HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

benatkin

8,119 karma · joined March 15, 2007

https://ristretto.codeberg.page/ https://codeberg.org/macchiato/ristretto/ https://notebook.resources.co/ https://gitlab.com/bat https://github.com/ResourcesCo https://benatkin.com/ https://fosstodon.org/@bat https://x.com/benatkin
submissionscomments
benatkin··on Apple caught off guard by AI demand for Mac Mini and Mac Studio
Not in this thread, the joke is in an aunt comment.
benatkin··on Claude Session URL appended to commit messages and PR descriptions by default
It's deliberately hostile, in the way that Facebook is to its userbase. I guess Claude doesn't have nearly the grip on their users that Facebook does. Facebook can make it hard to communicate with (via WhatsApp) or stay connected with some of your friends or relatives, while Claude can just make you use the second-best model for cheaper (if Fable is the best).
benatkin··on Claude Session URL appended to commit messages and PR descriptions by default
Indeed, the disclaiming of it being human-coded isn't the problem with their commit messages, them using it as a growth hack mechanism is. BTW to say it's attributed to Claude, I don't give that much importance, but I think it's useful to other coders to know what model was used. A simple assisted by AI would mostly handle the plaigiarism problem, because Claude's training data didn't come from Claude.
benatkin··on Claude Session URL appended to commit messages and PR descriptions by default
For a good chunk of my AI coding work, I make my own commits. I add Assisited-by: to them. I glance at the AI commit messages, and though I usually come up with my own messages sometimes I paraphrase. This would just make it a bit more annoying to review the AI commit messages, though I could hide it.
benatkin··on Warp builds self-improving agents on Claude
It's interesting because Anthropic chose to put it on their Claude blog.
benatkin··on Warp builds self-improving agents on Claude
Seems to be, but I find it hard to believe. It's like if Five Below had announced they came out with a better forklift than Toyota.
benatkin··on Our decision on Cursor following its acquisition by SpaceX
It's going to be tough for Origin, their code hosting platform, to follow in the footsteps of GitHub, if they can't be treated as a neutral party.
benatkin··on Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
I'd recognize the emotional robot if it was like Marvin the paranoid android.
benatkin··on Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
This reminds me of a provocative YouTube video title I read the other day, one that makes me want to fight factory farming injustices. The title is "Animals to me are "Philosophical Zombies" - Destiny" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtpLbmr4ijY I agree with Destiny a lot of the time but not here, though he seems to come around somewhat as the video goes on.

If a sheep or a pig isn't thought of as conscious because it doesn't have a name, like someone's pet dog or cat, indicating that we care about them, then that feels problematic to me. So this isn't a way to neatly solve the problem of AI consciousness.

benatkin··on Stripe acquires Clerky
AI is making it a low-moat industry too. It's a lot quicker to build some API docs, a behavior tracking JavaScript library, and some fraud detection, with LLMs.
benatkin··on New Mac mini, featuring M6 and M5 Pro
No 8GB option? Oh the horror.
benatkin··on ElevenLabs, TwelveLabs, ThirteenLabs
57 could be a reference to the Chevy. Get it while it's hot... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1957_Chevrolet
benatkin··on Extensible Software in the age of LLMs
FWIW I saw the original posts, knew who wrote them, and know that Cloudflare OS is open source. It's because Sandstorm is about running anyone's apps, while where you introduce it you say this:

> the AI cannot introduce a significant security bug

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49183266

That suggests running your own apps, which is a different thing.

benatkin··on Extensible Software in the age of LLMs
It isn't the only wrong thing they're calling it. They're also calling it a successor to sandstorm.io, which it clearly is not.
benatkin··on Show HN: I canceled my AI code reviewer and wrote a free local one
Seems to be mixing up linting with code review - though this does lint only the changes which is an option (I prefer to lint the whole codebase though)
benatkin··on Abdominal fat predicts heart disease risk better than BMI
They talk so much about freshness. That is an indirect and unnecessary and probably unintentional dig at dry beans, grains, seeds, nuts, etc. While I can entertain the idea that they're more reasonable in their diets this makes them bad nutrition communicators.
benatkin··on Government sponsored study on alcohol doesn't stand up to scrutiny
Flâneur psychosis?
benatkin··on Abdominal fat predicts heart disease risk better than BMI
To Michael Pollan it seems they aren't worth mentioning right in the first breath when talking about real food, but perhaps an afterthought. "Shop the peripheries" causes them to be lumped in with potato chips and oreos and other stuff that aren't in the peripheries of a supermarket. I don't accept the same real food dichotomy that they do.
benatkin··on Abdominal fat predicts heart disease risk better than BMI
Eh, the "real food" of Jamie Oliver and Michael Pollan (shop the peripheries) and such isn't very health promoting. So I'll pass and keep eating a mix of fresh food and cheap food that keeps for a long time like legumes. Kthxbai.
benatkin··on Firefox is now the last major browser that still supports uBlock Origin
They should have vetted ViolentMonkey instead of TamperMonkey the last time around.
benatkin··on Firefox is now the last major browser that still supports uBlock Origin
I seem to remember TamperMonkey being on there but not ViolentMonkey, which I didn't agree with. However, I see neither of them on there. Both are available but not recommended. I wonder what is going on with that.
benatkin··on YC startups are abandoning .com
Counter-example: Alphabet doesn't have alphabet.com
benatkin··on WorldClaw Agentic 3D open-world generation at scale
To me it's like a creature. A distinguishing feature of OpenClaw is SOUL.md.
benatkin··on Celld: Self-hosted, distributed Durable Objects
If it were intended to be a direct alternative for the biggest use case, I think it would be more like Cloudflare Workers and Durable Objects. However, I think it's an alternative for a lot of uses of those two things. For a lot of uses of them, likely most uses, they are overkill.

So where it's overkill, this is where Celld is a good fit. It's a 100% open play, despite mentioning three hosted APIs: S3, Cloudflare Workers, and Durable Objects. The thing is, that Deno tried making similar ones. Deno Deploy is analagous to S3, and Deno KV is analagous to Durable Objects. However, with Celld the only dependencies are being able to run a binary and some S3-compatible storage. Cloudflare provides S3 compatible storage, but this README doesn't mention that, except in an example. Perhaps Ryan is leaving the door open for Deno to be acquired by Cloudflare.

FWIW here's an old Deno blog post comparing Durable Objects to other stuff: https://denoland.medium.com/deno-kv-vs-cloudflare-workers-kv...

benatkin··on Cloudflare OS: an open platform for agents, apps, and work
Ah, that changes the amount of work and the reward in the equation for attempting to self-host Cloudflare OS. And I knew that I could run WebAssembly manually inside of JavaScript, but it seems to be runnable directly too. What would help me to know further is how Cloudflare OS integrates its access control in that open source project, and if it is conveniently available to WebAssembly, Python, or Rust workers.
benatkin··on Cloudflare OS: an open platform for agents, apps, and work
There is also qm with smol machines. I found this out the long way, by looking at the contributors to qm at https://github.com/yc-software/qm where I found BinSquare, the founder of smol machines. Then I found a tweet about a public instance of it where I could try out having it code something agentically - I'm in the replies here: https://x.com/binsquares/status/2083305704274976819

I guess the lock-in is to Cloudflare Workers, which is limited to JavaScript. I would in fact look into projects that are built around MicroVMs and WebAssembly. It seems Buzz would be happy to use smolmachines, or whatever. You'd have to roll your own permission system, but smolmachines would at least take care of being able to use stuff within an app, by offering persistent, portable containers.

Actually I think now I can finally say why this sandstorm.io with Cloudflare OS has lock-in. The promise is "you can pretty much go wild" and that you can hand it off to non-technical people to do that. Much as you squint, there is not a sophisticated access control system available to self-hosted users. There's a framework for building a sophisticated access control system, but that isn't the same as having something open source that you can self-host and let non technical users go wild.

However, this is cool. I just agree with you that Buzz sounds more interesting to me as someone who was into Sandstorm.

benatkin··on Qwen3.8-Max: A New Bar for Coding and Cowork
To say that you're building agents, is based on a way of viewing things that isn't at all pervasive. Some might say you're building a customer support chatbot. To talk of building agents as a common activity makes sense if you use LangChain I guess, where its title is "Open Source AI Agent Framework | Build Agents Faster". But for instance, YC just released qm, and in its README it talks about customizing the agent, which is quite a bit different from just casually dropping the phrase "I'm building an agent". https://github.com/yc-software/qm
benatkin··on Welcome to Agents Week
It feels weird to be welcomed to a week. As though were it not for this, I wouldn't be welcome to this week. They seem to have lost the plot.
benatkin··on Rewriting Bun in Rust
Fortunately the site is right next to the title, and so HN regulars can see it's a Simon Willison post about it. And like many expect, it isn't merely reporting, but offers interesting thoughts on it, including some not in the HN discussion you mentioned.
benatkin··on Rewriting Bun in Rust
That isn't what dupe means here.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →