HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bengillies

456 karma · joined May 6, 2011

http://bengillies.net
submissionscomments
bengillies··on Poll: Best RSS reader
The best RSS clients that I've found (Reeder for iOS and Pulse for Android) both use Google Reader as a backend to keep the feed list in sync. I don't really want a whole ecosystem, any social features, a fancy web site, etc. All I really want from an alternative is for it to provide an API for keeping feed lists in sync and for the many Google Reader clients currently available to support it.
bengillies··on Update from the CEO
He's done quite a good job of increasing Android adoption, so my guess would be that he'll be working on the hardware/nexus side of things.
bengillies··on Draft (YC S11) Is The Best Word Processor You Can Write With Today
Cool, thanks for the rapid reply. For the record, most of the interface seems to look and work just fine on an iPad. Keep up the good work.
bengillies··on Show HN: Word Tree in D3.js
Yep, I find it helpful to think of D3 as a data manipulation/data binding library rather than a data visualisation library.
bengillies··on Draft (YC S11) Is The Best Word Processor You Can Write With Today
Very cool. I really like the simple approach and feel there's a _lot_ of mileage in it. However, a couple of questions/points:

1: How do I give my documents a title? 2: Does it support Markdown/how do I link to stuff? 3: The home button doesn't appear to work on an iPad

I may very well have missed something (I haven't published anything yet and didn't search too hard for instructions (it didn't seem to need any)) but thought I'd ask anyway in the hope that they prove useful.

bengillies··on Show HN: Real-time Wiki
Indeed. Google Docs suffers a lot from discoverability and, while you can collaboratively edit on it, it feels too much like a locked down blob of content and so suffers from a lot of the same problems that Word suffers from (in my experience with it at least): it's hard to know when it's changed; when someone updates it, you get an email; when someone writes something, they have to "share" it with with you before you know it exists; WYSIWYG is a terrible way of editing content.

I'm not sure how many of these problems this solves, but Wikis in general solve many of them.

bengillies··on Focus: an editor theme for focussing on content
I've often thought that something like this is what's missing from the various online Markdown editors that exist. Many of them have some way of quickly previewing what you've written, which is important, but some sort of content-focussed approach like this seems like it would also be a good idea.
bengillies··on Don't be mean, it's stupid
I think mean comments, such as you get on Hacker News often have a grain of truth to them. That such emotion is attached to that grain of truth suggests that someone likes your idea or cares enough about your product or the area you're focussing on that it's worth pursuing.

Better then to count the meanness as validation of what you're working on and to extract the grain of truth as constructive criticism suggesting how you can improve.

bengillies··on EmberJS Confuses Me
I totally get that it's different to what's in other frameworks (the router is similarly different), it's just that, for the most part, on the surface, it pretty much serves the same purpose (other than some relationship stuff that half works). That is, it's the same the same part of the framework, just with extra features. Oh, and with a whole load of undocumented coventions in it.

Btw, is there a diagram or something that shows how it's put together internally (I'm pretty comfortable with how to use it from an API perspective, but find myself having to dive into the source code fairly regularly)?

bengillies··on EmberJS Confuses Me
Without meaning to offend, I'm afraid I have to take issue with your points about Ember-Data.

Yes it's optional, and yes you can use jQuery.ajax or whatever, but in reality, it's not quite that simple.

The official guides in Ember default to assuming you're using Ember-Data (though they do at least mention it explicitly). This despite Ember-Data being far from production ready (as stated on the Github page) and far too slow for dealing with large quantities of data. At the same time, the conventions that are found in Ember-Data appear to be built in to core Ember (it says as much in the guides).

As far as Ember-Data not counting against Ember - it may be larger in scope than other client side data libraries (or the M part of other MVC frameworks or whatever) but the fact is that they are most definitely comparable, as it's the way that Ember gets stuff off the server, and saves it back to the server. Without Ember-Data, Ember has no built in way of doing that, which counts against it. With Ember-Data, well, it's not really ready yet, which also counts against it.

bengillies··on Marissa Mayer is killing telecommuting, and that’s a good thing
As long as the person saying it understands that the majority of people already working at said company, and the majority of people who would otherwise be interested no longer will be, I think it's fine.
bengillies··on I'm not too happy about Sublime Text 3
> (Dear “just use vim lol” trolls – and I know you’re reading this: I’ll switch to vim the very second I truly believe it will make me more productive. Promise!)

I'd be interested in why he believes this isn't currently the case.

bengillies··on Apple applies for iWatch patent
It sounds like they're making an iSlapBracelet to me. That means the whole surface would potentially be a screen with just the part facing you being active.

I kind of wonder where else would be appropriate to wear it other than on your wrist, given that it explicitly mentions that (Geordi LaForge style visor perhaps?)

bengillies··on Google Glass
> To be honest I still see headphones as an utilitarian thing only.

FTFY. There are a _lot_ of people who would disagree with you (which is why Beats/Skullcandy/etc headphones are so popular).

bengillies··on This is how you healthcare: American Death in London
Can you explain this please, as I'm pretty sure you can totally sue the NHS if you want to.
bengillies··on I'd like to use the web my way, thank you very much Quora
It's funny because (on Chrome at least) you can select the "request desktop version" option from the menu and this goes away completely (although you do still have to login).
bengillies··on Robots.txt
It seems that most people here would like it very much if SEO died a horrible death as quickly as possible. Let me try and paint a (probably somewhat sketchy) picture of why it should exist (I have nothing to do with SEO consulting btw):

1. You have a business. 2. Said business has a website. 3. Said website is bringing in no discernable revenue for your business. 4. Poking around for reasons, you discover that your website ranks really lowly on Google. 5. You have no idea why. 6. You pay an SEO consultant. They take a look at your web site, and your overall web presence, to try and find out what's going wrong. 7. They discover that your markup is terrible, the wrong things are enclosed in header tags, etc. Also, you have little to no visibility outside of your website. 8. They advise some sensible changes to your markup, and force you to start posting things on Google+, Twitter, Facebook, etc. 9. Your ranking improves. As does your revenue.

Which bit of that process is evil and wrong?

Of course, there will always be a shady side to SEO (people taking it too far, etc), but there's a valid reason reason it exists: many people simply do not know enough to get the basic components right. SEO consultants help them do that, and improve revenue as a result.

bengillies··on Tom, Dick & Harry
I believe the point is that he was fired because he spent a full day coming up with a complex solution to a trivial problem and that when he eventually did arrive at a solution, it was impossible for everyone else to understand and verify.
bengillies··on Discourse
One of the main problems I've found when trawling forums looking for answers is that the answer's often buried somewhere far down in the thread. I think Discourse suffers from this same problem and doesn't really do anything to address many of the issues that forums usually have.
bengillies··on D3.js 101 - Technical Intro
It really depends on who your intended user is. If the slides are intended to form a presentation (quite likely), then the user is often the person making the slides in the first place. In such cases they're not a usability disaster at all. Rather, they're really helpful (being able to switch between different sections, or miss sections that your audience already knows about easily is really useful).

On the other hand, if the slides are intended for reading, then yes, they may be a usability disaster. But then, slides aren't going to be the best format for reading anyway.

bengillies··on Crafting Code in Clojure
I'm fairly new to Clojure, but am not new to bash (and its ilk), so tend to view the threading stuff as Clojure's version of bash's piping syntax (I realise they're not the same thing).
bengillies··on Twitter Hacked – 250,000 User Accounts Potentially Compromised
Salted and hashed passwords? Companies emailing affected users? What is this the future?
bengillies··on Three charts are all I need
Those three may be fine (and indeed all you really need for representing most data) in some fields. In other fields though, they're entirely unsuitable.

A lot of people have mentioned scatter plots.

I'd quite like to know how you'd represent relationships between things using only a histogram or line chart.

I realise that it's covered somewhat by the "95% of all cases" statistic, but really, as with most things, if all you're doing is visualising relationships, then that statistic is likely way off.

The general point is a good one - use a visualisation that's appropriate for representing your data not one that's appropriate only for looking nice, but I think the message is lost somewhere in amongst the rhetoric.

bengillies··on ZenPen
You might want to checkout the HTML sanitizer from the Caja project [1]. You'll need to build it with ant first, but it's pretty good and should be able to do what you want it to.

[1] http://code.google.com/p/google-caja/wiki/JsHtmlSanitizer

bengillies··on Is Ember Data just unfinished or fundamentally broken?
If Ember-Data isn't ready for production, and Ember is, then why is it in the documentation on http://emberjs.com? Either it's ready to be used, and can go in the official guides, or it isn't, and the guides should recommend something that is ready to use.
bengillies··on The Firefox OS marketplace is brilliant
> Basically, the main reason why an app store or marketplace is important, is because the web suffers from a discoverability problem.

Isn't it the other way around? There's no effective way of publicising you app or helping people to find it in an app store short of hoping that the Apple/Google overlords will decide to stick it on the front page. It's remarkably hard to find apps that you're looking for unless you know the name of it (and it isn't a common name, etc), and there's no way of working around it.

In contrast, on the web, if one site doesn't work very well, you go to another one. If one discovery tool isn't working very well (e.g. Digg), you use a different one (e.g. Hacker News).

The web is very discoverable. It just doesn't force a particular discovery mechanism on people like app stores tend to do.

That said, this is a large part of why FirefoxOS is so promising.

bengillies··on Why Am I So Upset About Aaron Swartz's Suicide?
While the untimely death Aaron is tragic, the constant fawning over celebrities on Hacker News is frequently depressing. Both in the sense that we, as a community, are not able to rise above it and, rather more selfishly, that I am not one of them.

While, to a large extent, I already knew everything that you'd written, I'd like to thank you for reiterating it.

bengillies··on I want the world to scroll this way
I hate to be picky (well actually...), but you appear to be complaining about a bug on the site causing all content to disappear and then concluding that the scrolling effect is rubbish.

Your conclusion may be valid, but I don't think the bug you found has anything to do with it.

bengillies··on Japan's ninjas heading for extinction
The book recommended to me when I was doing Ninjutsu was "Ninjutsu: History and Tradition" [1]. It's written by Masaaki Hatsumi himself.

[1] http://www.amazon.co.uk/Ninjutsu-History-Tradition-Masaaki-H...

bengillies··on Wisdom from Psychopaths?
Well it states what Broadmoor is and says that it contains some of the most dangerous people in the country (and mentions the casual references to physical violence a couple of times). Does that not adequately describe how dangerous these people can be? It seemed fairly obvious to me at least.

It also points out that there's such a thing as going too far and that merely learning/using some of the techniques that psychopaths tend to exhibit (in a mild form) is potentially useful. It doesn't seem (to me at least) that he's directly advocating pretending to be a council inspector/whatever to kick people out of their home.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →