HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

breischl

1,890 karma · joined May 18, 2012

submissionscomments
breischl··on Tacit knowledge is more important than deliberate practice
This reminds me of this post: https://putanumonit.com/2021/09/10/rules-for-noobs/

I don't think the guy is any sort of "certified expert" but it rings true to me. And occasionally I've tried to give people related advice but found I couldn't. For example: How do you know when you you're close enough with someone that you tease them in a way that they'll take well vs badly? I'm pretty good at knowing it, but I'll be damned if I can explain it.

tl;dr of the article is that when people are learning then explicit rules and guidelines are helpful. Once you get better at it, they are unnecessary and even harmful. People in the latter stage tend to give crappy advice like "just be yourself" because it works for them now, they don't really exactly know what they're doing (ie, the knowledge is implicit) and they've forgotten what it's like to be totally incompetent.

Anyway, perhaps the point is that while it's difficult to externalize how to "not be awkward" (and indeed it would likely be different for every social group) you can probably use rules to get along well enough, for long enough, to figure it out the hard way.

breischl··on Web3? I have my DAOts
With a _personal check_? Nobody I'm aware of, having done a good 10+ transactions myself.

But everybody is happy with a _cashier's check_. Admittedly you have to go physically get those, which kinda sucks. Or wire the money to the title company instead, which I personally prefer over carrying around a piece of paper worth $75k (or whatever).

breischl··on Boards are dangerous to founder/CEOs
It is normal, but a lot of the rank & file don't understand that ahead of time.

I also think that fact that management went out of their way to leave the common shares with nothing is scummy, bordering on unethical. Which is not the same as saying it's uncommon.

(FWIW, I was not one of the downvotes)

breischl··on Zillow lost money because they weren't willing to lose money
>as I reduced price on it for it to gain attention, I noticed the zillow estimate also went down to always stay below my listed price. I believe the estimate that both Zillow and Redfin display prominently were purely based on what my list price was changed to last, not on any meaningful algorithm

The fact that a house is for sale at a given price, but has not sold after some time, is a strong signal that it's overpriced. The longer it's been sitting, the stronger that signal is. They'd be crazy not to include that data in the Zestimate.

Now, if it's extremely fast, eg they adjust the price down within a day or so, then it seems a little ridiculous. OTOH the Zestimate has always been a rough indicator at best.

breischl··on Boards are dangerous to founder/CEOs
Had this happen on a much smaller scale as an employee. I (foolishly) bought out some of my options when I left the company. Years later they sold it, but structured the deal such that the major investors got paid out all the proceeds, leaving zero for the common shares. Yes, I realize preferred shares and payout preferences and so forth. The really galling part is that the exec team (who had themselves acquired, not built, the company) paid themselves massive bonuses. The employees mostly got a token amount and a kick out the door. Common shares got zero. Thanks guys.

tl;dr, shares in a non-public company are a lottery ticket at best. Just like options, but more expensive.

breischl··on Covid-19: stigmatising the unvaccinated is not justified
> From where I'm sitting in Montana, with no mandates, low vaccine uptake, and nobody giving a crap about the "OMG CASES THE CASES", the firmament remains.

You should check out places like Alaska, where the hospitals are (or were a couple weeks ago, anyway) overwhelmed. Even aside from the people directly affected by COVID, it affects anyone else who may have needed to use those hospitals for things like unrelated accidents, other diseases, complications from births, etc.

"It's not a problem right here, right now, so therefore it's not a problem at all anywhere." is not exactly a great argument.

breischl··on JVM Anatomy Quark #26: Identity Hash Code
I don't know about bloat per se, but I think putting `equals` on all objects is a design flaw. This implicitly assumes that every object has a single implementation that works for every case, which is frequently false. Some objects have no semantically meaningful concept of "equals". Others have situation-specific definitions.

A better design (which C# has made some steps towards) is defining interfaces for Equatable and Hashable, and requiring the object to implement methods that return them. Then they can return them or not, or have multiple implementations of each if needed. Or users of the objects can define their own, custom implementations easily.

breischl··on Analyzing the legal implications of GitHub Copilot
>If I studied a bunch of different open-source projects, learned techniques from them, and implemented them in my own projects, is that a derivative work? Probably not.

That's pretty unclear actually. If it's quite close to the original work, it is derivative. Even though you have probably been "trained" on quite a few different codebases over the years. Hence the existence of clean-room implementations, wherein the people building a new implementation have never seen the original.

Also, given that code that has been passed through a biological network (ie, brain) can constitute infringement, it seems obvious that code passed through a mechanical one could too. Maybe not in every case, but it certainly seems plausible.

breischl··on Good and Bad Monitoring
In the context of alerting, I agree with TFA. You should not be alerting on bad request errors, because you might have no control over it. That said you might want monitoring on it so you can check if the rate jumped at some important point (eg, after a deployment) but I wouldn't look at it on a regular basis.

I had something like that on an internal system. The 400 rate would jump all over the place because our edge systems had shitty input validation, and bots would crawl us with broken requests ("can I reserve this item starting last week?" kind of thing) with no rate throttling. After a few years the edge validation (and bot detection) got better, but alerting on that would've been worse than useless.

breischl··on How to build a small town in Texas
>managing heat for example should be approached holistically

Agreed. Also behaviorally. So many people would tell me I was crazy for living without A/C while they were standing in their house with the blinds open, windows closed, dishwasher and stove on in the middle of the day. If you make your home into a greenhouse with a heater in the middle, yeah it's gonna be hot - maybe don't do that.

But I think my last phrase is the issue. People really hate having to not do what they want, when they want. Like not cooking or whatever until the cool part of the day, when the heat can be managed by ventilation.

breischl··on How to build a small town in Texas
I did find it weird to assert that you can't use wood for construction materials because it wouldn't fit, but then require it for fuel. If you can't find enough wood to build out of, then it seems even harder to find enough to cook & heat with, even in a relatively warm climate like Texas.
breischl··on Text editing hates you too (2019)
>selection of text + pasting of a link as "turn this text into a link using the URL in the clipboard"

Seems like an interesting UX debate. It's a handy shortcut, but it makes "paste" modal depending on what's in the clipboard. Pasting might replace the selected text, or might link it. And because the behavior depends on whether the clipboard text "looks like" a URL, there's an element of DWIM (Do What I Mean) in there. Does it only handle http:// links? What about www.? Or mailto:? etc.

breischl··on Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain
Certainly it can be used as a record of ownership. But it's not the real record - that's whatever the legal system holds. So now we're talking about just using it as a view on top of the actual system of record.

It being difficult to mess up doesn't even matter, because it's just a view - it it's wrong go back to the source and fix it. Distributed consensus doesn't matter, because no matter what the consensus says the truth is whatever is in the legal system.

The main design goals of a blockchain are valuable for a system of record. They are not valuable for things that are just a copy of something else. So while you could use it for that, it's not a good fit.

breischl··on Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain
But the point is that the blockchain is not a source of truth, the legal system is. So the blockchain is at best an eventually-consistent view.

But if that's the case, then why bother with a blockchain at all? Just use a regular database. There are plenty of ways to make that auditable and/or public without bothering with consensus algorithms.

breischl··on Why are modern 50mm lenses so damned complicated?
>it is a spectrum

Yeah, for sure, I didn't intend to make it sound like as much of a clear cut dichotomy as I ended up doing.

>who is branded a legitimate photographer instead of some weirdo with too much money?

You ask the Internet Photography Police to render a verdict, of course! But yeah, it's not a clearcut distinction in most cases.

breischl··on Why are modern 50mm lenses so damned complicated?
The expensive lenses are usually big and heavy. If you don't need that degree of sharpness, then it's potentially a worse tool than a lighter (and cheaper) lens.

>So why wouldn't they be called "hobbyist photographers" like the rest of us?

I feel like I explained my thoughts on that in my previous comment. Basically if you're in it for the love of the gear rather than to make photographs that's fine, but your hobby is collecting rather than photography. Or, to put it another way, photography gear rather than photo-making.

>why does it have any importance whatsoever?

Sometimes the photo-makers get annoyed at being lumped in with the gear collectors. And a fair number of people get taken in reading the gearhead commentary and end up buying expensive lenses that won't actually help that person take better photos.

breischl··on Why are modern 50mm lenses so damned complicated?
Average photographers can certainly benefit from better gear to a degree. But for many people (myself included) a $300 lens will work as well (or even better) than a $3000 one. Which I think is the point the original commenter was making.

The sneering is pretty typical for any hobby that lumps practitioners and collectors under the same heading. The former group tends to see the gear as mere tools, to be used as needed to achieve some other end. For the latter group the gear is the whole thing - or perhaps talking about the gear.

Neither is bad, but it would probably work better to call the hobbies by different names. Perhaps "photographers" and "camera collectors" or something. But then, being a collector doesn't have quite the same cachet as being an artist.

breischl··on Why are modern 50mm lenses so damned complicated?
A lot of photographers buy amazing gear, and ignore the fact that they lack the skill that would use it well or even require that gear.

I think the closest analog might be someone that reads the reviews, buys the latest-and-greatest computing hardware... and then uses it to surf the web and play Tetris.

breischl··on Why are modern 50mm lenses so damned complicated?
Yeah, you're not wrong. There are people who are into photography for photographs, and then there are people are into it for the gear. Not that the latter is necessarily a bad hobby - no worse than any other collecting type of hobby - but it's not the same thing at all.

I do like reading Roger's work (here and at his LensRentals blog) just for curiosity about how lenses actually work, though.

breischl··on A centrifugal spin on a 500-year-old air compressor design
>you're going to wash the particulates through a fluid that stays in the pump permanently, so how quickly is the funk going to make that compressor unpleasant to be around?

Yeah, I was wondering about that too. But is the water going to be there permanently?

If the input air is quite dry, presumably (total guess) it would pick up some extra water. So you'd need to supply more. And probably not just tap water because of dissolved minerals and so forth - distilled seems like a better idea.

Conversely if the input air is humid, you might end up condensing water out of it, and need to bleed water from the system.

And then you're dissolving particulates in it either way...

All sounds like maintenance work, but maybe not a prohibitive amount of it.

breischl··on A centrifugal spin on a 500-year-old air compressor design
I'm certainly no expert, but as they pointed out this is basically a trompe, which...

>Compressed air from a trompe is at the temperature of the water, and its partial pressure of water vapor is that of the dewpoint of the water's temperature. If the water is cool, the compressed air can be made very dry by passing it through pipes that are warmer than the water. Often, ordinary outside air can warm the pipes enough to produce dry, cool compressed air.

[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trompe]

So use a better heat exchanger to cool the water, and then heat up the air until it's dry enough, I guess?

breischl··on First genetically modified mosquitoes released in the United States
>you either do something, or you don’t. There is simply no middle ground.

Only in the narrowest sense.

Another valid response is "you can't do this as-is, but if you make changes X, Y and Z then you can." Or "do more experiments with captive populations first." Or "do this in an area where it's less likely to cause unexpected side effects (eg an unpopulated island somewhere)" Or "use a different set of genes or tweaks"

It's pretty rare that the _only_ possible choices are to do this _one exact thing_, or do nothing at all.

breischl··on First genetically modified mosquitoes released in the United States
>both humans and condom market collapse at the same time

lol, I like your framing of that. I can just picture the headlines:

HUMANITY TO BE ERADICATED!!!!!

Also, condom sales fall

breischl··on Ask HN: What's your keyboard and what you love and hate about it?
I have a Das Keyboard Model S Professional with MX Brown switches. I like it fine - it's solid, and works fine. Not too hard to pull the keycaps and clean it. I like the built-in USB slot, though really it's just a passthrough.

The MX Browns are still pretty loud and "clacky" for use when on a call or video conference. If I make and effort to type softly I can get away with it, but full speed typing is pretty loud.

TBH I'm not that much of a keyboard nut though. For me personally the experience doesn't justify the price, though this keyboard may last long enough that the amortized cost makes it worthwhile.

breischl··on Where does a candle go when it burns?
It pretty much has to be. 1kg would be 1L of water, which is not that much to lose over 5 hours.

But 1kg of fat is 7700 kcal, which would be a massive amount of energy to expend in 5 hours. Unless your "walks" involve running uphill with a 25kg pack or something like that. :)

breischl··on Vertical turbines are more efficient in large-scale wind farms: study
Tangentially, I ran into the bladeless vortex concept recently (https://vortexbladeless.com/), do you have a take on that?

It seems like all your concerns/critiques from above would apply equally, but then I don't have any real expertise in the area.

breischl··on Trans-Pacific deteriorating, brace for shipping ‘tsunami’
This is pretty true. I think this whole thing has been an argument for a low across-the-board tariff, to internalize the risk of supply chain disruptions.
breischl··on Google promised its contact tracing app was completely private, but it wasn’t
Headline seems to be conflating two different kinds of promises. My recollection is that the promise was that Google and the government wouldn't (couldn't) track you with the data. That appears to be generally true. Finding a bug that exposes some data is unfortunate, but it seems the be an unintentional mistake.

tl;dr, they didn't try to do anything evil, they just failed to be 100% perfect.

Also as /u/arsome points out elsewhere, the other apps that can read this data could get better data more easily through another method anyway.

breischl··on Instructions around the usage of meta robot tags and robots.txt files
JSON is allowed, but not required. They just required open, non-proprietary, formats. They specifically gave YAML and XML as other examples.
breischl··on Commits are snapshots not diffs (2020)
When I've done this, your private/dev branch may be a series of broken commits. Then you rebase onto main, squash to one commit, and test (if necessary). So what shows up on the main branch is a single, squashed, tested commit that contains one logical unit of code (usually a feature or fix).

In this model the main branch history is "real" in that it records the sequence of changes to the production code. It's "fake" in that it doesn't record the exact sequence of fumbling steps and backtracks you took to get there. But IME the latter is usually not very useful anyway.

← PreviousPage 4 of 20Next →