[1] https://betrusted.io/xous-book/ch00-00-introduction.html
2,002 karma · joined March 9, 2013
[1] https://betrusted.io/xous-book/ch00-00-introduction.html
It is empirically determined by watching for chlorosis on the edges of the leaves. Not enough, and the leaves grow pale; too much and the plants are poisoned. Observations showed that brazilian spinach developed chlorosis if I did not give it a bump of iron compared to the other species.
That being said, there are plenty of confounding factors so you're also correct that one may not simply conclude it is iron-hungry just because it needs more micronutrients to stay healthy. It could also be inefficient at uptake, could be a pH problem in the water, or it could be growing at a faster rate, etc. etc. A more accurate reporting of my experience would be to just say a "15uL per week bump for species like spinach" without opining on a causation.
Readers should be aware that the article is riddled with problems like this, and should not be cited as any authority on botany. For example, I also haven't taken samples of the things growing around the roots and examined them to ensure they are mycorrhizae, although I assumed they are. They could also be bacterium or any other number of phenomenon.
It's also interesting to see how the game of "telephone" works out when the message comes full circle. Mobilecoin did reach out to me, initially to see if I would write a whitepaper on SGX. After I told them I would be frank about all my opinions, the conversation pivoted to "well, if you could make something that fixed this problem what would it be?". Which I entertained by saying I think the problem may not be solvable, but whatever it was, it had to be open source; and "oh by the way let me tell you about my latest projects, perhaps I could interest you in those". To which it trailed off with a "I'll have my people call your people" and that was that, modulo a podcast I did for them about a month ago which surprisingly didn’t touch on SGX.
So: long story short, no, I'm not creating a solution for them, and I think remote attestation is both a bad idea and not practical. Is it worse than burning some hundreds of tera-watt hours of power per annum to secure a cryptocurrency? That is a harder question to answer: is climate change a bigger problem than remote attestation? The answer is probably obvious to anyone who reads that question, but no two people will agree on what it is.
To your point on RA being not impossible but possibly just exceedingly difficult – you might be right. My take on it is that remote attestation is only "transiently feasible": you can create a system that is unbreakable with the known techniques today; but the very "unbreakability" of such a scheme would cause ever more valuable secrets to be put in such devices, which eventually promotes sufficient investment to uncover an as of yet unknown technique that, once again, breaks the whole model.
Which is why I’m calling out the legal angle, because the next step in the playbook of the corps currently pushing RA is to break that cycle -- by lobbying to make it unlawful to break their attestation toys. Yet, somehow, they still carry no liability themselves for the fact that their toys never worked in the first place. I feel like if they actually bore a consequence for selling technology that was broken, they’d stop trying to peddle it. However, if they can get enough of society to buy into their lie, they’ll have the votes they need to change the laws so that people like you and me could bear the penalty of their failure. With that strategy, they get to decide when the music stops – as well as where they sit.
I'd like to see a return to sanity. Security is fundamentally a problem of dealing with people acting as humans, not of ciphers and code. Technology tends to only delay the manifestation of malintent, while doing little to address the root cause, or worse yet -- hiding the root cause.
I feel like part of the problem is that Remote Attestation providers get to have their cake and eat it too: they make a theme park, set up boundaries, and charge admission under the premise that it's safer to play in their walled garden than in a public park.
But if a bad actor slips through their gate and picks a few pockets or kidnaps a couple children, the operators get to say "not our problem, our services have no warranty -- read the EULA".
I feel like in the real world, if a park operator explicitly bills itself as "a safe place to play" it's their problem if someone goes on a crime spree on their property -- there is some duty to deliver on the advertised safety promise.
But somehow, in the software world people can control admission, control what you do and somehow have no liability if things still go off the rails. It's just a sucker's game.
Of course, I'd rather not see remote attestation happen, but maybe part of the reason it keeps creeping back is exactly because there is zero legal downside to making security promises that can't be kept, but incredible market advantages if they can sucker enough people to believe in the scheme.
If I'm not mistaken, the point of the term is that you're not just punting to the firewall to protect your network: eggshells are not sufficient to protect eggs. Thus the proposal isn't "zero shell eggs", it's closer to "all shell no egg".
I don't have a good alternative to it, but maybe something like "Continuous Skepticism", "Always Verify", "Pervasive Vigilance", or "Verify Everything" might be terms that evolve in the right direction. I don't think any of these are winners, but at least none of these take a fairly universally positive term (like trust) and negate it without further explanation.
"Zero trust" really feels more like just an eye-popping bullet point in a consultant's slide deck that gets thrown in to make sure the client hasn't totally nodded off by the 10th slide...
The "easiest" way to get around noise problems is to put more signal in, but power consumption increases with the square of voltage -- so it's extremely costly to overcome noise with more signal. However, noise is a fundamental limit; there's a set of tricks you can maybe do to improve it but for example, kT/q (thermal voltage of noise at roughly room temp) is about 25mV and that plays a role in a lot of device physics.
Thus most signals engineers would steer away from higher-order PAM and go to QAM, where they use phase to encode one dimension of data, and voltage to encode the other. This gets you out of a one-dimensional line of voltages and into a two-dimensional matrix of voltage vs. time to represent information.
This helps fight against that square-law term for power, but it comes at the expense of more precise timing sources. Time also has noise mechanisms, that are typically only overcome at the expense of -- you guessed it -- power.
At the end of the day, probably the most fundamental limit all computation will run into is power -- both how much you can afford to put in, and more importantly, the limit of what you can pull out reliably and efficiently. I'd be curious to see the plot of PCI-express energy-per-bit over its generations...I suspect it improves over time, but not improving as fast as bandwidth is going up, which means in net each link should run hotter.
If I'm not mistaken you can't implement traits on types that aren't in your crates, so, there's that limitation. But generally it's just another layer of friction that feels like it shouldn't be there, and it manifests itself as a form of technical debt. For example inside the microkernel itself there is an array that tracks the connection IDs in and out of a process. It's limited to 32 elements. Back when it was created, that seemed like a lot. Now maybe it'd be nice to bump it up just a little bit...but it would require opening up a can of worms since it never had all the traits implemented around it, so it's just sitting there until it becomes really worth the effort to upgrade that limit. There's a few spots like this.
Things got much better after we got std and could use Vec, as you note, but there are still a few locations where we have no choice but to use arrays (ie some crypto APIs that are too risky to redesign, the boot loader, and micro kernel itself which is still no-std come to mind immediately).
The script isn't that complicated... it actually uses an existing tool, cargo-download, to obtain the crates, and then a simple Python script searches for all the build.rs files and concatenation them into a builds.rs mega file.
The other reason to give the tool its own repo is crate-scraper actually commits the crates back into git so we have a publicly accessible log of all the crates used in a given release by the actual build machine (in case the attack involved swapping out a crate version, but only for certain build environments, as a highly targeted supply chain attack is less likely to be noticed right away).
It's more about leaving a public trail of breadcrumbs we can use to do forensics to try and pinpoint an attack in retrospect, and making it very public so that any attacker who cares about discretion or deniability has deal with this in their counter-threat model.
The complexity is real, but in a typical SoC the actual CPU core is maybe 10% of the area and tossing in an MMU impacts maybe 1-2% of the total chip area. I haven't seen the pricing sheets, but I suspect the much bigger cost is the higher royalty payment associated with instantiating the MMU.
[1] https://support.bitmain.com/hc/en-us/articles/900000253583-S...
However, one factor not mentioned in the study is that China, which had announced a plan for foundry independence, had its capacity expansion program disrupted by the trade war, as the US restricted China's ability to acquire key equipment to build out fabs.
As a result China could not build the plants it needed to meet its own consumption, forcing them to buy chips from the same vendors that everyone else is also trying to buy chips from. This is an additional shock which is hard to estimate in magnitude but it's probably not small as it represents the missing capacity of entire fabs for many months or years as they struggle to be built.
Thus while the US trade policy may have effectively hamstrung China's plans for foundry independence in the short term, it may also have contributed to a global shortage of semiconductors and its own inflation problems as collateral damage. Trade wars are tricky: without careful and long term policy planning there is a high risk of even more collateral damage.
Another factor that could also be contributing specifically to the difficulties of the automotive supply chain is that China internally had made electric vehicles a strategic technology focus, which means that domestically China's demand for automotive-grade semiconductors was set to surge. Even before the pandemic I was getting tips from buyers that power semiconductors, particularly those in SiC and GaN, were going to be in short supply, due to that shift.
edit - emphasized original paper
Furthermore, things could be much worse because the filters that are used to prevent leakage into radar altimeter frequencies can fail on a 5G device, but the 5G device would continue to operate just fine without anyone noticing (except for the plane that ended up in pieces on the runway).
In other words, 5G transmitters would normally emit sidebands that jam altimeters, if not for a handful of components that prevent it from happening. But if one of these components were to fail -- say, a user dropped their phone and one of the filter elements cracked or de-tuned -- it'd just straight up jam an airplane's altimeter.
I'd like to think that regulatory bodies exist because they are supposed to consider public safety as part of their mandate. We don't want to lose our children in an airplane crash and have the best answer be "whelp, that radar designed 20 years ago should have anticipated 5G jamming. Therefore that altimeter was defective. Anyways, no actual laws were broken, so those lives lost is just the price of progress".
I think an alternative view would be that the FCC should have spectrum auctions not just "because valuable things should go to the highest bidder", but in part to raise funds to upgrade things like airplane radars so they could tolerate the interference caused by the new equipment that was going to be installed in an adjacent band. Government does this all the time: you want to move your business into the neighborhood? You have to upgrade the infrastructure to support the burdens of your new business. We didn't run megawatt-scale power lines to every suburban block just in case someone wants to setup a datacenter there, and if the power goes out because of the datacenter's loads we don't blame the residents of the town for not having anticipated the Internet.
And with over $80 billion raised in spectrum auctions, you'd think that'd be within the realm of possibility - one could replace 100,000 radar altimeters at $10k a pop for "just" a billion dollars, or about 1% of the auction proceeds.
Whenever I complain about how outdated and ineffective the FCC is, the literal pushback I get is "but what about airplanes and satellites". To which I say, touche', we should all do our part to make sure we have safe airports and open channels for satellites and astronomy.
Reading through a Link posted by @supernova87a (https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Slides-5G-In...) I have two take-aways:
1. The spectrum involved is valued in excess of $4.6bb
2. Most 5G deployments will create in excess of 100x (20dBm) the allowable interference for radar altimeters
From the report, page 18 (SC-239 study results):
HUGE AMOUNT OF SCENARIOS INVOLVED
Every base station configuration produces harmful interference both from 5G fundamental emissions in the 3.7–3.98 GHz band and 5G spurious emissions* in the 4.2–4.4 GHz band, across virtually all operational scenarios and relative geometries between the aircraft and base station.
5G user equipment (mobile phones) that may be operating onboard aircraft were also found to exceed the safe interference limits for Usage Categories 2 and 3.
I find it increasingly difficult not to be cynical about the role of the FCC with respect to public safety issues with a lapse like this.
If I shipped a product into the US that had a radar altimeter interference profile like this, I'd be fined and sued into the ground a hundred times over, and I'd accept that fine and outrage because I personally couldn't live with being responsible for any planes literally falling out of the sky because they thought the ground was in the wrong place on account of my product's interference.
But apparently, with enough lobbyists and money, it's an acceptable risk. It's hard for me to take the rest of the FCC's rules seriously, when they act as just another rent-collecting agency at the beck and call of lobbyists whose sole mandate is to create market barriers against small startups and imported goods, with little regard to actual safety, science, or modern technology...
edit - formatting
1) Certain types of mutations are favored by different host biologies. In other words, in humans, you would tend to see one type of coding substitution, in mice, pigs, bats, etc. you'd see another type of coding substitution. The paper gives specific mechanisms that underly this biases; I'm not an expert in these, so I can't say for sure if they are correct, but it the mechanisms as proposed make sense on a first read-through.
2) The early omicron variants have a set of mutations that would be consistent with evolution in a non-human host, overlapping most strongly with mice biology.
3) Perhaps even more significantly, _later_ omicron variants that have spread through human populations have picked up mutations that are once again more consistent with human biology. So the paper manages to show both positive and negative data toward their hypothesis, which makes it stronger.
For the TL;DR crowd, figure 3 summarizes this pretty well.
To analogize this in computer terms, it's as if someone was tracing the evolution of memes by observing the types of compression artifacts introduced in various re-compressions of the meme. For example, JPEG might introduce artifacts related to DCT math, whereas JPEG-2000 would introduce artifacts related to wavelet math. The analysis shows that the artifacts of this new Omicron meme has compression artifacts consistent with, say, Wavelet compression up until it jumped to being shared by JPEG-users, at which point newer modifications to the Omicron 'meme' show JPEG-consistent artifacts.
That's basically the scientific core of the paper. So, to contest the validity of the paper, I think it would be helpful to find citations that dispute the observation that mutations accumulate with a certain bias based on the host biology, rather than whattaboutism pointing to other hypotheses and leaving it at "there are other alternative explanations" therefore this paper is not interesting.
So, while I don't dispute your statement that there are other alternative explanations, what I would really like to see are comments addressing the core scientific thesis of the paper, which is that certain mutations appear more frequently in other host biologies; and that the first omicron cases showed a preponderance of these differently-biased mutations; and that since it has been circulating in humans, the later mutations are once again consistent with a human host.
At the very least, I thought it was a very interesting analysis, as I had never seen the molecular bias of mutations used as a proxy for host biology before. If this is true, then viruses that can spread through alternate host biologies would gain a diversity of mutations that would be less available co-evolving with a single host, which could lead to evolutionary advantages over viruses that are unable to hop between hosts.
Those on the bottom of the totem pole need the recognition, esteem, and resume building much more than the CEOs.
Once you are selling to customers like that, you have left the realm of the so-called economically rational customer which has a value curve that seeks a good product at a fair price. Instead they feel entitled to the best product because they can/have paid the top price for it.
Thus there is going to be a subset that will deeply care that they have "the bestest of the best", and so micro differences become an obsession.
If you still don't believe me, go to Fedex.com and quote the price to ship a large screen TV from your home to Shenzhen.
The cost to put one extra box into a shipping container containing thousands of identical units, the pick up of which is scheduled months in advance (so utilization of the overall cargo ship is near ideal), is negligible. Similarly, the cost to break down the incoming shipment, warehouse it and check it in is small, because the factory ensures the correct bar codes are on the outside of the boxes. The worker checking them in is completely stateless - scan a barcode, stick the box in the rack with a light, move on, thus the worker is not specialized and cheaper. From there individual orders are scheduled and collated overnight into trucks that carry hundreds of boxes to individual cities, which are then broken down into the last mile courier.
Now, to arrange the reverse logistics within a bounded amount of time (less than two weeks, say), you are likely to have to send an empty truck to the end address; if you're lucky the route has other packages, but you can't count on it. The reverse logistics sender may not be there when the pick up arrives, so you either have to arrange multiple pickup or risk leaving the item unguarded. Then the box arrives at the local warehouse, with no specific routing information to where the rest of the inventory is, so you have a specialist inspect the box and also make sure there isn't fraud going on - eg people ordering phones and returning similarly weighted bricks. Then if you want that box to make it all the way back to the overseas factory where it was produced, you're probably booking it on an airplane, and not a cargo ship.
20x is actually on the low end. A wall wart power supply might run an incremental cost of about $1 to ship from Shenzhen to your door. Sending that same thing back to the factory by FedEx - a process that takes about a week with customs and pick up delays - probably north of $50 for the 'rack rate' retail shipper.
That bin of 'just throw it away' packages is a pretty good visualization of the cost asymmetry of reverse logistics. That, and how the delivered cost of an item is often 4-5x over the 'ex factory' cost, so altogether it's cost effective on average to abandon mis delivered products as long as your error rate is low enough. I'd wager that the cost to handle the support ticket that reported the delivery issue alone may start to approach the ex-factory replacement value of the cheapest goods in the pile...
This is the key line for me. Why did Saura Taniguti summon police force to prevent the removal of such a hazardous object?
The link above is helpful but you have to dig through a very long Portuguese website to find this key nugget (via Google translate):
> However, at the end of 1985, this institute stopped working in these facilities and moved to other new facilities. Meanwhile, the property of the clinic's services was disputed in court, and the cobalt 60 teletherapy unit was transferred to the new facilities and the teletherapy unit in Cesio 137 was abandoned in its original place because it was embargoed.
> Most part of the clinic was demolished as well as adjacent properties. The treatment rooms in the fueron were demolished but were in a ruined state, abandoned. The date has not been notified to the licensing authority - Comisión Nacional de Energía Nuclear: CNEN.
https://scienceinfo.net/nuclear-disaster-from-a-stolen-medic... adds that:
> According to [Saura Taniguti], because there was a dispute between IGR and Saint Vincent de Paul Association - which owned the real estate block - where the IGR Hospital was located, and the court had a sealed order and cut it [sic]. security guards should all equipment in the hospital must remain the status quo.
My guess is the events were probably something a bit like the following:
1. IGR decides to relocate.
2. The technicians in IGR seemed very aware of how dangerous the Cesium source was. It was likely installed in a large machine, that would be inaccessible until most of the other items in the facility had been relocated.
3. Furthermore, to move such a source, they would not just pick it up and carry it in their pocket - you'd book perhaps an armored/lead-lined car, carry Gieger counters, dose badges, and wear contamination suits in case of an incident. Speculation: IGR thought it would be prudent to have most of the facility moved by untrained movers, but leave the nuclear source in place to reduce risk of an incident. Once the facility was emptied, they could bring in the the hazmat suits and move the source more safely.
4. All articles agree that the landlord, SVPA, is unhappy. Speculation: IGR had to terminate its lease early, or SVPA couldn't find a new tenant to cover their losses on the space.
5. After the initial move of the "easy" items, SVPA learns some "important equipment" is still on premises. They move to seal the building, to gain leverage in court negotiations.
6. The court negotiations go on for two years. Meanwhile, the developer moves to demolish the property so that it may be redeveloped so they can monetize the land. Speculation: offers were made to move the radiation source, but this would only be allowed if IGR would, for example, agree to pay for the cost of the broken lease and lost rent. (This is almost the exact situation of the SFO Safer, the oil storage unit off the coast of Yemen; people want to make it safe, and have been try to for years; but the group controlling access to the vessel is unwilling to grant free access to it, because the vessel in its current state is too valuable for negotiations).
7. The IGR was prevented "by police" from moving the source on May 4 1987. While the source could have been carried out by one person, nobody who knew how dangerous it was would just casually carry it out. Speculation IGR made a last-ditch to recover the source, and a task force arrived with e.g. Geiger counters, hazmat suits and a containment vessel. This did not go unnoticed -- authorities were notified; police came to enforce the embargo, because once the radiation source was removed, SVPA would lose a key negotiating chip.
That would be my "read between the lines" of how the situation might have played out. Once the leak happened, of course, the finger pointing would begin and presumably someone with sufficient connections to prevent the radiation source from being removed would also have sufficient connections to pin the blame on someone else for having it not removed.
The incident reminds me a bit of the port explosion in Beirut -- authorities were made aware of the danger, but the right thing simply couldn't happen in time, and the entropy of the universe eventually won out.
edit: formatting and correction of acronym
If you miss your chance to challenge the patent before it issues, the cost to protest goes way up, even if your arguments would have been just as valid during the publication phase.
I get that the system is trying to reward vigilance, but it punishes people who put more time into sharing ideas than protecting them, especially considering the PTO does not search most modern repositories of open source for prior art.
I personally haven't had any vendors in China eat the cost of tariffs. Export terms are often FOB or EXW which means variable tariff costs get eaten by the importer or distributor. Even if a large buyer like Walmart owns/jv/leases a facility in China, to say the tariff is borne by the China entity is like saying money in the left pocket is different from money in the right pocket... eventually the cost catches up to them. It'd be helpful to share citations on arrangements where the manufacturer simply ate the cost of the tariff, it could help to educate a lot of struggling importers and small businesses.
Is it just that we forgot that these cost increases and trade barriers are still in effect, or is it that the trade war is so politically popular that even the suggestion of perhaps suspending it for a couple of years is simply unmentionable?
In other words, your argument is like saying occam's razor concludes that fire extinguishers start fires because they are always found in the vicinity of fires.
Also I think many on this thread greatly underestimate the adaptive and evolutionary capabilities of nature. Having done some wet lab myself, I'm impressed at the ability of nature to do lateral gene transfer, and also it's damn hard to make any experiments work. Plus there are multiple layers of safety and containment around any lab experiment. Movies make engineering look like AI robots in labs and biology experiments that work on the first try, and people who say lab near outbreak must implicate the lab have probably spent more time watching movies about outbreaks than trying to engineer organisms themselves. Having spent a lot of time trying and failing to engineer organisms, occam's razor screams to me that the most likely explanation is natural evolution.
The real lab of concern are the hundreds of millions of people living in close contact with animal reservoirs, performing millions of competitive, uncontrolled evolution experiments daily, with single hosts sometimes simultaneously infected by multiple viruses, thus facilitating lateral gene transfer... and this continues to be the status quo. If you can accept that MERS and SARS CoV-1 are naturally evolved, then occam's razor would indicate that SARS CoV-2 is just one point in a series, and yet another coronavirus outbreak is likely to emerge in the next decade or so, from a dense urban area near animal reservoirs.
Distracting ourselves by fantasizing that only humans could be so devious to create such a virus makes us miss a very important opportunity to try and prevent the next outbreak through careful monitoring and research.
So, if you believe that we should have fire departments and fire extinguishers near ignition sources then, maybe we should have /more/ labs like Wuhan's in high risk areas, not less. And we'd want to encourage more cross border cooperation, not antagonize it, because viruses don't give a damn about your politics.
It's concerning that threads like this, on a forum as ostensibly pro-science as HN, are pushing ourselves further away from science and transparency...