HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

codyrobbins

1,168 karma · joined January 30, 2009

Former CTO of a few venture-backed startups and advisor to others. I’m trained as an engineer in both computer science and electrical engineering and later as a research linguist specializing in theoretical syntactic models. I have a strong technical background in modern web and mobile technologies and extensive applied experience in the product and business side of startups.

     Email: cody@codyrobbins.com
       Web: codyrobbins.com
   Twitter: twitter.com/codyrobbins
    GitHub: github.com/codyrobbins
 AngelList: angel.co/codyrobbins
  Facebook: facebook.com/codyrobbins
  LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/codyrobbins
submissionscomments
codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
I guess my comments may come across as slightly antagonistic, but I don’t mean them that way at all. I’m just very excited about the topic of language in general.

I should tell you that I have a masters degree in linguistics, so I’m not pulling any of this out of thin air. Most of the arguments I’ve made are more or less generally understood among the linguistic community. Most of the objections and issues you are raising are the kind of questions that are dealt with in undergraduate linguistics courses.

I don’t have time to continue discussing this today unfortunately, but if you’re really interested in this stuff, you should reader The Language Instinct by Steven Pinker. He does a far better job at systematically explaining these issues than I do. Something like The Foundations of Language by Jackendoff is much more technical but also a very good introduction.

http://www.amazon.com/Language-Instinct-Steven-Pinker/dp/006...

http://www.amazon.com/Foundations-Language-Meaning-Grammar-E...

codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
Again, you’re missing the point. I can’t prescriptively judge whether something is grammatical or not, nor can anyone else. Grammaticality isn’t something which someone decides — a grammatical sentence is by definition a sentence which speakers of the language produce and understand. It is grammatical if people use it. If there is a particular dialect of English where they use isn’t as the first person singular form of the copula, then it is grammatical.

It would not be grammatical in the standard American English dialect, which I think is what you’re getting at. But you have to be careful with your terms here, because in the technical sense ‘grammatical’ means an acceptable sentence of the language, whereas I have a feeling your understanding of ‘grammatical’ means ‘how we were taught to write in school to communicate to other people that we have been educated’. My entire point is that there’s a difference.

You would probably call the sentence

  He been had that job.
completely ungrammatical. In Black Vernacular English, however, it’s perfectly acceptable. What’s more, depending on the pronunciation of been, this sentence can communicate a tense that doesn’t exist in standard American English. In SAE it can only be communicated by adjunct material like ‘for a long time’. Ostensibly, this is more efficient.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_American_Vernacular_Eng...

codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
He said people were lazy and ignorant for using could care less. I’d consider that equivalent to calling them wrong. You’re just nit-picking.
codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
The presence of the apostrophe is an orthographic convention and has nothing to do with language in the least. There’s no apostrophe in it’s when people pronounce it.
codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
Notice that in the "care less" example, it is the phrase that has changed, whilst the surrounding language has remained the same, whilst in the "board" example the phrase has remained the same, whilst the surrounding language has changed.

I used room and board for the sake of argument because I felt it was easy to understand. It may be true that the meaning of could care less has changed, but Pinker’s analysis is that it has not — it always meant the opposite of its literal interpretation.

You really can’t imagine some kid intoning in a sickly sarcastic voice to their parents, ‘Oh, I could SO care less!’? You must realize the kind of massive influence youth subcultures have on the language, and from there it’s really not a big leap to image how a usage could enter the language that means the opposite of its literal interpretation.

"Room and board" is not in popular usage whilst "I could care less" is (as far as I understand). Thus the potential for confusion is greater.

Completely disagree. A quick look at the number of hits in Google’s index shows that they’re both in common use:

  2,220,000 for "could care less”
  1,960,000 for "room and board"
Anecdotal, but telling. If you really wanted me to, I could do a corpus search in the Corpus of Contemporary American English, but I expect the results would be about the same.

"Room and board" has a long established use. The use of "could care less" is much more recent.

