From this video it seems like there's no record of timing or emphasis, like you'd get with music transcribed today. So I wonder how close this was to how it sounded...if you take a familiar song, and just play the notes strung together with none of the right timing it might sound pretty unrecognizable.
I dunno, Carmack's take seems weird to me...there are tons and tons of games and apps made by tons of different companies and people, what would the common thing be that is holding them back? The OS is not that hard to use, you can pick up the Quest and be playing a game in 10 seconds. It makes more sense to me that the burden of using the hardware is making it so the bar is much higher for games and apps in VR.
Yeah, for me it's more than fast enough except for the Microsoft pylance and C# extensions, both of which I really need to feel productive, and both of which (especially pylance) make VS Code much slower and buggier. It has been getting bad enough that I've been looking around for other editors, but as far as I can tell VS Code really wins on having all the language features, plus copilot and git integration in a single place.
On Reddit/Quora there is more context. You can see other replies, upvote count, and evaluate based on "fishy-ness" of the overall tone of writing. But with an LLM chat every answer has the same obnoxious college essay format, where it writes an entire blog article to say one thing. I find it pretty hard to gauge if something is plausible or not. If I know I'm going to have to verify with a web search anyway, I might as well go straight to the web search most of the time.
That's interesting, you mean something you forgot but could verify when you see the answer? Or something you know, but you need a write-up for it or something?
Yeah, I guess I should have said I think AI chat interfaces in general would be more useful if they could help with the questions that weren't already easy to answer. Sometimes I can get use out of an LLM chat, but it's really hit or miss.
The main thing I want LLMs to help with is obscure stuff. If the answer is mainstream or well known, I can get it more reliably through a normal web search.
You can just talk to your AI companion about it. If you involve another human there's always a chance somebody might be slightly bored or inconvenienced, so we want to avoid that.
I've been thinking along those lines too, but more from the angle that our goal is to eliminate any need to rely on other humans for anything. We consider the need for interacting with other humans as a burden and an inconvenience, and we're going to get rid of it, at the cost of all the indirect benefits we got from being forced to do it.
I agree that would be a false narrative to some extent, but in this thread I don't see a better explanation. Just the idea that in e.g. parts of the USA they have been told it's impossible to control their weight, so they then go on to eat too much and exercise less than in other places and other times in history, doesn't make any sense to me as an explanation. Apologies if that's not what you're saying.
It might be that simple from a high level conceptual standpoint, but when the amount of calories you burn passively adjusts up or down as your body fights to maintain its weight, it is much more complex.
Couldn't your body burn more or fewer calories passively and release the energy as heat? Or you could make more or fewer micro movements throughout the day, in a way that adds up to whatever your body thinks energy expenditure should be?
I don't mean "gaining respect" like that's some explicit goal, but I do feel like people are pretty concerned with others, and most of us do really care about the opinions of others. It might be selfish on some level but it's a big part of being human. I can't speak to everyone's relationship with creating, I imagine if your social needs are being met already then you might just use art to pass the time and not care much about it. But usually the outcome we want when sharing our work is to feel appreciated, noticed or special in some way that scales with the amount of effort, time and skill we put in.
To me it seems like a fundamental motivation - we do art because we want to impress those around us, gain respect, help to attract a mate, make money... Those reasons don't exist without other people to show our art to, and are much less effective if art is too easy to make and too common.
I'm sure there are people who don't have ambition to ever show others the skills they've been building, even in indirect ways, but I doubt it's common... What do you think the motivation is?
Okay, I see. I'm less worried about AI running the whole thing, and more about the diminishing quality of life for creators. Also I'm less sure than you about AI being unable to compete with larger pieces of work in the near future, especially books and comics seem pretty doable. Humans might stay in control, but over time it moves from creation towards curation, which is pretty different and has different implications over who gets to experience artistic fulfillment, and who gets to make a living. But hopefully you are right and it takes long enough that we can make some sort of societal adjustment.
> Finally, most artists don't think like you. It's not "pointless" to do something that can be technically repeated by other humans or AI. You do art because you want to express yourself.
I've seen this sentiment a bunch of times, but I don't agree. Most people practice skills and make art in order to demonstrate their value to society. Art (and media) doesn't exist in a vacuum, it surely exists for societal reasons.
A person may want to make a game or a comic, but the reason they want to make those things, instead of just consuming existing media, is also to demonstrate their value to society. But they won't have any value either when everyone else can easily make games and comics.
I have this and I'm not even a good guitarist, but I used to practice every day. Now my index finger curls into my palm whenever I try to play. It sucks, and cratered my practice time because now practice is just frustrating. I hope someone figures out a way to retrain, but I haven't seen a lot of solutions in the reading I've done.
That's so cheap though, you'd have to sell hundreds of thousands of copies per year to even support a few developers, in the USA anyway. The app store model is driving companies towards subscriptions and micro-transactions, because otherwise like you say users pay a low price once, and get new development and support forever for free. IMO it would be better to raise prices and charge for new versions of apps every year or so, like we used to do, but the app store and user expectations make that unfeasible.
Yeah, this price is frustrating from a small developer perspective. Back when prices were established, tablets weren't used for anything serious, so productivity apps were simple and cheap. Now Procreate is used for professional work and it competes with desktop apps that are much more expensive. Users still expect tablet app prices to be unrealistically low. I guess Procreate can do it because they have a huge amount of the market already. But in the long term it isn't sustainable to keep improving the same app, if everyone already bought the app.
I'd be careful of anthropomorphizing this too much though. Yesterday I was experimenting with a ChatGPT (3.5) Twitch streamer that played a text adventure, that was supposed to return JSON like this:
And it occasionally would put the "speak" part into the "game" part so the game would get long sentences that were supposed to be spoken out loud. ChatGPT just fails in all kinds of weird ways because it doesn't actually know what it's doing. It can't look at what it's returning and use common sense to fix obvious problems. It makes errors in ways that normal programs don't.
I'm curious why you're using your key? I want to try this out on my work codebase, but for security reasons it would be better to use my own key, since I don't know if OpenAI might decide to share API search history with whoever owns the key.
Just to be clear, since you say it's local, when you say no code is sent to a third party AI that includes Codeium? For search and indexing, code is not sent over the network at all?