HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on Psychologists Shielded U.S. Torture Program, Report Finds
> It would be nice to know why they're so intransigent about it.

I think people have very strong convictions (maybe even inborn in us) about how the society should be organized, that contradict empirical evidence.

One example is emphasis on punishment, rather than on consensus or other form of persuasion. There is just another article on HN about how psychotherapy may be a better tool for young criminals than putting them into jail. Torture falls into a similar category, IMHO.

From evolutionary standpoint, this is perhaps understandable. Punishment is good enough strategy and evolution probably didn't have time/resources to come up with something better, such as more complicated systems of therapy and intelligence gathering and whatnot. Huge societies of today can however afford such advances and don't have to rely on these crude methods.

asgard1024··on The Long-Term Future of Artificial Intelligence [video]
I had a chuckle when Stuart Russell mentioned that one idea of how to "contain an AI" would be to make it strongly prefer "no action" to everything else. I think humans already have that trait, we just call it "laziness". So, I am not sure to make AI to prefer no action is all that useful.
asgard1024··on The Long-Term Future of Artificial Intelligence [video]
I agree, and you could go further with that argument. Most humans already live in the universe where there are powerful entities whose goals are not aligned with what they would consider ethical.

In the talk, Stuart Russell mentions funny examples like make paperclips as a goal, but if we consider the goal of maximizing monetary profit, we can easily see that it is already being done without regard to other values, such as human life, preservation of resources or biodiversity, or even any relation to production of anything useful (consider all the "financial innovations" that allow inflation of Ponzi schemes and bubbles).

And some people even bow to that goal..

asgard1024··on Germans Forget Postwar History Lesson on Debt Relief in Greece Crisis
> Europe is already helping hundreds of thousands of Greeks by offering them good jobs in other countries

Yeah, brilliant idea, let's move 10 million people out of the Greece, because moving investments into the Greece is so difficult these days..

asgard1024··on To Be Continuous
This claim about ETL not needed in the future sounds dubious. I work on a large application that is all about ETL. If we wanted to use this new method instead, I am not sure how it would deal with the following:

- State in the data. In many sources we have, processing depends on some internal state, which must be kept along the time. For example some process has started and we will know when it ended, and we must keep its state so we could correctly process the ending event (to match it up). I am not clear how this will work with continuous views. I would say this is actually the major reason of what makes ETL processing non-trivial.

- Processing failure. Let's say something goes wrong and the data processing fails (or it can actually be even planned downtime). How do we know where to restart, to avoid processing data twice or miss data? Does the continuous stream take care of this metadata? And how does it deal with the state information per above? If you do data processing in batches, there is an obvious point of restart. Again, I think the extra complexity that "continuous" approach says is unnecessary relates to the fact that you want to be able to checkpoint the state of processing for various reasons.

asgard1024··on Physical Intuition, Not Mathematics (2011)
I am no expert, but it seems to me that intuition is what the machine learning algorithm develops as a model.

The model itself cannot explain how it arrived to its conclusions; that could be done with the training data which are long gone.

Similarly to machine learning, humans can develop intuition about things by learning and training in the subject (that's why I believe rote learning is actually quite useful).

Just like with intuition, it crucially depends on (and varies with) the input data (experience) and there can be different models, but successful models (those that give good results on training data) are quite similar in appearance.

Of course, the big disadvantage of intuition is that you cannot explain it to others, even if it works. They have to believe that you are expert and made correct judgements (that you have correct model). That's why science (and especially mathematics) has tried to formalize the process, so that people could double check the reasoning and wouldn't have to rely on expert authority. That's why the two processes are called differently, I think.

asgard1024··on Why feminists are so annoying
> No rational actor wants equal rights, only increased rights.

I can't agree with that. There are many smart people out there who are interested in other people's rights, for example, Noam Chomsky.

Now you could say that he does the cause he does just because he is interested in self-promotion. But how does that work then? If other Americans agreed with his views, then it would mean they are too interested in other people's rights and so they are not rational. If they wouldn't agree, it wouldn't be a very efficient way to self-promote.

You could also say that Noam Chomsky is not rational. Then, many people like him are not, and your comment is not relevant to the real world.

In fact, the blog post author herself is probably not interested in getting more rights for herself. If she was, she would just be a feminist, and wouldn't be annoyed at them. You have very simplistic view of other humans. (It could actually be stated in terms of game theory, which is itself simplistic, that you believe everybody is a hawk.)

asgard1024··on Education in Minecraft
I wasn't making a comparison, I was just suggesting that people play flight simulators for fun which have enormous amount of complexity and detail. And I think the tedium can be alleviated (for example, the game could just track "effort" and require you to pay for it in food or medicines etc.) without compromising realism. It's not a problem because interesting part of realism comes from interaction, and complexity, and learning about it, not from the tedium.
asgard1024··on Education in Minecraft
I know Factorio, although I haven't played it very much. My thoughts exactly - it teaches kind of engineering, but the realism is lacking.

What I would like to see from the game is less focus on how are things laid out in space (that's a different puzzle) and more focus on what crafting materials to use and what their different tradeoffs are (physical and chemical properties, cost, processing complexity).

asgard1024··on Education in Minecraft
Actually, I think the blocky world is good enough for the application I described. Getting geometry and kinematics right is not so important for the game. I think something like Minecraft with a rudimentary thermodynamics system, statics/continuum mechanics for blocks, and mixture system for fluids (including air) would be doable. I think what would be more important is to change the crafting system from specific items to be more based on what materials you use (kinda like Tinker's construct does it).

I even think the game doesn't have to be 3D - Terraria like world would be good fit too, if done right (probably allow several different layers at each tile - like background wall, plumbing and ambient layer for fluids).

asgard1024··on Education in Minecraft
That was a disappointment. I think education in Minecraft (-like game) is a great idea, but what they presented lacks imagination what it could be. They mention mathematics and history and problem solving, and I think for that, it is exactly the wrong medium, and let me explain why.

I really like to play with mods, especially the tech ones, I enjoy building automated processing systems and factories and bootstrap myself in the style of "The Mysterious Island". Here's a game I really wish would exist (and I think it will, eventually):

Realistic sandbox game based around technology and history of technology. De-emphasize the kinematics, and emphasize other types of physics such as statics, thermodynamics and electromagnetism, and also chemistry, material engineering, biology and geology.

Imagine a game where you could learn about almost any industrial process (including historical ones), ranging from agriculture through chemical engineering to computer-controlled 3D printing.

I wouldn't mind complexity too much. There are people who enjoy flight simulators which are quite complex. It should capture the spirit of common industrial processes, within the first order of approximation.

I think this would be a great game to understand how the modern world is built, on what basis, what it takes for economy to operate. So it would also be very educational in the economics aspect (actually changing focus from money to production would help people to understand economics a lot better).

Current Minecraft is not there though, even with mods. The basic physical laws are not preserved, and often realism is eschewed. It's quite hard to make such a game, because people who know the industrial processes well enough are rare, but I really wish it would exist. And I think it would be highly educational, but mostly in fields of natural sciences and technology.

asgard1024··on A game whose source code fits in one tweet
Reminds me when my father showed me "number guessing" game on TI-57 calculator. It had 50 instructions (button presses) of memory. It's interesting that the size wasn't that a big deal then. :-)
asgard1024··on Should I Work for Free?
You should work for free as in freedom, not for free as in beer.
asgard1024··on Why do ten Chicken McNuggets cost the same as twenty?
There is a contradiction, you just chose not to see it. Homo economicus assumes that the utility of the person is reflected in price optimization. If you define utility in a circular way, based on the behavior of real humans, then it will become completely meaningless concept.
asgard1024··on What's Really Warming the World?
That's pretty much it. If someone wants to avoid said taxes, they should build a solar power plant.

It is certainly better than subsidies (because it lets market, not government, to decide on the best solution), although of course for politicians it's easier to create subsidies than taxes.

