HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

boredguy8

5,054 karma · joined January 8, 2008

submissionscomments
boredguy8··on Treating Students as Gifted Yields Impressive Academic Results, Study Finds
Print screen, upload to Google Docs, convert to text.

Works wonders for long passages.

boredguy8··on EFF: forced disclosure of encryption password violates 5th Amendment
The only way the password itself can be self-incrimination is if it's something along the lines of "fraudrealestateisfun". The government said, "Fine, don't tell us the content of the password: enter the password so that we can access the contents of what's behind it."

People's arguments that you have an expectation of privacy are irrelevant: you have a genuine expectation of privacy in your home. If the state shows there's a compelling interest to enter your home (i.e. obtains a warrant), you can't stop them. Similarly, you can't stop them from decrypting your data. Well, you can, but you're going to suffer as a result.

Similarly, you don't have to show your hiding places. Suppose you had an encrypted folder structure and one of the folders was hidden to someone who doesn't understand how to see hidden folders. You don't have to say "there's a hidden folder", just like you don't have to say, "There's a false floor." Encryption isn't a 'hiding place': they've found the data.

Encryption is a locked door. The state wants to know what's behind it. Opening your front door to the police holding a warrant isn't self-incrimination (i.e. it in no way points to your guilt or innocence). Similarly, entering the password to your encrypted drive isn't self incrimination if the state has proved you're the sole possessor of the device.

Although the only way the password content can be incriminating is via the language of the password, the fact that a password works on a particular machine may be incriminating. This is the only line of argument that could work, for what it's worth, and none of these 'privacy' lines of argument. "Your honor, the state has no compelling basis for thinking my client had possession or knowledge of the drive in question. Compelling my client to enter a password on the chance it could unlock the files would prove that they did have possession or knowledge of the drive." &c. But once the state can show it's your encrypted data, it's game over. Fortunately, it's this "foregone conclusion" line of argument that the EFF actually pursues, and not the 'Privacy' line that seems to be popular in these replies.

boredguy8··on Android takes huge lead in US Smartphone market
First, thanks for the historical data. That's nice to see.

But it doesn't seem to me that we'd expect to see an immediate bump in iPhone's numbers from Verizon for at least three reasons unrelated to the platform's (potential) desirability:

1) The iPhone has a lot more competition among Verizon customers. For a while, if you wanted a good smartphone with AT&T, you were getting an iPhone. We wouldn't expect to see "auto-flocking" to the iPhone on Verizon like there was on AT&T for that reason.

2) Contract rollover inhibits fast reaction to new developments. I know a substantial number of people who went Android with the Motorola Droid release in November, 2009. For a 2 year contract, that means November, 2011 is when those customers will be reevaluating their smartphone brand.

3) For some people who wanted an iPhone, they probably bought an iPhone regardless of the network. iPhone on Verizon was (or will be) a chance for some people to change carriers and keep the phone they love.

I think those three factors inhibit a massive switch to iPhone simply because of its availability on a new carrier. Other factors may play a role, too. For instance, AT&T put a lot of their own advertising weight behind the iPhone. Verizon hasn't platformed the iPhone in the same way.

boredguy8··on Physicists: Universe Almost Certainly Not a Hologram
Can you clarify something? This article reads as though energy can't be quantized. Am I misreading the article, or is that an open question now? (Or was it always an open question, and I never understood Planck's Constant correctly?)
boredguy8··on Google+ is Awesome. Facebook Maimed, Twitter Mortally Wounded?
I actually like Facebook's privacy better. Except for chat's online/offline status, it seems to follow a 'most restrictive permission applies" policy, which is nice.

Using Google's example: If I have a biking group and a work group, there's probably someone in the intersection of those two groups. I might want to share something with my biking group but not share it with my work group. There's not a mechanism to do that, that I can find, in Google+.

On the other hand, in Facebook, if I post something but restrict it from my work group, people that are in my work group won't see the post even if they're also in another group that does have permission.

This is a vastly superior approach, it seems to me.

boredguy8··on Revisiting 'Zork': What We Lost in the Transition to Visual Games
There's as much 'there' in, say, the 'never let go' of "Titanic" as there is in FFVII. You being obstinate does not an argument make.
boredguy8··on Revisiting 'Zork': What We Lost in the Transition to Visual Games
"It just happened to me."

No, you have years of experience in a medium that prepared you to interpret that event a certain way.

"it was because you were prepped by playing the game to experience that scene in a particular way."

That's like saying, "Yeah, I jumped into the Iliad at the funeral games for Patroclus, and I just don't get it: it didn't have an impact at all." Duh. The literary experience leading up to that event leads to a connection to the characters that has little weight if you skip it. Saying the same thing applies to video games isn't an argument as to why video games can't be expressive. It means they can, and you have to invest in them to have that experience, much like reading a book.

And the best games aren't "built around" movie-like cutscenes. But suppose they were, and that those scenes were evocative. How, exactly, is that a bad thing? It's not, unless you've a priori decided it is.

boredguy8··on Revisiting 'Zork': What We Lost in the Transition to Visual Games
1911: "Edison's Frankenstein proves the simple fact that these things aren't 'film', they're shitty books."

I think at their best, video games do better than "shitty movies". If someone made a list of "Top 10 Moments" from film & video games, I'm betting Aeris' death at the hands of Sepiroth makes that list.

boredguy8··on Pinboard.in service limited - FBI raided hosting company and pulled equpiment
Sadly this isn't implied, so let me suggest: "Off site backups with a tested restore process saves the day"
boredguy8··on You don't understand something until you think it's obvious.
The intersection of "things I thought were obvious at one point in time" and "things I currently think are wrong" is a rather large set. It's hard for me to claim I "understood" those thing I now think I was wrong about.
boredguy8··on Okay, Okay, Maybe Netflix Is a Problem for Cable After All
Between Hulu (free) & Netflix ($8/mo), the only bill I pay to cable is for internet.

It seems to me that Hulu is way worse for cable companies than Netflix, as Hulu lets me watch current shows nearly immediately. If I didn't have Hulu, I might get basic cable for current shows.

boredguy8··on The Dangerous Mr. Khan
The problem is that you think someone who watches this video would then "know there was a Russian Revolution." No, they wouldn't--at least not in any strong sense of the term "know". All they would have is some phonetic sequence that they could repeat.

At that point, it's just a game of 'guess the password'. http://lesswrong.com/lw/iq/guessing_the_teachers_password/

boredguy8··on Previewing Windows 8 (Video)
I'm pretty sure Julie Larson-Green came from Microsoft Office during the overhaul of that product, which was an amazing leap forward in UI design for Microsoft. The "ribbon" certainly had/has its detractors (and I was one at first), but I soon realized what I didn't like about it was that it wasn't the old, broken system I had learned to use over my lifetime. For nearly everyone I worked with in customer service, approaching the system as an "Office Newbie" was several times easier under the new system.

She also led the Win 7 overhaul, for which I'm forever thankful if only because of the changes to how title bars work (being able to drag to maximize or cover 1/2 the screen, for instance). It was so intuitive that one day I was complaining about how Windows DIDN'T do that, but was on a Win7 box and it worked. I know Jobs likes to use the word "magic", but that was the first time I experienced it with a UI.

I'm wary of the changes I see outlined here, but I think that might, again, be the consequence of having adapted myself to bad design that's been prevalent. Past experience has me hoping I'm wrong to be wary, and I'll be delighted if I am.

boredguy8··on Reverse Engineering Firmware : Linksys WAG120N
Relatedly: is there a good home wireless router on the market today? Hardware & firmware revs have made googling for an answer somewhat difficult: I figure here I'm likely to find a good replacement for my less-than-stellar WRT54G.
boredguy8··on Robots Invent Their Own Spoken Language
'Approximate that using this limited tool set and tell us when you think you're close' is a nontrivial problem. Without getting into a discussion of what creativity 'is', we can probably agree most everything about human activity begins as imitation.
boredguy8··on Monthly Chromebook subscriptions for businesses ($28/mo) and schools ($20/mo)
"But they did so without asking what the market actually needs/wants or looking at what smart schools are currently using (and the related costs)"

That's not true. Just empirically not true. Additionally, you didn't include fully-loaded costs in your blog. Trivially: how many hours go into testing and deploying updates? What is your AV update subscription annual cost? Those are just the first two I noticed without really re-thinking the problem.

boredguy8··on A Rough Guide to Social Skills for Awkward Smart People
"How to accept a compliment. Thanks or agreement feels egotistical. Trying to act as humble by playing it down doesn't seem to be received well either."

I'm now in the habit of accepting and reflecting. Not only is it generous, it also tends to be true. "Wow, Bob, you got N done really fast and you did a great job, thanks!" "My pleasure, Steve - I couldn't have done it without Mary's help." Getting in the habit of forcing myself to give others credit _really_ opened my eyes to how solo efforts are still group efforts: "My pleasure, Steve - I couldn't have done it without Mary picking up my other clients' work during this project."

Worst case scenario, where you're convinced it really is solo work or where deflecting 'correctly' takes too much explanation, accept and deflect to the praiser. "My pleasure, Steve. Thanks for saying something."

I'm not sure this approach is "right", but it's what I've been doing in the face of the dilemma you mention.

boredguy8··on A Rough Guide to Social Skills for Awkward Smart People
I'm glad I wasn't the only one who felt put-off by this. Generally the smartest people I know are also the most humble. And is it just me, or does this article not even take its own advice as evidenced by phrases such as "oh ye smart and lonely"?

Some more nuanced advice would have been nice, so I'll toss this out there: my current effort is to avoid over-qualifying what I say. Because I care about precision & nuance (and being 'actually right'), I can end up taking 90 seconds to say something that a 'normal person' can say in 15. "I thought it was a pretty good movie" turns into, "Though the cinematography seemed like it was trying too hard to be cinematography (though it resulted in some moments of beautiful film,), I thought the actors did great. Obviously not his best acting, but pretty good, really, considering that..."

Conversational negotiation demands shorter transactions: if the other person wants to know more they'll ask, "Oh, what did you like about it?"

It's hard stuff :)

boredguy8··on Apple Q&A on gathering and use of location data (Apple Press Release)
For getting angry at Android privacy, Jobs certainly seems to be missing out on the fact that this isn't an opt-in service, whereas it is in Google. http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/08/bright-side-of-sittin... Apple is GOING to get your traffic data, whether you want them to or not. With Google, I have the option.
boredguy8··on How SmugMug survived the Amazonpocalypse
If the point is "test your supposed redundancy," I agree 100%. But please, for your customers' sake, don't do it in the middle of the day, especially if it's your first test.
boredguy8··on Never say “no,” but rarely say “yes.”
One note: if you're charging enough to cover a hire, make sure you have someone in mind willing to take the position. Otherwise you'll easily end up hiring someone you don't really want in order to cover a commitment you made.
boredguy8··on My National Security Letter Gag Order (2007)
Sorry for the old link. I usually check dates more carefully, but this was sent to me by a newsie so I didn't pay as close attention.

Thanks for the additional info, though: having the follow-up links makes me less sad I posted it.

boredguy8··on Do we understand ethics well enough to build “Friendly artificial intelligence”?
From the article: "And it only takes one error for a chain of reasoning to end up in Outer Mongolia."

Your kids can be punished and rewarded in ways that matter. It's hard to imagine, though, someone with the Ring of Gyges staying moral for very long. And with strong AI, that being could easily be equally free from repercussions.

If AI Blue can't be socially ostracized or punished, your "it's just a kid" story quickly breaks down. And it turns out "follow these examples" runs into problems when you ask "why?" about 3 to 5 times.

boredguy8··on Cellular Automaton Music Generator
http://earslap.com/projectslab/otomata/?q=8g804u08022p4q4s

I like this one because the two left-right components switch the period of the beat on the 5th and 9th rows (themselves also alternating pitch and period) while not breaking the base beat.

I do with the "make link" would let you 'bookmark' a phase: the way it started out went through some cool sequences before stabilizing into this.

boredguy8··on Why the password "this is fun" is 10 times more secure than "J4fS!2"
Using "000" for 3 months then "111" for 3 months isn't secure. So changing a password regularly doesn't make it secure at all.
boredguy8··on Poll: Display points on comments?
I also want to suggest that it might be interesting to have some non-numeric display that still allows for the 'quick scan' that you mention.

I also dislike the lack of points because I find myself voting things down more than I would before. In the past, if something were at 0 or -1 points, usually I'd think, "They probably get the point." Now I find myself downvoting things that probably don't need one more down vote.

boredguy8··on How food-breaks sway the decisions of judges
"It’s not possible that someone ordered the cases in a special way. The judges know nothing about upcoming cases ahead of time, so they can’t decide to take a break in the knowledge that an easy positive case is coming up. They also have control over when they set their breaks, so prison staff cannot predictably schedule the hearings in order of ease."
boredguy8··on How to hack yourself a standing desk - an illustrated guide
I managed to craigslist this desk and love it. Finding the accessories, on the other hand, has been harder.
boredguy8··on Are graphical calculators pointless?
I learned assembly on my TI calculator while I was bored in math class. But that doesn't seem like a reason to keep the calculators: whatever ends up in its place can also be where people 'learn to program', and it might even be better to learn in another environment.
boredguy8··on The Megabus Effect
What does "curbside pickup" mean in this context?

And I've often wished for an LA->LV option that wasn't either shady or as expensive as the cost of a Southwest ticket.

← PreviousPage 5 of 29Next →