I checked the OED and could care less seems to have been in use since the 1960s. Therefore, both phrases have been in use since well before I was born. So, for me, and most people who aren’t really old, they’re both completely established.

If you found the phrase confused you, I'd comply.

The crux, though, is that it would still be in the language. Just because you stop producing it doesn’t mean it’s been wiped from existence. If someone came up to you and used it, you couldn’t help but understand what they just said to you. More importantly, though, there’s no reason why you should stop using perfectly legitimate language just because someone else says it doesn’t make sense, but when it’s obvious that it does make sense, because everyone understands you when you say it.

codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
The burden for justifying the change lies with those supporting the change.

You’re the one categorically claiming that the way people talk is somehow ‘wrong’. If you want to make that claim, you need to support it. Without going into highly technical details, I explained some ways why the usage could make sense. Your response was simply to say, as if declaring it somehow makes it true, that there is no reason for the usage.

There is nothing anecdotal about my experience. If I have to blink and think twice about what someone is saying, then he is using nonstandard idiom.

By definition your experience is anecdotal. I doubt you have to think twice when someone says it, but we’d have to subject you to an experiment to be sure. But simply put, there are so many cognitive biases that may potentially be at work that you really can’t reliably judge yourself whether it takes you longer to process. Sentence processing happens on the order of tens of milliseconds.

That stuff can fossilize, doesn't mean we should let it fossilize.

You’re assuming that you have some control over whether the use develops in the language. I’m saying that’s a flawed assumption and that you don’t.

If you’re so sure the usage is wrong, it may be interesting to note how many hits there are for each phrase in Google’s index:

  2,220,000 for "could care less"
  1,410,000 for "couldn't care less"
I readily admit that this, too, is anecdotal evidence. But it’s quite telling, no?
codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
It’s funny, because you’re not inclined to have a practical discussion rather than a philosophical one — my entire point is that by declaring that people are speaking the language ‘wrong’, you are yourself introducing the entire philosophical question of what ‘wrong’ means. You can’t say people are speaking the language wrong unless you’re ready to define what ‘wrong’ means. And I think you’ve realized that there’s no good way to answer that question.

Can you give me another example of where we use the word board in English to mean food? If not, I could ask you never use the phrase room and board again. But that would be silly. It does not matter whether could care less is a one-off instance — it is an idiom and that is the entire point. It does not matter whether you argue that the phrase adds unnecessary complexity to the language: it is already in the language despite your objections, because people use it. There’s nothing you can do to change that. Language is what people say; if they say it, it’s language.

It does not impede understanding because the idiomatic usage is pronounced differently. There is no confusion and no ambiguity. What you are saying simply isn’t the case.

Finally, it’s not the case that we ‘may or may not’ be going through a period of transition in the language. Language change is always happening.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_change

codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
No, that’s not really what I’m saying at all. Human language is not simply a series of control paths that branch the way you’ve described. That’s exactly how people tried to program computers to understand language 50 years ago, and what resulted is toy things like Eliza.

What I said is that the two uses are entirely different words, because they’re pronounced differently. You’re right that it’s bizarre — that’s why no one knows how language works yet.

Taking the stance that people speak English ‘wrong’ is not a simple interpretation, because it leads to the following question: please define what ‘wrong’ means.

codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
I’m not presenting it as a reason or justification, but as a fact. You, personally, are unable to engineer the course of the language, and your resistance to a change does not stop the change from occurring. The language does not need your acceptance for change to occur. It may seem to you like it’s changing for no reason whatsoever, but that’s only because — sitting there in your armchair — you’re unable to come up with a good reason off the top of your head.

Saying that it takes you longer to parse the sentence is anecdotal nonsense, because there’s no way for you to measure that without doing a controlled psycholinguistics experiment.

What I said was fairly clear, but to be explicit, room and board is relevant to could care less because it shows that forms can fossilize. It does not matter that board doesn’t mean ‘food’ anymore, just as it no longer matters that could care less means the opposite of what it would literally. You don’t mention my example of a little bird told me, but it is relevant because it shows that idioms do not have to be interpreted as the literal sum of their parts (and, in fact, by definition, aren’t).

You’re missing the point of just about everything I originally said, and you really don’t address any of the arguments I brought up, other than to say you fail to understand them.

codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
Yes, that’s a very insightful remark! I was going to mention that human language and programming languages are fundamentally different things, but I already wrote too much.

Interestingly, though, in the 1950s Chomsky’s first attempts at characterizing human language took just such a route, and involved simple transformational grammars and other concepts that did not work for human language, but turned out to be useful for the analysis of programming languages. As a result, we now learn about things like the Chomsky Hierarchy in undergraduate models of computation classes.

codyrobbins··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
I disagree with almost every single response in this entire thread, so I don’t know where to begin. The use here is idiomatic, as many people have pointed out. The intonation contour of the phrase is completely different than the non-idiomatic usage. I think that those people who say that there is no intonation difference are simply not consciously sensitive enough to intonation to realize that there’s a difference. Another example might illustrate intonation differences more clearly, even though the nature of the difference in the example is different than that in could care less. There is a difference between the intonation of black bird meaning a bird that is black, and black bird meaning a specific type of bird known as a black bird. The former has a relatively flat intonation contour, while the latter has definite stress on the initial word. So, there you go: we have the exact same word mapping to two different referents, but people can somehow distinguish which referent is meant based solely on the intonation contour. (Let’s not get into a discussion of the definition of ‘word’, but it suffices to say that black bird is two orthographic words in both cases, but one lexical item in the latter case and two in the former.) So, the fact that there’s a difference in the intonation of could care less means that listeners can distinguish between the literal and idiomatic uses, and the intended meaning is perfectly clear. As someone else points out, Steven Pinker has happened to analyze this exact phrase in The Language Instinct, and he concludes it comes from a sarcastic interpretation of the original literal meaning. For those of you sitting in your armchairs who don’t agree with his analysis, all I can say is that he’s a highly respected linguist who knows what he’s talking about.

We still say room and board even though board no longer means food. Should we stop using that collocation because it includes an obsolete word? We say a little bird told me even when a little bird did not, in fact, literally tell you something. Furthermore, birds can’t tell anyone anything, because birds can’t talk, so the phrase logically doesn’t make any sense either. But we still use it, because it doesn’t need to be ‘logically’ consistent to communicate meaning. So it doesn’t matter whether could care less ‘logically’ makes sense based on its literal meaning — its literal meaning is not the meaning people ascribe to it when used idiomatically. Even more importantly, though, the surface form of language is not necessarily ‘logical’, simply because it’s so complex under the surface that it’s unintuitive what’s going on. It doesn’t make any everyday sense that subatomic particles exhibit quantum tunneling and entanglement and all sorts of other strange phenomena, because the underlying physics is so ridiculously complicated that it has to be studied in minute detail before a real picture emerges.

Another similarly uninformed objection, along the same lines of reasoning, that I often hear people make is that we ‘should’ eliminate redundancy from language. They say that’s why double negatives and words like irregardless are ‘bad’. But Spanish has double negatives and they’re perfectly grammatical, so what’s wrong with having them? If you use a word like irregardless, everyone understands what you mean perfectly, so what’s wrong with using it? Furthermore, as hackers you should all realize that redundancy is good. Having a multiply redundant array of disks makes sure there’s not a single point of failure, and having multiply redundant backups means that you don’t go down like Ma.gnolia. Speech is a signal, and signals experience loss, attenuation, interference, etc. A word like irregardless — with redundant affixes in it — may very well be far more communicative in noisy environments. Even if the end of the word is cut off, people can still reconstruct or extrapolate what was said. And remember, the point of a word in spoken speech is to communicate. How do you know usage hasn’t shifted to that form, as a preference over regardless, for exactly that reason? The answer is that you really don’t.

There are processes at work in language change that you don’t have any control over by being a nazi or a pedant. The language changes, whether you like where it goes or not. And it’s twelve steps ahead of you, because it’s changing to satisfy or maximize requirements and utility functions that none of us can even begin to understand fully.