As for what to do with the collected money, I would suggest lowering other taxes, or just give it to everybody in the same amount.

asgard1024··on What's Really Warming the World?
More correct would be to say, at the time (2006), Lomborg was a denier. He only recently turned around (although first by saying that climate change is not a serious problem), which is to his credit. Still in retrospect, people shouldn't have listened to him, he was wrong.
asgard1024··on What's Really Warming the World?
> Animals turn chemical energy into heat, but plants turn energy from light into chemical energy.

They do, but the heat is byproduct of that conversion. From the 2nd law of thermodynamics there will always be some residual heat (probably quite a lot, efficiency is given by the ratio of absolute temperatures between the heater and cooler, which is quite low in plants). And don't forget that plants also burn sugars to feed their processes. As I said, you can see for yourself in early spring that plants do indeed generate more heat than surrounding dead objects, such as rocks.

In any case, forests have, I believe, lower albedo than deforested landscape, so deforestation should cool the planet if anything. And one of the big arguments for global warming is that we observe more warming during the night, during the winter, towards poles and stratospheric cooling, which is again indicative that the problem is outgoing radiation being recaptured rather than more incoming radiation being reflected.

asgard1024··on What's Really Warming the World?
> Last time I checked, it's way cooler in a forest than standing in a parking lot.

Perhaps you forgot to account for the shade and humidity? (As an aside, I believe forests generate heat, just like any biological system. The best it can be seen during spring, the snow patches around plants will melt sooner.)

asgard1024··on The Curious Phenomenon of Stochastic Resonance
The phenomenon is interesting, although the connection to UI is a little vague. Still, I think author has a good point.

Take bevels for instance. They may be considered a visual "noise", and in flat design they are frowned upon, but how do I know where I can click (push a button)?

Similar thing for window shadows, they help to recognize the window boundary.

asgard1024··on Downsides of Being Clever
What if the causation is the opposite? What if the people who ruminate more or are more anxious about conversations become smarter and more eloquent, by taking more time analyzing those things?
asgard1024··on 19 days to build a 57-storey tower
I appreciate the attitude, but other than that, he is a real control freak. It fascinates me that people on the right often praise entrepreneurs as champions of personal freedom while they are often being very authoritative against their employees.
asgard1024··on “Thank You” in Hindi and English Mean Very Different Things
This reminds of what David Graeber said about debt: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZIINXhGDcs

He mentions that historically, cultures tried to keep people indebted to each other, and not settle the debt as is in fashion now. The reason was to keep people doing favors to each other.

asgard1024··on Computer Scientists Are Astir After Baidu Team Is Barred from A.I. Competition
> Even when attempting to do research on this, the political backlash could destroy any scientist's career. No official evidence will ever be collected because of this.

This is really offtopic, but I think you're wrong. There are two ways to do such research - the proper one and the racist one.

The proper one is to link specific genes to specific behavior. This presumes that you screen individuals in the study for those genes. Then you are not being racist, because existence of those genes is rarely 100% coinciding with culture or skin color. Research like that is quite common, if there is a reason to think there is indeed a link (for example there is a genetic study of above average intelligence in Ashkenazy Jews, they were extremely homogenous group and yet they don't all share the genes that has been shown to have the link).

The racist way is to match skin color or culture to behavior. This is scientifically useless, because you don't show any actual genetic link, and it only serves for stirring racial hate (you could pick any indirect attribute from many, like eye color or facial hair, so why pick skin color?). Such studies are rightfully being rejected by real scientists.

asgard1024··on Why do people waste so much time at work?
I think the "bullshitness" of a job is determined primarily by the person that does the job, if she judges it to be socially useful or not (under assumption that being the person doing the job, that is an expert, she is the most qualified to judge its utility).

So, someone creating a "phoney" friendly atmosphere is a bullshit job, even if it increases the bar attendance, while a genuine entertainer (like a magician) is not a bullshit job. Even though both may be payed the same, both may have to smile when they don't really have reason to, and both may lie (in case of magician). The dividing line is that phoney friendly atmosphere is not socially useful thing (as judged by both by people who do it and common sense), while a magic trick may be.

> You can't ignore pleasure and satisfaction of other people when considering a job is useful or not.

Extreme example would be a drug dealer - his job is not useful yet he provides pleasure and satisfaction (and also gets it himself, in making money). It's not necessarily a bullshit job, because drug dealer does not have to care about it being socially useful.

asgard1024··on Why do people waste so much time at work?
> Why do I even have to answer that question.

There is an excellent Chomsky snippet that agrees with you and gives more context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWZltIXZ2WY

asgard1024··on Yagni
The extreme examples are just to illustrate the tradeoff.

Some architectural decisions have to be made in advance, because they are hard to take back. In your example, size of the property (if any) on which your house is standing is such a decision. Good luck building a pool in a 4-bedroom apartment.

(Interestingly, you said, "like pretty much everyone does" - isn't that actually a sounder advice than YAGNI?)

asgard1024··on Yagni
> How hard is it to understand the notion of "building what you need, and not what you don't"?

Very hard, because it's in fact a tradeoff. Let's say you are building a house. Will you have wife and kids in the future? YAGNI says you can always expand your house once you have kids. But do people really build houses that way?

To take more extreme example, first thing you expect from housing is a protection from elements. So according to YAGNI, you should build the roof first, and see if it's good enough for you (and you don't bother, for instance, that you can only stand in the middle of the room). Again, no one really does that with real houses.

The whole art of engineering is to pick the reasonable tradeoffs, and this includes hedging against the risk of future expansion. That's why simple pronouncements as YAGNI are not of much help.

asgard1024··on House Votes to End N.S.A.’s Bulk Phone Data Collection
> I would rather have private companies holding the records than government for reasons that should be obvious

They are certainly not obvious to me. With government, there is a democratic oversight, you can (at least in theory) vote to have these records destroyed or stop collecting them and so on.

However, when private company does it, what kind of control do you have over them? Especially if they are 3rd party.

asgard1024··on Online shaming: The return of mob morality [video]
> As far as I'm concerned, Adria Richards did pretty much zero wrong.

I reread this account: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5398681 and I disagree. It doesn't deserve a death threat, no one does, but it is a sort of reckless, misguided behavior (at least, I think the guy would appreciate an upfront honesty).

It reminds me of another lady, Anita Sarkeesian, who also received death threats. I sympathize with her, but I also watched her videos about Tropes vs. Women in Video Games and I can't escape the conclusion that she is little crazy. I really wonder how she managed to get such a collection of brutality, I have seen lot of things in porn myself, but this was just sickening. I really have to ask, why does she play these games?

It seems to me that behavior these ladies engage in is just an equivalent of climbing a mountain, or similar adrenaline-filled activity. Apparently, there are people out there who misread this as some sort of sexual signal or they are mentally ill or whatever, so whether these women realize it or not, it is very risky.

Just like if you fear heights, don't climb the mountains! It doesn't alleviate the risk of falling entirely, but significantly. Maybe a better comparison would be Charlie Hebdo attack. Sure, no one deserves to get killed over a joke, but still, poking fun at something that millions of people take extremely seriously is a risky proposition.

I think free speech is important. There shouldn't be a social norm that bans (or causes shaming of) feminism, nor there should there be a social norm that bans anti-feminism. Both views can be extreme, but they are still legitimate.

asgard1024··on Can Algorithms Form Price-Fixing Cartels?
> And it is possible for someone to enter the market using a different algorithm.

By the way, I think this often happens in the real world, where some person irrationally (from the economist's point of view) provides a valuable, yet underpriced (with respect to the real demand curve) service, because he is just being misinformed, idealistic or is interested in success for its own sake, not for the sake of money. Or it's just that the product is new and actual demand curve hasn't been established yet.

Absurdly, this is then hailed as an example of market efficiency, while there is nothing rational in such behavior from the game theory perspective (unless you consider much wider frame of how human morality evolved etc.).

← PreviousPage 11 of 22Next →