HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

atweiden

566 karma · joined June 1, 2013

submissionscomments
atweiden··on Animal testing is exploitative and largely ineffective
> Generally my point in this discussion is that you should not bundle together factory farms and slaughterhouses in the US with, e.g. small dairy farms in the Pyrenees or Austria, or Bantu farmers in Africa, etc. There is one way that people eat meat in the Americas, Australia and China, and quite another in other parts of the world.

The countries which you claim aren’t factory farming are just importing much of their meat from countries which do, see: https://oec.world/en/profile/hs92/poultry-meat

And even if you assume the existence of supposedly “ethical” animal agriculture — which is considerably farcical given the non-consensuality of murder in any case — it’s inherently irrelevant because these niche models of food production don’t scale to feeding the world.

atweiden··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
In that case, could you please expound upon why increasing the human population by X% increases our technological advancement by X%? I must’ve missed where you supported that assertion with facts or evidence.
atweiden··on Animal testing is exploitative and largely ineffective
The French AOC [1] regulates what’s allowed to be marketed as Comté etc by stipulating location, breed, population density, etc; however aside from cheese, I’m not aware of a similar set of standards existing for animal products. As someone who has lived in a rural area with much animal agriculture, I can tell you labels like “free range” roughly translate to “Let’s put as many animals as we legally can fit onto this plot of land modulo our budget, then neglect them to every extent allowable by law, followed by killing them because we need the money”. You specifically give the example of the animals having a shed to shelter in, which IME is an exceptional rarity.

In any case, cherrypicked examples of “free range” farms that actually provide shelter for their animals are about as irrelevant as saying hunting is “more ethical” than factory farming. We cannot feed billions more people sustainably on diets heavy in animal products, no matter the method, especially so with the more inefficient methods like free range and hunting. There’s a reason factory farming exists.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appellation_d%27origine_contrô...

atweiden··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
Despite claiming “a direct and (emphasis added) bidirectional link” exists, you’ve only argued for a link between technological advancement and population size, and not vice versa. So it would seem we actually agree?

(E.g. you don’t seem to be arguing increasing the human population by X% leads to X% technological advancement.)

Current human population levels are ecologically unsustainable without several major shifts taking place — Sir David Attenborough counts regulating the human population size among them [1].

[1]: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/10/david-attenborough-wa...

atweiden··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
Technological advancement and human overpopulation are orthogonal concepts. It’s perfectly reasonable to believe the planet is heavily overpopulated with humans and also that technological advancement is desireable.

There is very much not a direct relationship between absolute number of humans, and technological advancement. This is increasingly true as we inch closer to AGI.

atweiden··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
> Part of this problem is our societal failure to build enough housing to keep up with the increasing number of people.

The issue is human overpopulation, not our society’s “failure” to destroy the fabric of closely knit communities.

Humans are by far the least efficient life form on this planet, and what little enjoyment most humans get out of life mostly comes down to the integrity of their local communities: their safety, their health, their prosperity. Yet we’ve become so hyperfocused on economic growth that we’ve turned our larger society into a malignant tumor unto Earth, while ironically an increasingly high proportion of humans lead unhappy, unfulfilled lives.

Why do so many people just accept the answer is more growth? Until we can master interstellar travel, we have to contend with finite physical resources.

atweiden··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
See: 1971 Cost of Living [1].

    New House:                     $25,200.00
    Average Income:                $10,622.00 per year
    New Car:                       $3,560.00
    Average Rent:                  $150.00 per month
    Tuition to Harvard University: $2,600.00 per year
    Movie Ticket:                  $1.50 each
    Gasoline:                      40¢ per gallon
    United States Postage Stamp:   8¢ each
Whether due to currency debasement, globalization, or overpopulation, the disparity in cost of living between the two eras is staggering.

[1]: https://wtfhappenedin1971.com

atweiden··on Software is eating the car
I drove an Electra Meccanica Solo in Victoria BC a few years ago, and it was exactly this. The founder of the company wanted to design the air cooled Porsche of EVs. All analog, minimal electronics, incredibly nimble. One of my favourite aspects of it was the sound it made under acceleration, think: Star Wars Landspeeder.

(You can faintly hear it over annoying background music in this video [1].)

It felt better to drive than a Tesla, even though it was orders of magnitude slower. Unfortunately, last I heard they were trying to tone down the Landspeeder-esque “cabin noise”. I’m not sure if the current executive team at Electra Meccanica even realizes what they have.

[1]: https://youtu.be/0eUlPeXL8wc?t=40

atweiden··on Bitcoin becomes Legal Tender in El Salvador
> If you owned all the Bitcoin in the world, the world wouldn't accept its use, and would just create another currency with identical properties.

Don’t all modern currencies work like this?

atweiden··on Embedding Lisp in C++ – A Recipe
Fennel combines the simplest general programming language (Lua) with the simplest syntax (homoiconicity). The result is like a Lisp without all the esoterica.

Embedding Fennel in Rust allows you to ship user-facing macros written in Fennel without users having to setup a Lua environment beforehand (e.g. [1]).

[1]: https://git.sr.ht/~ioiojo/kiwi/tree/master/item/tests/data/c...

atweiden··on Embedding Lisp in C++ – A Recipe
Similarly, Fennel [1] is a Lisp which compiles to Lua, and Lua is well supported in both C++ [2] and Rust [3]. Fennel’s a very reasonable option for delivering S-expression based user interactivity — e.g. REPLs and scriptable config [4].

[1]: https://fennel-lang.org/

[2]: https://github.com/ThePhD/sol2

[3]: https://github.com/amethyst/rlua

[4]: https://git.sr.ht/~ioiojo/include-fnl

atweiden··on Unstoppable Code?
Unfortunately, oweing to the fierce competition in the Bitcoin space, it’s long since become difficult for onlookers to distinguish between an argument of the form “PoW bad, PoS good, insert weakly anti-PoS sentiment as controlled opposition here to end up with a pro-PoS post”, and furtive PoS astroturfing — which has proliferated as of late.

As someone who has long been all too familiar with the various sophistry tactics commonly employed by Bitcoin’s competition, frankly that was my impression of your post. I apologize if I misread your intent.

> This is inherent to the PoW consensus. Satoshi Nakamoto himself even said Bitcoin would end up in data centers because of this property

Bitcoin wouldn’t have ever warranted industrial scale mining operations if not for BTC’s significant price appreciation. But PoW systems were never guaranteed to be commercially successful. It’s perfectly possible for Bitcoin to once again become CPU mineable on ordinary Windows PCs — assuming its market price collapses.

atweiden··on Unstoppable Code?
> Unlike Proof of Work based blockchains which require seizable factory infrastructure to break even, Proof of Stake doesn't need one.

This isn’t inherent to PoW consensus. In 2010, Bitcoin was CPU mineable on any ordinary Windows PC. It wasn’t until Bitcoin commanded a significant market value — which wasn’t guaranteed in the slightest — that industrial scale mining operations came into the foray.

> Most Proof of Stake supporters see this as a good thing because it means there's no electricity waste and higher degree of "censorship resistance".

Your understanding of censorship resistance is gravely mistaken [1]:

    Overcoming censorship is not possible in a PoS system, as the censor
    has acquired majority stake and cannot be unseated. As such PoS
    systems are not censorship-resistant and the theory is therefore
    invalid.
If 51% of the stake — even if owned by separate entities — were to deliberately engage in censorship, the general public would have absolutely no recourse. Conversely, in Proof of Work systems, new miners could join the network at any time to challenge the majority miner censor. That is simply impossible under a Proof of Stake model with network censors.

In addition to being vulnerable to total censorship, Proof of Stake consensus suffers from the misfeature of not even having a quantitative fork ranking protocol — i.e. it lacks a way to objectively compare the truthfulness of divergent blockchains. Under adversarial conditions, the PoS chains pos1, pos2, and pos3 cannot be quantitatively ranked by hashing power the way the PoW chains pow1, pow2 and po3 could be, as there is no hashing power in PoS. Instead, there is only “phone-a-friend” consensus, which Vitalik Buterin has euphemistically referred to as “weak subjectivity”.

Jude C. Nelson, who has a PhD in distributed systems from Princeston, critiques PoS better than anyone [2]:

    PoW requires less proactive trust and coordination between
    community members than PoS -- and thus is better able to recover
    from both liveness and safety failures -- precisely because
    it both (1) provides a computational method for ranking fork
    quality, and (2) allows anyone to participate in producing
    a fork at any time. If the canonical chain is 51%-attacked,
    and the attack eventually subsides, then the canonical chain
    can eventually be re-established in-band by honest miners
    simply continuing to work on the non-attacker chain. In PoS,
    block-producers have no such protocol -- such a protocol
    cannot exist because to the rest of the network, it looks like
    the honest nodes have been slashed for being dishonest. Any
    recovery procedure necessarily includes block-producers having
    to go around and convince people out-of-band that they were
    totally not dishonest, and were slashed due to a "hack" (and,
    since there's lots of money on the line, who knows if they're
    being honest about this?).
> Proof of Work blockchains, while wasting a lot of energy, can be regulated easily because the government can simply regulate the large miners in their countries.

Because Proof of Stake blockchains can’t even come to consensus under adversarial conditions without human intervention (per JCN), these “blockchains” can actually be understood as distributed append-only ledgers managed by trusted central organizations the membership to which is gated by wealth. It’s highly misleading — even outright deceptive — to promote such systems as being more permissionless than PoW-powered systems like Bitcoin.

“Green-friendliness” was never a design goal of cryptocurrency: creating a lasting store of value sans institutions, exchangeable pseudonymously over the internet, was.

[1]: https://github.com/libbitcoin/libbitcoin-system/wiki/Proof-o...

[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26810619

atweiden··on El Salvador to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender
It would seem so, yes. But I disagree with the GP’s premise: claiming economies rise and fall based on monetary policy alone is like claiming the Roman empire fell because they debased their currency. It’s a contributory factor, but certainly not the only one.

We’d need to assess the merit of anarcho-capitalism vs collectivist democracy to understand whether disempowering governments would in fact decrease economic stability.

atweiden··on El Salvador to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender
> A currency needs stability.

The word “currency” is inherently a tautology. How does something become a currency?

> Speculation only works when there's a stable currency to dump your value into when the the security is going in the wrong direction.

Precious metals long predate government monies. Gold and silver couldn’t have become currency under the definition you’ve presented here.

atweiden··on El Salvador to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender
> If they want to actually send money to someone using bitcoin, they will have to get their balance on to the main chain

Strike payment recipients can withdraw their USD balance as BTC to any Lightning-enabled wallet (or any other wallet, for that matter) [1]:

    How to purchase bitcoin with Strike

    1. Open a Lightning wallet or Bitcoin wallet of your choice. (If
       you do not already have one, see our recommendations below)

    2. Generate a receive address or invoice for the amount of btc you
       wish to purchase.

    3. Scan with Strike and hit send. Done! You have just converted USD
       from Strike to btc in your wallet.
[1]: https://strike.me/faq/howtopurchase
atweiden··on El Salvador to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender
Doesn’t the Lightning Network scale to millions of transactions per second, which is what El Salvador will be using? Fees are miniscule on LN, as well.
atweiden··on Show HN: Floptimal – Preflop ranges reimagined
Given the success of AlphaGo, and Pluribus’ ability to dominate humans 1-on-1, I’d be surprised if Pluribus couldn’t eventually be generalized to ring games. I’d also be surprised if today’s batch of online poker bots weren’t actively informed by ML or AI. Nor am I confident poker can be played in a fully online setting in a way that is impervious to cheating with bots.

Perhaps augmented reality experiences could help professionals play more hands of live poker, balancing volume with integrity of the games.

atweiden··on Helix: a post-modern modal text editor
If you like VSCode, you might be interested in Onivim — it’s a VSCode/Vim hybrid.
atweiden··on Elon Musk: Bitcoin's energy usage trend over the past few months is insane
Basically none of that is consensus breaking. And I acknowledged the potential of a deep reorg leading to needless network downtime. In the author of the article’s opinion, this deep reorg would’ve resulted in utter chaos, which seems hyperbolic to me. Regardless, how does that disprove the existence of a fork ranking protocol in Bitcoin?
atweiden··on Show HN: I open sourced a game I just released on Steam, written in Lua
Janet is what introduced me to Fennel. Conjure [1] sold me on Fennel over Janet. The Neovim community is rallying around Lua.

(And in fact, what sold me on Rust was its truly excellent Lua FFI support [2].)

[1]: https://github.com/Olical/conjure

[2]: https://github.com/amethyst/rlua

atweiden··on Show HN: An experimental, people-powered search engine
Great idea. Reminds me of a previous HN comment [1]:

    How to build the next Google: all good results these days are within
    communities, and Google search has become useless for most of these
    searches.

    So don't build a search engine: build a "rotten tomatoes
    for X" where the sources for each X are "the top N
    subreddits/communities/editorial-sites/forums for X".
I’d be curious to know how you plan on covering costs.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24714546

atweiden··on Colorado becomes first state to ban legacy college admissions
> The authors acknowledge that an enriched social, educational, economic and intellectual environment can and does raise intelligence scores, but they insist that even when due allowance is made in terms of statistical comparisons of all other factors and measuring their relative weights, intelligence still seems to be strongly influenced by the genes of one's forebears.

https://www.nytimes.com/1994/10/16/books/what-is-intelligenc...

https://www.nytimes3xbfgragh.onion/1994/10/16/books/what-is-...

atweiden··on Collusion rings threaten the integrity of computer science research
> there is something to be said for having roots and knowing your neighbors

I think knowing your neighbors is overvalued. My evidence is Tokyo and living in transient, largely ethnically homogenous sharehouses — in ethnically homogenous areas — for long periods of time.

atweiden··on Show HN: Find Subreddits for Your Niche
Not to belittle the problem of spam, but spam isn’t really what people are increasingly taking issue with. “Political” moderation or just plain obstinance are the biggest shortcomings of present day moderation policies. It leads to de facto namesquatting of popular topics the moderators of which have unfettered power to control the narrative surrounding it.

I bet fame and karma points could counteract the disincentives to moderate. What if opting in to a particular moderator translated into 1 karma point per week for that moderator? Moderators of popular topics (e.g. topics with 100k+ subscriber counts) would quickly become some of the most highly upvoted users on the site.

And if commenters could “layer” opt-in moderation policies one on top of the other, moderators could specialize then. Much of the specialization could be done by bots. Anti-“flagrant spam” policies would be easy to bot and easy to combine. The moderation policies left to be done by hand would largely amount to narrative control.

> And of course you need a default for people who have just arrived at the site, so that they're not buried in spam or attacked by trolls on their first post.

That choice could be left up to GUI frontend maintainers, assuming the site itself were open source.

Really I just think social bookmarking has the clearest signal for human communications in general, by far — by leaps and bounds in fact. It’s a public service for such a thing to exist in modern pop culture.

atweiden··on Show HN: Find Subreddits for Your Niche
Social bookmarking site moderation is in need of an overhaul. Moderators have turned into gatekeepers who can’t be unseated.

I’m dreaming of an “old Reddit”/HN-esque discussion board where moderation policies are opt-in. E.g. submit a thread to /r/bayarea, users compete to moderate e.g. ban/censor content. Users “follow” moderators to opt-in to their moderation policies. Basically upvoting/downvoting but for moderation itself.

Even better if a user’s moderation policies could be forked and lightly edited. I even think there’s room for a learning curve here, given how thoroughly social bookmarking sites have trounced traditional media.

atweiden··on The Limits to Blockchain Scalability
> Finance requires lending and borrowing.

And representing corporate shares on a blockchain isn’t in the purview of “finance”?

Everything old is new again.

atweiden··on The Limits to Blockchain Scalability
> The ongoing coin-days staked in that fork specifically is what allows it to continue making forward progress.

Coin-days staked has no bearing on a pure PoS chain’s risk of being 51% attacked, nor does it have any bearing on the risk 1/3 or more of its validators get disrupted. Not so with PoW hashrate: enormous hashrate imbalances between forked PoW chains directly translate into decreased data immutability per the risk of deep chain reorgs.

Those risks are simply not present in the PoS corollary.

atweiden··on The Limits to Blockchain Scalability
If “coin-days staked” is massively higher on one side of a PoS chain fork, that doesn’t impact the other side’s security in the way PoW hashrate imbalances would.

To use a real world example, Bitcoin PoW mining consumes in excess of 100 Terawatt hours of electricity per year. If Bitcoin were to undergo a repeat of 2016 today, and the Bcash blockchain were to be serviced by miners consuming less than 10% of the energy spend of the incumbent (Bitcoin), Bcash could be easily 51% attacked.

But in the PoS corollary to Bitcoin v Bcash, coin-days staked would have no bearing on Bcash’s ability to continue making forward progress. Just so long as it remained difficult to either disrupt 1/3 of Bcash validators or acquire 51% of it, Bcash would continue functioning perfectly well (see: Jude C. Nelson [1]). At that point the rightful heir to the Bitcoin title would have to be determined socially. It could not be determined without top-down human intervention.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26810619

atweiden··on The Limits to Blockchain Scalability
When the PoW chain ‘pow’ forks into pow1 and pow2 with both sides claiming to be the original ‘pow’, the general public can compare the cumulative hashrate of pow1 and pow2 to ascertain legitimacy (see: Bitcoin v Bcash, 2016).

In PoW, external input to the system — electricity — powers hashrate. Electricity is altogether foreign to the context of cryptocurrency, and by necessitating the wasting of electricity on one fork over another, PoW consensus systems ensure miners can vote on only one side of a fork without bearing additional costs.

When the PoS chain ‘pos’ forks into pos1 and pos2, however, with both sides claiming to be the original ‘pos’, there is no hashrate to base our decision on. External inputs are never burned in any PoS chain’s forward progress.

If a Bitcoin v Bcash political fork were to unfold in a pure PoS context, the general public would be faced with a situation where both pos1 and pos2 chains were equally secure. If pos1 claimed to be the rightful heir to the ‘pos’ title while defensively slashing pos2 sympathizers, it wouldn’t harm pos2’s ability to make forward progress on the pos2 chain while pos2 also slashes pos1 sympathizers and equally claims to be the rightful heir to the ‘pos’ title.

It’s as if an OSS project forked with both forks claiming to be the real thing. If both sides are steadfast, it is ultimately up to the public to pick winners and losers based on nothing besides social signaling. See: 2015-2017 block size debate in Bitcoin for pitfalls to this.

Notice how no math is involved whatsoever in the decision to pick pos1 over pos2.

Notice how human intervention is inherently required to reach a decision as to which side of the pos1/pos2 split is given title to ‘pos’.

Pure PoS consensus is substantially similar to Git repos. If people are just going to trust a nebulous human hierarchy to resolve disputes like this, then the system is de facto permissioned, and a public blockchain isn’t required.

← PreviousPage 5 of 12Next →