HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on The Latin America WikiLeaks Files
It's nice that you probably genuinely want to help other nations, however, if you look at what actually happens (and thanks also to Wikileaks we have the sources), it's not so rosy. I suggest maybe better looking into what your government is doing before you're going to praise it.

> But we should consider the counterfactual. What if Allende had stayed in power? Chile would not be the beacon of stability and growth that it is today.

Excuse me, but this is utter bullshit. We don't know what would happen. I was born in communist country (Czechoslovakia), and in the 1970s and 1980s (and in fact overall), it was much more civilized than Pinochet's regime. Maybe we had slower GDP growth (probably not by much, Pinochet economic policies were no super success either); so what? Higher GDP growth, in my book, doesn't justify killing a single dissident (because, "considering the counter factual", there are plenty examples of having high growth without violence).

> Membership in the euroclub requires fiscal responsibility; governments can no longer rely on running the print presses to pay their debt.

Weirdly, in the U.S., rules like that apparently do not hold. California didn't have fiscal responsibility and is still a member of the club, and FED not running a printing press?

asgard1024··on The Latin America WikiLeaks Files
I take it you're not from the Eurozone, because this is no laughing matter.

It is kind of like FED deciding not to provide dollar liquidity to, say, California, just because people didn't recall Joseph Davis.

asgard1024··on The Latin America WikiLeaks Files
> But propaganda cuts both ways

You are absolutely correct. But wouldn't the U.S. behave badly, people in Venezuela would perhaps have little reason to vote for soft totalitarians like Chavez.

(I also think Hitler rose to power partly because he was one of the few politicians who were willing to call BS on the Germany's WW1 debt.)

I am not actually sure this will 100% prevents rise of authoritarians (given what is going on in Hungary), however, there is some difference in ideology, and also success, if you compare Marshall doctrine to Washington consensus.

Nations get a free pass on behaving badly abroad because of nationalism. Then they get more that they bargained for. Actually, when I think of it, this dynamic is not just between states, it also happens in different social classes as well (for example, policy of being tough on unemployed or drug users, which ultimately makes things worse).

asgard1024··on Learning Real Haskell Incrementally [video]
Thanks, I almost lost hope that I will get a sensible answer. I don't buy the argument that real world code cannot be pretty; what would be the reason to use Haskell, then?
asgard1024··on Zuckerbergs' New “Primary School”: Private but Free
Yeah, maybe it isn't zero sum when you include time dimension, but at each point in time, it still is zero sum.

Why that matters? Because humans need to eat at every point in time, and have limited timespan.

In fact most of the today's wealth was generated by people who are long dead. Despite this wealth being effectively "free", it is still a zero sum game how to distribute it.

asgard1024··on Zuckerbergs' New “Primary School”: Private but Free
> Denying private citizens the ability to have great wealth basically gives the Government a large scale monopoly on far out projects.

Not necessarily. People can still organize, collect wealth and build a large scale project themselves. Or the bureaucrats running companies can organize and together finance big projects. There are many other possibilities.

> allow the private citizen to decide how to deploy the fruits of their work

Assuming these really are their fruits, which is pretty disputable in case of very wealthy people.

> it's always easier to play with other people's money

I agree, and this is actually the reason why one person owning a billion may be more willing to invest to crazy projects than a thousand people owning million each.

asgard1024··on Zuckerbergs' New “Primary School”: Private but Free
> governments are (as the data shows) really, really bad at. eg. reforming the education system

Are you sure? Finland government did pretty good in reforming education system..

> governments are a monopoly

No they are not! Bad governments, maybe. But ideally, they should be democratically controlled by the population, and then the usage of the term "monopoly" is meaningless. (Not to mention that each nation competes with other nations.)

asgard1024··on Learning Real Haskell Incrementally [video]
What projects in Haskell are considered to have well-written, idiomatic code?