Second of all, this isn’t a syntactic issue in the first place, so it’s misleading to call yourself a grammar nazi. The sentence ‘I could care less’ is perfectly syntactically valid. This is purely an issue with the lexicon. And if you’re going to be a lexicon nazi, there are a few things you should know about the lexicon. First, it’s one of the most rich, fluid, and dynamic aspects of the language, and changes the fastest. Trying to keep it ‘pure’ or stop it from changing is not possible. Second, lexical differences are present across a multitude of axes: geographic, socioeconomic, gender, etc. There is no ‘correct’ lexicon, therefore there is nothing for you to ‘correct’ about the way someone else is speaking.

Third, I really don’t like how so many people on HN have a general attitude of anti-authoritarian superiority, but then you get these sort of rambling hypocritical threads where people pounce on perfectly legitimate uses of language. People pounce like that in other places, but it doesn’t bother me so much because it’s not coupled with the anti-authoritarian bent. The kind of prescriptive rules you are discussing are essentially a marker for whether someone has been educated or not. Those who do not have access to education, for whatever reasons, do not learn the prescriptive rules that allow you to write in a manner that sounds educated. There is absolutely nothing wrong with the way hillbillies or inner city black kids talk — it is demonstrable that their language follows the same kind of rules as Standard American English, and are just as logical and consistent. It’s ironic because, in certain respects, those dialects are more logical and consistent than SAE. So by making these sort of glib, ad hominen, red herring remarks whenever anyone makes a grammatical ‘error’, you’re really just reinforcing the entire system. Note that I’m not making any value judgment or stance on the existence of a prestige dialect, or on anti-authoritarianism itself; it’s just that I find the combination of the two hypocritical. This entire thread gives me the same feeling I get when you hear Victorian era drawing room discussions about how the savages in Darkest Africa and Oceania and the Orientals have to shown the light about the superiority of ‘correct’ Western culture. In hindsight, those opinions are so black and white as to be laughable, because there is so much nuance involved just in the question of what the words correct or superior even mean.

Hmm, I didn’t realize how much I wrote until I just posted this. If I had a blog I guess this should be a blog post.

codyrobbins··on Mojito island is a mirage
Yeah, but I think his point is that the amount of money in your bank account is a direct result of your own choices and actions. And the fact that you have a kid is a result of your choices.

If you have a kid to feed and that’s constraining your ability to focus on a startup as you would like, maybe you shouldn’t have chosen to have a kid.

codyrobbins··on Dark Stalking on Facebook
Yeah — events they didn’t go to. So?
codyrobbins··on Ask HN: How do you wake up?
My only complaint about the iPhone alarm is that I really, really wish it had a setting for how many minutes ’snooze’ is. When I hit snooze I always want to sleep for another half hour, not nine minutes.
codyrobbins··on Google user comment in 2000
Yeah, the fact that it searches for terms you don't type in has really been annoying me for a while. You essentially have to put a + in front of every term in a technical search. I have to say, though, it makes sense for non-technical users, who are apt to type in misspelled and suboptimal terms. For the vast majority of users, Google probably knows better than they do what they should be searching for. Also, I think this change may have evolved as a more generic implementation of an attempt at stemming. For example, it makes sense for Google to additionally search for stereos when you enter stereo, and brings, bringing, and brought (and probably brang and brung) when you search for bring.

Another bugaboo of mine, though, is the fact that hyphenating words no longer acts the same as putting them in quotes. Searching for car-stereo used to be the equivalent of "car stereo" — one less character to type. Now Google ignores the hyphens.

codyrobbins··on Why Google won't create the next Twitter or Facebook or Posterous
Why the implicit assumption that Google should be creating such things?
codyrobbins··on Rewriting Returning in Rails
OK, I think we're on the same page regarding our meta-discussion =)

Yes, I absolutely find

  customers.map(&:name)
a win over

  customers.map { |c| c.name }
My reasoning is that the former is less code overall, is fundamentally 'simpler' (passing a parameter to a method rather than calling with a block), and the code it replaces has redundancy (the block parameter is there only to be immediately referenced for the sole purpose of getting at one of the object's attributes). With #try, there's similarly less code overall and it removes redundancy.

I agree that brevity alone is not enough to prefer one idiom over another. Expressiveness is a big part. I like these idioms, so I'm actually in the camp that they do make the code more precise and communicative.

In my book, though, #returning is simply an exception. A simple assignment and return are already so fundamentally expressive on their own, that — to me — replacing them with a method invocation and block doesn't get you more expressiveness, and instead it actually makes things less readable.

To me, it would be like writing an abstraction layer to replace the use of variables in the language, where you have to invoke a special-purpose lookup table class to set and retrieve values. Why would you prefer

  Variable.set(:foo, 'bar')
  puts(Variable.get(:foo))
over

  foo = 'bar'
  puts(foo)
Why not just use variables?
codyrobbins··on Rewriting Returning in Rails
Isn't it implied and understood that I can only speak for myself and from my own perspective? I think my post was littered liberally enough with words like 'personally' and 'I feel' that it's understood I'm not trying to speak in absolutes. So, would you rather I didn't raise any questions about the relative merits of the code simply because there may be people who find it useful? I'm certainly not arguing that no one will find it useful, I'm simply saying that I don't like it and giving the reasons why I think so. If you didn't want people to discuss the relative merits of the code, why did you post it?

EDIT: Ah, you elided what the above is a rebuttal of, which is good because that brings the discussion back to the actual code in question.

There are a ton of little idiomatic extensions to Ruby that are immensely useful, SymbolToProc being a very good example. The presence of so many of them is one of the great things about Rails. So, I'm not arguing against such things as a whole, as you imply I am. I'm simply saying that #returning in particular is one that I have problems with.

Nor am I saying that making things less readable for the uninitiated is a sufficient motivation to bar use of such things. However, this particular idiom gives you so little that I feel what you gain from it does not outweigh the cost of introducing it. So, I do feel that the idiom doesn't add any value, and for that reason there is a cost associated with its use.

It doesn't save you any code, and it's more complicated than the code it replaces, which is why I am puzzled that you find it easier to understand. It makes things wordier with a block invocation when a simple assignment will suffice. Ostensibly, assignment is a much 'lower level' mechanism than invoking a method with a block.

I readily admit, though, that if you find it easier to read then there's no argument I can make, because it works for you. Similarly, though, I can state that it is not easier to read for me. So, I guess we just have to agree to disagree on the basis that our brains work differently =)

codyrobbins··on Rewriting Returning in Rails
Yeah, I know I don't have to use it. I just think the style it introduces is more abstruse overall than the problem it's solving. To answer your question, I'm mostly arguing with Rails, not you. Obviously, if it's useful to people they'll use it and who am I to declare by fiat that something's not useful to somebody else? But just because some level of personal preference is involved doesn't mean we can't try to talk about something on the basis of its objective merits.

But I'm often (usually?) wrong — I was just putting in my two cents for the sake of discussion =)

codyrobbins··on Rewriting Returning in Rails
I personally find the #returning method very ugly. It's an abstraction that seems completely unnecessary to me. Instead of assigning a variable and then returning the value, two very fundamental mechanisms in the language that are easily understood by any programmer (whether they know Ruby or not), you're bypassing them and introducing this method whose purpose I don't feel is immediately obvious.

It would be one thing if the pattern saved a lot of unnecessary code, but it doesn't. The assignment of the local variable just becomes the block variable, and you have an 'end' where the method-final return would be. Instead of a simple assignment, you now have the method invocation and the arguably more complicated block syntax.

I'll address the two particular motivations raised by the author specifically because I don't agree with either of them. First, I don't think forgetting to return the variable is a common bug. Anecdotally, I can't ever remember making this mistake myself. Even if I were to, it would be immediately obvious what the problem is. I'm open to the fact that other people perhaps make this mistake, but I'd be surprised if they routinely do. Second, I don't feel like it's obvious at all what the return value of the method is up-front, because the method invocation is confusing if you don't know what it does. Even if you do, it doesn't gain you anything you don't get by simply initializing a local at the start of the method, especially if you call the local return_value or something self-descriptive like that.

This kind of refactoring is the kind that I don't like — refactoring for the sake of refactoring, and making the code less accessible (that is, more complicated and harder to understand) for no discernible benefit.

codyrobbins··on Inside the Cafe at Facebook Headquarters
Am I the only one who thinks it's absolutely crazy that they have a kitchen staff of 50 people for only 800 employees? That means 1 for every 16 other employees. I actually completely agree with a lot of the other posters who are saying how important good food is to productivity, and 50 employees to produce the kind of food they're producing doesn't sound unreasonable. But given all that, thinking of the overhead and expense involved, that number still just strikes me as an incredibly massive proportion of their staff being devoted to foodservice.
codyrobbins··on Ask HN: Trivial etiquette question - can he touch my laptop screen?
I stand by what I said. Just because I'm a hacker I don't have to have a misplaced sense of my own self-importance in front of someone like a vice president.
codyrobbins··on Ask HN: Trivial etiquette question - can he touch my laptop screen?
The company shouldn't fire someone for not knowing their place in front of a vice president and making a snide remark? I think that's absolutely acceptable. If the vice president wants to touch your screen, you're not really in a place to chew him out about it. I would venture to guess that doing so was most likely indicative of broader issues with the employee in this case, i.e., if she doesn't know her place in front of upper-level executives, how is she interacting with important customers, contractors, vendors, government officials, etc.?
codyrobbins··on A hacker's easy dinner: Vegetarian Tacos
Here's one of my carefully developed hacker easy dinners, refined over a number of years, optimized for minimal prep and cleanup time, cost, and healthiness:

  * Family-size package of bone-in chicken thighs with skin
  * 4 cups white rice
  * Bag of frozen vegetables
  
  1. Preheat oven to 400°.
  2. Salt and pepper chicken.
  3. Place chicken on half sheet pan.
  4. Bake for approximately 20 minutes, until the juices run completely clear, with
     no trace of pink, when a fork is inserted.
  
  While the chicken's cooking:
  
  1. Place rice in saucepan.
  2. Add 2 cups water (or as much as the package instructions say).
  3. Bring to boil.
  4. Turn heat down as low as it goes, stir, and cover pot.
  5. Cook for approximately 15 minutes, or until all the water has been absorbed. Do
     not lift the lid until the end, to check whether the water's been absorbed.
  
  5 minutes before the chicken and rice are done:
  
  1. Place frozen vegetables in a microwave-safe container.
  2. Add a few tablespoons of water.
  3. Microwave for 5 minutes.
  4. Salt and pepper.
Upsides: It takes 20 minutes, it will all be ready at the same time, there are only two pieces of cookware to clean, it makes enough for dinner for a week, and it costs about $10 total.

Downsides: It doesn't taste very phenomenal. But, hey — cooking food that tastes good is what makes cooking time-consuming.

The chicken will taste better if you brown both sides in some butter and vegetable oil in a frying pan first, but that takes more time. If you don't want the carbs in the rice, you can switch in some black beans.

codyrobbins··on Self-Enforcing Protocols
Your argument is that because there are already restrictions on private property, that there should therefore be more. I respectfully but completely disagree.

I also don't think your analogy is very applicable, since domain names are just floating in the ether, not sitting in physical proximity of one another. Ads plastered on one will not drive down the values of the others — the complete opposite, in fact. Furthermore, no one would buy prime commercial real estate, do nothing with it, and then be able to cover their costs with some ads on it — whoever bought it would go bankrupt. Ignoring all that, however, I really feel that if someone wanted to do so, the city council should not be able to levy fines on them for letting their property go into disrepair. Would I want to live next to such a property? No, definitely not. But it's their property and I respect their rights to do as they wish with it. I don't feel the ends justify the means in this case.

codyrobbins··on Self-Enforcing Protocols
I think this really perverts the concept of private property, though. In order to thwart domain squatters, you'd eliminate property rights and create a fluid pool of domain names that could be forcibly purchased by anyone else at any time. Domains would become like oiled pool balls so slick and slippery that no one would be able to keep ahold of them long enough to do anything useful with them. That is, without massively overpaying taxes on them to insure they couldn't be taken at any time.

I think one of the most important things about private property is not necessarily that you can demand its fair value when you sell it, but rather that you alone can decide whether it is for sale in the first place.

From my way of thinking, domain squatting certainly isn't a dignified way to make a living or something to be proud of, and it's certainly a pain in the ass to everyone else, but I think it certainly is within the rights of those who choose to do it. Who cares if someone has a better use for a domain name? If you bought it, it's yours whether anyone else like it or not.

You might argue that squatting is not within the rights of those who do it — according to ICANN regulations — but then I would say that there's already process in place to resolve those sort of disagreements. Whether there are issues with that process is another question. That process may be imperfect, but I think what you are proposing introduces many more problems than it solves.

codyrobbins··on Self-Enforcing Protocols
Sure, the government can already do this, but certainly not so easily. Things like building high-tension powerlines or rezoning require many steps involving proposals, reviews, environmental impact studies, community input, etc. before final approval. There's also eminent domain, which I didn't mention, but again even that requires lots of review, justification, general consensus, and approval.

There is definitely a difference between those things and the government being able to arbitrarily seize your property with no justification at all, other than that you've arguably undervalued it, regardless of whether they pay you what you valued it at.

So, while this may not really give the government power that it doesn't already have per se, what it's doing is removing a ton of barriers.

Assuming you over-report the value, you'd be making a profit on the sale - enough that moving wouldn't be much of a issue for you.

This is assuming that all you care about is money. What if you don't want to give up your home regardless of how much they pay you for it? There are some things people are not willing to sell for any price. And being forced to relocate would be far more than an inconvenience to some people. In these cases, how much should you be forced to overvalue your home by as insurance that the government won't arbitrarily seize it if you get on someone's bad side? 25%? 50%? 200%?

codyrobbins··on Self-Enforcing Protocols
Here’s a self-enforcing protocol for determining property tax: the homeowner decides the value of the property and calculates the resultant tax, and the government can either accept the tax or buy the home for that price. Sounds unrealistic, but the Greek government implemented exactly that system for the taxation of antiquities. It was the easiest way to motivate people to accurately report the value of antiquities.

Yeah, it does sound unrealistic. What if the homeowner truthfully and in good faith reports an accurate value for their home, and the government decides to purchase it anyways? I would not like the government to have the ability to instantly render me homeless.

codyrobbins··on Scientific Speed Reading: How to Read 300% Faster in 20 Minutes
For a long time I was really into the idea of speed reading, and I worked through one of the original books on it:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/073520019X

After a lot of practice I ultimately came to the conclusion that it doesn't really work. I could 'read' the pages really fast, but it's not what I'd call reading. It's skimming. Sure, the speed of fixation and regressions limit your theoretical maximum reading speed, but — for me at least — the real bottleneck was how fast I could understand what I was reading. You may be able to look at 10 pages of words per minute, but understanding 10 pages of material per minute just doesn't really work.

Another thing I learned is that there's no good metric for what constitutes 'retention'. It's usually measured by making a list of how many 'things' you can remember from what you read. It's arguable whether remembering a list of words from what you've read relates in any meaningful way to whether you comprehended what you read. Having the word 'scientific' in the title of the article is misleading at best.

codyrobbins··on USAA Bank Will Let Customers Deposit Checks by iPhone
This is one of the most brilliant uses of the iPhone I have heard in a while.

Now if only I could pay for purchases via credit card by waving my iPhone over an RFID receiver, and use it as a MetroCard…

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →