Conversely, with PoS, people — and particularly insiders who are in on the ICO, pre-ICO or premine — can click a button and earn X% per annum in perpetuity. Which they do.
Bitcoin has many problems, it just doesn’t have this particular one.
566 karma · joined June 1, 2013
Conversely, with PoS, people — and particularly insiders who are in on the ICO, pre-ICO or premine — can click a button and earn X% per annum in perpetuity. Which they do.
Bitcoin has many problems, it just doesn’t have this particular one.
And I don’t know anyone who uses Bitcoin for illicit purposes. Imagine that.
You have to spend money on mining hardware and electricity to get those yields. To do that on a large scale requires a datacenter and enormously expensive long-term power contracts with utility companies.
But with PoS mining, little to no effort is required. Click a button, and start earning yield in perpetuity.
Put yourself in the shoes of an early adopter of any PoW coin. At what point do you decide to spend millions of dollars ordering mining rigs from Asia, and setting up a datacenter with power contracts? Whereas with PoS this is simply a matter of clicking a button, which costs almost nothing and can be done more or less instantly. It’s a night and day difference.
PoW mining is fundamentally more fair than PoS mining because $BIG_VC has to spend money to mine at all. To mine a PoW coin, $BIG_VC needs to pay for electricity, for ASICs and for datacenter running costs. Conversely, in PoS, there is no true “mining” — investors essentially park their cash and start earning a yield on it cost-free. Ergo it adversely impacts fairness of mining when a PoS coin is 50% premined by investors at pennies on the dollar.
It’s an incredibly dubious narrative that the situation with PoS mining here is as fair as Bitcoin mining, let alone more fair than Bitcoin mining.
Equities typically aren’t masquerading as global currencies. Fairness does matter, here.
It’s absolutely material that the pseudonym “Satoshi Nakamoto” had no reasonable expectation of profit at the time of launching Bitcoin c. 2009, for instance.
It’s also material that Bitcoin miners couldn’t continue mining bitcoin absent continuously ordering new ASIC miners from Asia, whereas PoS miners can plop down cash on day one, and mine the same proportion of coins forever at little to no additional cost.
AMZN investors aren’t typically peddling narratives involving fairness the way PoS investors are. These people are claiming PoS is “more fair” than Bitcoin. It’s profoundly incorrect, but also rather unsurprising.
It isn’t clear to me what you meant to say here. Early investors tend to be by far the biggest winners in general, crypto or not. However, we were discussing mining revenue, not profits in general.
Importantly, early PoW miners had to source new ASIC mining rigs from China year after year, pay to install those ASICs in datacenters, and pay for the electricity to power them. For the better part of a decade. Only then would they have continued earning bitcoin mining revenue at all.
Conversely, PoS staking yield requires little more than showing up with cash on day one. From then on out, PoS stakers earn mining revenue in proportion to their holdings. It costs them almost nothing to do this in perpetuity.
In addition, PoS is sadly linked with ICOs, pre-ICOs and pre-mines. These financial shenanigans allow early investors to stake disproportionately more coins than later investors. IMO it’s highly misleading to present this situation as being somehow “more fair” than PoW mining.
> If a proof-of-work cryptocurrency holds its price, its energy usage can only go up
“Energy usage can only go up”
Only go up? When price is flat? I’m really sorry, but it seems you’re just grasping at straws, here.
> If a proof-of-work cryptocurrency holds its price, its energy usage can only go up
But in fact, if BTC holds its price, Bitcoin miners won’t increase their energy usage — unless they’re willing to mine at a loss.
Knowledge preceedes enlightenment. For example, Git is also green-friendly, and shares a virtually identical consensus model to pure PoS consensus designs. It’s just that “green-friendliness” wasn’t a design goal of cryptocurrency — creating a lasting store of value sans institutions, exchangeable pseudonymously over the internet, was.
As it were, pure PoS consensus suffers from the misfeature of not even having a quantitative fork ranking protocol — i.e. it lacks a way to objectively compare the truthfulness of divergent blockchains [1]. In PoW networks, cumulative hashing power can be simply and easily mathematically compared to produce cold, quantitative consensus. In PoS networks, there is no hashing power, and human intervention is required — just like Git.
Which begs the question, why do PoS networks even need a blockchain? I think we all know the reason for that, though — Git doesn’t have a hype train. Git just isn’t good enough at separating the general public from their hard-earned money.
Whether ICO investors are stakemining coins issued through inflation or transaction fees doesn’t matter — they’re still mining orders of magnitude more coins, at the end of the day. Their artificially low cost basis translates into them reaping outsized profits which dwarf that of later investors.
(And frankly, it’s absurd the PoS astroturfing has gotten so out of hand that this needs to be pointed out at all.)
The rest of your post could be read as a criticism against incomplete application of hypothetical carbon taxation regimes. It seems weird to single out PoW cryptocurrency as the one and only benefactor to a patchwork carbon taxation regime globally.
You don’t have to be rich to mine physical bitcoins, you just won’t mine very many of them. Same as it works in PoS — join a mining pool.
Or buy mining equities, e.g. Blockstream’s BMN token (not an investor).
It’s funny how much flak PoW networks take from PoS investors, and it’s pretty blatantly due to investors investing in things which aren’t PoW. None of the PoW criticisms in play today save for the environmental ones — and even those are subject to considerable astroturfing [1] — are supported by fact. In spite of what PoS investors commonly tout, PoS as a technology is neither theoretically sound, nor practically proven in any sense [2].
(Despite not being an island, AK is still highly comparable to OZ.)
And yet, anyone who buys these proof-of-stake coins now, years after they were launched, suffers from having a cost basis orders of magnitude higher than that of the early investors. Yeah, they’re all superficially earning “the same staking ROI”. But in relative terms, the earliest investors are mopping the floor with the later investors, because the earliest investors can stake orders of magnitude more coins.
The earliest stakers become by far the biggest miners. They’re given an outsized influence over the network, and it’s sadly telling — and a bit unsurprising — that early PoS investors astroturf their coin by focusing on irrelevant minutia, e.g. “open access to staking ROI”, or whataboutism, e.g. “but what about ASIC miner distribution”. That is a classic Red Herring.
“Rate of profits” doesn’t matter more to fairness than, say, premining half or more of the outstanding supply of a given coin to give early investors absurd ROI advantages. “Fair access to yield” doesn’t matter more to fairness than exclusive pre-ICOs rounds which only prestigious investors have access to.
Similarly, it’s disheartening to see so many people — especially on partisan lines — promulgate the talking point that we just need to “learn to live with it”. This is insanity. Annual mRNA booster vaccines ad infinitum, with continuous vaccine passports is a wholly inadequate vision for the future. Melbourne, Oz — a diverse, international city of 5M — demonstrates it’s very possible to eradicate Covid with international, interregional and interstate border closures, with hard lockdowns plus federal financial support. Four months later, zero covid.
The wild housing market is 90% of the inequality. The other 90% can be summed up by this 1994 article in the New York Times [1].
[1]: https://www.nytimes.com/1994/10/16/books/what-is-intelligenc...
[1]: https://www.nytimes3xbfgragh.onion/1994/10/16/books/what-is-...
Firstly, the “underlying [PoW] protocol” assumes the “majority of CPU power is controlled by nodes that are not cooperating to attack the network” (Satoshi, 2009). IOW “Bitcoin” is defined as the chain with the highest cumulative hashing power. That assumption is baked into all PoW networks.
Secondly, Jude C. Nelson — who you seem to have a professional/academic disagreement with — has a PhD in distributed systems from Princeton. I’m not saying your disagreement with Jude deserves no credibility, but I’m also not prepared to give a pseudonyous commenter on HN the same weight.
(JCN runs circles around Vitalik Buterin — a highly entertaining read [1].)
The 2013 bitcoin-0.7 BDB chainsplit incident you’ve propped up as “proof” PoW lacks a fork ranking protocol — which it doesn’t — was ultimately resolved with hashpower (of course). Humans only got involved there to prevent needless network downtime, read: “Eventually 24 blocks would be lost”. The incident would’ve eventually resolved itself on-chain by PoW miners, with hashing power only.
> I'm not saying [PoS] is better by the way... they're all the same.
Proof-of-Stake consensus lacks all notion of cumulative hashrate, and altogether lacks a quantitative fork ranking protocol. To claim PoS and PoW are “the same” in this respect is simply false equivalence.
PoS systems undeniably lack an on-chain mechanism for resolving fork disputes. Hence they have little need for a blockchain — after all, if a top-down human hierarchy presiding over a blockchain is going to unilaterally decide which chainfork to favor anyway, they might as well just skip the blockchain and use Git. As with Git repos, in PoS, forking disputes have to be handled by centralized authorities who outright dictate which Git history is valid. No other dispute resolution protocols are possible here.
Conversely, PoW systems make this determination by ranking cumulative hashing power amongst forked blockchains. PoW networks coldly and quantitatively come to consensus about what constitutes the longest valid chain. PoS systems use less energy than PoW systems, but they can’t even come to consensus without top-down hierarchical human intervention under adversarial conditions, hence they have little reason to use a blockchain at all.
PoW requires less proactive trust and coordination between
community members than PoS -- and thus is better able to recover
from both liveness and safety failures -- precisely because
it both (1) provides a computational method for ranking fork
quality, and (2) allows anyone to participate in producing
a fork at any time. If the canonical chain is 51%-attacked,
and the attack eventually subsides, then the canonical chain
can eventually be re-established in-band by honest miners
simply continuing to work on the non-attacker chain. In PoS,
block-producers have no such protocol -- such a protocol
cannot exist because to the rest of the network, it looks like
the honest nodes have been slashed for being dishonest. Any
recovery procedure necessarily includes block-producers having
to go around and convince people out-of-band that they were
totally not dishonest, and were slashed due to a "hack" (and,
since there's lots of money on the line, who knows if they're
being honest about this?).
Under adversarial conditions like those outlined by Jude C. Nelson, PoS reverts to “phone-a-friend consensus”, or — to use a euphemism coined by Vitalik Buterin — “weak subjectivity”. Centralized Git repos offer a close to identical consensus model.What’s the point in having a “blockchain” at all if under adversarial conditions, miners are necessarily demoted in favor of trusted human coordinators? Git is very “green-friendly”, too.
Satoshi Nakamoto did nothing wrong: hard to imagine, but Bitcoin started out as a crummy C++ GUI Windows application hosted on SourceForge and adopted almost exclusively by batshit insane people. It had no value: you could CPU mine it on any ordinary Windows PC. Many people refused to do even that because of how worthless BTC was at the time.
Enter the Libertarian/profiteer cohort, and the rest is history. Really think a bunch of you need to redirect your anger at the ICO game. Try to imagine Vitalik Buterin hard selling a clear gray market IPO on Reddit in combination with a high pressure countdown timer, and lots of fancy lawyers and Swiss foundations. That — the fact so many bitcoins were raised so easily for so little — is what unleashed the hellfire shillnado that has become synonymous with cryptocurrency in the modern era.
No. Cryptocurrency valuation is 100% driven by narrative, categorically.
Your post in and of itself exemplifies the narrative pumping rhetoric which is at the core of all cryptocurrency valuation. There are absolutely no exceptions to this, and that is not an exaggeration in any way.
I retired at 30 and have done nothing but travel the world developing open source software since then. I have little to no possessions, and nothing tying me to any geographic area aside from a preference for clean air and such.
To your point, in my travels I’ve rarely come across anyone working a job out of anything other than financial necessity. Only a small fraction of people seem to do what they do out of genuine passion. Much more often, artistic, well-natured people are toiling away on menial tasks for money because that’s what it takes for them to survive.
> It turns out that capital is everything.
The gains from this are disproportionately accruing to billionaires while most people add almost nothing to the total output in exchange for cash and at the cost of much of their waking hours. These bullshit jobs are costing people time they’ll never get back, for dubious societal gains in many cases, while also depleting us of creative energy on an unbelievable scale.
Meanwhile, because of the dog-eat-dog nature of our existence, it seems as if there are only two viable paths for most people to achieve “freedom”: either you can withdraw deep into the proverbial jungle, or exploit the underexploited. A staggering amount of what passes for “industry” today is essentially just strip mining our planet of its natural resources, and/or converting it to food in whichever way using as inhumane of a process as is allowed by our current legal systems. The remainder of profitable human activities are by and large facilitating the dominion’s continuity, or quaint distractions from our highly cancerous existence.
“Goods and services” strikes me as being overly broad. Self-education is increasingly obtainable online, and has had an outsized impact on my quality of life compared to other things I’ve spent money on. Regardless, it’d be putting it mildly to say there’s ample room for interpretation here.
(And this is without getting into all the abstract philosophical concepts that creep their way into any discussion about “life betterment”.)
> If you have all the goods and services you need, you're supposed to loan or invest your money to someone
Particularly if we take an “infinite growth at all costs despite finite physical resources” world view. But if not...
> Deflation disincentivizes these exchanges, and a fixed supply is even worse.
Worse for who? Humans? Humans are already vastly overpopulating this planet. To someone like myself who’d be pleasantly surprised if humankind lasted another three decades here on Earth, I think your system of value is of questionable merit. We need to curb growth, starting today, to avoid an ecological collapse. A deflationary economic system like Bitcoin can help avoid calamity for billions.
Govcoin: Digital, so you have no privacy. Centralized, so your money is subject to inflation and confiscation and can be arbitrarily frozen. Government, because let’s limit this to a region or nationality.
Pitting these clearly inferior govcoins against existing cash instruments let alone fixed-supply global cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin is going to be a good old fashioned boondoggle.
FWIW, real world data suggests end users avoid adopting inflationary monies on an open market: “Freicoin”, a cryptocurrency which taxed its holders a small percentage annually via demurrage “for the greater good”, failed to see any level of user adoption, despite having a sufficiently high profile in the cryptocurrency world at the time (c. a decade ago).
In spite of what many people claim, it turns out no one actually wants inflatable money assuming they can easily opt out of it.
> Unlike most great apes today, whose diet is primarily plant based, we can thank the incredible nutrient density in meat and our incredible hunting and tool creating ability for prefrontal cortex development.
Complete and utter speculation.
> We were pack hunters, forging tools and strategies capable of taking down mammoths. Call it 'diabolicaly evil' if you want, but this is simply nature and survival.
Subsistence hunting amongst early human tribes is not comparable to modern day factory farming in any conceivable way.
B12 doesn’t come from eating plants OR animals: it comes from bacteria, and ironically that bacteria is in such short supply on factory farms that the animals need to be injected with synthetic B12.
> I don't personally believe highly processed plant alternatives such as Beyond meat are a long term option if you're even vaguely interested in your own health.
I eat raw soybeans, legumes, grains, nuts and seeds. I’d recommend watching the documentary Forks Over Knives [1] if you care about your personal health, and the documentary Dominion [2], if you’d like to see what really happens on factory farms.
The ethical base of factory farming starts off equivalent with putting a wild animal into a zoo cage for the remainder of its life against its natural will to have freedom. Tack off some “ethical” points for the misery of its living conditions, which are almost universally terrible. Tack off still more ethics points for systematic premeditated murder on a commercial scale for profit.
> Isn't it better for an animal to live its best life on a free range farm being grass fed, then get quickly and humanely slaughtered?
As someone who has lived in an area with heavy animal agriculture, “free range” basically translates to “cram as many $ANIMALS as we legally can into an area modulo our budget, and then neglect them to every extent allowable by law, followed by murdering them in cold blood because we need money”. IOW “free range” is sick, twisted marketing that doesn’t reflect reality.
> If I made a personal decision to stop eating meat, would there be any significant impact at all on the overall environment realistically?
Nothing matters more than money to animal agriculture operations. Don’t underestimate the power of taking your money elsewhere.
The rest of your commentary is more a critique of human overpopulation, and the myriad problems this poses.
Or, consider animal agriculture’s role in deforestation of the Amazon, in massively polluting our planet, and in being a breeding grounds for zoonotic disease transmission, etc.
IMO “allowing” a cow to live the entirety of its early life as a confused, neglected, and often tormented slave doesn’t offset a single one of those evils.
It’s impossible not to ask. Could you share any recipes or dish preparation tips?
The same thing happened to me when I first tried going vegan. It wasn’t until I went through a major effort at planning my meals — to the point of making an outright diet plan for myself — that I was able to make veganism work for me.
From your description, it sounds like you were eating too little calories.
Herbivorous ruminants like cows would never eat you, and would generally never harm you unless provoked. Breeding intelligent lifeforms in a bespoke way to murder them for cash — whatever the reason or creature involved — is diabolically evil. If you do this for a living, you’re a merchant of death in my book.