1,171 karma · joined April 2, 2009
At first glance it appears very affordable. Rents in the city center appear to be about $5 per square foot per month judging from a quick perusal of craigslist listings. So to give all 7500 homeless in the city a 100 sq foot efficiency would have plausible annual expenses of about $45 million -- a small fraction of the $300M plus mentioned in the parent article. Obviously there are many problematic details, such as there are almost no appropriate apartments currently available, but ultra-small units do exist [2] and seem to be a favorable alternative to sleeping on the street.
[1] http://www.npr.org/2015/12/10/459100751/utah-reduced-chronic... [2] http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/truly-tiny-4-apartments-unde...
It seems pretty clear to me that 10% or 20% makes a big difference. Plenty of people will move across town to pay $2,400 a month instead of $3,000, why would home-owners be fundamentally different.
The key thing is that bitcoin transactions are not reported to the government -- very helpful if you're desperate to move a large amount of cash out from a country with heavy currency controls like China or Venezuela.
These authors have developed a system to tease out the optionality using standard financial methods (using methods like Black-Scholes, for example), which can give us all a better understanding of the true worth of these companies. Far overdue in my opinion.
If you're worried about sampling bias with respect to Asian countries specifically, here's a time series analysis supporting the same conclusions [0]. Another angle that you may find interesting is that low tax US states tend to outgrow high tax US states [1].
One other way to look at is expert opinion. You'll note that under the CBO dynamic scoring methods, they assume higher economic growth under low taxes -- this is controversial politically, but the majority of economic forecasters appear to use an inverse relationship between taxes and growth -- presumably this should be worth something. Also note that, although there is not a hard, climate-style consensus, there are substantially more professional economists who believe that taxes slow growth than not as it relates to the current US system [2].
A lot of people like to point to some anecdotal evidence of good results in Sweden, but then ignore poor results in Denmark -- I think broad based statistical evidence is needed for these sorts of things since many other factors, such as debt, immigration policy, trade policy, and so forth can easily confound your results. The key is to look at the same problem from a wide variety of angles and see if a conclusion starts to emerge given that some studies will point in one direction and some will point in others. If 90% of the research is saying one thing, 8% is saying there's no effect, and 2% is pointing the other direction, what should you believe?
[0] http://www.nber.org/papers/w13264 [1] http://www.laffercenter.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/2012-... [2] http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/laffer-curvehttp://www.igm...
To answer your question more scientifically, a preponderance of the evidence does suggest that countries with smaller governments as a percent of GDP do experience higher growth in standard of living [1]. So if your goal is to maximize long term standards of living, you would tend to support a relatively smaller government than is common among rich countries today.
[0] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/10/no-not-... [1] https://taxfoundation.org/what-evidence-taxes-and-growth
Regardless, you're still at a low rate of growth, not deflation. If labor force participation was the issue, we'd see that trending up, which we do a bit, but not much.
One other theory somewhat consistent with the data is that we're seeing downward pressure from automation, yet if that was true productivity should be rising faster.
[1] https://www.clevelandfed.org/newsroom-and-events/publication...
After all of this, we're back at market socialism? You could have just said that at the start if you meant it.
>This is why I argue that it is not a possibility to have the Socialist revolution in only one country, it is unsustainable; Communism must mature to a stateless society
This is slavery. Are you mad? No choice, no flight over the border to freedom, no escape from compelled labor at the hands of your government... And all of this, for a system you admit is worse at providing a high standard of living than the status quo. What's the gain?
>the usual functions of force of the state should be abolished soon after the proletariat have taken control of it
And how does the proletariat take control anyway? Bloody revolution? Once the state dissolves the market, and then dissolves itself, the market will simply emerge again -- it has happened everywhere. Remember, you admit the co-op leads to worse outcomes than the market -- the market will re-gain control since it's better at the function of 'providing a standard of living for people,' and people want 'a standard of living'. You need a mechanism to maintain your desired social designs, if there is none, a market emerges, to prevent the market, you need totalitarianism.
It seems that you're opposed to the profit motive in it's entirety. I don't I need to tell you that every time they've tried to pull the profit motive out a system in the past, it's been a complete disaster... You can't just wave a magic wand and create a better mouse trap / make central planning work well.
You yourself admit that co-ops get crushed by for-profit companies. Won't co-op countries get crushed by for-profit countries? Therefore isn't the communist economy, by design, poorer than the market economy? Don't people in poor countries try to flee to rich countries? Sounds like the only way you can sustain such a system is with global totalitarianism. You've read Hayek right?
Yes, labor should be compensated according to it's quality. You appear to be saying that, by and large, it is not. Yet if management and labor are one in the same, then who is setting the compensation rates for labor except labor itself? By that same logic, capital is only deferred consumption derived from labor -- meaning everything is labor. Meaning labor is extracting surplus from itself... At which point the attempt to moralize labor as deserving and capital as non-deserving collapses upon itself. The system is a process. It goes round and round. People who are talented get bigger shares because they produce more. Anyone who saves to create capital gets compensated for that as well. Where is the surplus?
>it is not the combination that creates value, the inputs to the process give a value
I'm not sure this is a meaningful distinction. Where is a surplus created in this process?
>My point is that your argument for good direction requiring, for whatever reason, the surplus extracted from workers, would also seem to apply to good labour requiring surplus, which it clearly does not, as there is good labour while the workers are not rewarded with the surplus extracted from them.
I was trying to speak to you on your terms. Remember I lead by saying the 'surplus', as you're defining it, doesn't exist. What is 'good labor' and what is 'not rewarded'? You're resting your entire argument on normative, non-falsifiable judgments.
This can't possibly be true. If so, what explains the legions of so called undeserving 'Rich Techies'. Some kid makes a windfall writing code on his laptop -- That's labor, right?
Everyone needs to get paid for what they put in -- by and large, there is no surplus.
Contrasting Marx, there are really three, not two groups here. Labor, Capital, and 'Strategic Management' or 'Direction'. Capital is profit that has been saved for the purpose of investment instead of immediate consumption. You can't lease the factory if you've spent everything already, so you need to have some return on investment going to capital in order to compensate them for abstaining from consumption. Labor obviously needs to be compensated in order to work. Direction (who is often also capital, but may be a CEO, Entrepreneur or Inventor without capital), then combines labor and capital in a way that creates value. The problem, if there is one, is that good Direction can create a LOT of value vs bad Direction (e.g. Steve Jobs, Michael Jackson, or Ron Popeil) -- if 'surplus' exists, it's by and large going to the creators of Direction, or Managers, and not capital. However, most would call this 'compensation' for creating value.
Put it this way: Labor stays poor, Capital stays rich, and Direction gets rich. So I do not agree with your first quoted question, because the 'product', is inferior if no 'surplus' goes to compensate good Direction.
http://www.businessinsider.com/blackrock-sp-500-vs-equity-fu...
https://taxfoundation.org/how-scandinavian-countries-pay-the...
Sweden itself would be marked by much higher VAT/Sales taxes -- which collect about 9% of GDP in SWE vs 2% of GDP in the US -- as well as higher income taxes, collecting 22% of GDP vs 15% in the US. Also, despite much higher corporate statutory tax rates, the US does not raise a larger % of GDP from corporate taxes. I was also surprised to see the top income tax rate in SWE phase in at only 1.5x the median income vs 8.5x in the USA. They also have higher income taxes on middle and low earners. Because of this, more of the difference in total tax burden seems to fall on the middle class than is commonly thought.
[1] http://www.businessandeconomics.mq.edu.au/our_departments/Ec...
Very hard to say if that will come true though, if automation dramatically speeds up, we would see a surge in productivity. Yet in recent years, we are seeing slower, rather than faster productivity growth relative to the long term trend. Take note that the doomsday jobs predictions implicitly forecast that we'll be making more stuff, using less effort, meaning society will be richer.
From a tax policy perspective, a VAT addresses Gate's concerns pretty well.
http://blog.cordantwealth.com/how-much-can-i-spend-in-retire...?
source: http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042415/what-average-...
In my opinion, cheap luxury clones don't work because the market is too small. Plenty of people like the idea of a 'cool' car, but the car is a big ticket item for most people, so practical, reliable and having a good resale value tend to trump 'cool' as an important feature. You'll also note that classic, 'boring' colors tend to outsell flashy, 'cool' colors. Even the best selling sports cars in the mid-price segment, e.g. VW GTI, tend to have a hatchback and a large, useful interior that is workable for a family car.
Fun fact: The Fiero was featured in the movie Ferris Bueller's Day Off as the car owned by the feature character's sister.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pontiac_Fiero [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_Corrado
Your 50% number is more commonly called the 'labor force participation rate' and it's near 63% right now [1], but has trended down for the past few decades. I would argue (as Keynes did) that if work force participation falls and standards of living continues to rise (or stay flat) then society is having good results.
[1] http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/susan-jones/94333000-not...
>"we don't need to worry at all, everything will work out"
Strawman of course. A nuanced understanding of the historical context of other technological booms is the point of my original post and it's specifically the 'omg AI gonna take our jerbs' kneejerk reaction that I wanted to preempt. I would add that statisticians seem to be less worried about AI threats than your average HNer [1]. And although I don't have a handy source, I know that economists are also likely to brush aside predictions of major impacts.
[1] https://ai100.stanford.edu/2016-report/executive-summary