HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on Economics Can’t Answer Why Inequality Sometimes Declines
This is so true and I wish economists and other social scientists would research that more.

In general, we know many factors that decrease general level of trust (sometimes called "social capital") in the society. This is sometimes tied to inequality. But we don't know many reliable factors of how to actually increase trust, yet we intuitively understand that it is very closely related to well-being.

Heck, we don't even know how to reliably increase trust between individuals, for example in failing relationship. I think this is one of the biggest open problems in psychology and sociology.

asgard1024··on 'Escape Rooms' Challenge Players To Solve Puzzles To Get Out
In Czech Republic, we have many puzzle hunts per year. The "escape room" fad also came here, it seems similar; I haven't tried it, but it seems really overpriced.

Typical price for 20-hour puzzle hunt is about $3-5 per person. Escape room costs 1 hour for about $30. The room is probably much better done, but I would bet you would have more fun puzzle solving in a more traditional puzzle hunt.

asgard1024··on Confessions of a Right-Wing Liberal (1968)
I know everything is in the Bible, but I am interested in your beliefs! This is why I find libertarianism to be close to theology; when I start asking really difficult questions, you will refer me to some book, which turns out to be hopelessly circular (as in the case of property, which is defined in terms of non-coercion, which is also defined in terms of property).

It seems that you want to have world black and white, and so you invent new categories to deal with difficult moral dilemmas. But personal ethics is not something coming from a book, it's a result of intuitively answering these questions (by "feel") and sometimes accepting that there is no good answer, or that answer depends on different circumstances.

> look to the current system in the US (or most other Western countries) for answers to your questions .. it's a reasonable approximation to my ethic

Yes and no - that's my original problem. When I ask you a specific moral question, the answer indeed seems quite reasonable. But then you're (very definitely) against things like taxation or state (which are integral part of the Western culture). I would like to understand where this contradiction comes from.

Now that I think about it, the whole business of how libertarianism treats "property" seems kinda morally repulsive to me for a different reason. It seems to me that libertarians treat property as a kind of extension to human body, in a sense that someone losing half of their 1000-acre property forever is a comparable (or worse) crime to a homeless losing a toe to the cold. What I miss here, I think, is a certain "normal" sense of proportion (or even admission that there is a proportion).

Anyway, I appreciate the discussion, especially given you were the only person willing to respond to my original post.

asgard1024··on Confessions of a Right-Wing Liberal (1968)
OK, sounds reasonable.

So, if you don't mind - what about lying? What if somebody borrows something from you and they refuse to return it? How is initiating coercion against them bad?

What if someone falsely claims they own the piece of land that you think no one owns? So you give it up, and find out later the claim was false. Again, what about initiating coercion against them?

Frankly, I don't think the condemnation of "initiation of coercion" is a good ethics. Specifically, people can be intentionally misled and that by itself is actually a good reason to initiate coercion.

Also, cannot every coercion be interpreted as a retaliation for something? Does the fact that someone initiated a coercion at some point give the other party right to infinite (sanctioned by you) retaliation? Conversely, cannot anyone facing retaliation defend himself by saying (in attempt to get help) that this is initiation?

I simply think you cannot absolutely reject initiating coercion and accept retaliatory coercion.. You need to have some measure of what is fair, which will fall in the gray area. And this notion of fairness will eventually extend to things like taxes and so on.

asgard1024··on NASA Study: Mass Gains of Antarctic Ice Sheet Greater Than Losses
I am not sure I follow - this is what AGW theory is saying, that humans cause global warming by running civilization on carbon fuels.

I just wanted to address possibly wrong belief of GP that waste heat can be the primary cause of GW.

asgard1024··on Confessions of a Right-Wing Liberal (1968)
> I'm not sure you're actually asking me a question. You seem to already know my answer, and indeed, you know precisely the rebuttal you'd like to say to my answer.

> The only thing I know for sure is that my ethical self condemns coercion. How this plays out in reality isn't at all clear to me.

Jesus! Even you don't know the answer to the question, why on Earth do you think we already know the answer?

> Great, then that is inconsistent with my ethical beliefs.

Nice. But in practice - would you be willing to coerce a mafia member if a friend asked you to? Or if your child would be threatened by gang? Fear from self-preservation aside (we all have it) - does your ethical belief allow for retaliation with coercion on behalf of some other party?

asgard1024··on Confessions of a Right-Wing Liberal (1968)
It seems to me, since basic income didn't appear spontaneously so far, it probably requires coercive force to appear, so you're against it.

Anyway, thanks for the reply to my original comment. Like user "solipsism" though, I found your views somewhat contradictory. But it seems very apparent that your answer to my question "would you help me if I am in trouble?" is "NO, if it would mean to coerce the other party to leave you alone". Which is a rather weak ethic in my book.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> But did that persist, or was it just "switching cost"?

Opinion differs, but I think thanks to EU we were forced to accept a reasonable legal prevention to most egregious acts of economic crime. If that didn't happen, we would look.. probably kinda like Russia. In a sense it persisted because the people who got rich during the "gold rush" (usually through botched "privatization" of former state enterprises, but also through various scams) of course didn't lost their wealth.

Anyway, the point is, free market left to its own devices is not very pretty; I have seen that as a teenager. Arguably, Americans should remember that lesson from late 19th century.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> considering the economics literature says that the strength and consistency of the law is a crucial component of making a market economy successful

Unfortunately, in large parts of Eastern Europe, this advice was ignored. In reality, the main right wing (or pro-market) parties fought tooth and nail against any sort of regulation (to be fair there were couple individuals who were exceptions). And to this day, pro-market supporters vote for some of these, so it's not like they are too unhappy about it. It's much like the difference between communist rhetoric and practice.

asgard1024··on NASA Study: Mass Gains of Antarctic Ice Sheet Greater Than Losses
> we probably are warming the world with all of our machines

Probably very little compared to GH gases contribution, see here: http://skepticalscience.com/waste-heat-global-warming.htm

There is a lot of energy coming to the Earth in the form of sunlight. We could power world economy with it many times over.

asgard1024··on Confessions of a Right-Wing Liberal (1968)
I kinda agree with you, and I think it's unfair you're getting downvoted by fundamentalists.

I don't understand the libertarian stance either. They are against concentration and misuse of power (big business and government), which I can relate to, to an extent. But at the same time, they seem unwilling to help or even compromise with the other people who are getting screwed (which is often a majority). Specifically, they don't want to support poor in any way, and are often against democracy.

Now I sympathize with the cause, but why should I (politically, economically) help/support person (a libertarian) that is unwilling to help/support me? It doesn't make any sense, in fact it sounds as a fishy proposition, where I am gonna get screwed (though at least I appreciate the honesty).

I'd be happy to hear from libertarians how is this supposed to work - why should I support you? Is your system going to help me when I am in trouble and how? (Or don't forget to downvote me as a signal that you don't want to have a tough but mature discussion about your precious beliefs.)

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
I disagree. I think the monopolist (or bigger company in general) has more options, regardless whether or not it's government backed. At the very least, bigger companies can afford to play chicken game with safer margin of error. Having more options translates to having more power in keeping the market position.

Just one example out of many. Microsoft preinstalls Windows on PCs. I can't get e.g. a Linux one because every time someone tries to sell them, Microsoft will signal to the seller that they will have to change the terms of contract with them. Since no seller can really afford to lose MS, they will always cave in and forget about the Linux deal. This is how "the market" actually works in the real world.

> Competition still exists even without actual competitors, since the potential for competitors to enter the market is ever present, should the monopolist abuse the consumer.

I am sorry, I don't buy this, this is wishful thinking. You're basically telling me that someone abusive will not abuse even if he knows there is nothing to stop them, just because there is always a possibility that something to stop them will suddenly appear out of thin air?

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> The economic answer would be that the possible costs it could impose on you can be expressed as violations of your property rights

Let me explain a specific example: If a person A cheats person B out of his money, it affects me negatively. It poses a risk in the future that person A, being a cheater, will repeat this many times and eventually will have enough money to cheat me. (Both B and me will agree to be cheated by A at the time when we will be cheated, yet it won't be our preference. Kind of like getting a forced move by check in chess.)

Now I am not sure your claim, that this problem can be expressed as property rights, is correct. At very least, these would have to be collective property rights. In fact, I think what we are getting here, if we are to express this correctly as property rights, to is state control over transactions, in one way or another.

> Being absurd doesn't necessarily make it less philosophically valid.

I would say it's a good way not to be taken seriously, but YMMV.

> On a more concrete level, the rejection of quantifiable utility is based on rejection of the extra assumptions it requires.

Which is a bullshit excuse. We have mathematical capabilities to deal with these kinds of problems - probability, fuzzy logic, whatever. It's just laziness of economists to show that the free market assumptions hold under these new assumptions. (To be fair, it's probably not laziness, I doubt they would hold.)

In particular, we can model things like this in computers. I don't know of much cases where this was actually done, but I heard that free market in silico very quickly collapsed into an oligopolic mess.

Anyway, your assumptions should be close to the real world as much as possible. That should be the criteria for choosing them. It's a nice curiosity to have free markets work under some weird, unrealistic assumptions, but it's rather useless in the real world.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> Beating people up isn't market activity - it's at least borderline criminal.

The beauty of the example is that you don't have to beat people up. What is only needed is A to risk more than B and C.

The point was though you cannot prevent this kind of activity taking place on the market (it can actually be reformulated through money and investment, existence of which also requires 3 parties). So by using 2-party model only, you are missing a good chunk of reality here.

> My bias is that they simply don't happen or only happen very rarely , that wealth and power are almost completely illusory

I guess we can agree we live in a different reality, then :-)

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> I think that the information derived from what people say with money is more accurate than what they say verbally.

OK. But I still don't understand the point you're trying to make.

But even if markets were more honest, it is still not good enough argument to have them. War may also make people more honest but it's not a reason to have it either.

> People who try to lie in markets don't do well.

I wish it would be true. You probably come from the U.S., which has an extremely strong culture of fairness (although it slowly weakens), expressed in its justice system. But in other nations, this culture is not strong. The problem is that markets cannot really punish anybody; once you successfully cheated, you get more money. If you have been found out, you at most lose a little bit of investment (and a mark, but those are dime a dozen). You can generally start another company with different name and continue with dishonesty. In other words, I don't consider losing a good job or opportunity to be a punishment; it's just a bad luck.

> How many Bernie Madoff stories are there? Not many.

In Czechoslovakia, shortly after the Velvet Revolution, there were many. The justice system didn't understand the new economic system and wasn't capable to deal with cheaters. Our prime minister, Vaclav Klaus, had the opinion - free markets are of primary importance and the justice system is secondary. What happened during the era (before we passed enough laws to be compatible with EU) was just huge "gold rush" of embezzlement.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
Well, if you only consider interactions of two people, you have already decided to ignore power dynamic in your model.

Just consider the simplest case of how it can happen that someone has power over someone else despite having same real strength. Person A comes to person B and says: "If you don't do what I say, I will have me and person C to beat you up." Since B doesn't know C, he would better comply. Then person A comes to person C and says: "If you don't do what I say, I will have me and person B to beat you up." C doesn't know B either, so he has to comply. Now A has (some small amount of) power over B and C. This power could be easily broken if B and C would meet and talked about A's bluff (this is actually the price A pays in higher risk of B and C finding out).

Now you may observe in the example that neither interaction was about just two parties; every interaction was about all three parties. So to be able to discuss power, you need to have interactions that involve at least three parties, and also some information hiding.

(In fact, as an aside, I believe that for any n there exist n-person games that cannot be accurately modeled via any series of (n-1)-person games, and the above is just example for n=3.)

> The stories about monopolies of market power from the morgue of the Hearst newspapers

Not sure what you refer to here, but I will say this:

I consider the idea of free market to be some set of rules of how people conduct business. These rules then can lead to (moral) failures, such as accumulation of wealth and power. This can be seen not only in the real world, but also by putting those rules into a computer and running a simulation.

Many people apparently don't agree with this approach. If I point to a market failure, such as monopoly, they will say "but this is not really a free market". Well, with such a definition of free market, you deliberately didn't allow for failure. But unfortunately, this approach doesn't give you rules that you can just apply and get whatever you call the free market.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> But there is a difference between what people say and what they do.

I am not sure what is your argument. Voting (if that's what you're alluding to) can have the same real consequences as spending money. Both are a limited resource.

Anyway, I wanted to remark something that perhaps wasn't obvious. When I say "distribute resources democratically", it doesn't necessarily mean to vote about every resource. It can also mean to democratically establish rules that go against the market in specific cases, or choose market in some other cases.

Pretty much what I am saying is that free markets can fail and it should be democratic decision on whether they failed in specific case and how to remedy it.

> but social interaction does not reward honesty

Interesting. Not sure what you mean by social interaction, but it seems that this contradicts the idea that free markets can work in human societies. In particular, it implies that people are rewarded for dishonesty, which breaks down the free flow of information assumption needed for proper market function.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> A key notion of economics is that if two people voluntarily agree to something, it must be of some benefit of them at that moment compared to alternatives else they wouldn't have agreed. A market can consist solely of such interaction.

The problem is that interactions of two other people can also impose cost on me. Then if this is worse than some opportunity lost is not clear cut.

> Pure free-market economics adopts the epistemological stance that utility isn't quantifiable

I know, but it's an absurd stance, isn't it? It let's you do things like seeing a person that has a heart attack and thinking "I see you have a heart attack, but why should I help you, maybe it's your preference!"

I think any actor has to assume certain, at least very fuzzy, preferences of other actors to be able to operate in the world.

I suspect there are actual rational reasons why people don't want to have their preferences revealed, and this economic school of thought's usage of the "non-quantifiable argument" is just a one of the possible rationalizations.

> so discussing solutions without defining optimality is pointless

I actually feel the same way reading the article.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> Democracy has a similar basis to capitalism actually.

I absolutely disagree with this statement. In democracy, you cannot trade or accumulate votes, and it is one of its tenets. In capitalism, you can trade and accumulate "votes".

This means, at the very least, what family you were born into influences your life. It's better than feudalism, for sure, but it's still far from the ideal of equal opportunities.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
> Price signals work better as the rationality and level of informedness of participants goes up, this should be obvious.

It actually isn't obvious. Optimal strategy is not a continuous function of game parameters (ultimatum game is a good example). You can find situations where prices are entirely useless no matter how close to rationality or well informed you happen to be.

> you still need prices

I agree you can use prices as a substitute for preferences, but I disagree that you can use them as a substitute for information about the product.

> Ballot-box style voting is not a replacement for markets.

I actually wasn't suggesting it as a practical alternative, I was only saying that the same moral arguments OP had for the free markets work in that case too.

> Which are in a sense highly democratic.

If we were all only consumers, it would be true. But market participants also invest or save, and that's a problem - these are ways to gain votes over other actors. That's the reason why I find democratic voting morally superior to free markets.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
Who then defines what is fraud? If I can't stop transaction of two other people based on what I think is fraud, who can ever? And if you are telling me that I can't ever stop any transaction of two people, that actually poses extra risk for me, from serial fraudsters gaining too much power.

Basically, you cannot model society as two-person interactions. That doesn't capture the power dynamic.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
I wouldn't have big problem with the free market (as you describe), if the following big feedback loop of investing would be limited:

People can "cheat" (for example give incomplete information, or mislead about how much stuff they have really done, etc.) and then for that, they get more votes about what is socially useful activity? Of course they will reinvest those points into more what they are doing, and at the end of the day, you will end up with people like that controlling the economy.

And that's what actually happens - owners of capital decide by huge margin where to invest, because accumulation of capital gives you a leverage which just doing normal work doesn't. It also happens to a lesser extent between other social groups.

Now, I see two realistic solutions to this loophole:

- Limit personal wealth to some amount (say 100x average) and redistribute the rest.

- Limit amount of overall wealth (let's say GDP) than can be subject of competition to a certain percentage (say 50%) and redistribute the rest.

These are essentially proposals for having a mixed economy.

> any centrally planned system will be inefficient

Is democracy central planning or not? I don't think "central planning" is particularly useful category, to be honest. All larger-scale human activities have to be done by cooperation of many people, and this cooperation can be always viewed as central planning, or at least as place where individual values are suppressed.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
This article reminds me of theologians who use argument from ignorance to justify their own beliefs in one true god (basically an attempt to impose some absolute moral framework on society).

OK, there is always competition, no problem here. But there are nonetheless many other systems than market decision-making, and there is no clear winner from the moral point of view. Just one example can be democratic voting about economic allocation. I would love to see him show that this is not socially optimal, without showing the same about the market system. (To simplify things, we can consider market system to be one where you can accumulate votes.)

In fact, we don't even know if "socially optimal" solution exists or is unique!

Also, a minor point. It's been shown that price signals work only in the environment with perfect information and rational actors, but then the price is superfluous! This well-known counterargument is not addressed at all.

Someone put it nicely here on HN, once economics stopped calling itself political economics, it became much more ideological.

P.S. Downvoters, please, leave a comment. I will happily have a discussion with you.

asgard1024··on Did Humans Evolve to See Things as They Really Are?
Not quite, I think even most cognitive biases can be corrected at higher level of thought. It's more like cognitive dissonances and the strategies you use to cope with them, but it's hard to tell without knowing the architecture of the brain.
asgard1024··on Why Software Outsourcing Doesn't Work Anymore
I think you can generalize it like that, although maybe it more depends on type of relationship you want to have; physical proximity is only a proxy for that.

Perhaps building a more robust reputation systems is a true way to get a more efficient economy.

asgard1024··on Did Humans Evolve to See Things as They Really Are?
Eh, where to start.. Probably with the Peter Thiel's famous line "competition is for losers". Then you have things like industry associations or unions the sole purpose of which is to advocate non-free market for a certain group of people. Governments (comprised of people, not aliens!) enacting things like subsidies, intellectual property, limited liability, social security, privacy and many other regulation ensure that free market doesn't happen.

Free market predicts zero margin but most industries operate pretty far from that, for a good reason. It's also undesirable from the workers perspective - free market translates as subsistence wages. Everybody is running from the free market as fast as they can; there is a reason why "price war" is called "war" - it's an exhausting and ugly enterprise.

asgard1024··on Why Software Outsourcing Doesn't Work Anymore
If that's the reason why outsourcing doesn't work, why employment does work? I think this is the flaw in the article.

Perhaps outsourcing and employment do work, but it's always better to hand the job to somebody from local culture or to your friend/family. At a higher price, though.

asgard1024··on Did Humans Evolve to See Things as They Really Are?
I think he is quite right, but the real blind spots are way higher in the human thought than object representation. Perhaps that's how it has to be, at the very top level of cognition, there is no other mechanism for correcting errors, except perhaps somewhat following behavior of other people, which may also be completely foolish (or may be deliberately obscured).

I just commented here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10460022 Maybe, just like the beetle looks for a good bottle, we need a good narrative (or friend recommendation) to find the news or idea interesting.

Or another example, many believe in free markets, despite evidence (which can be interpreted as an argument both for and against free markets) that people (including the believers) don't want to participate in free markets.

The thing called "ego" often seems to act against the true reality. It would be my prime candidate for the blind spot in human thought.

asgard1024··on The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter of the Silent Film Era
I am thinking someone should do a similar list for technology news. For instance:

- A renowned researcher gives hope to solve a long-standing problem.

- A famous hacker releases some cool software (or hardware blueprints) as an open source project.

- Please take a minute to pay homage to somebody who accomplished great things.

- A pressing social problem became even more pressing.

- A noble individual gains a legal victory over a faceless institution.

- A corporation announces structural changes.

..and so on. And then perhaps somebody could write categorization software based on the list.

asgard1024··on The Latin America WikiLeaks Files
> Greece is a sovereign country

Not quite, being a member of monetary union. Of course, it would be better not to have the hybrid that is Eurozone, but that's the situation.

> If we loan money to Greece, they can simply decide not to pay us back

No, they can't. If they would, they would indeed have to leave the Eurozone. (Although, absurdly enough, it was Greece that canceled German debt after WW2.)

The disagreement wasn't over whether Greece should pay debt; it was over austerity policies, which in fact prevent growth, and make matters worse. The bad investments have already been made, there is no point in trying to "heal" German banks on poor Greeks inside of what is effectively a single economy (Eurozone).

In any case, the decision of ECB to stop liquidity to Greece was obviously political (since ECB itself cannot make that decision). That's what problematic. EU is supposed to be a democracy, and (at least) built on consensus of member states.

← PreviousPage 4 of 22Next →