are those I’m familiar with and they’re all much nicer and more frequent and have high farebox recovery.

In fact, I find the whole thing confusing. Do people actually believe public transit is meant to be some kind of giveaway to a small number of riders? It’s clear from looking worldwide that where it is useful riders pay high enough fares because it is so useful.

I can understand some sort of bootstrap capital investment (or one-off interventions like for COVID-19) but the idea that operating costs should be predominantly covered from general taxation doesn’t really hold up if you look at which places are effective at this.

arjie··on Who Cares Whether Academics Use AI to Write?
The voters have decided that grant funding should be cut. I am glad for that. Indeed, I agree. The voters decide all and I’m happy that they will find that plumbers need not pay for the self-actualization of mathematicians.
arjie··on Blaise Pascal invented fixed route public transport (2024)
You need some combination of high-ridership and low-personnel-cost. You can get that in most of Europe and Asia, but incomes in North America are quite high and labour capture is high too. Most jurisdictions cannot afford the drivers necessary at high frequency because there isn’t enough density for it.

Skytrain bypasses this by not having drivers and perhaps as buses become AVs we could add many more of them here in the Bay Area with much higher frequency.

arjie··on Who Cares Whether Academics Use AI to Write?
Well, the problem I have with this is that I'm paying academics. At the point where they're a proxy between my money as allocated by the government and an AI provider, I no longer wish to pay them. I am capable of paying the AI provider myself. I'm not upset about the output being what it is. That's fine. I just don't care so much about the being wishing to be paid to intermediate me and the machine I am fully capable of prompting without the aid of a professional hand-holder.

> That is why the model needs far more instruction to write than to code. I deploy it for its strengths and am constantly on alert for its weaknesses, which is what makes it a tool and not a ghostwriter.

Everyone is convinced of these grand truths - that they alone have contributed something of value to the machine work. But that value is extractable by almost anyone who interrogates the machine.

Like everyone else alive, I too believe this is monocausal. This is all a problem caused primarily by a distinction between the one who sees the supposed benefit of the academic (therefore induced to pay) and the one allocating resources to the academic. It is time we remove this intermediary who does this. Should you desire to read analytical writing by a professional machine speaker there is no doubt he will gladly take your money to talk to the AI for you. Let there be a market for academia - the mathematicians can be paid for the beauty they wish to glimpse between coffees and the philosophers can prompt their machines for money.

For the rest of us, release us from this compulsory taxation so that the plumber - should he so desire - can ask Fable 5.1 "Why should I pay academics to use AI to write?" and receive a satisfactory answer without needing to pay out of his taxes a compulsory fee for an answer to a question he may never desire to ask.

arjie··on Oregon Police Are Charging a Local News Outlet $2.5M for Records About One Cop
Haha, Bay Area agencies are truly amazing. When a driver (negligently, in my opinion, considering that she lied about what happened) derailed a muni train, I asked for what actions were taken as a result and the only thing that was provided was that a hearing was performed.

I don’t mind waiting but I think I’d prefer paying for faster results. BART took half a year to respond to how they calculate on-time rating but they did finally give me the answer. It had some interesting properties (canceling trains leads to higher on-time performance if trains are late) and I wrote it up here: https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/BART_On-Time_Metric

arjie··on AI use leads UC Berkeley math professor to see 'no point' in grading homework
What is the point of grading homework for college students anyway? The objective of exams is to determine mastery of the subject. It makes sense to have a grade act as a certificate of mastery.

Grading homework is a measure of conscientiousness and perhaps a pedagogical tool to force learning but by college perhaps we should have moved out of the need for the latter.

One can simply measure conscientiousness through attendance grade and mastery through exam grade and then we have two grades the universities can certify students for that are no longer dimension reduced into a single number.

arjie··on Dolly Parton's Imagination Library
My daughter receives books through this program and I was curious how it was sustained at a $2.5/book wholesale cost.

Interestingly, the coordinating body that selects books, facilitates distribution, and negotiates wholesale pricing is the Dolly Parton Imagination Library, but per-book funding is actually entirely through local charities and so on. This means that where charities are unable to act as partners, children will not receive books, but it also means that the program can operate by growing and shrinking as local support (including from state and local government grants) comes online and goes offline while keeping the overhead for local partners low.

Dolly Parton came up with the initial local structure for her region in Tennessee and David Dotson of Dollywood scaled the operation using this decentralized model. Very impressive structure that makes this sustainable.

Here’s the interview where he talks about it: https://www.endbookdeserts.com/dolly-parton-imagination-libr...

arjie··on America has lost 200k of jobs in media, film and the arts. How much is AI?
Based on the rise of short form video content, this seems like amateurs are just outcompeting professionals for eyeballs.
arjie··on Air Purifiers as White Noise Machines
Transcription error there, you’re right, from Airgradient.
arjie··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
You can do whatever you want with what you own. And I want this restricted device. So you go be the market for yours and I’ll be the market for mine. I don’t understand what the problem is here. There are no shortage of phones on the market - many of them entirely rootable. It seems like you’re upset I want to buy an EV because you want to put gas in your car. Just go buy the gas car. No one is stopping you here (well except the EU I suppose haha).
arjie··on Job loss and cortisone mania
We can have piped potable water simultaneously with landlords that raise rent less frequently than 6 months. I live in SF and have both, which shows it’s not physically impossible.
arjie··on Air Purifiers as White Noise Machines
What are people's target AQIs? I have indoor monitors in our high-rise building in SF and live 100 m from the freeway and we have:

    PM2.5: 2.6 µg/m³
    PM10: 0.5 µg/m³
    VOC index: ~97
    CO₂: ~505 ppm
That's the baseline. When we're cooking, like now, it's:

    PM2.5: 10.8 µg/m³ (AQI ~46)
    PM10: 17.5 µg/m³
    VOC index: 122
    CO₂: 572 ppm
None of those seem particularly concerning. We have a gas range, and 15 min past the end of cooking everything is fine. I must imagine that most people don't live right next to the freeway so they probably have even better air quality except during wildfire season.
arjie··on Gemma-4-26B-A4B with 39-69% less thinking at same accuracy
It feels clear to me that smaller models are moving parameter-level thinking into inference time. i.e. they use more tokens to perform computation because they don't perform it in the model itself. There's some conservation of difficulty for tasks and you either do the computation in the model or you do it in the looped iterations of the model.

This is why the massive tok/s you see on many small MoE never manifest as worthwhile outcomes. Sonnet 5.5 can be faster on tasks than DeepSeek 4 Flash Vision simply because it gets there faster.

arjie··on Job loss and cortisone mania
I actually think that piped potable water at home is incompatible with a hunter-gatherer society. The infrastructure required to maintain this requires civilization with a stable non-mobile population centre.
arjie··on Kimi K3.1 Pro and K3.1 Pro Highspeed
If the Chinese want it, they have it. BGI does an enormous amount of sequencing. My own genome is entirely public (or was, and will be again when/if Personal Genome Project comes back) so you can watch and see if it harms me.
arjie··on Kimi K3.1 Pro and K3.1 Pro Highspeed
Fascinating that we’re converging on AI safety and alignment in time across jurisdictions. The cybersecurity approach taken here is interesting because should the model be opened it’s still not dealignable because it just doesn’t know enough.

The slow warming of the water is a good approach. I’ve been using abliteration.ai’s cybersecurity models to pentest my own software and it produces much more usable defensive results. Opus 5.5 can fix everything but the guardrails trigger too easily.

The Fable ban affair was a nightmare for defensive cybersecurity. As far as I’m concerned we’re already in the world of Void Star and Cloudbreaker is here.

arjie··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
True, it’s a critical difference but perhaps shows what it’s like to be a minority participant in a shared enterprise.
arjie··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
I want a device I can give the elderly in my family that they cannot be easily induced into doing insecure things on. If there were an unlockable iPhone and a locked iPhone I want to give them the latter. It’s not enough for me to tell them not to scroll to General and click seven times on About to activate developer mode. I would prefer to just give them a device that can’t do that.

My own parents are still relatively young and my in-laws are sceptical enough of other people that it’s currently safe but it won’t be so forever.

arjie··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
Same guys who found the PHP.

Edit: hahaha you guys are funny. “The php hack” is what I meant!

arjie··on Job loss and cortisone mania
This life is still available in the least civilized parts of the world. And unfortunately it comes with all the other problems of that time: your children will die, other tribes will occasionally kill you, and you need to stay on the move to escape enemies as well as seek food.

For my part, there is a huge price I’m willing to pay to be able to drink water out of my tap. I didn’t have this always and I really value it.

arjie··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
Yeah that’s what it will look like if you have this kind of structure. No one is selling a perpetual license for a movie for anything less than top dollar. The proposed plan inevitably tends to this outcome.
arjie··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
NFLX is publicly owned with only one share class and it only does video streaming so it does that.

Anyone motivated to do this for a smaller group would rather just run a private tracker. The overheads are enormous when you’re not negotiating in bulk.

arjie··on Swedish government offices to ban ChatGPT and Claude
Loads of companies over a small size do this. They have an internal wrapper around the services and you just can’t go direct. Then they can meet local data retention and ensure the vendor is going through their ZDR path. You can even put safeguards inside your wrapper. It’s completely normal.
arjie··on A farewell to Arc browser
One could argue that what I really want is a tiling window manager with workspaces to swap around in, but really I want to keep my contexts separate and a command palette to swap between. e.g. https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/File:Screenshot_-_Convoke_be...

Obviously more interesting if I'd thought to screenshot prior to going to bed but you can have multiple tabs in a 'stream' and they can be terminal or web tabs. The relay (which I'm pentesting in the screenshot) transports the AI chats to a paired phone where they're adapted to have a common UI across the Claude / Codex / Oh My Pi that I use. You can obviously see the Arc lineage to the ideas here.

arjie··on Ask HN: If the models are so good, why doesn't OpenAI just start 100 companies?
Well, they've certainly moved up the application stack already. There is no doubt that they'll keep doing that while deploying services through deploy.co and ode.com.

Some 15 years ago people would say "Why would crypto miners even sell you hardware? Why not just keep it for themselves and mine the crypto?" and then it turned out that after you paid for a device you'd often get it slightly used with the cryptocurrency going to the hardware miner. The models are unbelievably good.

arjie··on The same AI request emits 8.5 times more CO2 in Texas than in Sweden
Site is HTTP 503. It does make sense that an nginx 503 would cost much less to serve.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →