HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

calhoun137

1,201 karma · joined February 8, 2013

I am a builder, not a breaker.
submissionscomments
calhoun137··on The Two Pillars of JavaScript: Part 1: How to Escape the 7th Circle of Hell
Javascript is a great language, and people who hate on it are very often just mindlessly repeating what they heard somewhere.

A person I used to work with liked to hate on js constantly. Then I looked at his code. He was trying to write js like it was java, because that was his background! If I wrote js like that, then I would hate it too.

If you don't know the fundamental concepts of a language, then you are clearly not in a position to take advantage of it's built in characteristics. Different languages have different "natural logical patterns" that take advantage of that languages design choices. By learning these patterns in one language, then when working in a different language if you get stuck you will have them available.

This article makes the point that you should avoid trying to do standard OOP in js, and I would generalize this idea as follows:

Every programming language has its own unique attributes, conventions, patterns, etc... when working in a new language, it's important to learn how to write in that language's style, instead of imposing a different languages style.

calhoun137··on Scientific Peer Review Is Broken – Fighting to Fix It with Anonymity
You should read the last link in the article. The whole thing is a great read actually. But take a look especially at the results section that starts on page 22. It proves very convincingly that "for each of the 28 image-issues... evaluated, strong evidence supports the conclusion that the images are not authentic or contain other irregularities symptomatic of tampering": https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/files/assets/krueger_affi...
calhoun137··on Excuse Me While I Kiss This Guy: The Science of Misheard Song Lyrics
"A dead head sticking off a cadillac" -from boys of summer
calhoun137··on The story of Jelani Henry, who says Facebook likes landed him in Rikers
This was a very disturbing read. Nice work.
calhoun137··on The Saddest Thing I Know about the Integers
If you haven't seen Qiaochu's answer about this subject over at math stack exchange, it's easily one of the best answers on any stack exchange site: http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/11669/mathematical-d...
calhoun137··on Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence
This article makes a number of very bold claims about poorly defined concepts, and provides zero evidence to back anything it says up.
calhoun137··on A clock that can detect tiny shifts in the flow of time itself
Your counter argument is correct, in my opinion.
calhoun137··on Have We Been Interpreting Quantum Mechanics Wrong This Whole Time?
I would characterize these fluid dynamics experiments as "very cute", but nothing more.

One of the sad things about physics these days is that it has become more like religion in a bad way. I first heard about Bohmenian mechanics, which this article is about, 8 years ago. I never believed in it, and always thought it was silly. I say "believe" because at this point it really is a question of faith.

It was amusing to me to read this article, it makes all the same points I used to argue against but in a very clever and well written way. What the Bohmeanian mechanics people used to say was the only reason they couldn't respond to this or that problem with the theory was "not enough people were working on it".

From the article:

"Some researchers said that [Bohmean Mechanics] has trouble dealing with identical particles, and that it becomes unwieldy when describing multiparticle interactions. They also claimed that it combines less elegantly with special relativity. But other specialists in quantum mechanics disagreed or said the approach is simply under-researched."

calhoun137··on Researchers see signature of “Majorana particles” inside superconducting iron
There is a pretty strong overlap between material science and quantum field theory. To name just one example, the idea of the Higg's particle actually has it's genesis in theoretical solid state physics [1].

Most material solids can be described as a lattice, where there is some unit cell of a given size, say L, which is repeated periodically in all directions.

There are various types "quasi-particles" that can move through a lattice, examples include phonon's and poloron's. The thing that makes the quasi-particle concept useful is that it is greatly simplifies the description of the collective motion of a large number of particles which are all interacting.

An electromagnetic field in a region of space can (sort of) be described as a lattice, and this result is one of the deepest and most profound results in theoretical physics, imo. The basic idea is the EM field can be thought of in the following way: every point in space can be treated mathematically as a simple vibrating spring (harmonic oscillator).

In other words, the analogy between fundamental particles and quasi-particles breaks down because in a material solid there is a unit cell of size L, but in the vacuum this lattice size is 0.

The idea that every point in space is a harmonic oscillator works in the sense that it makes predictions that agree with experiment; however theoretically it has an extremely severe flaw which has motivated a large amount of research on the quantum vacuum. The problem is that the energy of a region of space with zero EM field (i.e. a vacuum) comes out to be infinite. There are various tricks to avoid this infinity, but the simplest one is to just use some non-zero value for the lattice spacing of the vacuum.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_Warren_Anderson

calhoun137··on Researchers see signature of “Majorana particles” inside superconducting iron
This article does demonstrate the principle that virtually every area of active research in material science, no matter how obscure, will one day have a Very Important Application in Quantum Computers. sigh
calhoun137··on Fourier Image Filtering
I am willing to accept that "audio engineering is much more complex" than I seem to think it is, and because of your comment I will look more closely into things before making any claims like that again.

Would you be willing to explain in more detail the "good reasons why they're not a one-size-fits-all solution for audio effects"?

calhoun137··on Fourier Image Filtering
Since you used the example of sound engineer's, I would like to expand on the point I made in my previous comment about pro tools; and also clarify that I believe sound engineer's and graphic designers are a smart bunch, and are more than capable of handling it.

I actually recently went to a studio and worked with a professional sound engineer. Most of the time, he would right click on a track, and then select from a list of filters to apply to some segment. These filters have a GUI that looks like an effects pedal with knobs etc... Having used many of these programs myself, I can assure you virtually nothing is based on fourier methods, even though this is all that these effects pedals are doing, often with large amounts of redundancy.

A curious fact is that a large majority of the popular types of effects pedals actually correspond to the most well studied convolutions, which is something I hope and plan to research more carefully and write up in a blog post one day soon.

Effects pedals for guitars were originally circuits discovered basically by chance; and it was only much later that these things were made digital. This clearly demonstrates the problem I was talking about when I said there is a "massive inertia against re-formulating the entire UI/UX for ... filtering based on the only possible unified approach"

calhoun137··on Fourier Image Filtering
This is very cool and impressive, really good job!

Image filtering is a popular subject these days thanks partly to Instagram, and this subject is on the boundary between art and science, which is nice for a change of pace sometimes.

Anyway, to master image filtering in photoshop/GIMP for example requires learning a (very) large number of words and concepts which seemingly have no organizational structure. These words/concepts exist for historical reasons, and not because they represent some sort of cohesive or unified approach to filtering in general. The exact same problem exists for simulating effects pedals for guitars in programs like Pro Tools, interestingly.

Only Fourier methods can possibly unify this type of filtering, for a number of reasons which are actually obvious to anyone who is familiar with the fundamental role played by these methods in analysis.

The problem seems to be that the people who actually use this stuff all the time do not know Fourier methods and are not in a position to learn it; and this has created a massive inertia against re-formulating the entire UI/UX for image filtering based on the only possible unified approach.

It might be thought that Fourier methods are too hard for a graphic designer to understand, but I believe that it is up to people like us who do understand these things to redo the entire approach to filtering from square one, based on Fourier methods. In fact, I believe such an approach will make this subject much more accessible to everyone, and will be significantly easier for power users as well.

calhoun137··on What Is Time?
Time is reversible in general relativity, in the sense that if you replace t by -t everywhere the solution is still valid. I don't remember the full proof off the top of my head, and the argument I do remember is complicated.
calhoun137··on Astrophysicists propose new twist on Big Bang
I think this idea is almost certainly false, and it has it's genesis from a mostly discredited psuedo-physics theory called the holographic universe[1]. But at least there is a testable prediction! In my opinion, the fact that they offer a testable prediction merits a more thorough consideration of the claims.

First of all, it has been well understood for multiple decades that the General Relativity(GR) breaks down, and is no longer true, at mass/energy scales that are present inside of a black hole. This is known because physical quantities must be finite, but GR predicts the strength of a gravitational field inside of a black hole is infinite. If string theory is true (and I don't believe it is), then this would be a valid situation to apply it to, since we know that there is unknown physics at play inside of a black hole.

Furthermore, the standard big bang cosmology is based on the idea that the beginning of time is a "black hole in time", in the sense that as t->0, the strength of the gravitational field diverges to infinity. Thus, it has been well known for decades that GR is not a valid physical theory at very short time scales after the beginning of time (this would be the epoch of inflation[3]).

It is perhaps not apparent to the casual observer that this paper is based on a very bizarre sect within string theory, known as the "Holographic Universe", which according to Wikipedia "suggests that the entire universe can be seen as a two-dimensional information structure "painted" on the cosmological horizon". This is just a bunch of fancy words designed to blow smoke in your eyes, and the entire theory is sort of a joke as far as most physicists I know are concerned.

There are actually a number of strange cults within string theory, another one that is good for a laugh is the Anthropic Princple[4]. This theory claims that even though the 11 dimensional D-Brane that is folded into a Calubi-Yau manifold upon which string theory is based predicts trillions of possible universes, the universe we live in exists because it is the only possible one we could live in:

"the conditions happen to be just right for the existence of (intelligent) life on the earth at the present time. For if they were not just right, then we should not have found ourselves to be here now, but somewhere else, at some other appropriate time."

This kind of nonsense is why I left research in theoretical physics to purse computer science and programming, which truly is the cutting edge of science. There is a lot of valuable physics research going on in material science departments(for example), but the string theory department needs to constantly justify their funding by making extremely bold claims such as "what we perceive as the Big Bang could be the three-dimensional “mirage” of a collapsing star in a universe profoundly different than our own".

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D-brane

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_(cosmology)

[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle

calhoun137··on Most Math Problems Do Not Have a Unique Right Answer
There is a funny story about Gauss from the book Men of Mathematics, in which Gauss asked two of his students to compute a certain infinite series to 30 decimal places. After many days and nights, the students had a disagreement over what number was in the 30th decimal place, so they asked for help. After looking at the calculations for a few seconds, Gauss accurately pointed at the correct answer and went back to what he was doing.
calhoun137··on Most Math Problems Do Not Have a Unique Right Answer
It is refreshing to find an article with a false title that contains it's own refutation within the first five paragraphs:

"The only career in which a high school graduate can expect to continue to work on [problems with a unique correct answer] is academic research in pure mathematics"

Unfortunately for this article, the premise that mathematics is the same thing as engineering is false.

If an engineering problem does not have a unique solution, its because of complications introduced by the real world. Any engineering problem which can be well-posed as a pure math problem, does of course have a unique solution; as the author concedes.

calhoun137··on The Axiom of Choice is Wrong (2007)
The comment section on this blog post is spectacular. Many of the comments are by very accomplished mathematicians.
calhoun137··on The Axiom of Choice is Wrong (2007)
A mathematical axiom cannot be wrong, since by definition an axiom is always true. More accurately, a system of axioms can be vacuous, in the sense that it leads to conclusions that are logically impossible.

To ask "Is the axiom of choice true" requires that we agree on the meaning of 'truth', which is of course a very complicated philosophical question.

The author tries to make an appeal to our intuition by describing an example that (supposedly) takes place in the real world, but the real world is the realm of physics. In physics, truth derives from the result of experiments; whereas in mathematics, true statements are derived from a set of axioms.

Considering that an axiom is a rule that is made up by a person, and that there are an infinite number of consistent axiom systems, the question of the "truth" of a set of axioms has no meaning, unless we are actually asking, is a given axiom necessary for an accurate description of nature.

As far as I am aware there is no part of physics in which the axiom of choice plays any direct role.

calhoun137··on Introducing Anonymous Login and an Updated Facebook Login
This is a huge win for all of the people who use facebook login that care about remaining anonymous on the internet.
calhoun137··on Is There Anything Beyond Quantum Computing?
The most important application of quantum computers seems to actually be to enable scientists who do fundamental research to answer questions from reporters such as "What practical purpose does your research serve?" with a single catch all buzz word. So the answer to the title of this article is clearly: Yes.
calhoun137··on Mathematics: Why the brain sees maths as beauty
> In short, humans see math as beautiful because it is a signal for intelligence, which is a deciding factor of fitness in our evolution

I disagree, although I think I see where you are coming from. Perceiving beauty is a form of pleasure, and the brain feels pleasure as the result of a chemical process. The real question is what causes the brain to initiate that process. Certainly cultural influence plays a huge role, as does the need to reproduce. But I don't see any evidence or arguments as to why that has to be the only explanation for why a person perceives beauty.

I think the concept of mathematical beauty is highly subjective, but if I had to put it into words: I think the perception of mathematical beauty is related to the human brains natural capacity to understand patterns and do mathematics.

calhoun137··on Mathematics: Why the brain sees maths as beauty
Mathematical beauty is not only for pleasure, according to the great quantum theorist Dirac, who taught us that we should let mathematical beauty guide us in our discovery of new physical laws.

This is how Dirac was able to predict the existence of anti-particles before they were discovered experimentally, and his philosophy about mathematical beauty is a cornerstone of modern theoretical physics.

calhoun137··on Google: 80% of news organisations are targeted by state hackers
If China is behind this, then they are committing a horrible crime that no free society can stand for, and the entire western world must band together to fight this menace.

If the US government is behind this, the best thing to do is form a commission to prove that no wrong doing has been done, and make sure these two "researchers" are punished as severely as extra-legally possible.

calhoun137··on Why I Eat Lunch at My Desk
I think the article, as well as many of the comments, are missing the crucial point: going out for lunch is about spending time with friends, socializing, and maintaining work/life balance. And of course, it's also about networking.

Although the article makes an interesting point about how doing work while everyone else is out to lunch can lead to accelerated career advancement; I think going out to lunch provides a valuable networking opportunity that is an important aspect of career advancement inside any organization.

calhoun137··on Apparent Theft at Mt. Gox Shakes Bitcoin World
false. that depends on the size of the bankroll.
calhoun137··on How not to write a job post
I just wrote my first every job post yesterday, what a great life experience =) !!!

Anyway I did all of these things except salary range. If I left that out, I thought it would give me more room to negotiate, it's an iOS job for a startup btw (email me if interested I guess). I mean, these iOS guys know what the going rates are, I didn't see the point of writing down a number for my first ever job post, plus I was scarred of picking the wrong number =/ How bad is it to not include the salary range type info?

calhoun137··on Economics Simulation
One flaw with this model is that the value of money is not absolute, it is relative to the price of goods and services. Furthermore, the rate of circulation of money is directly related to the amount of economic activity taking place in the society (since each transaction represents an economic event), and economic activity creates wealth as PG says.

I once tried to develop a similar theory to the link, by applying the principles of statistical mechanics, and treating the rate of circulation of money as the temperature, and each actor's amount of economic activity as their kinetic energy. It seemed like a neat approach but it has it's flaws obviously.

calhoun137··on Solution claimed for Navier-Stokes equations, one of the millennium problems
I'm curious why you think that would be funny, since in my opinion, that is the most likely outcome should such a solution exist at all.
calhoun137··on Solution claimed for Navier-Stokes equations, one of the millennium problems
A long time ago, I started working on an approach that never panned out, attempting to prove that such solutions could not exist. I will briefly mention it here in case anyone would like to comment or continue the strategy.

In [1] I learned that it is known that certain differential equations associated with embedding manifolds in R^n possess no smooth solutions. And in [2] I asked if it was possible that the Navier-Stokes equations were of this nature, since if this was the case it would create a clear path towards a negative solution. There was no definitive answer given, but the community (of mathSE) did seem to agree that it would turn it this is not the case.

[1] http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/8586/what-is-an-exam... (See Willie Wong's answer)

[2] http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/9085/manifold-interp...

← PreviousPage 6 of 10Next →