HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

belugacat

1,221 karma · joined September 1, 2012

French/Californian designer in Tokyo
submissionscomments
belugacat··on We need more of Richard Stallman's ideas, not less
Some companies like to be sneaky with whether they're open to remote or not.

"Oh we have plenty of remote employees! But it is on a team per team basis so that's something you'll have to bring up with your manager", says the recruiter

"Oh that's a great question, let me check in with my VP but we should definitely keep the ball rolling!", says the manager.

The interviews go on, and then they push an offer with a big number, except now they're not ambiguous and they tell you you're gonna have to move to SF/NYC/etc, hoping the big number will do the convincing.

In my experience, pulling that trick on a Swedish or a Swiss person will be met with a flat "nah I'm not interested in SF, thanks for wasting my time".

(same trick applies with companies who have multiple offices and tell you they're open to you working at $OFFICE_OF_CHOICE... until the offer is on the table and all of a sudden they really care where you'll have to be)

There's definitely lots of cultural things at play here; one of them in my experience is that American culture tends to see a lot of things as "negotiable", whereas European cultures (especially nordic/germanic ones!) like things to be clear and black on white from the get go.

belugacat··on We need more of Richard Stallman's ideas, not less
> What volunteer would not be seduced by a 6 figure USD salary

This seems to be more of an NA thing. I know/have heard of plenty of EU devs who cut short interviews with NA companies offering 6 figure salaries because they lived very comfortably on their (often lower end) 5 figure salaries and why would they want any more? Especially if it involves sacrificing QoL.

belugacat··on OpenLLM
short answer: because it's one of the options with least friction to get running

a lot of people who are into tech stuff already have a discord account making joining the community a one click process, the instant nature of it seems to appeal to younger users more than async forums, it's a fairly mature platform so it has a bunch of moderation/customization/integration features you might want, etc.

> are discord conversations persisted and indexed on search engines ?

nope (and that is a drawback many point out)

belugacat··on Finish your projects
> Lots of places in Europe seem to have mostly figured the balance out [...]

> [...] I don't think I'd prefer to live in a world without Intel and Microsoft

Now guess why Intel and Microsoft aren't European companies :)

belugacat··on One man’s 8-bit quest to finish his teenage Commodore 64 RPG
“I think if you do something and it turns out pretty good, then you should go do something else wonderful, not dwell on it for too long. Just figure out what’s next.”
belugacat··on Teenage Engineering OP-1: The micro synth with massive impact
My best interpretation of it is that a purchase is akin to a promise to yourself. Buying an OP1 is a promise that you’ll write music in the future, maybe release an album. Buying a Leica is a promise that you’ll get really into photography, maybe publish a book or have a gallery showing.

Of course, the effort to keep a promise is manyfolds greater than that to make it, and spending a few thousands of dollars only requires clicking a button, whereas putting thousands of hours into something requires… putting thousands of hours into something.

Anyways, when I have such consumerist impulses now, I try to break it down. What about this purchase is flattering my ego or making promises to myself? Is there anyway I can get those results without dropping a month of living expenses on a new piece of gear?

belugacat··on Japan will not enforce copyright laws on AI data training, says minister
Interesting, given how stringent Japanese copyright is otherwise. I'd bet large Japanese media companies lobbied against that (eg Nintendo surely doesn't want AI nets able to make Mario/Zelda/etc art indistinguishable from source material). Curious what ultimately led them to reach that conclusion.
belugacat··on AI camera with no lens
I can't find it now, but there was a prototype someone made in the 2000s of a camera that, when you pressed the shutter, would fetch an image on Flickr that most closely matched your GPS coordinates + time of day, acting in a similar way as a "crowdsourced camera with no lens".

Fun to the see a modern reincarnation of that idea.

(While digging around to find the above, I did find yet another camera project that does the opposite: "Matt Richardson's "Descriptive Camera" sends your pictures to Amazon's Mechanical Turk and jobs out the task of writing a brief description of each image, then outputs the text on a thermal printer. It's a camera that captures descriptions, not pictures." (https://boingboing.net/2012/04/25/descriptive-camera-prints-...)

belugacat··on User: Junnn11
That sounds like an amazing teacher. In elementary school I remember being extremely frustrated that art classes weren’t about actually learning to draw/paint, just doing silly things out of papier mâché. I went down the science/engineering route, and it’s only as an adult that I finally took the leap and signed up for proper drawing classes.

It’s been mind expanding to say the least - I thought I spent my whole life seeing, but I realized I saw nothing until I took my first sketching/figure drawing class. Drawing is seeing.

belugacat··on The days are long but the decades are short (2015)
That’s why there’s a biological impulse to procreate, such that by the time you’ve reached your 30s/40s your main drive is not to fulfill your own goals, but help tiny humans navigate the world and fulfill their own. That becomes your metagoal, and adding a 25th stamp to your passport or getting 100 more stars on your GitHub library doesn’t seem to matter as much.
belugacat··on Is the US education system in a state of collapse, and what caused it?
Can you be a bit more specific with what you mean by "collapse"? When we talk about a bridge or a building collapsing, we're talking about a very obvious and immediate mode of failure. Are you using "collapse" to mean "noticeable degradation"?

FWIW, the European nation I'm from (France) is definitely not doing OK on healthcare and public education (and debatable on infrastructure). Hard to compare with the US 1:1 in any case, but I'm not sure I'd designate either as a collapse.

belugacat··on Why do we even bother making indie games?
People are much more likely to click a link than do a Google search. There’s no need to do anything really, but if you’re complaining about lack of attention, why wouldn’t you maximize your (people who see the post) -> (people who visit the steam page) conversion rate?

The indie dev subreddit has no rule against making your game name a clickable link. (The whole point of the subreddit is kind of self promotion for indie devs…)

belugacat··on Why do we even bother making indie games?
If you go into something creative, you’re going to have to accept that you’ll have to play the marketing game. This studio sucks at marketing; their Reddit post, which may well have had tens or hundreds of thousands of views by now, doesn’t even have a link to the game’s steam page. It’s all about the acquisition funnel.

I went to GDC last month solely to attend business/marketing talks as I have a couple game projects in early stages and I’ve been wondering whether I wanted to commit the effort and money to see them through production.

Everyone there seemed to be unanimous that as far as marketing goes, the only thing that matters right now is TikTok. Posting a 10 second video once a week - even if it’s just a silly recording of your dev process - can and will net you hundreds of thousands of views, all through the organic “For You” page. None of the marketing people who spoke had good things to say about Instagram/Twitter and the general takeaway was to not waste your time with them.

So many indie game developers want to work on their project alone in a cave until they release it to the world and everyone unanimously declares it to be a work of genius and they sell 10 million companies. Every once in a blue moon that does happen, but if you’re investing years of your life into making a game, do you really want to take that gamble? There are people who have made it their specialty to figure out how to get your game in front of people, can you really afford to not listen to them?

Florent, if you’re reading this, hire a marketing person. (if you already have one, fire them). With 2 award winning games under your belt this is where your problem is.

belugacat··on South Korea to give $490 allowance to reclusive youths to help them leave house
Between Cowley & Divinity and the Tesco Express on Cowley if I remember correctly. Looking around on street view I can’t seem to find it :( maybe it was where there is now an Oodles according to Google maps but my memory’s hazy. Perhaps it was further down on Cowley and I’m misremembering.
belugacat··on South Korea to give $490 allowance to reclusive youths to help them leave house
When I lived in Oxford, UK (as a broke student) one of the cheapest places to get dinner on my street was a restaurant with a few very long tables with benches on each side. It was usually pretty full, so you’d always meet interesting people if you were the kind of person to walk in there in the first place.

They didn’t pay you to do so though.

I haven’t found many places like this later in my life, which is too bad. I’m currently on the island of Réunion, which I understand used to have very similar setups, but not many are left. For all I know the one in Oxford doesn’t exist anymore; I last went there almost 2 decades ago.

belugacat··on Terence Tao on GPT-4
True, but one obvious difference is that a senior contributor can typically validate the work of a more junior one in less time than it took them to produce, that’s why the overall equation works. And if you decide to keep the more junior person, it’s probably because you feel like they’re improving and becoming more trustworthy over time.

Another key difference is that a deterministic script that has determined to be valid will be valid for all subsequent runs, regardless of input size. That is not the case for ChatGPT, which might be correct on some runs and not others, or do well on small input sizes but start messing up when thousands (or more) of data items are involved.

Again, I still think ChatGPT is really cool, but thinking about all these nuances about the nature of the work that is actually being done when you use ChatGPT vs writing a script vs handing it off to an intern seems crucial to the debate.

belugacat··on Terence Tao on GPT-4
And here’s an exchange about how he validated the data was correct - which to me seems like the most important part:

> Out of curiosity, are you sure that GPT did it correctly? If yes, is it because you were able to "spot check" it in a few places? Or have you used GPT enough that you trust it with a task like this? Or is this for some kind of internal use where a few small errors is unimportant, and you only need the broad strokes to be correct?

> Yes, yes, and yes. (There were some obvious checksums, for instance by computing the total number of speakers several different ways.)

Still cool, but the circumstances above aren’t always true. In fact, in a lot of meaningful work, none of them probably are.

If GPT is like an assistant whose work you always have to double check in order to be sure of the validity of the results, that seems to be a pretty big caveat to me. In that case it’s probably better to just write a script whose output you know to be deterministic, even if it takes slightly longer (and the bigger your dataset to verify, the more likely it is that it’ll take less time to write a script than to validate results one by one).

The scary part is if/when companies/bureaucracies/governments/etc start using GPT for all sorts of Important Tasks and skip the validation part because they assume the machine will always get it right.

belugacat··on Displaying My Washing Machine's Remaining Time with Curl, Jq, and Pizauth
Great hack, but I’m sure any engineer worth their salt winces at the thought of a machine in their home roundtripping through far away 3rd party servers (I guess they’re the manufacturer’s, but if it’s hardware I own in my house those servers are 3rd party to me) just to notify them of a numerical value when they’re sitting literally 10 meters away (I live in the countryside and experience internet interruptions not infrequently, things running locally matter a lot to me).

I was thinking the other day as I was remodeling my kitchen that I would happily pay several times the price of regular appliances (fridge, clothes washer, dish washer) if they were built with a tasteful, minimalist design (eg 1960s Braun style), quality materials, and fully open source PCB/firmware/schematics/etc. I’m probably not the only one. It’d be a weird niche market but perhaps there’s something there.

If you tie it with the building consumer awareness of right to repair, anti consumerism, planned obsolescence, etc, the marketing just writes itself.

Maybe that’s a kind of company I want to start myself, having worked in consumer hardware for a long time and thinking about my next step, but if anyone wants to take the idea go ahead.

belugacat··on Make Something Wonderful – Steve Jobs in his own words
Writing as if you were Aristotle, speak to the relationship between Large Language Models and human knowledge/cognition.

//

As Aristotle, I would like to reflect upon the relationship between Large Language Models and human knowledge and cognition.

Firstly, it is important to understand that knowledge and cognition are closely intertwined with language. Human beings have the unique ability to use language as a tool to convey and acquire knowledge. However, with the emergence of Large Language Models, such as GPT-3, we are now seeing machines that can also manipulate language to produce and process knowledge.

These machines are built using complex algorithms and trained on vast amounts of data, allowing them to produce outputs that can mimic human language to a remarkable degree. However, it is important to note that these models are not conscious beings, and their outputs are based solely on the patterns they have learned from the data they were trained on.

While Large Language Models can certainly augment human knowledge and cognition by providing access to vast amounts of information, they cannot replace the unique capabilities of the human mind. Human beings have the ability to reason, to form concepts and abstractions, and to apply knowledge in creative and innovative ways. These are capabilities that cannot be fully replicated by machines, at least not at present.

In conclusion, while Large Language Models can certainly contribute to human knowledge and cognition by providing access to vast amounts of information, they cannot replace the unique capabilities of the human mind. The human mind remains a unique and powerful tool, capable of processing and synthesizing knowledge in ways that machines are not yet able to replicate.

belugacat··on Finding Photo Opportunities Near Home
> Personally the whole dick move thing I don't care about.

I’ve met many such photographers when traveling, yep. They make things worse for all of us.

belugacat··on Finding Photo Opportunities Near Home
> It's quite scary to ask someone for their photo and it's a bit rude to take photo without permission. I advise you to just go for it and not care.

I agree with just going for it when it comes to asking strangers for their portrait. If you’re friendly and confident (and know how to take rejection swiftly and just move on), you’ll have a 90%+ success rate. Having a weird old film camera bumps that up even more, in my experience. So does opening with a compliment (“oh wow I love your outfit”).

However, taking a portrait of someone without their consent in 2023 is just a dick move. This debate has been had so many times under so many angles that you just can’t claim ignorance anymore if you take yourself seriously as a photographer.

A great book I enjoyed recently is Dawoud Bey on Photographing People and Communities.

Depending on where you are in the world and whether you obviously fit in within the cultural fabric or not, people might get very offended/aggressive about it (you deserved it), or not say anything but that doesn’t make you any less of a dick.

Just ask. It can be as simple as pointing to your camera and showing a thumbs up with a quizzical look waiting for a nod in busy situations, it’ll take a second. If the person is performing/selling/etc, buying something/leaving a tip beforehand will help a lot.

If asking scares you so much, that picture isn’t yours to take.

belugacat··on Italian government seeks to penalize the use of English words
If you can read French, I highly recommend “Civilisation : comment nous sommes devenus américains” by Régis Debray. One of the most lucid analyses of the cultural situation we’re in I’ve found.
belugacat··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
I had a former coworker who bought a Tesla very shortly after getting her license, and relied almost exclusively on autopilot. I rode with her a few times when she offered to drive me home, it was legit terrifying when she had to drive in manual mode to eg get out of a parking garage.

Years later, I don’t think her driving has meaningfully improved.

belugacat··on Apple’s Best Hope for New Headset: a Smartwatch-Like Trajectory
> when Steve returned […] is when you started seeing political jockeying, coattail riding and all the other rather gross human behaviors I had not experienced at Apple up until then.

What do you make of the fact that this is also when the company went from nearly bankrupt to wildly successful?

Is making humans compete (within ethical boundaries that should be set by labor law etc of course) a great way to get the best out of them?

belugacat··on Transformer architecture optimized for Apple Silicon
Siri is so bad it needs to be scrapped and rethought from the ground up (it can’t even give me the time when internet is down at my rural house). No one at Apple who wants a career there would dare propose that. The switch to a LLM architecture could be the perfect transition point for this.
belugacat··on Tim Cook bets on Apple’s mixed-reality headset to secure his legacy
Steering wheel controllers have outsold the GameCube. The fact that there’s a dedicated niche of users for a product has no correlation to broader market interest.

Not to mention that consumer electronics sales in 2002 vs 2023 are just nowhere near in the same ballpark. A phone maker sells more phones in a year today than a top selling line of mp3 players might have sold over its entire lifetime in the 2000s.

belugacat··on Do Large Language Models learn world models or just surface statistics?
Ecosystems (what I infer you mean by "the world", since things that are part of the world such as gravity, plate tectonics, etc don't follow the laws of evolution) haven't had thousands of years to evolve, adapt, and settle around the capabilities that we've had since the industrial revolution started. AI is merely an aspect and consequence of the logical progression of that continuity.

(In terms of tangible effect on the world today and what seems on track for the few decades to come, AI is still far behind coal - to pick one - when it comes to concrete negative externalities tho)

belugacat··on My husband was right about DVDs
This is also true of DRM-free files on thumbdrives. More of my friends have devices with USB ports that can run VLC than optical drives these days (not to mention the whole zone thing, which is quickly a pain when you're a movie nerd)... thankfully generating a DRM-free file from a DVD is trivial.

- signed, someone who also owns lots of CDs and DVDs, mostly old non US-produced things that are close to unfindable on streaming services :)

belugacat··on Google to reduce workforce by 12k
In some cultures the prevalent view is that employees should be grateful to their employer for providing them with a job and a paycheck, and that the needs of the business comes first and therefore the business should be free to layoff employees when it deems it necessary.

In other cultures, the view is more that the business benefits from various social contracts (governments providing various structures & regulations so that businesses can flourish, the cost of healthcare/education that leads to a productive workforce being taken on in part or whole by the state, etc), that the employer/employee relationship is fundamentally asymmetrical, and therefore that an employer has a social responsibility to provide stability and not do reckless things like hire 20k people to layoff 10k the following year.

US work culture, and tech particularly, lean more towards the first side of the spectrum in my experience, but that doesn’t mean everyone is aligned with it or that it is the One Truth.

belugacat··on Fire and Homo Naledi
A dangerous path. The act of accumulating in itself might deeply change who you are, such that by the time you've reached your original goals new mirages have clouded your eyes.

If you want to do something, do it now.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →