115 karma · joined September 17, 2014
Maybe so, but as the wiki article points out in its criticism section, this excludes Earth, Mars, Jupiter, and Neptune from being planets.
I don't think it's so much folly as much as a waste of everyone's time. "Planet" isn't a natural thing like the speed of light, if astrophysicists want to be more specific about which orbiting bodies they're talking about, which "dynamical processes" they're talking about, they should come up with a new term instead of dragging literally everyone (including the children!) into an argument over definitions. It's like a scientist insisting that "sound" can only refer to this vague thing a brain experiences, and it can't refer to generic vibrations in the air, but some people are still on the fence about whether it can refer to vibrations in water.
(Also efficient wars cost less time, and that one was even against a much more formidable enemy.)
Personally, I fear writing certain things with a username that's easily associated to my real name by the public at large, not the government with their clever tools. That's because I know the real and not-so-improbable consequences of doing so[0]: losing my job and getting blacklisted from the entire industry I've spent most my life trying to improve in and contribute to. It can be economic death. The threat of the mob is much realer to me than the threat of the government.
[0] https://handleshaus.wordpress.com/2013/12/26/bullied-and-bad...
But hey, like, that's just my opinion, man. De gustibus non est disputandum.