HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

byerley

156 karma · joined March 27, 2013

submissionscomments
byerley··on U.S. Is No. 1, China Is So Yesterday
It's interesting to note that people always leave off the other end of the wealth inequality figures. - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Share_top_1_percent.jpg

The top 1% share is roughly the same now as it was in the 1930's. The "Great Compression" afterwards was largely fueled by government regulation (as best as I can understand it - not being an economics guy) so I'm not convinced that the gap will continue to grow.

byerley··on U.S. Is No. 1, China Is So Yesterday
Having studied at both a cheap state university and also one of the famed "top 20," I'd wholeheartedly argue that the educational opportunities at the two were similar if not the same.

The degree from the latter is potentially worth more in the job market, but the level of education you come away with is largely a matter of personal drive - especially now that information is so readily available everywhere.

byerley··on Why I Am Not An Integrated Information Theorist (or, The Unconscious Expander)
I'd argue that the author's views are too concerned with intuition. If we reduce consciousness to a scale rather than a binary property; of course a thermostat is somewhere on the scale, it simply has such a small value that it's not worth considering - leading to our philosophical intuition. There's nothing magical about our level of consciousness; as unintuitive as that may be. Aaronson argues that the model must yield to our intuition, but if the model is consistent and explains our observations, our intuition should yield to it. - the obvious analog here being quantum mechanics

In regards to saying "both that the Hard Problem is meaningless, and that progress in neuroscience will soon solve the problem if it hasn’t already," neuroscientists and mathematicians too often overlook the Turing test here. It's consistent (if not accurate) to say that the "Hard Problem" is ill-defined, but maintain that we've clearly solved it if we can comprehensively beat the Turing test. That's what the Turing test was designed for, knowing that we've created a conscious machine because it's indistinguishable from a human; even if we can't decide on what consciousness is.

byerley··on Why I Never Hire Brilliant Men (1924)
I mean,

If I repeatedly get fucked up and crash Fords over the course of my life while having much better luck with other cars, I might start looking for a causal relationship.

byerley··on Computing 10,000X more efficiently (2010) [pdf]
Probably more relevant is the greatly reduced clock speed (ignoring that the brain doesn't so much have a centralized clock - neurons only fire at <1k Hz compared to the ~2k Ghz processors used in clusters).

The technology also seems somewhat incomparable. The purely chemical signal processing at the synaptic cleft presumably saves a lot of power.

byerley··on A Star in a Bottle
Perhaps scarier and more accurate is the idea that it's done for a very good reason, but that we lack the context/intelligence to understand it as individuals. No one wants to be the organism in a superorganism.
byerley··on Voevodsky’s Mathematical Revolution
I was under the impression that even verification is Turing undecidable in general - ie http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entscheidungsproblem
byerley··on California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
I cringed when I saw "informal survey," but this seems to be in the important bit -

"In most cases, the scam began through Facebook and ended when “Gary Jones” gained access to the victim’s email account."

Unfortunately it doesn't make a lot of sense without context that I can't fine in the article. Was it phishing?

byerley··on California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
The problem is that people have gotten comfortable with the idea that it's acceptable to hate someone for their hateful beliefs - forgetting that virtually every belief can be considered hateful with the right spin.

While I think this case had mitigating factors and the guy could have been charged anyway, I certainly don't trust the jerks in the DA's office to decide who the other jerks are.

byerley··on California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
When has the media ever had a good handle on what "hacking" means and how prevalent it is?

Why would someone with the ability to "hack" a large number of gmail accounts choose nude photos to make their money with? I can't imagine the payoff is comparatively good and large-scale blackmail is a pretty good way to get targeted for prosecution.

Further, aren't these pictures in their email because they were sent to someone? How would the average person distinguish between their account being "hacked" for the purpose of retrieving the picture opposed to the receiver sharing it? It sounds more like the instinctual "my account was hacked!" response to something embarrassing.

byerley··on Riot tells pro League of Legends players they can’t stream competing games
I suspect it's the opposite. The current trend was to play another game (Hearthstone in particular) and in some cases the streamer would actually keep playing Hearthstone during champ select/the beginning of the game - a really bad message to be sending your customers (especially with free-to-play games where someone spending money with a competitor means disposable income they can't spend on you).

People who read the news stories might think it sounds controlling (but the number of people who read the story and get notably upset is very small compared to the people watching these streams).

Seems like a calculated and rational choice by Riot.

byerley··on Nearly All Binary Searches and Mergesorts are Broken (2006)
As a theory guy I'd argue you're looking at it backwards.

The proofs are fine in that the correctness logically follows given the appropriate assumptions. In this particular example, it's implicitly assumed that integer overflow isn't a concern. Ideally, something like that should be explicitly stated, but let's be honest, Algorithms and Math in general have to be shorthand heavy - the alternative is painful and often not human readable.

It's always been the responsibility of the implementer to dive deep enough into the theory to grasp all the omitted assumptions. A less gratuitous headline might read - "Common implementation pitfalls: Integer Overflow"

byerley··on How Chris McCandless Died
McCandless had a map (though given that Krakauer himself perpetrated the myth, you can't really be faulted for thinking otherwise). Wikipedia, as well as the movie and a variety of primary sources make it clear that one was found among his possession. It's also possible, if not likely, that the onset of lathyrism left him no window for realizing his plight and walking out - the damage was irreversible at the time of ingestion (I'm admittedly sketchy on how fast the onset actually is - presumably it varies a lot).

Personally, I find the details completely beside the point. McCandless sacrificed everything to test his philosophical conjecture and I have nothing but respect for that. I honestly would've thought there'd be more empathy for it here.

byerley··on [dead]
While I doubt it's an issue in practice, I have a real hard time believing that a compromised source of randomness actually improves the function. If it does, the algorithm is presumably not well designed in the first place - which would be similarly concerning.
byerley··on Strongbox and Aaron Swartz
There's a difference between being security-minded and being a crypto-nut. If you're proud of the work you're doing and it's not secretive, why bother encrypting the hard-drive? Similarly, he wouldn't have been caught in the first place if he had been security-nutty about the process, but he didn't think he was doing anything immoral.
byerley··on Global Internet slows after 'biggest attack in history'
'Security experts' are full of it. Root DNS servers have seen attacks on the same scale regularly.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3