I looked at some about a year ago but almost all projects I saw had lot of IO and bangs everywhere.

asgard1024··on Andrew Ng on Life, Creativity, and Failure
I am not sure why you're saying they cheated. I am a layman, but my understanding of that quote is that he refers to a rather large deep neural network, which was trained unsupervised to encode general images (not just cats), had a neuron representing the concept of "cat". You can run the network in generative mode to see how the general concept of cat would look like.

So I am puzzled by your comment - you seem to be talking about supervised learning, but I think the network was trained unsupervised.

asgard1024··on Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S.
> Increasing investment today will indeed increase production in the future - that's the whole point.

So you agree that for the investment to be worth it (and thus made), consumption in the future must increase (or at least appear that it will increase to the investor)? That was my point.

> The production is either consumed, invested, spent on government or exported.

I talked about money, not production. Money can be saved, or in today's world more likely, ran around in circles through the financial system, without ever causing more consumption to happen.

asgard1024··on Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S.
What I mean is that there can't be more investment without more demand. In the Uber example, there won't be more investment either - if you expect Uber to grow on behalf of other companies, these will be divested. In fact, you could expect decrease of investment with Uber, like with any other new technology (disputable in Uber's case, but for the sake of argument), because the whole point of moving to new technology is to decrease investment needed to maintain the same level of consumption (that is, increase productivity).

> all the money from QE will be funneled into consumption

They are, after sitting there idly for a while. The bank CEOs have to pay their mistresses and so on.

And distribution is important too. The whole problem of debt deflation is that you have money sitting idly (or better say idly circulating in an endless vortex of financial machinations), not being spent on goods and services.

asgard1024··on Research into fusion went down a blind alley; a means of escape may be at hand
Although I think the fusion will eventually happen (and ITER will help), I wish it wouldn't.

I think having fusion is a danger for our civilization. People will use this energy for stupid things, like moving mountains; eventually, it will either heat up the planet or produce huge amount of toxic waste or use up all the water we will be able to find. It will be like with carbon fuels but order of magnitude worse.

I would much rather see our civilization to learn to live with the plentiful, yet on decent timescales sustainable, solar energy.

asgard1024··on Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S.
What you're saying doesn't make sense. Why would anyone invest without expecting more consumption?

The economy cycle doesn't start with investing, it starts at consumers having money and giving them to someone in exchange for a service or product. How could you know what to invest in before there is even demand?

asgard1024··on Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S.
> Nobody has ever explained to me, in a satisfying way, what's wrong with a helicopter drop.

There is nothing to explain, since there is nothing wrong with it. Steve Keen did a simulation of policies against debt deflation, comparing austerity (business as usual), quantitative easing (giving money to banks) and helicopter drop (giving money to consumers).

The result was that helicopter drop worked the best, followed by QE, and austerity came last. This is consistent with recent historical data we have on austerity (Japan and Europe) and QE (USA); I am not sure if someone ever attempted helicopter drop in debt deflation (although a similar thing - debt cancellations - happened in history).

asgard1024··on Xkcd and Bill Gates on Polio Eradication
I think Feynman is worth quoting here:

All the major problems of the relations between society and science lie in this same area. When the scientist is told that he must be more responsible for his effects on society, it is the applications of science that are referred to. If you work to develop nuclear energy you must realize also that it can be used harmfully. Therefore, you would expect that, in a discussion of this kind by a scientist, this would be the most important topic. But I will not talk about it further. I think that to say these are scientific problems is an exaggeration. They are far more humanitarian problems. The fact that how to work the power is clear, but how to control it is not, is something not so scientific and is not something that the scientist knows so much about.

Let me illustrate why I do not want to talk about this. Some time ago, in about 1949 or 1950, I went to Brazil to teach physics. There was a Point Four program in those days, which was very exciting--everyone was going to help the underdeveloped countries. What they needed, of course, was technical know-how.

In Brazil I lived in the city of Rio. In Rio there are hills on which are homes made with broken pieces of wood from old signs and so forth. The people are extremely poor. They have no sewers and no water. In order to get water they carry old gasoline cans on their heads down the hills. They go to a place where a new building is being built, because there they have water for mixing cement. The people fill their cans with water and carry them up the hills. And later you see the water dripping down the hill in dirty sewage. It is a pitiful thing.

Right next to these hills are the exciting buildings of the Copacabana beach, beautiful apartments, and so on.

And I said to my friends in the Point Four program, "Is this a problem of technical know-how? They don't know how to put a pipe up the hill? They don't know how to put a pipe to the top of the hill so that the people can at least walk uphill with the empty cans and downhill with the full cans?"

So it is not a problem of technical know-how. Certainly not, because in the neighboring apartment buildings there are pipes, and there are pumps. We realize that now. Now we think it is a problem of economic assistance, and we do not know whether that really works or not. And the question of how much it costs to put a pipe and a pump to the top of each of the hills is not one that seems worth discussing, to me.

(from https://www.nytimes.com/books/first/f/feynman-meaning.html)

asgard1024··on A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls
> think that the root of this issue is that there are basically two ways to fix inequalities: flattening out the entire system or raising those below up to the same level as everyone else. The technique that has proven most successful was really the type of communist philosophy that was used by lots of these Eastern European states, and that essentially comes out to be leveling the playing system by putting everyone below where they could possibly be. Of course raising everyone up is a possibility, but as a whole it's proven extremely difficult to do.

I disagree there is a binary choice. Educational system in Finland was intended to address the inequality, but in the effect it actually helped the performance.

On the other hand, the U.S. with No Child Left Behind policy failed, mostly because it didn't address the inequality.

I think there are two things conflated here: power and choice. We should strive for equality in power, but still give people the choice. If you have the choice, then no one puts you below. I think the fallacy here is that people actually don't need huge resources to become successful, only modest ones. So you can distribute resources equally and yet the best people won't be topped out.

Contrary to popular opinion, lack of possibility to be rich wasn't the biggest obstacle in Eastern European countries. The biggest obstacle was existing bureaucracy (which actually had more power than normal people, it just wasn't expressed in money). Good innovators don't need financial incentives; they need (at least modest) access to resources and freedom. For example, this guy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otto_Wichterle

asgard1024··on Free will is back, and maybe we can measure it
> Arguably, if you knew the exact system date and all other software installed, you could predict exactly how your program would behave.

First of all, there is a difference between what you can predict about the system and what you want the system to be. Since even on nondeterministic system you can build a deterministic one, it doesn't matter what you can or cannot predict about the underlying system. If you want a deterministic system, you can simply ignore the unpredictable parts by averaging over them.

Although, if you know the other software, you could predict the system. But normal application, unless it has root privileges or there are privilege escalation loopholes, cannot inspect the whole system and cannot see all the processes that go on. Therefore, deterministic modelling of the system from a perspective of one application is impossible.

But there is actually a simpler example. Just take an application using the pseudorandom number generator. You can't know if there are other processes using the generator too, so once you use pseudorandom generator, your application becomes non-deterministic. If on the other hand the application wants to be deterministic, all it has to do is not use system-wide generator of randomness, regardless of whether the generator is actually deterministic or not.

The point is, for free will to exist, it doesn't really matter if the universe is deterministic. Just as it doesn't matter in D&D game if the result is determined by dice rolls or a pseudo-random number generator with a known starting seed. People cannot calculate the latter in their heads, so the difference won't affect their reasoning (these things are conditionally dependent on the observed reality); that's all that matters.

asgard1024··on Google’s growing problem: 50% of people do zero searches per day on mobile
No, I am not talking about talent at all! I am talking about the crap that is produced for consumers, that is intentionally making them less productive.

Does my mother, for instance, deserve a text processor (MS Word) that cannot read save from one version to the next properly? Or doesn't she deserve a well researched UI (which actually was in the original MS Word!), instead of some modernist crap? Just because she is not a professional writer? These are all things that little by little improve productivity.

Or take computers, how today you cannot even install an operating system on your device. People should have right to tinker. To prevent it is making people less able to do stuff, and the whole economy suffers as a consequence. You really think that Eastern Europeans, who during communism often had to resort to "doing to yourself", are more talented than Westerners?

The point is great (or the best) technology doesn't require talent to improve productivity. Productivity improvements often stem from things that "just work".

asgard1024··on Google’s growing problem: 50% of people do zero searches per day on mobile
Oh cry me a river! Computer industry wanted to create docile "consumers" who don't do anything useful, so they could sell actually useful devices (for example mobile with keyboards or netbooks with 3:4 aspect ratio) to "professionals" for 10x the price, or "enterprise" for 100x the price. And now you complain about the fact that most of the consumers actually are docile?

I really wish the idea of tiered pricing would die, at least to significant extent. Can you imagine living in a world where everybody has access to potentially the best, professional equipment for affordable prices? How much more productive such society could be? I think access to the best technology should be an universal human right!

asgard1024··on Free will is back, and maybe we can measure it
> The fact is whether or not we have free will is largely irrelevant.

I think perhaps more proper would be to say, whether there is an underlying determinism or not is irrelevant (and that's what Dennett is saying). Free will (as in freedom) is relevant.

And about that question, it's quite easy to:

- Build a deterministic system on top of non-deterministic one. Just take a lot of indeterminism and average it. For example, we do that with computer gates, which are deterministic, but built on very non-deterministic (random) behavior of atoms.

- Build a non-deterministic system on top of deterministic one. Take a pseudorandom generator and keep the seed/algorithm for yourself. For example, we do that in operating systems, where operating system itself is deterministic but each application lives in non-deterministic environment, because it doesn't know what other applications or processes are running inside the system.

So just going from atoms to applications, we switched from non-determinism to determinism and back!

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
> I need to learn more about those other systems, I might revise some of my opinions

I really recommend looking at Switzerland; U.S. on state level also has lot of direct democracy and similar tradition.

> the cost is higher but not limiting, so the result is that more of society's resources are redirected towards that

It's not a failure of democracy, it's absence of it. Some people have more power due to economic inequality.

> basic assumption is that of a population well-educated in the issues to be decided

This is not really an issue. Switzerland and places in U.S. (not to mention Iceland) have more than 100 year tradition in direct democracy, do you think back then the population was better educated? And the sky didn't fall, in fact these places are some of the most advanced in the world.

> And yet we accept this from companies and politicians, and we even turned it into a respectable occupation choice

I agree.

> people may be "pretty positive towards solving these problems" as long as it doesn't require any sacrifices from them

In practice, not always true. There have been some examples in direct democracies where people voted for e.g. higher taxes. As long as it is fair, people can actually accept it quite well. But it requires lot of trust in the society, which Eastern Europe countries, for instance, may not have. Good democracy actually produces this trust.

> At this point we really need someone to force some solutions on people

The problem is once you start forcing solutions onto people, you have opened a really bad can of worms. Lot of dictators had good intentions in the beginning, but somehow their "forcing of solutions" got a little out of hands.

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
That may happen, but it doesn't answer the question what the cut will be. I don't think there is an answer, since as GP pointed out, in free market, both margins should approach 0, so the ratio can be anything in that limit.

This also raises a question, if no one can make a profit, why should people want free market? Basically, free market promises subsistence wages to workers.

And what about consumers switching to distributors? That's the problem, you (wrongly) see economy as having two parts - one part producers, another part consumers (and so presumably you put distributors together with producers), but it really isn't like that, it's cyclic. You can't always hammer it into some supply-demand model (that's actually what makes the example interesting!).

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
I actually didn't.. They are just there! I got them for free (as a part of my training) and they have immense value.

You argument hints at something called labor theory of value, which quickly leads to contradictions, once you include time and technological progress into your models (such as people should get more for labor even if they are doing less of it).

Honestly, I think if people are honest to themselves, they will see that there is plenty of stuff providing value for free (a simple example - tree that grows apples). Then asking to be paid just for your merit is obviously a losing proposition.

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
You're assuming representative democracy; there are other kinds of democratic systems. For example, the indecision could be easily resolved by referendum. Although I admit that general population tends to vote pretty conservatively in referendums.

> The average voter has to oppose people who are trained specialists in lying. I don't see how you could argue it's actually their preference.

People have to oppose these people in all areas of life. By having democracy, you actually distribute power more equally and using money to gain influence becomes more costly (its much cheaper to buy a senator than to influence people to vote certain way, and the latter poses much higher risk).

I don't think people are that stupid. I agree they can be temporarily confused by lack of information or fear, and that in representative democracy, there is a risk of the person lying. But that's a problem with that system, and there are many options how to prevent that. For example, in Switzerland, on some referendums, people can get a summary information with arguments for and against. And often the debate itself is very healthy.

It seems to me this argument is blaming the victim. In all other areas of life, we call out the liar. Whether or not you can tell it's a preference depends on the information you have. Say a girl decides to sleep with a ladies' man, and he breaks up with her afterwards. If she knew, maybe she wouldn't do it. But at the time, she expressed her preference.

> But at this moment in time, we have several important problems - like supergerms, climate change and depletion of fossil fuels

As far as I know (at least in U.S. and my country), based on various opinion polls and so on, general public is pretty positive towards solving these problems. It's the actual politicians who are reluctant to act.

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
The first two objections, while they are real, are true for any agent and any decision system. Currently we live in era where people on Earth are most connected and most educated in human history. We could sure do better, but there are countries with democratic tradition that worked extremely well for much less educated and connected population.

The last objection I don't understand. The best way to know person preferences is just to ask them. If someone charismatic changes their preferences, so what? People change their preference based on other people all the time. As long as it is clearly their preference, we have to assume that it's in their interest.

The point of democracy is that people express their interest. There may be smarter people doing smarter decisions, but why should they make the decisions in the interest of someone else?

In any case, I think it's a good idea, often neglected, to structure society so that impact of any wrong decision at any level is minimized. Things like democratic decision-making, subsidiarity principle, reversibility of laws, non-discrimination, limited liability, social security, no capital punishment, time limited government contracts and free access to information all help.

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
Exactly! 15 years ago, I was interested in economics. Since I originally studied physics, and I couldn't help noticing that some very simple examples are missing from the economic textbooks, namely how to build the macroeconomic model (aggregate functions) from the microeconomic ones.

One very simple example is to have two markets, one between producer and distributor and another between distributor and consumer. It turns out, there is no "rule" as to what the distributor's cut should be. Any margin is possible! It depends on relative negotiation positions of all parties.

So, to say (sufficiently) free markets are the answer is pretty much as no answer at all..

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
> So how about we spend a few minutes trying to solve those problems rather than just throwing up our hands?

If I were to solve it, I would just give people democratic rights (pretty much everyone the same vote) to decide how economic resources are allocated. But lots (if not most) of people are against that idea.

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
> people who believe they possess an inordinate amount of intelligence so often fail to notice how limited is its capacity for solving actual human problems

> we who have studied computer science and know a thing or two about completeness and complexity and therefore the limits of reason, can easily call the bluff

It seems that even with that, there are many people in the second group who belong to the first group.

To me, humans are not actually that different in their inborn intelligence. The bell curve actually falls of quite quickly besides the mean. The most difference is specialized training.

asgard1024··on The fall of the meritocracy
Meritocracy is a very quaint goal. There is so much value in our societies produced by capital that cannot be attributed to work or decision-making of some living person - such as machinery, know-how (technological and organizational), land, natural resources, organic products.

Most people, if they would be paid based on merit, couldn't survive in our society, because they produce so little of value on its own.

Fighting for "meritocracy" therefore becomes fight for attribution, how big piece of resulting pie you deserve. But this deserve has not much to do with merit of your work, it has to do with your ability to fight for it, imperfect information, and kindness of other people.

asgard1024··on Why Twitter’s Dying (And What You Can Learn from It)
I would agree with you on the webdesign, although I actually liked the image. It's a nice one as a wallpaper.
← PreviousPage 5 of 22Next →